Law covered in these questions
- Scotland Act 1998 s 29(1), (2)(b), Sch 5
- Scotland Act 1998, s 29
- Scotland Act 1998, ss 29(2)(d) and 102
- Scotland Act 1998, ss 32-33
- Scotland Act 1998, s 35
- AXA General Insurance Ltd v Lord Advocate [2011] UKSC 46
- Scotland Act 1998, s 101
- Reference by the Lord Advocate of devolution issues under paragraph 34 of Schedule 6 to the Scotland Act 1998 [2022] UKSC 31
- Re United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Bill [2021] UKSC 42
- Imperial Tobacco Ltd v Lord Advocate [2012] UKSC 61
- Scotland Act 1998, s 29(3)
- Government of Wales Act 2006, s 108A
- Northern Ireland Act 1998, ss 6 and 8, Schs 2 and 3
- Northern Ireland Act 1998, s 1 and Sch 1
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Scottish Parliament passes an Act in an area reserved to the UK Parliament. Which statement best describes the effect?
- It is valid, because the UK Parliament has no power to legislate for Scotland.
- It is valid for 12 months and then lapses automatically.
- It is valid, because the Scottish Parliament is sovereign within Scotland.
- The provision is outside the Parliament's legislative competence and is not law, as the Scotland Act 1998 reserves certain matters to Westminster.Correct answer
- It is valid but applies only to Scottish courts.
The Scottish Parliament can legislate only within its competence. A provision relating to reserved matters is outside competence and is not law. The UK Parliament remains sovereign and can legislate for Scotland.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998 s 29(1), (2)(b), Sch 5 ↗Question 2 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Scottish Parliament passes an Act regulating the licensing of nuclear power stations in Scotland. Energy generation from nuclear sources is a reserved matter under Schedule 5 to the Scotland Act 1998. A power company asks what the legal status of the Act is. Which of the following is the best answer?
- It is not law so far as it relates to a reserved matter, as that is outside competence.Correct answer
- It is valid law until the UK Parliament passes an Act expressly repealing it.
- It is valid law, because the Scottish Parliament has unlimited legislative power over all matters within Scotland.
- It is valid law unless the Secretary of State for Scotland revokes it by order within 28 days.
- It is not law until the Supreme Court has confirmed that it is within legislative competence.
Section 29(1) of the Scotland Act 1998 provides that an Act of the Scottish Parliament is not law so far as any provision is outside the Parliament's legislative competence. Under section 29(2)(b) a provision is outside competence if it relates to reserved matters listed in Schedule 5. Unlike the UK Parliament, the Scottish Parliament is a body of limited competence, so the courts may decide that its Acts are not law. There is no general requirement for prior Supreme Court confirmation or a revocation order.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998, s 29 ↗Question 3 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
An Act of the Scottish Parliament on a devolved matter contains a provision allowing the indefinite retention of DNA samples from people who are never charged. Andrew argues in the Court of Session that the provision breaches Article 8 ECHR. If the court agrees, which of the following best describes what it can do?
- Make a declaration of incompatibility only, because the provision remains valid until amended.
- Refer the provision to the UK Parliament, which must then decide whether to repeal it.
- Do nothing, because devolved legislation is treated as primary legislation under the Human Rights Act 1998.
- Hold that the provision is not law, because Convention-incompatible provisions are outside competence.Correct answer
- Award damages to Andrew but leave the provision in force for all other purposes.
Under section 29(2)(d) of the Scotland Act 1998, a provision of an Act of the Scottish Parliament is outside legislative competence if it is incompatible with any of the Convention rights. By section 29(1) it is not law. Unlike Acts of the UK Parliament, for which only a declaration of incompatibility is available under section 4 HRA, devolved legislation can be invalidated by the courts on Convention grounds. Section 102 gives the court powers to limit retrospective effect or suspend its decision to allow correction.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998, ss 29(2)(d) and 102 ↗Question 4 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Scottish Parliament has just passed a Bill which the UK government believes relates to a reserved matter. The Bill has not yet received Royal Assent. The Advocate General for Scotland wants a definitive ruling on competence before it becomes law. Which of the following best describes the procedure?
- The Advocate General must wait until the Bill becomes an Act and then bring a challenge in the Court of Session.
- The Advocate General may refer the question to the Supreme Court within four weeks of the Bill being passed.Correct answer
- The Advocate General may ask the Presiding Officer to rule on competence, and that ruling is final.
- The Advocate General may refer the question to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council at any time.
