Law covered in these questions
- Re Astor's Settlement Trusts [1952] Ch 534
- Morice v Bishop of Durham (1805) 10 Ves 522
- Re Endacott [1960] Ch 232
- Re Denley's Trust Deed [1969] 1 Ch 373
- Re Hooper [1932] 1 Ch 38
- Re Dean (1889) 41 Ch D 552
- Pettingall v Pettingall (1842) 11 LJ Ch 176
- Re Recher's Will Trusts [1972] Ch 526
- Neville Estates Ltd v Madden [1962] Ch 832
- Re Grant's Will Trusts [1980] 1 WLR 360
- Re Lipinski's Will Trusts [1976] Ch 235
- Re Bucks Constabulary Widows' and Orphans' Fund Friendly Society (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 936
- Re West Sussex Constabulary's Widows, Children and Benevolent (1930) Fund Trusts [1971] Ch 1
- Re Shaw [1957] 1 WLR 729
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Delia settles £1 million on trustees to apply the income for 'the maintenance of good understanding between nations and the preservation of the independence of newspapers'. The purposes are not charitable, and no individual beneficiaries are named. Which of the following best describes the validity of the trust?
- The trust is valid, because the Attorney General can enforce any trust for public purposes.
- The trust is valid, because the trustees are under a clear moral obligation to carry it out.
- The trust is valid, but only for the perpetuity period of 125 years.
- The trust is void, because no beneficiary can enforce it.Correct answer
- The trust is void only as to the newspapers, because that purpose benefits private companies.
The beneficiary principle requires a private trust to have beneficiaries who can enforce it, so that the court can control its administration. In Re Astor's Settlement Trusts a trust for very similar purposes was held void, both because there was no one to enforce it and because the purposes were too uncertain. The Attorney General enforces charitable trusts only, so the answer relying on him is wrong for a non-charitable trust. The 125-year perpetuity period under the Perpetuities and Accumulations Act 2009 applies to interests under trusts, not to non-charitable purpose trusts, which remain subject to the common law rule against inalienability.
Law basis: Re Astor's Settlement Trusts [1952] Ch 534; Morice v Bishop of Durham (1805) 10 Ves 522Question 2 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Edgar's will leaves his residuary estate to the parish council 'for the purpose of providing some useful memorial to myself'. The council wishes to use the money for a memorial garden. Edgar's next of kin claim the residue. Which of the following best describes the gift?
- The gift is valid, because a memorial is a recognised exception to the beneficiary principle.
- The gift is valid, because a parish council can enforce a trust for local purposes.
- The gift is valid, because a memorial garden would be a charitable purpose for the public.
- The gift is valid, provided it is spent within the 21-year perpetuity period.
- The gift is void as a non-charitable purpose trust outside the exceptions.Correct answer
The anomalous exceptions to the beneficiary principle cover trusts for the erection or maintenance of particular tombs and monuments, the care of specific animals, and a few other narrow categories. In Re Endacott the Court of Appeal held that a gift of residue to a parish council 'for the purpose of providing some useful memorial to myself' was not within the monument exception, because it was too wide and uncertain, and it was not charitable because it was intended to commemorate the testator rather than benefit the public. The residue therefore passed on resulting trust to the next of kin. The court refused to extend the anomalous exceptions.
Law basis: Re Endacott [1960] Ch 232Question 3 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Felix, owner of Felix Foods Ltd, transfers a sports field to trustees 'to be maintained and used as a recreation ground for the benefit of the employees of Felix Foods Ltd and, secondarily, such other persons as the trustees allow', for a period ending 20 years after the death of the last survivor of the descendants of King Charles III now living. A shareholder argues that the trust is an invalid purpose trust. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The trust is void, because a trust for the maintenance of land is a purpose trust without beneficiaries.
- The trust is valid only as a charitable trust for the recreation of the public.
- The trust is void, because 'such other persons as the trustees allow' is conceptually uncertain.
