Oscar's will says, 'I leave £50,000 to my brother Paul in the hope that he will give some of it to my friends.' Which statement best describes the effect on a trust of the money for the friends?
- A trust arises, because Oscar named his friends as intended recipients.
- No trust arises, because the words are precatory and show no certainty of intention to create a trust, so Paul takes the money absolutely.Correct answer
- No trust arises, because wills cannot create trusts.
- A trust arises for the friends, with Paul as trustee for half.
- A trust arises, because a will can create a trust of any sum.
An express trust needs certainty of intention, subject matter and objects. Words of hope or wish are precatory and do not show an intention to bind the recipient as trustee.
Law basis: Re Adams and the Kensington Vestry (1884) 27 Ch D 394; Knight v Knight (1840) 3 Beav 148