- The Advocate General may apply to the Secretary of State for Scotland, who decides competence.
Under section 33 of the Scotland Act 1998, the Advocate General, the Lord Advocate or the Attorney General may refer the question whether a Bill, or any provision of it, would be within legislative competence to the Supreme Court for a decision. The reference must be made within four weeks of the Bill being passed, and the Bill cannot be submitted for Royal Assent while the reference is pending. The Presiding Officer's statement on competence under section 31 is not conclusive. Devolution references now go to the Supreme Court, not the Privy Council.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998, ss 32-33 ↗Question 5 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Scottish Parliament passes a Bill on a devolved matter. The Secretary of State for Scotland believes it would have an adverse effect on the operation of UK-wide law on a reserved matter. Which power is most directly available to the Secretary of State to stop the Bill becoming law?
- A direction to the Lord Advocate to withdraw the Bill and reintroduce it in an amended form.
- A power to amend the Bill himself by statutory instrument before it is submitted for Royal Assent.
- A power to advise the King to refuse Royal Assent, which is not subject to any statutory conditions.
- A power to suspend the Scottish Parliament until the Bill has been withdrawn or amended to his satisfaction.
- An order prohibiting the Presiding Officer from submitting the Bill for Royal Assent.Correct answer
Section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998 allows the Secretary of State, by order, to prohibit the Presiding Officer from submitting a Bill for Royal Assent if it contains provisions which he has reasonable grounds to believe would modify the law as it applies to reserved matters and would have an adverse effect on the operation of that law. The order must identify the provisions and state reasons. It was first used in 2023 for the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill and was upheld by the Court of Session. The other powers do not exist.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998, s 35 ↗Question 6 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Insurance companies challenge an Act of the Scottish Parliament which made certain asbestos-related conditions actionable personal injuries, arguing that it is irrational and should be set aside on ordinary judicial review grounds. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- Its Acts are reviewable on all the ordinary grounds, because the Scottish Parliament is a creature of statute like a council.
- Its Acts can never be reviewed at common law, because they are treated in all respects like Acts of Parliament.
- Its Acts are not reviewable for irrationality, but might be reviewed in extreme cases offending the rule of law.Correct answer
- Its Acts are reviewable for irrationality only if the UK government supports the challenge.
- Its Acts are reviewable only by the UK Parliament through a resolution of both Houses.
In AXA General Insurance Ltd v Lord Advocate the Supreme Court held that Acts of the Scottish Parliament are not subject to judicial review at common law on the grounds of irrationality, unreasonableness or arbitrariness, because the Parliament is a democratically elected legislature. However, they are subject to the statutory limits in section 29, and Lord Hope suggested common law review might be available in extreme cases where an Act offended fundamental rights or the rule of law, for example by abolishing judicial review. The Act was upheld.
Law basis: AXA General Insurance Ltd v Lord Advocate [2011] UKSC 46Question 7 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
An Act of the Scottish Parliament could be read either broadly, in a way that would touch on a reserved matter, or more narrowly, in a way that would keep it within competence. Seren, a solicitor, asks how the courts will interpret it. Which of the following is the best answer?
- The court will adopt the broader reading and then hold the Act to be outside competence.
- The court will read it as narrowly as is required for it to be within competence, if possible.Correct answer
- The court will refer the question of interpretation to the Presiding Officer of the Scottish Parliament for a binding ruling.
- The court will adopt whichever reading the Scottish Government states it intended.
- The court will apply the reading which the UK government considers most consistent with reserved law.
Section 101 of the Scotland Act 1998 requires any provision of an Act of the Scottish Parliament which could be read in such a way as to be outside competence to be read as narrowly as is required for it to be within competence, if such a reading is possible, and to have effect accordingly. This interpretive obligation resembles section 3 of the Human Rights Act 1998 and favours upholding devolved legislation. Neither government's stated intention, nor the Presiding Officer, determines the interpretation.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998, s 101 ↗Question 8 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Scottish Government proposes a Bill to hold an advisory referendum on Scottish independence, without the agreement of the UK government. It argues that an advisory vote has no legal effect on the Union and is therefore within competence. Which of the following best describes the Supreme Court's view?
- The Bill is within competence, because an advisory referendum has no legal consequences.
- The Bill is within competence, because the Sewel convention prevents Westminster from objecting.
- The Bill is outside competence only because it breaches Article 3 of Protocol 1 to the ECHR.
- The question is non-justiciable because it concerns a political matter for the Scottish electorate.