- The trust is valid, but only for 21 years from Felix's death.
- The trust is likely to be valid, because it directly benefits ascertainable individuals.Correct answer
In Re Denley's Trust Deed Goff J upheld a very similar trust of a sports ground for employees. He held that the beneficiary principle is aimed at purpose trusts that are abstract or impersonal; where a trust, though expressed as a purpose, is directly or indirectly for the benefit of ascertainable individuals, it is outside the mischief and valid, because those individuals have locus standi to enforce it. The trust here is limited to a valid perpetuity period by reference to lives in being, so it does not offend the rule against inalienability. The objection that it is a purpose trust is tempting, but the employees receive a direct and tangible benefit.
Law basis: Re Denley's Trust Deed [1969] 1 Ch 373Question 4 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Gwyneth's will leaves £5,000 to trustees to maintain the graves of her parents in the village churchyard 'for so long as they legally can'. The graves are not part of the church fabric. Her residuary beneficiary argues that the gift is void. Which of the following best describes the gift?
- The gift is void, because a trust to maintain graves has no beneficiary who can enforce it.
- The gift is valid indefinitely, because the upkeep of graves is a charitable purpose.
- The gift is valid for 125 years, because that is the statutory perpetuity period.
- The gift is valid for 21 years as an anomalous trust for particular graves.Correct answer
- The gift is void, because the trustees cannot know how long the law allows them to act.
Trusts for the erection and maintenance of particular tombs and monuments are among the anomalous exceptions to the beneficiary principle. In Re Hooper a gift to maintain family graves 'so far as they legally can' was upheld for 21 years, the period allowed under the rule against inalienability. The maintenance of a private grave is not charitable unless it forms part of the fabric of a church, so the gift cannot last indefinitely. The 125-year period under the Perpetuities and Accumulations Act 2009 governs the vesting of interests under trusts, not the duration of non-charitable purpose trusts, which is why the 125-year answer is wrong.
Law basis: Re Hooper [1932] 1 Ch 38Question 5 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Hedda's will leaves £20,000 to trustees to provide for the care and feeding of her two horses and her dog for the rest of their lives. The residuary legatee argues that the gift fails for want of a human beneficiary. Which of the following best describes the gift?
- The gift is void, because animals cannot be beneficiaries and no person can enforce it.
- The gift is likely to be valid as an anomalous purpose trust, within the perpetuity period.Correct answer
- The gift is valid indefinitely, because the welfare of animals is a charitable purpose.
- The gift is valid only if Hedda's executors agree to supervise the trustees.
- The gift is void, because the animals' lives are not lives in being for perpetuity purposes.
Trusts for the maintenance of specific animals are a recognised anomalous exception to the beneficiary principle, as in Re Dean and Pettingall v Pettingall. Such a trust is not charitable, because it benefits particular animals rather than promoting animal welfare for the public, so it must comply with the rule against inalienability. Since an animal's life is not a life in being for this purpose, the trust is generally treated as valid for up to 21 years. The answer that the gift is void because no person can enforce it states the general rule but ignores the exception, and the residuary legatee can in practice supervise performance.
Law basis: Re Dean (1889) 41 Ch D 552; Pettingall v Pettingall (1842) 11 LJ Ch 176Question 6 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivor's will leaves £10,000 'to the Riverside Angling Club', an unincorporated members' club whose rules allow the members in general meeting to change the rules and wind up the club and divide its assets. The will says nothing more. Which of the following best describes the gift?
- It is likely to be valid as a gift to the members on the terms of the club's rules.Correct answer
- It is void, because an unincorporated association cannot own property.
- It is void, because it is a purpose trust for angling with no human beneficiaries.
- It is valid only as a gift to the present members as joint tenants, free of the rules.
- It is valid only if the club registers as a charity within a reasonable time.
