Law covered in these questions
- Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223
- Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374
- R v Ministry of Defence, ex p Smith [1996] QB 517
- R (Daly) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2001] UKHL 26
- Bank Mellat v HM Treasury (No 2) [2013] UKSC 39
- R (Keyu) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2015] UKSC 69
- R (Rogers) v Swindon NHS Primary Care Trust [2006] EWCA Civ 392
- R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Nottinghamshire County Council [1986] AC 240
- R v Chief Constable of Sussex, ex p International Trader's Ferry Ltd [1999] 2 AC 418
- Kennedy v Charity Commission [2014] UKSC 20
All 11 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
A council decides that a cinema may open on Sundays only if no children under 15 are admitted. The cinema challenges the condition as unreasonable. Which statement best describes the test the court applies?
- Whether a majority of local people support the decision.
- Whether the court would have made the same decision itself.
- Whether the condition is the best available policy choice.
- Whether the decision is so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could have come to it.Correct answer
- Whether the cinema owner agrees with the council's reasons.
Wednesbury unreasonableness asks whether the decision is one that no reasonable decision-maker could have reached. The court does not substitute its own view on the merits.
Law basis: Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223Question 2 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
A minister refuses to renew a licence for a long-established charity shop on the ground that its signage is painted green, a reason unconnected with the licensing scheme and contrary to all the evidence before him. Which of the following best reflects Lord Diplock's formulation of the ground of challenge?
- The order was lawful, because the Lord Chancellor has an unlimited statutory power to set any court fees he chooses.
- A decision that was not the most proportionate option among those available to the minister.
- A decision taken without consulting those likely to be affected by it.
- A decision made by a minister who had a personal financial interest in its outcome.
- The order was unlawful, as a general power did not authorise barring access to the courts.Correct answer
In Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service Lord Diplock classified the grounds of judicial review as illegality, irrationality and procedural impropriety. Irrationality, or Wednesbury unreasonableness, applies to a decision 'so outrageous in its defiance of logic or of accepted moral standards that no sensible person who had applied his mind to the question to be decided could have arrived at it'. The court does not substitute its own view on the merits. Lack of consultation is procedural impropriety, and personal interest relates to bias.
Law basis: Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374Question 3 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
Before the HRA came into force, several members of the armed forces were discharged under a policy excluding gay people from service. They challenged the policy as irrational. Which of the following best describes the Court of Appeal's approach?
- A decision with which the reviewing judge disagrees after weighing all of the relevant evidence afresh for himself.
- The court refused to review the policy at all, because defence matters are wholly non-justiciable.
- The court treated the policy as irrational because it conflicted with the European Convention.
- A decision so outrageous in its defiance of logic or morals that no sensible person could reach it.Correct answer
- The court applied the ordinary Wednesbury test without any adjustment for fundamental rights.
In R v Ministry of Defence, ex p Smith the Court of Appeal held that, where a decision interferes with human rights, the court will require more by way of justification before it is satisfied that the decision was reasonable, an approach often called 'anxious scrutiny'. However, applying that heightened Wednesbury standard, the court held that the policy was not irrational, given the support it had in Parliament and among military authorities. The European Court later found a breach of Article 8 in Smith and Grady v UK, highlighting the limits of Wednesbury review.
Law basis: R v Ministry of Defence, ex p Smith [1996] QB 517Question 4 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
A prison policy requires all prisoners to be absent when their cells, including legally privileged correspondence, are searched, regardless of individual circumstances. Mr Daly challenges the policy under the HRA. Which of the following best describes the House of Lords' approach?
- The court applied full proportionality review and quashed the policy as a disproportionate interference.
- The greater the interference with rights, the more the court required by way of justification.Correct answer
- Proportionality applied, but it requires the court to decide the merits of the policy afresh.
- The policy was lawful, because prisoners have no rights to privacy in their cells.
- The policy was unlawful only because the governor failed to consult prisoners before adopting it.
