HomeTrusts LawCertainty of objects

Trusts Law · FLK2

Certainty of objects: SQE1 notes and practice questions

Key rules, exam traps and 13 single best answer questions on certainty of objects, with the answer explained and the law behind each one.

  • 3,641 SQE1 questions across all 14 subjects, in the exam's single best answer format
  • Reviewed by a team of qualified solicitors, with the case or statute behind every answer
  • Full 85-question FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks, built for the January 2027 format
  • Progress tracked topic by topic, so you revise what you actually get wrong
  • Start free: all notes and guides plus a sample question in every topic, no card needed
  • Solicitor-reviewed questions
  • Law cited on every answer
  • One-off payment, no auto-renewal
  • Secure Stripe checkout
Full SQE1 question bank
from£35£35 £24.50one-off
Black Friday: 30% off, up to 80% on bigger basketsUnlock all 3,641 questions

No auto-renewal · instant access · or try free sample questions

Revision notes

At a glanceWhich certainty of objects test applies to which disposition
IRC v Broadway CottagesFixed trustA complete list of every beneficiary must be capable of being drawn up.
McPhail v DoultonDiscretionary trust'Is or is not' test: can it be said of any given person that they are or are not in the class?
Re Gulbenkian; Re HayPower of appointmentSame 'is or is not' test; width alone does not invalidate a power.
Re BarlowCondition precedentValid if one person can be shown to qualify, e.g. 'any friends' buying paintings.
Re Baden (No 2)Conceptual v evidentialClass must be conceptually certain; difficulty proving membership does not invalidate. 'Relatives' passes, 'good friends' does not.
ex p West Yorkshire MCCAdministrative unworkabilityDiscretionary trust for a vast class, such as all inhabitants of West Yorkshire, fails.

Key rules

The test depends on the type of disposition.

Disposition Test Authority
Fixed trust (e.g. "equally among") Complete list of all beneficiaries must be capable of being drawn up IRC v Broadway Cottages Trust [1955]
Discretionary trust "Is or is not" test: can it be said of any given person that they are or are not in the class? McPhail v Doulton [1971]
Mere power of appointment "Is or is not" test Re Gulbenkian's Settlements [1970]
Gift subject to condition precedent Can one person be shown to qualify? Re Barlow's Will Trusts [1979]
Condition subsequent (forfeiture) Must be clear from the outset precisely what causes forfeiture Clayton v Ramsden [1943]
  • Conceptual v evidential certainty. The class must be conceptually certain (clearly defined words). Evidential difficulty in proving that a person is in the class does not invalidate the trust (Re Baden's Deed Trusts (No 2) [1973]). "Relatives" and "dependants" are conceptually certain; "good friends" is not.
  • Administrative unworkability. A discretionary trust can fail if the class is so wide that it cannot form "anything like a class", e.g. all 2.5 million inhabitants of West Yorkshire (R v District Auditor, ex p West Yorkshire MCC (1986)). Width alone does not invalidate a power (Re Hay's Settlement Trusts [1982]).
  • Capriciousness may invalidate a power where the class has no sensible connection with the settlor (Re Manisty's Settlement [1974]).
  • Resolving doubt by a third party. A clause allowing a named person (e.g. the Chief Rabbi) to decide whether a condition is met can cure uncertainty (Re Tuck's Settlement Trusts [1978]).
  • Missing beneficiaries. If a fixed-trust beneficiary cannot be traced, the trustees can obtain a Re Benjamin order (1902) allowing distribution as if they were dead.
  • If discretionary trustees fail to act, the court can execute the trust in the way best suited to the settlor's intention, e.g. appointing new trustees or directing a scheme (McPhail v Doulton).

How it is tested

  • Lost records in a fixed trust. "Equally among all employees since 1990" where records are destroyed: fails because no complete list can be drawn up.
  • Discretionary class with proof problems. A claimant cannot prove he is a relative. The trust remains valid; the trustees simply do not treat him as a member.
  • "Friends" as a condition. A right for "any friends" to buy paintings is a series of individual gifts subject to a condition precedent; Re Barlow applies and it is valid.
  • Very wide class. A non-charitable discretionary trust for an entire county's inhabitants fails for administrative unworkability.