An unincorporated association has no legal personality, but a gift to it can take effect as a gift to the members at the date of the gift, not beneficially as individuals but as an accretion to the association's funds, to be dealt with according to the rules by which they are bound to each other. That is the contract-holding approach in Re Recher's Will Trusts and Neville Estates v Madden. It works where the members can, by changing the rules, control the funds, which is the case here. The gift is not a purpose trust, so the beneficiary principle is not engaged. A gift to members free of the rules would allow each to claim a share, which the testator did not intend.
Law basis: Re Recher's Will Trusts [1972] Ch 526; Neville Estates Ltd v Madden [1962] Ch 832Question 7 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Jarvis's will leaves his property to 'the Committee of the Westshire Constituency Labour Party for the benefit of the party'. The constituency party's rules can be changed only by the national party, which can also require the local party to hand over its funds. Which of the following best describes the gift?
- The gift is valid, because a gift to a committee is a gift to its members beneficially.
- The gift is valid, because political parties are treated as charities for this purpose.
- The gift fails, because the members cannot control the property under their own rules.Correct answer
- The gift is valid as a purpose trust, because the national party can enforce it.
- The gift fails, because a gift to a political party must be made by deed.
The contract-holding analysis only works if the members of the association can, under their rules, control the property and, if they wish, divide it among themselves. In Re Grant's Will Trusts a gift to a constituency Labour party failed because the local members could not change their rules, which were controlled by the national party, and so could not take the property for themselves. The gift could not be saved as a purpose trust, because it was not charitable and had no ascertainable beneficiaries. Political purposes are not charitable, so the answer treating the party as a charity is wrong.
Law basis: Re Grant's Will Trusts [1980] 1 WLR 360Question 8 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Kalinda's will leaves £50,000 to the Hull Judeans (Maccabi) Association, a members' sports club, 'to be used solely in the work of constructing new buildings for the association and improvements to the said buildings'. The club's members may change the rules by majority vote. The residuary legatees argue that the gift is a void purpose trust. Which of the following best describes the gift?
- The gift is valid, because the members control the money under their rules.Correct answer
- The gift is void, because the word 'solely' imposes a binding non-charitable purpose.
- The gift is valid only if the money is spent on buildings within 21 years.
- The gift is valid only for members who joined before Kalinda's death.
- The gift is void, because a sports club cannot benefit from a gift by will.
In Re Lipinski's Will Trusts, on almost identical words, Oliver J held that a gift to an association for a stated purpose was valid where the purpose was for the benefit of the members, who could alter the rules and decide how to use the money, including by dividing it among themselves. The stated purpose was treated as an indication of the testator's wishes rather than a separate trust. He also relied on Re Denley as an alternative basis. The answer that 'solely' imposes a binding purpose trust is tempting, but the members' control over the fund means the gift takes effect on the contract-holding basis.
Law basis: Re Lipinski's Will Trusts [1976] Ch 235Question 9 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
The Riverbank Friendly Society, an unincorporated association providing benefits to members' widows, is wound up. Its funds come entirely from members' subscriptions. The rules say nothing about distribution on dissolution. Which of the following best describes who is entitled to the surplus?
- The Crown is entitled, because the surplus of a dissolved association is bona vacantia.
- All past and present members are entitled in proportion to their subscriptions.
- The widows who were receiving benefits are entitled under a resulting trust.
- The members at dissolution, usually equally, under their contract.Correct answer
- The surplus must be applied cy-près for similar purposes by the Charity Commission.
In Re Bucks Constabulary Widows' and Orphans' Fund Friendly Society (No 2) Walton J held that the surplus funds of a dissolved unincorporated association belong to the members at the date of dissolution under the implied terms of their contract, in equal shares unless the rules provide otherwise. The assets are not bona vacantia, because there are members entitled to them, and they are not held on resulting trust for past subscribers, who received what they contracted for. Cy-près applies only to charitable property, and nothing suggests the society is a charity. The answer giving the surplus to past members confuses contractual entitlement with a resulting trust.