- The Bill relates to the Union, a reserved matter, so it is outside competence though advisory.Correct answer
In Reference by the Lord Advocate of devolution issues (Scottish Independence Referendum Bill) the Supreme Court held that the proposed Bill related to the reserved matters of the Union of the Kingdoms of Scotland and England and the UK Parliament, under paragraph 1 of Schedule 5 to the Scotland Act 1998. Although advisory, a lawfully held referendum would have important political consequences for the Union, so the Bill's purpose and effects were more than loosely connected with it. The question was justiciable and was decided under the Scotland Act, not the Convention.
Law basis: Reference by the Lord Advocate of devolution issues under paragraph 34 of Schedule 6 to the Scotland Act 1998 [2022] UKSC 31Question 9 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A Scottish Parliament Bill incorporating the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child would have allowed Scottish courts to declare Acts of the UK Parliament incompatible with it and to read them down in devolved areas. The UK law officers refer the Bill to the Supreme Court. Which of the following best describes the outcome?
- The provisions were within competence, because the Scottish Parliament may incorporate any international treaty into Scots law.
- The provisions were within competence, because they applied only to matters within devolved legislative competence.
- Those provisions were outside competence, as they would modify Westminster's power to legislate for Scotland.Correct answer
- The provisions were outside competence only because they breached the Human Rights Act 1998.
- The reference was rejected, because only the Lord Advocate may refer a Scottish Bill to the Supreme Court.
In Re United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Bill the Supreme Court held that the provisions allowing Scottish courts to read down, or declare incompatible, Acts of the UK Parliament would modify section 28(7) of the Scotland Act 1998, which preserves Westminster's power to make laws for Scotland. Section 28(7) is protected from modification by Schedule 4, so the provisions were outside competence. The Advocate General and Attorney General may refer Bills under section 33, not only the Lord Advocate.
Law basis: Re United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Bill [2021] UKSC 42Question 10 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Scottish Parliament bans the display of tobacco products in shops. A tobacco company argues that the Act relates to the reserved matters of the sale and supply of goods to consumers and product safety. Which of the following best describes the test the court applies to decide whether a provision 'relates to' a reserved matter?
- The court considers purpose and effect, asking if there is more than a loose connection with the reserved matter.Correct answer
- The court asks whether the provision has any effect on a reserved matter, however incidental that effect may be.
- The court asks only what the Scottish Government intended when introducing the Bill, as stated in its policy memorandum.
- The court asks whether the UK government has objected to the provision under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998.
- The court asks whether the provision would be within the competence of the Senedd under the Government of Wales Act 2006.
Section 29(3) of the Scotland Act 1998 provides that whether a provision relates to a reserved matter is to be determined by reference to its purpose, having regard among other things to its effect in all the circumstances. In Imperial Tobacco Ltd v Lord Advocate the Supreme Court held that the provision must have more than a loose or consequential connection with the reserved matter. The display ban's purpose was public health, a devolved matter, so it was within competence. Incidental effects on reserved matters are not enough.
Law basis: Imperial Tobacco Ltd v Lord Advocate [2012] UKSC 61; Scotland Act 1998, s 29(3)Question 11 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A Welsh lawyer, Gwen, is asked to explain the current model of devolution to the Senedd. Her client thinks the Senedd may legislate only on subjects specifically listed as devolved. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Wales has a conferred powers model: the Senedd may legislate only on the subjects listed in a schedule to the 2006 Act.
- Wales has no primary legislative powers, so the Senedd may make only subordinate legislation.
- Wales has the same powers as Westminster, subject only to Convention rights and EU-derived law.
- It is a reserved powers model: the Senedd may legislate unless a matter is reserved or excluded.Correct answer
- Wales has a conferred powers model, but the Senedd may add new subjects by its own resolution.
Following the Wales Act 2017, section 108A of the Government of Wales Act 2006 adopts a reserved powers model similar to Scotland's. An Act of the Senedd is within competence unless, among other things, it relates to reserved matters listed in Schedule 7A, breaches the restrictions in Schedule 7B, extends beyond Wales, or is incompatible with Convention rights. The earlier conferred powers model under Schedule 7 was replaced. The Senedd has primary legislative powers, but they remain limited and it cannot extend its own competence.
Law basis: Government of Wales Act 2006, s 108A ↗Question 12 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A Member of the Northern Ireland Assembly proposes a Bill on firearms licensing, a reserved matter under the Northern Ireland Act 1998. Another member proposes a Bill on national security, an excepted matter. Which of the following best describes the Assembly's competence?
