Law covered in these questions
- Dyer v Dyer (1788) 2 Cox 92
- Re Vandervell's Trusts (No 2) [1974] Ch 269
- Bennet v Bennet (1879) 10 Ch D 474
- Pettitt v Pettitt [1970] AC 777
- Patel v Mirza [2016] UKSC 42
- Tinsley v Milligan [1994] 1 AC 340
- Re Vinogradoff [1935] WN 68
- Fowkes v Pascoe (1875) LR 10 Ch App 343
- Barclays Bank Ltd v Quistclose Investments Ltd [1970] AC 567
- Twinsectra Ltd v Yardley [2002] UKHL 12
- [2002] 2 AC 164
- Vandervell v IRC [1967] 2 AC 291
- Re Abbott Fund Trusts [1900] 2 Ch 326
- Re Osoba [1979] 1 WLR 247
All 17 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Yasmin pays the whole £200,000 for a house that is put into the name of her friend Zara, who contributes nothing. There is no discussion of the arrangement. Which statement best describes the beneficial ownership?
- Yasmin has no claim, because there was no written agreement.
- Zara owns the house, because she is the legal owner.
- Zara owns it, because the presumption of advancement applies between friends.
- They share it equally, because they are friends.
- A purchase money resulting trust arises in Yasmin's favour, because she provided the whole price and the presumption is that the legal owner holds the property for her.Correct answer
Where a person pays the purchase price of property put into another's name, the law presumes a resulting trust for the payer. The presumption of advancement applies only to certain relationships, such as a husband to wife or a parent to a child, and is of limited force.
Law basis: Dyer v Dyer (1788) 2 Cox 92; Re Vandervell's Trusts (No 2) [1974] Ch 269Question 2 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Egon buys a flat for £250,000 with his own money and has it registered in the sole name of his 22-year-old daughter Freya. Nothing is said about the arrangement. Egon now claims the flat is his. There is no other evidence of his intention. Which of the following best describes the likely beneficial ownership?
- Freya is likely to own the flat under the presumption of advancement.Correct answer
- Egon owns the flat under a presumed resulting trust, because he provided the whole price.
- Egon owns the flat, because the presumption of advancement was abolished by the Equality Act 2010.
- Freya owns the flat only if she can show that Egon intended an outright gift to her.
- They share the flat equally, because family members are presumed to intend joint ownership.
Where a person pays for property put into another's name, equity presumes a resulting trust, unless the relationship raises the presumption of advancement. A transfer or purchase by a father for his child raises the presumption of advancement, so the child is presumed to take beneficially, though modern courts regard the presumption as weak and easily rebutted, as Pettitt v Pettitt indicates. Section 199 of the Equality Act 2010 would abolish the presumption, but it has not been brought into force. With no other evidence, Freya is presumed to take beneficially. The resulting trust answer would be correct if Egon had bought the flat for an unrelated person.
Law basis: Bennet v Bennet (1879) 10 Ch D 474; Pettitt v Pettitt [1970] AC 777Question 3 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Gina and Hassan buy a house together with equal contributions, but register it in Hassan's sole name so that Gina can make false benefit claims as a non-owner. Gina's claims are later discovered and she repays the money. The couple separate and Hassan argues that Gina's claim to a half share is barred by illegality. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- Gina's claim is barred, because she cannot establish her interest without relying on her illegal purpose.
- Gina's claim is barred, because any equitable claim tainted by fraud fails under the clean hands maxim.
- Gina's claim succeeds only if she can prove her interest without referring to the house purchase.
- The court will weigh the policy factors set out in Patel v Mirza, and Gina's claim is likely to succeed.Correct answer
- Gina's claim succeeds automatically, because illegality is no defence to a claim under a resulting trust.
In Tinsley v Milligan, on similar facts, the House of Lords allowed the claim because the claimant could rely on the presumption of resulting trust without pleading the illegality. That reliance test was replaced in Patel v Mirza, where the Supreme Court held that the court should consider the underlying purpose of the prohibition, any other relevant public policies, and whether denial of the claim would be a proportionate response to the illegality. Here the fraud has been repaid and the illegality is collateral to the acquisition, so denying Gina's beneficial interest would be disproportionate. The reliance test is therefore no longer the law, and illegality is not automatically irrelevant.