Law basis: Re Bucks Constabulary Widows' and Orphans' Fund Friendly Society (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 936Question 10 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
A non-charitable benevolent fund for widows of local police officers is wound up. Its surplus came partly from the proceeds of street collections and raffles, and partly from a legacy from a named testator. Which of the following best describes who is entitled to the money from the street collections?
- It is held on resulting trust for the donors, who may claim their contributions.
- It must be divided among the widows receiving benefits at the date of winding up.
- It is held on resulting trust for the fund's officers, who organised the collections.
- It must be applied cy-près by the Charity Commission for similar purposes.
- It passes to the Crown as bona vacantia, because the donors parted with it outright.Correct answer
In Re West Sussex Constabulary's Widows, Children and Benevolent (1930) Fund Trusts Goff J held that money given anonymously in street collections, and the proceeds of entertainments and raffles, were given out-and-out with no intention of getting it back, so on failure it passed to the Crown as bona vacantia. Identifiable donations and legacies, by contrast, were held on resulting trust for the donors or their estates. This differs from Re Gillingham Bus Disaster Fund, where a resulting trust was found even for anonymous donors, but West Sussex is generally preferred on this point. Cy-près is unavailable because the fund is not charitable.
Law basis: Re West Sussex Constabulary's Widows, Children and Benevolent (1930) Fund Trusts [1971] Ch 1Question 11 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Leandro's will leaves his residue to trustees to research the advantages of a new 40-letter English alphabet and to publish a play transliterated into it. A court finds that the research is not educational in the charitable sense, because it would merely increase knowledge without any educational value. Which of the following best describes the gift?
- The gift is valid, because research is always charitable under the advancement of education.
- The gift fails as a non-charitable purpose trust with no beneficiary to enforce it.Correct answer
- The gift is valid as an anomalous purpose trust for the duration of the perpetuity period.
- The gift is valid, because the public benefit of a new alphabet is presumed.
- The gift fails only as to publication, and the research can proceed as a valid trust.
In Re Shaw a gift for research into a new alphabet was held not to be charitable, because the increase of knowledge alone, without an educational element, was not within the advancement of education. Not being charitable, it was a purpose trust with no human beneficiary and failed under the beneficiary principle. The anomalous exceptions are confined to tombs, animals and a few historic categories, and the courts will not extend them. Research can be charitable if it is of educational value and the results are disseminated, as Re Hopkins later recognised, but that depends on the court's finding, which here was against charity.
Law basis: Re Shaw [1957] 1 WLR 729Question 12 · Purpose trusts and unincorporated associationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Mared transfers £2 million to trustees to maintain a private hall and grounds 'for ever for the recreation of the employees of Mared plc'. The trust is not charitable. A beneficiary asks whether the trust is valid. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The trust is valid, because it benefits ascertainable employees under the principle in Re Denley.
- The trust is valid, because the rule against perpetuities does not apply to employee trusts.
- The trust is likely to be void, because it may continue beyond the permitted perpetuity period.Correct answer
- The trust is valid for 125 years, after which the property results to Mared.
- The trust is valid indefinitely, because it is a trust for the use of land.
A non-charitable trust that may last for ever offends the rule against inalienability, which requires that capital must not be tied up beyond the perpetuity period, generally a life in being plus 21 years or 21 years where no lives are chosen. The Perpetuities and Accumulations Act 2009 preserved the common law rule for non-charitable purpose trusts. Re Denley allows trusts that directly benefit individuals to be enforced, but the trust there was limited to a valid period; it does not remove the need to comply with the rule. Mared's trust is expressed to last 'for ever', so it is likely to fail.
Law basis: Re Denley's Trust Deed [1969] 1 Ch 373; Perpetuities and Accumulations Act 2009, s18More Trusts Law topics
Back to all Trusts Law questions, or sit a timed mock.