In R (Daly) v Secretary of State for the Home Department the House of Lords held that the blanket policy unjustifiably infringed the common law right to legal professional privilege and Article 8. Lord Steyn explained that proportionality review is more intense than Wednesbury: it may require the court to assess the balance struck and the relative weight given to interests, and to consider whether the limitation is necessary. However, it does not mean a shift to merits review. Lord Cooke also commented that Wednesbury was an 'unfortunately retrogressive decision'.
Law basis: R (Daly) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2001] UKHL 26Question 5 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
HM Treasury issues a direction prohibiting all UK financial institutions from dealing with Bank Mellat, an Iranian bank, to hinder Iran's nuclear programme. Other Iranian banks are not targeted, although they present similar risks. Which of the following best describes the Supreme Court's approach?
- Wednesbury review applied, and the policy was lawful because it was not outrageous in its defiance of logic.
- It applied ordinary Wednesbury review and found the measure lawful because it was not outrageous.
- It held the measure unlawful only because the Treasury failed to give the bank prior notice.
- It held the measure unlawful because economic sanctions may only be imposed by an Act of Parliament.
- Proportionality applied, which is more intense than Wednesbury, and the blanket policy was unlawful.Correct answer
In Bank Mellat v HM Treasury (No 2) Lord Reed set out a four-stage proportionality test: whether the objective is sufficiently important to justify limiting a fundamental right; whether the measure is rationally connected to it; whether a less intrusive measure could have been used without unacceptably compromising the objective; and whether, balancing the severity of the effects against the importance of the objective, a fair balance is struck. The majority found the direction irrational and disproportionate because it singled out Bank Mellat arbitrarily. The Court also found procedural unfairness, but that was not the only defect.
Law basis: Bank Mellat v HM Treasury (No 2) [2013] UKSC 39Question 6 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
Relatives of civilians killed by British soldiers in Malaya in 1948 challenge the government's refusal to hold a public inquiry. They urge the Supreme Court to replace the Wednesbury test with proportionality as a general ground of review in all public law cases. Which of the following best describes the Court's response?
- It held the measure lawful, because national security decisions cannot be assessed for proportionality.
- It held that proportionality can never apply in domestic law outside cases involving EU law.
- It applied a four-stage proportionality test and found the measure disproportionate.Correct answer
- It held that Wednesbury applies only to decisions of local authorities, not to ministers.
- It held that the refusal was unlawful because it was disproportionate to the gravity of the killings.
In R (Keyu) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs the Supreme Court declined to hold that proportionality should replace rationality as the general test for review of executive decisions. Lord Neuberger said such a change would have potentially profound implications and would require consideration by an enlarged panel of nine justices after full argument. The refusal to hold an inquiry was not irrational. Proportionality continues to apply in HRA cases and other contexts, and Wednesbury applies to ministers as well as councils.
Law basis: R (Keyu) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2015] UKSC 69Question 7 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
A primary care trust adopts a policy of funding an unlicensed cancer drug only for patients with 'exceptional circumstances', but cannot identify any circumstances which would make one eligible patient different from another, and cost is not a factor. Ann is refused funding. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It declined to make that change, which would need a nine-justice panel and full argument.Correct answer
- It replaced Wednesbury with proportionality as the general test for all judicial review cases in England and Wales.
- The policy is lawful, because courts never review decisions about the allocation of medical resources.
- The policy is unlawful, because a health body must fund any drug a patient's doctor prescribes.
- The policy is unlawful only because Ann was not given an oral hearing before the decision.
In R (Rogers) v Swindon NHS Primary Care Trust the Court of Appeal held that a policy of funding a drug only in exceptional circumstances was irrational where the trust could not identify what would make one patient's circumstances exceptional compared with others in the same eligible group, and where cost was not a reason for refusal. The policy amounted in practice to a blanket ban with no rational basis. Courts are reluctant to interfere with resource allocation, but they will review rationality, and there is no duty to fund every prescribed drug.
Law basis: R (Rogers) v Swindon NHS Primary Care Trust [2006] EWCA Civ 392Question 8 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
A minister sets local authority spending targets using guidance on expenditure which has been approved by a resolution of the House of Commons. A council argues that the guidance is unreasonable because it bears more harshly on some authorities than others. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- Courts will review the guidance rigorously, because all local authorities are entitled to equal treatment.