Exam traps

  • Applying the "is or is not" test to a fixed trust. Fixed trusts still need a complete list.
  • Treating evidential uncertainty as fatal. Only conceptual uncertainty defeats the trust.
  • Saying a power fails because the class is wide. Width defeats discretionary trusts (unworkability), not mere powers (Re Hay).
  • Using Re Barlow's relaxed test for a discretionary trust; it applies only to individual gifts subject to a condition precedent.
  • Forgetting that a forfeiture clause void for uncertainty leaves the beneficiary with the gift free of the condition.

Quick check

Remember: fixed trusts need a complete list; discretionary trusts and powers need only the "is or is not" test, and only conceptual (not evidential) uncertainty is fatal.

Law covered in these questions

  • IRC v Broadway Cottages Trust [1955] Ch 20
  • McPhail v Doulton [1971] AC 424
  • Re Baden's Deed Trusts (No 2) [1973] Ch 9
  • Re Barlow's Will Trusts [1979] 1 WLR 278
  • R v District Auditor, ex p West Yorkshire Metropolitan County Council (1986) 26 RVR 24
  • Re Gulbenkian's Settlements [1970] AC 508
  • Re Hay's Settlement Trusts [1982] 1 WLR 202
  • Re Tuck's Settlement Trusts [1978] Ch 49
  • Clayton v Ramsden [1943] AC 320
  • Re Benjamin [1902] 1 Ch 723

Worked answer: 1 free sample question

Try it above first, then read the worked answer below. Members get every certainty of objects question.

Question 1 · Certainty of objects✓ Solicitor reviewed

Quinn settles £500,000 on trustees to divide 'equally among all persons employed by Quinn Engineering Ltd at any time since 1990'. The company's personnel records before 2010 were destroyed in a flood, and the trustees cannot identify many former employees. Which of the following best describes the validity of the trust?

  1. The trust is valid, because the trustees need only be able to say whether any given person is an employee.
  2. The trust is valid, because the trustees can divide the fund among those employees they can trace.
  3. The trust is valid, but the trustees must hold the shares of untraced employees on resulting trust.
  4. The trust fails, because a class of employees is conceptually uncertain.
  5. The trust fails, because a fixed trust requires a complete list of beneficiaries to be drawn up.Correct answer

Members

12 more certainty of objects questions with full answers

Unlock all 3,641 solicitor-reviewed questions, full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks and the practice builder. From £35, one-off, no auto-renewal.

More Trusts Law topics

Back to all Trusts Law questions, or sit a timed mock.

What you get

Everything you need to practise for SQE1, from £35

One-off payment, no subscription. Every question, every mock and every member tool unlocks the moment you pay.

Every subject covered

3,641 questions across all 14 SQE1 subjects and every topic in the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) specification.

Built like the real exam

Five options, one single best answer, client-based scenarios: the format SQE1 uses.

The law behind every answer

Each answer cites the case or statute that decides it. Statute questions link to legislation.gov.uk.

Timed FLK1 and FLK2 mocks

Full 85-question sessions at exam pace (2 hours 33 minutes), matching the January 2027 format.

See your weak topics

Your score is tracked by topic, so your next study session goes where the marks are.

Checked by solicitors

Every question is reviewed by a team of qualified solicitors in England and Wales.

Why it matters: SQE1 costs £2,006 per attempt, and only 53% of candidates passed both papers in January 2026. A few weeks of exam-format practice costs a fraction of one resit. See pass rates.

1 month

Black Friday −30%
£35£35 £24.50one-off

£35 a month · A focused final push before your sitting.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 30 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 1 month for £35
Most popular

3 months

Black Friday −30%
£79£79 £55.30one-off

About £26 a month · The most popular length for one SQE1 sitting.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 90 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 3 months for £79

6 months

Black Friday −30%
£129£129 £90.30one-off

About £21.50 a month · Time to study steadily, sit, and resit if needed.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 180 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 6 months for £129
  • Solicitor-reviewed questions
  • Law cited on every answer
  • One-off payment, no auto-renewal
  • Secure Stripe checkout