Law covered in these questions
- Bill of Rights 1689, Article 9
- Buchanan v Jennings [2004] UKPC 36
- R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52
- Wason v Walter (1868) LR 4 QB 73
- Defamation Act 1996, s 15 and Sch 1
- Parliamentary Papers Act 1840, ss 1 and 3
- Stockdale v Hansard (1839) 9 Ad & E 1
- Bradlaugh v Gossett (1884) 12 QBD 271
- Church of Scientology of California v Johnson-Smith [1972] 1 QB 522
- Recall of MPs Act 2015, s 1
All 9 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
During a debate in the House of Commons, Andrea MP names a local businessman, Victor, as a fraudster. The allegation is untrue and damaging. Victor wants to sue Andrea in defamation. Which of the following best describes his position?
- His claim will succeed if he can show that Andrea spoke maliciously, because the privilege is only qualified.
- His claim will succeed, because parliamentary privilege does not cover statements about private individuals.
- His claim will fail only if the Speaker certifies that Andrea's words were relevant to the debate.
- His claim may proceed, provided the House of Commons first votes to waive its privilege for this purpose.
- His claim will fail, as Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1689 makes debates in Parliament privileged.Correct answer
Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1689 provides that the freedom of speech and debates or proceedings in Parliament ought not to be impeached or questioned in any court or place out of Parliament. Words spoken by an MP in a debate are therefore absolutely privileged; malice is irrelevant and no civil or criminal liability arises. The privilege protects Parliament's function and applies regardless of who is named. Victor's remedy, if any, lies within Parliament, for example through a complaint to the Speaker. The House cannot waive the privilege by vote for one case.
Law basis: Bill of Rights 1689, Article 9Question 2 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
Andrea MP makes a defamatory allegation about Victor in the Commons. The next day she is interviewed on local radio and says, 'I stand by what I said in Parliament', without repeating the words. Victor sues for defamation, relying on the radio interview. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- Victor cannot succeed, because any statement referring to proceedings in Parliament is absolutely privileged.
- Victor cannot succeed, because the words were not repeated in full and so there was no publication.
- Victor may succeed, because effectively adopting the words outside Parliament is not privileged.Correct answer
- Victor may succeed only if he obtains permission from the Speaker to rely on Hansard in court.
- Victor cannot succeed, because the radio station, not Andrea, is responsible for the broadcast.
Parliamentary privilege protects what is said in proceedings, not what an MP says outside Parliament. In Buchanan v Jennings the Privy Council held that an MP who later affirmed, outside the House, that he did not resile from his earlier statement made in Parliament could be liable in defamation, because the effective repetition was a fresh publication. Reference to the parliamentary record to prove what was adopted did not impeach or question proceedings. Speaker's permission is not needed, and Andrea is liable as the speaker of the words.
Law basis: Buchanan v Jennings [2004] UKPC 36Question 3 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
Three MPs are charged with false accounting for submitting fraudulent claims for parliamentary expenses. They argue that the claims were part of 'proceedings in Parliament' and that the Crown Court has no jurisdiction because only the House can deal with them. Which statement best describes the court's ruling?
- The claims are not proceedings in Parliament, so the MPs can be prosecuted in the ordinary courts.Correct answer
- The claims are proceedings in Parliament, so the MPs can only be disciplined by the House itself.
- The claims are protected by exclusive cognisance, so the prosecution requires the Speaker's consent.
- The claims are proceedings in Parliament, but the privilege is waived where criminal offences are alleged.
- The claims are not protected, but the trial must take place before the House of Lords sitting as a court.
In R v Chaytor the Supreme Court held that submitting expenses claims was not part of 'proceedings in Parliament' under Article 9, nor within the exclusive cognisance of the House. The claims were administrative matters with no connection to Parliament's core legislative and deliberative functions, and prosecuting the MPs would not inhibit freedom of speech or debate. The ordinary criminal courts therefore had jurisdiction. Parliament does not waive Article 9 privilege in criminal cases, and no consent of the Speaker is required.
Law basis: R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52Question 4 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
A newspaper publishes a fair and accurate report of a Commons debate in which an MP accused Zoe, a company director, of bribery. The allegation was false. Zoe sues the newspaper in defamation. Which of the following best describes the newspaper's defence?
- It has absolute privilege, because any report of proceedings in Parliament shares the MP's immunity from suit.
- It has no defence, because privilege attaches only to MPs and not to those who report their words.
- It has a defence only if it obtained permission from the Speaker before publishing the report.
- It has qualified privilege, which is defeated if Zoe proves the report was published with malice.Correct answer
- It has absolute privilege, but only if the report was published within 24 hours of the debate.
A fair and accurate report of proceedings in public of a legislature is protected by qualified privilege, both at common law since Wason v Walter and under section 15 and Schedule 1 of the Defamation Act 1996. The privilege is defeated if the claimant proves that the publication was made with malice. Absolute privilege attaches to the proceedings themselves and to papers published by order of Parliament, not to press reports. No permission is needed, and there is no 24-hour time limit for this defence.
Law basis: Wason v Walter (1868) LR 4 QB 73; Defamation Act 1996, s 15 and Sch 1 ↗Question 5 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
A select committee report, published by order of the House of Commons, contains criticisms of a care home company. The company sues the printers and publishers of the report for defamation. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The publishers have qualified privilege, which the company can defeat by proving that they acted with malice.
- The publishers have no protection, because privilege attaches only to words spoken in debate.