Law basis: Patel v Mirza [2016] UKSC 42; Tinsley v Milligan [1994] 1 AC 340Question 4 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ilse transfers £60,000 of government stock that she owns into the joint names of herself and her four-year-old granddaughter Jana. Ilse continues to receive the interest. On Ilse's death, Jana claims the stock by survivorship. There is no evidence of Ilse's intention. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Jana owns the stock beneficially, because she became sole legal owner by survivorship.
- Jana owns the stock beneficially, because a grandmother's transfer raises the presumption of advancement.
- Jana owns half the stock, because property in joint names is presumed to be shared equally.
- Jana holds the stock on trust for Ilse's estate only if Ilse's will expressly mentions the stock.
- Jana holds the stock on resulting trust for Ilse's estate.Correct answer
Where personal property is voluntarily transferred into the name of another, or into joint names, equity presumes a resulting trust for the transferor unless the presumption is rebutted or the presumption of advancement applies. In Re Vinogradoff a grandmother who transferred stock into the joint names of herself and her granddaughter was held to have retained the beneficial interest, so after her death the granddaughter, as surviving legal owner, held it on resulting trust for her estate. The presumption of advancement applies to a father or person in loco parentis, not ordinarily to a grandmother. Survivorship affects only the legal title.
Law basis: Re Vinogradoff [1935] WN 68Question 5 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Kamil, a wealthy man with no children, buys shares in the joint names of himself and his young housekeeper's son Leo, whom he treats like a grandson. Witnesses say that Kamil repeatedly told them at the time that the shares were 'for Leo when I'm gone'. Kamil dies. His executors claim the shares on a resulting trust. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The executors succeed, because the presumption of resulting trust can be rebutted only by documents.
- The presumption of resulting trust is likely to be rebutted by evidence that Kamil intended a gift.Correct answer
- The executors succeed, because statements made after the purchase are always inadmissible.
- Leo succeeds only because Kamil stood in loco parentis, raising the presumption of advancement.
- The executors succeed, because a gift to take effect on death must comply with the Wills Act 1837.
The presumption of resulting trust is only a starting point and can be rebutted by evidence of the transferor's actual intention. In Fowkes v Pascoe the Court of Appeal held that the presumption was rebutted where an elderly woman bought stock in the joint names of herself and her daughter-in-law's son, because the surrounding circumstances showed an intention to make a gift. Contemporaneous statements are admissible evidence of intention, and oral evidence suffices. The gift was an immediate gift of a joint interest carrying survivorship, not a testamentary gift, so the Wills Act is not engaged. It is unnecessary to rely on any presumption of advancement.
Law basis: Fowkes v Pascoe (1875) LR 10 Ch App 343Question 6 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Mila uses £40,000 of her own savings to buy shares registered in the sole name of her husband Niall. She gives no explanation. When they separate, Mila claims the shares. Which of the following best describes the presumed position?
- Niall is presumed to own the shares, because a gift between spouses is presumed.
- Niall is presumed to own the shares, because the presumption of advancement applies between spouses.
- Niall is presumed to hold the shares on resulting trust for Mila.Correct answer
- The shares are presumed to be owned equally, because they are matrimonial property.
- Niall is presumed to own the shares, because shares registered in a name belong to the registered holder.
The presumption of advancement has traditionally applied to transfers by a husband to his wife, but not by a wife to her husband. A wife's purchase in her husband's name therefore raises the ordinary presumption of resulting trust in her favour. Mila provided the whole price, so Niall is presumed to hold the shares on resulting trust for her unless he can show that she intended a gift. In practice the presumptions are weak and easily displaced by evidence, and on divorce the court's financial remedy powers will usually be more important. The answer that the presumption of advancement applies between spouses ignores its traditional one-way operation.
Law basis: Pettitt v Pettitt [1970] AC 777Question 7 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ottoline lends £1 million to Penhall Ltd on the express terms that it is to be used only to pay a declared dividend to the company's shareholders. Penhall pays the money into a separate account but goes into liquidation before the dividend is paid. The liquidator claims the money for the general creditors. Which of the following best describes Ottoline's position?
- Ottoline is an unsecured creditor, because the money was advanced as a loan.
