Quinn settles £500,000 on trustees to divide 'equally among all persons employed by Quinn Engineering Ltd at any time since 1990'. The company's personnel records before 2010 were destroyed in a flood, and the trustees cannot identify many former employees. Which of the following best describes the validity of the trust?
- The trust is valid, because the trustees need only be able to say whether any given person is an employee.
- The trust is valid, because the trustees can divide the fund among those employees they can trace.
- The trust is valid, but the trustees must hold the shares of untraced employees on resulting trust.
- The trust fails, because a class of employees is conceptually uncertain.
- The trust fails, because a fixed trust requires a complete list of beneficiaries to be drawn up.Correct answer
For a fixed trust, where each beneficiary takes a defined share, the trustees must be able to compile a complete list of beneficiaries, otherwise they cannot calculate each share. This 'complete list' test was applied in IRC v Broadway Cottages Trust and survives McPhail v Doulton, which relaxed the test only for discretionary trusts. 'Employees of a company' is conceptually certain, so the trust does not fail on that ground, but the loss of records means the class cannot be fully listed, so the fixed trust fails. The 'is or is not' test is the tempting answer, but it applies to discretionary trusts and powers, not fixed trusts.
Law basis: IRC v Broadway Cottages Trust [1955] Ch 20; McPhail v Doulton [1971] AC 424