- It may legislate on both matters, provided each Bill obtains cross-community support in the Assembly.
- It may legislate on the excepted matter with the Secretary of State's consent, but never on the reserved matter.
- It may legislate on the reserved matter with the Secretary of State's consent, but not on the excepted matter.Correct answer
- It may legislate on neither matter unless Westminster passes an enabling Act transferring the subject.
- It may legislate on both matters, because the Assembly has the same competence as the Scottish Parliament.
The Northern Ireland Act 1998 divides matters into excepted matters (Schedule 2), which are permanently retained by Westminster, reserved matters (Schedule 3), and transferred matters. Under section 6 an Assembly Act is outside competence if it deals with an excepted matter, unless ancillary. Under section 8 a Bill dealing with a reserved matter may proceed only with the Secretary of State's consent. Matters may be moved between the reserved and transferred categories by Order in Council, but excepted matters cannot be dealt with even with consent.
Law basis: Northern Ireland Act 1998, ss 6 and 8, Schs 2 and 3 ↗Question 13 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Opinion polls suggest that a majority of people in Northern Ireland might now favour a united Ireland. Ciara asks what the Northern Ireland Act 1998 says about Northern Ireland's constitutional status. Which of the following best describes the position?
- It stays in the UK unless a majority in a poll decides otherwise, when the Secretary of State must make proposals.Correct answer
- It may leave the UK only if both the Assembly and the House of Commons approve the change by a two-thirds majority vote.
- It may leave the UK by a simple resolution of the Northern Ireland Assembly supported by the Executive.
- It may leave the UK only if a referendum held across the whole of the UK approves the change.
- It is a permanent part of the UK, and the 1998 Act contains no mechanism for a change of status.
Section 1 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998 declares that Northern Ireland remains part of the United Kingdom and will not cease to be so without the consent of a majority of the people of Northern Ireland voting in a poll held under Schedule 1. If a majority votes for a united Ireland, the Secretary of State must lay before Parliament proposals to give effect to that wish as agreed with the Irish government. Under Schedule 1 the Secretary of State must hold a poll if it appears likely that a majority would vote for change.
Law basis: Northern Ireland Act 1998, s 1 and Sch 1 ↗Question 14 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A Scottish politician claims that, since the Scotland Act 2016, the Scottish Parliament can never be abolished. Kirsty, a law student, is asked to evaluate this claim by reference to section 63A of the Scotland Act 1998. Which of the following best describes the provision?
- It entrenches the Parliament legally, so that any Westminster Act abolishing it would be void in every UK court.
- It allows the Scottish Parliament to be abolished by a two-thirds vote of the House of Commons.
- It provides that the Parliament may be abolished only with the consent of the Scottish Government.
- It declares the Parliament permanent, not to be abolished without a referendum in Scotland.Correct answer
- It is a statement of the Sewel convention and has nothing to do with the permanence of the Parliament.
Section 63A, inserted by the Scotland Act 2016, declares that the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Government are a permanent part of the UK's constitutional arrangements, records the commitment of the UK Parliament and Government to them, and states that they are not to be abolished except on the basis of a decision of the people of Scotland voting in a referendum. Given parliamentary sovereignty and the reasoning in Miller (2017), the orthodox view is that it is a strong political commitment rather than legally effective entrenchment.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998, s 63A ↗Question 15 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A Senedd Act on social housing allows landlords to evict tenants without any hearing, contrary to Article 6 and Article 8 ECHR. Dylan, a tenant, challenges it. Which of the following best describes the court's power if it finds the Act incompatible?
- The court may only declare the provision incompatible, leaving it valid and enforceable.
- The court may hold the provision outside competence and so not law.Correct answer
- The court must refer the Act to the UK Parliament, which alone can decide whether it is valid.
- The court may not consider Convention rights, because the Senedd is not a public authority.
- The court must apply the provision, because Acts of the Senedd are primary legislation for HRA purposes.
Section 108A(2)(e) of the Government of Wales Act 2006 provides that a provision of an Act of the Senedd is outside competence if it is incompatible with the Convention rights, and section 108A(1) provides that such a provision is not law. As with the Scottish Parliament, devolved legislation can therefore be invalidated by the courts on Convention grounds, in contrast with Acts of the UK Parliament, where only a declaration of incompatibility under section 4 HRA is possible.
Law basis: Government of Wales Act 2006, s 108A ↗More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.