- Ottoline can recover the money only if she registered a charge over the separate account.
- The money must be paid to the shareholders, because the dividend had been declared.
- The money belongs to the company, because it was paid into an account in its name.
- Ottoline can recover it, because it is held on trust for her.Correct answer
In Barclays Bank Ltd v Quistclose Investments Ltd the House of Lords held that money lent for the sole purpose of paying a dividend was held on trust. When the purpose failed because of the company's liquidation, the money was held for the lender and did not form part of the company's assets. A loan and a trust can coexist: the recipient is not free to use the money as its own. The shareholders had no claim, because the trust was for the purpose, and on failure the beneficial interest was with the lender. No registered charge is needed, because the lender's interest arises under a trust, not a security.
Law basis: Barclays Bank Ltd v Quistclose Investments Ltd [1970] AC 567Question 8 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Quarry Finance lends £1 million to a borrower through the borrower's solicitor, who gives an undertaking that the money will be 'utilised solely for the acquisition of property' and for no other purpose. The solicitor pays the money to the borrower, who uses it for other purposes. Which of the following best describes the nature of the lender's interest in the money?
- The money belonged absolutely to the borrower, subject only to a contractual claim by the lender.
- The money was held on a purpose trust that failed for want of an ascertainable beneficiary.
- It was held on trust for the lender, subject to a power to apply it.Correct answer
- The money was held on trust for the property seller, as the intended recipient.
- The money was held on a constructive trust for the lender only after it was misapplied.
In Twinsectra Ltd v Yardley the House of Lords held that money lent on terms that it was to be used solely for a stated purpose was held on a Quistclose trust. Lord Millett explained that the beneficial interest remains with the lender throughout, subject to a power or mandate for the recipient to apply the money for the stated purpose; the trust is a resulting trust for the lender. That avoids the objection that it is an invalid purpose trust, and explains why the purpose need not be charitable. The trust arose on receipt, not only when the money was misapplied, which is why the final answer is wrong.
Law basis: Twinsectra Ltd v Yardley [2002] UKHL 12; [2002] 2 AC 164Question 9 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Raymond transfers shares to a college so that the college can receive dividends, and gives an option to repurchase the shares to a trustee company he controls, without stating on what trusts the trustee company is to hold the option. The tax authority argues that Raymond retained a beneficial interest in the option. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The trustee company holds the option beneficially, because Raymond made an outright gift of it.
- The college holds the option on trust, because it received the shares to which the option relates.
- Raymond retains no interest, because he intended to divest himself of the whole interest.
- The trustee company holds the option on resulting trust for Raymond, because its trusts were not declared.Correct answer
- The option is held on trust for Raymond's children, because the trustee company administers their settlement.
In Vandervell v IRC the option was transferred to a trustee company without any declaration of the trusts on which it was to be held. The House of Lords held that, since the trustee company was not intended to take beneficially and the beneficial interest had not been disposed of, it was held on resulting trust for Vandervell. This was a resulting trust of the automatic kind, arising because the beneficial interest was left undisposed of, regardless of the transferor's wish to divest himself completely. That is why the answer based on his intention to give everything away fails. The later events concerning the children's settlement belong to Re Vandervell's Trusts (No 2).
Law basis: Vandervell v IRC [1967] 2 AC 291Question 10 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
After a local accident, a group of friends collect £18,000 from named donors 'for the maintenance of Mrs Rees and her sister' who were left destitute. Both sisters have now died, and £6,000 is left over. The sisters' estates claim the surplus. Which of the following best describes who is entitled to it?
- The donors are entitled under a resulting trust, rateably.Correct answer
- The sisters' estates are entitled, because the fund was given for their benefit.
- The Crown is entitled, because the donors parted with the money outright.
- The collectors are entitled, because they organised the fund and hold legal title.
- The surplus must be applied cy-près, because the relief of destitution is charitable.
Whether a surplus goes to the beneficiaries or back to the donors depends on construction. In Re Abbott Fund Trusts a fund collected for the maintenance of two deaf and dumb ladies was held not to be an absolute gift to them; once they had both died, the surplus was held on resulting trust for the subscribers rateably. The purpose was to provide for the sisters' maintenance, not to give them the capital. Cy-près is not available, because the fund was for two named individuals and so was not charitable. Re Osoba illustrates the opposite construction, where the purpose is merely the motive for an absolute gift.
