Two officers acting on a warrant issued by a Secretary of State break into Tom's home and seize his papers. No statute or common law rule authorises such a warrant, but the minister argues that it is necessary for state security. Tom sues the officers in trespass. Which of the following best describes the outcome?
- Tom fails, because the officers acted on the instructions of a minister and are protected by Crown immunity.
- Tom fails, because the minister has an inherent prerogative power to issue warrants in matters of state security.
- Tom succeeds only if he can show that the minister acted in bad faith when issuing the warrant.
- Tom succeeds, because officials need legal authority to interfere with property; necessity is no defence.Correct answer
- Tom fails, because the courts will not review decisions involving state security or the defence of the realm.
Entick v Carrington is the classic rule of law authority. A general warrant issued by the Secretary of State to search and seize papers was held unlawful because no statute or recognised common law rule authorised it. Lord Camden rejected the argument of state necessity: officials, like private citizens, need legal authority for interfering with another's property. A minister's instruction gives no defence, and there is no general prerogative to issue search warrants. Bad faith is not required, as the absence of lawful authority is enough.
Law basis: Entick v Carrington (1765) 19 St Tr 1030