- Proceedings must be stayed on a certificate that the report was published by order of the House.Correct answer
- The publishers are protected only if the report was laid before the House of Lords as well as the Commons.
- Proceedings may continue, but the court may not award damages exceeding a statutory cap.
After Stockdale v Hansard held that a Commons resolution could not protect the publisher of a parliamentary paper, Parliament passed the Parliamentary Papers Act 1840. Section 1 provides that proceedings against persons for publication of papers printed by order of either House shall be stayed on production of a certificate confirming that the paper was so published. This gives absolute protection. Qualified privilege, defeasible by malice, applies under section 3 to extracts or abstracts of such papers, not to the authorised publication itself.
Law basis: Parliamentary Papers Act 1840, ss 1 and 3; Stockdale v Hansard (1839) 9 Ad & E 1Question 6 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
The House of Commons passes a resolution declaring that an activity carried on by MPs outside the chamber is covered by parliamentary privilege. In later litigation, Joe argues that the court is bound by the resolution. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- The court decides for itself whether a privilege exists; one House's resolution cannot change the law.Correct answer
- The court is bound by the resolution, because each House is the sole judge of the extent of its privileges.
- The court is bound only if the House of Lords has passed a similar resolution about the same activity.
- The court must refer the question to the Committee of Privileges and accept its view.
- The court is bound by the resolution only in criminal proceedings, not in civil claims.
In Stockdale v Hansard the court held that it is for the courts to determine the existence and extent of a parliamentary privilege; a resolution of one House cannot alter the law of the land. Once the courts accept that a matter falls within privilege, however, they will not interfere with how Parliament exercises it. This principle was confirmed in R v Chaytor, where the Supreme Court decided for itself whether expenses claims fell within Article 9. Neither House can extend privilege by resolution.
Law basis: Stockdale v Hansard (1839) 9 Ad & E 1; R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52Question 7 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
Bryn was elected as an MP but the Serjeant-at-Arms, acting on a resolution of the House, prevented him from entering the chamber to take the oath. He sues the Serjeant-at-Arms, arguing that the resolution was contrary to statute. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The claim succeeds, because the courts must always enforce statutory rights against officers of the House.
- The claim succeeds, because the Serjeant-at-Arms acted outside the chamber and is not protected.
- The claim fails, because officers of the House enjoy Crown immunity from civil proceedings.
- The claim fails, as the courts will not interfere with the House's regulation of its internal affairs.Correct answer
- The claim succeeds only if the House of Lords agrees that the resolution was unlawful.
In Bradlaugh v Gossett the court refused to intervene when the House of Commons resolved to exclude an elected member who wished to take the oath. Each House has exclusive cognisance over its own internal proceedings, and the court would not inquire into how the House had interpreted a statute concerning matters within its walls. This is distinct from the question of whether a claimed privilege exists at all, which is for the courts (Stockdale v Hansard). Crown immunity is irrelevant, and the Lords has no role in Commons internal affairs.
Law basis: Bradlaugh v Gossett (1884) 12 QBD 271Question 8 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
Harriet sues an MP in defamation for comments the MP made on television. To prove that the MP was acting maliciously, Harriet wants to rely on things the MP said in a Commons debate, as recorded in Hansard. Which of the following best describes whether she may do so?
- She may, because Pepper v Hart permits reference to Hansard in all civil proceedings.
- She may not, because using parliamentary statements to show malice would question proceedings in Parliament.Correct answer
- She may, because the privilege belongs to the MP, who can be taken to have waived it by speaking on television.
- She may, provided she does not allege that the MP's words in Parliament were themselves defamatory.
- She may only if the Attorney General certifies that it is in the public interest.
In Church of Scientology of California v Johnson-Smith the court held that Hansard could not be used to support an inference of malice in a defamation action about statements made outside Parliament, because that would involve questioning proceedings in Parliament contrary to Article 9. Pepper v Hart is a narrow exception permitting reference to ministers' statements to interpret ambiguous legislation, which does not question the proceedings. Privilege belongs to the House, not to an individual MP, and there is no Attorney General certificate procedure.
Law basis: Church of Scientology of California v Johnson-Smith [1972] 1 QB 522; Bill of Rights 1689, Article 9Question 9 · Parliamentary privilegeDraft, pending solicitor review
Following an investigation by the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards, the House of Commons suspends Sam MP from the House for 12 sitting days. Constituents ask whether this can lead to Sam losing his seat before the next general election. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Sam automatically loses his seat, because suspension for more than ten sitting days disqualifies an MP.
- A recall petition can be opened only if Sam has also been convicted of an offence and sentenced to a term of custody.
- Sam can lose his seat only if a majority of the House votes to expel him under its inherent powers.
- A recall petition will be opened, but the seat is vacated only if more than half of the electorate signs.
- A recall petition will be opened, and if at least 10% of eligible electors sign it the seat becomes vacant.Correct answer
Under section 1 of the Recall of MPs Act 2015 a recall petition process is triggered where, among other conditions, an MP is convicted and sentenced to custody (and not otherwise disqualified), is suspended from the House for at least 10 sitting days or 14 days following a report from the relevant committee, or is convicted of making false expenses claims. Suspension for 12 sitting days is enough. Under section 14 the petition succeeds if at least 10% of eligible registered electors sign, and the seat becomes vacant, leading to a by-election.
Law basis: Recall of MPs Act 2015, s 1 ↗More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.