Law basis: Re Abbott Fund Trusts [1900] 2 Ch 326Question 11 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Sorrel's will leaves her residue to her widowed sister-in-law 'for her maintenance and for the training of my daughter Tamsin up to university grade'. The sister-in-law has died and Tamsin has finished her university education. There is money left over. Which of the following best describes who is entitled to the surplus?
- Sorrel's estate is entitled under a resulting trust, because the stated purposes have been fulfilled.
- Tamsin is likely to be entitled, because the purpose stated was only the motive for the gift.Correct answer
- The sister-in-law's estate is entitled, because she was the first named recipient.
- The surplus must be held on trust for the education of Tamsin's own children.
- The Crown is entitled, because nobody is beneficially entitled to the surplus.
Where property is given for the benefit of named persons and a purpose is stated, the court asks whether the purpose was merely the motive for an absolute gift. In Re Osoba the Court of Appeal held that a gift for a widow's maintenance and the training of the testator's daughter up to university grade was an absolute gift to them, the purposes being the motive. Once the widow had died, the daughter, as survivor, took the whole fund absolutely, including the surplus. This contrasts with Re Abbott Fund Trusts, where the construction led to a resulting trust for donors. The resulting trust answer applies that contrasting construction.
Law basis: Re Osoba [1979] 1 WLR 247Question 12 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
A company pension scheme, funded by contributions from both the employer and the members, is wound up with a large surplus after all benefits are secured. A clause purporting to deal with the surplus is void for perpetuity. Which of the following best describes who is entitled to the surplus?
- It passes to the Crown as bona vacantia, because the members received all their contractual benefits.
- It belongs entirely to the employer, because the scheme was established for its business purposes.
- It belongs entirely to the members, because pension funds are held for their exclusive benefit.
- It is held on resulting trust for the employer and members in proportion to their contributions.Correct answer
- It must be applied cy-près for the benefit of pensioners generally.
In Air Jamaica Ltd v Charlton the Privy Council held that a pension fund surplus that was not effectively disposed of was held on resulting trust for the employer and the members in proportion to their contributions. The members had not received all they bargained for in a sense that excluded a resulting trust, and a resulting trust of this kind arises regardless of intention where the beneficial interest is not fully disposed of. Lord Millett rejected the view that the surplus went to the Crown, which had been the outcome in some earlier cases. Cy-près applies only to charitable funds, so it is not available here.
Law basis: Air Jamaica Ltd v Charlton [1999] 1 WLR 1399Question 13 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ulrich buys a house in his sole name for his partner Vesna and himself, paying the deposit and taking out the mortgage alone. After moving in, Vesna pays the removal costs and, for two years, half of each mortgage instalment. Vesna claims a share under a resulting trust. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- She has a resulting trust share proportionate to the mortgage payments she made.
- She has a resulting trust share equal to half the equity, because she paid half the mortgage.
- Her resulting trust claim is likely to fail.Correct answer
- She has a resulting trust share proportionate to the removal costs and the mortgage payments.
- Her claim under a resulting trust fails, because a resulting trust can never arise between partners.
A purchase money resulting trust arises from contributions to the purchase price at the time of acquisition. In Curley v Parkes the Court of Appeal held that payments made after the purchase, such as later mortgage instalments or removal costs, do not give rise to a resulting trust, because the beneficial interest is fixed when the property is acquired. Such payments may be relevant to a common intention constructive trust, under which the court considers the whole course of dealing, but Vesna has not brought that claim. Resulting trusts can arise between partners, so the final answer overstates the rule.
Law basis: Curley v Parkes [2004] EWCA Civ 1515Question 14 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Wilma and her adult daughter Xia buy a flat as an investment to let out. It is registered in their joint names. Wilma pays the deposit, and both are jointly liable on the mortgage, which is paid from the rent. When they fall out, Xia argues that, as joint legal owners, they are presumed to be equal beneficial owners under Stack v Dowden. Which of the following best describes the likely approach?
- Shares are likely to follow contributions, as for a resulting trust.Correct answer
- The court must presume equal shares, because the flat is in joint names.