- Courts will quash the guidance, because any measure that affects authorities unequally is irrational.
- Courts may not review the guidance at all, because Commons approval makes it primary legislation.
- Courts will review the guidance only if the House of Lords also approved it by resolution.
- Courts will rarely intervene for irrationality, short of bad faith, improper motive or absurdity.Correct answer
In R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Nottinghamshire County Council the House of Lords held that, where national economic policy guidance had been approved by the House of Commons, the courts should not intervene on the ground of unreasonableness unless the minister acted in bad faith, for an improper motive, or so absurdly that he must have taken leave of his senses. Such matters of political judgment are for the minister and the Commons. Commons approval did not, however, convert the guidance into primary legislation or exclude review on illegality grounds.
Law basis: R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Nottinghamshire County Council [1986] AC 240Question 9 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
Animal rights protesters repeatedly blockade a port used for live animal exports. The chief constable, with limited resources, decides to provide policing to allow exports only on two days a week. An exporter argues this is unlawful. Which of the following best describes the House of Lords' view?
- The decision was unlawful, because the police must provide whatever protection is needed for lawful trade at all times.
- The decision was unlawful, because the chief constable gave in to the threats of unlawful protesters.
- The decision was lawful, as the chief constable reasonably balanced demands on limited resources.Correct answer
- The decision was lawful only because the exporter had alternative ports available.
- The decision was unlawful because operational policing decisions must be approved by the Home Secretary.
In R v Chief Constable of Sussex, ex p International Trader's Ferry Ltd the House of Lords held that the chief constable's decision to limit policing of the port was lawful. He had to balance his duty to keep the peace and uphold the law with the finite resources available and other demands on his force. The decision was neither irrational nor, to the extent EU law applied, disproportionate. The courts give considerable latitude to operational policing decisions, which do not require ministerial approval, and there is no duty to provide unlimited protection.
Law basis: R v Chief Constable of Sussex, ex p International Trader's Ferry Ltd [1999] 2 AC 418Question 10 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
A newspaper journalist challenges the Charity Commission's refusal to disclose information about an inquiry. The Supreme Court considers the intensity of review that applies at common law where important rights such as openness and accountability are at stake. Which of the following best describes its approach?
- Wednesbury review is flexible, and its intensity depends on context and the rights involved.Correct answer
- Wednesbury review always has the same low intensity, whatever rights are affected by the decision.
- Common law review must always use full proportionality whenever any right is involved.
- Common law review is unavailable where the HRA provides a parallel remedy.
- Wednesbury review applies only to decisions of local authorities, not regulators.
In Kennedy v Charity Commission the Supreme Court emphasised that the common law, not just the Convention, protects fundamental values, and that the intensity of review under the Wednesbury principle is not fixed: it depends on the context, including the nature of the right affected and the subject matter. Lord Mance noted that the gap between common law review and proportionality may be narrower than often supposed. The HRA does not displace common law review, which applies to regulators and ministers as well as local authorities.
Law basis: Kennedy v Charity Commission [2014] UKSC 20Question 11 · Judicial review: irrationality and proportionalityDraft, pending solicitor review
A council decides to close one of two local primary schools. Parents produce expert evidence that closing the other school would have been more cost-effective. The judge hearing their judicial review privately agrees with the parents. Which of the following best describes the judge's proper approach?
- The judge should quash the decision, because the court must ensure the best decision is made.
- The judge should order the council to adopt the more cost-effective option identified by the parents' expert.
- The judge should decide the merits afresh, because education decisions affect children's rights.
- The judge must not substitute his own view; the decision stands unless unlawful or unfair.Correct answer
- The judge should quash the decision unless the council proves it was the most efficient option.
Judicial review is concerned with the legality of the decision-making process, not its merits. Under the Wednesbury and CCSU principles, a court may intervene only if the decision is illegal, irrational in the sense that no reasonable authority could have reached it, or procedurally improper. It is not enough that the judge thinks a different decision would have been better or more cost-effective. Choosing between two rational options is a matter for the decision-maker, and there is no burden on the council to prove its choice was optimal.
Law basis: Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223; Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.