The trustees of the Fellowship of the Quiet Way, a religious group, apply to register as a charity. They argue that, because their purpose is the advancement of religion, they need not show any public benefit. Which of the following best describes the position under the Charities Act 2011?
- They need not show public benefit, because it is presumed for the advancement of religion.
- They need not show public benefit, because religion was a head of charity under Pemsel.
- They must show public benefit only if the group charges fees for its services.
- They must show public benefit only if the group has fewer than 100 members.
- They must show public benefit, because it is not presumed for any charitable purpose.Correct answer
Under s2(1) of the Charities Act 2011, a charitable purpose must fall within the descriptions in s3(1) and be for the public benefit. Section 4(2) provides that it is not to be presumed that a purpose of a particular description is for the public benefit. That removed the old common law presumption that trusts for the relief of poverty, education and religion were for the public benefit. The group must therefore show both a benefit and that it is available to the public or a sufficient section of it. The answer relying on Pemsel is tempting, because religion was one of Lord Macnaghten's four heads, but the 2011 Act now governs.
Law basis: Charities Act 2011, ss2, 3 and 4 ↗