- The court must apply Stack v Dowden, because the parties are family members.
- The court must divide the flat according to their current incomes.
- The court must order sale and divide the proceeds equally under TOLATA 1996.
The Stack v Dowden starting point of equal shares for joint names applies in the domestic consumer context of a family home. In Laskar v Laskar the Court of Appeal held that where a mother and daughter bought a property primarily as an investment, resulting trust principles were more appropriate, so their shares reflected their contributions. Assumption of joint liability on the mortgage counts as a contribution. Wilma's payment of the deposit and the shared mortgage liability will therefore determine the shares. The tempting answer relies on the family relationship, but the purpose of the purchase, not the relationship, is what matters.
Law basis: Laskar v Laskar [2008] EWCA Civ 347; Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17Question 15 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Yew Bank pays £2 million to a local authority under an interest rate swap that is later held to be void because it was beyond the authority's powers. The authority has spent the money and is solvent. The bank claims that it held the money on resulting trust from the moment of payment, so that it can claim compound interest. Which of the following best describes the position?
- A resulting trust arose on payment, because the contract was void from the outset.
- No resulting trust arose, so the bank's claim is a personal claim in unjust enrichment.Correct answer
- A resulting trust arose once the authority discovered that the contract was void.
- A constructive trust arose on payment, because the authority received the money by mistake.
- A resulting trust arose, but only for the part of the money still held by the authority.
In Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale v Islington LBC the House of Lords held that money paid under a void swap contract was not held on resulting trust. The bank intended to part with the beneficial interest in the money, and the authority's conscience was not affected when it received the money in ignorance of the invalidity, so no trust arose. By the time it discovered the problem the money had been spent and was no longer identifiable. The bank's remedy was a personal claim in restitution. Lord Browne-Wilkinson classified resulting trusts as arising from presumed intention or from failure of an express trust.
Law basis: Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale v Islington LBC [1996] AC 669Question 16 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Zbigniew, a wealthy businessman, transfers several houses for no consideration into the names of companies that he wholly owns and controls. On his divorce, his wife seeks orders against the houses, and the companies argue that they are the beneficial owners. The companies give no credible explanation for the transfers. Which of the following best describes the likely position?
- The companies own the houses, because a company is a separate legal person.
- The companies own the houses, unless the court pierces the corporate veil.
- The houses belong to the wife, because they were acquired during the marriage.
- The companies hold the houses on constructive trust for the wife.
- The companies are likely to hold the houses on resulting trust for Zbigniew.Correct answer
In Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd the Supreme Court refused to pierce the corporate veil, because the husband had not used the companies to evade an existing obligation. However, it held that the companies held the properties on resulting trust for the husband. Properties had been transferred for no consideration and the companies offered no credible explanation, so the court drew the inference that the husband was the beneficial owner. The houses could therefore be dealt with as his property in financial remedy proceedings. The separate legal personality answer is correct as a principle but does not answer the trust question.
Law basis: Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd [2013] UKSC 34Question 17 · Resulting trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Before marrying Cosmo, Dalia's father settled £100,000 on trustees for Dalia and Cosmo for life, then for their children, expressly in consideration of the marriage. The marriage is later annulled as void, and there are no children. The trustees ask who is entitled to the fund. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The fund belongs to Dalia and Cosmo equally, because they were the life tenants.
- The fund belongs to Dalia alone, because the settlement was made by her family.
- The fund is held on resulting trust for the father or his estate.Correct answer
- The fund passes to the Crown as bona vacantia, because no children were born.
- The fund is held on the original trusts, because a void marriage does not affect the settlement.
Where a settlement is made in consideration of a marriage and the marriage is void, the consideration wholly fails and the beneficial interests cannot take effect as intended. In Re Ames' Settlement the court held that the fund was held on resulting trust for the settlor's estate, because the settlement was made on the basis that there would be a valid marriage. The spouses could not keep the benefit, since there was no marriage at all. The answer relying on the life interests overlooks that those interests were premised on a valid marriage. Bona vacantia is irrelevant where a resulting trust identifies who is entitled.
Law basis: Re Ames' Settlement [1946] Ch 217More Trusts Law topics
Back to all Trusts Law questions, or sit a timed mock.