Law covered in these questions
- Keech v Sandford (1726) Sel Cas Ch 61
- Boardman v Phipps [1967] 2 AC 46
- Tito v Waddell (No 2) [1977] Ch 106
- Kane v Radley-Kane [1999] Ch 274
- Holder v Holder [1968] Ch 353
- Re Macadam [1946] Ch 73
- Re Gee [1948] Ch 284
- FHR European Ventures LLP v Cedar Capital Partners LLC [2014] UKSC 45
- Trustee Act 2000, s29
- Trustee Act 2000, s28
- Re Duke of Norfolk's Settlement Trusts [1982] Ch 61
- Trustee Act 2000, ss29 and 31
- Luke v South Kensington Hotel Co (1879) 11 Ch D 121
- Re Londonderry's Settlement [1965] Ch 918
All 14 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Karim is trustee of a lease of a market stall held for a child beneficiary. When the lease expires, the landlord refuses to renew it to Karim as trustee, because a child cannot be bound by the covenants. Karim then takes a renewed lease in his own name. Which of the following best describes his position?
- Karim may keep the lease, because the landlord would not renew it for the trust.
- Karim may keep the lease, provided he pays the trust its market value.
- Karim may keep the lease, because he acted honestly and the trust suffered no loss.
- Karim holds the renewed lease on trust for the child.Correct answer
- Karim must surrender the lease to the landlord, because his acquisition was a breach.
A trustee must not place himself in a position where his interest and duty may conflict, and must not profit from his position. In Keech v Sandford a trustee who took a renewal of a lease for himself, after the landlord refused to renew for the infant beneficiary, was held to hold the renewed lease on trust for the infant. The rule is strict: it applies even though the trust could not have obtained the lease and the trustee acted honestly, because otherwise trustees would be tempted not to try to obtain renewals for the trust. The landlord's refusal and the absence of loss are therefore no defence.
Law basis: Keech v Sandford (1726) Sel Cas Ch 61Question 2 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Lucian, solicitor to a family trust, attends company meetings as the trust's representative and obtains confidential information showing the company is undervalued. With the information, he buys shares in the company personally, acting honestly, and both he and the trust make large profits. Which of the following best describes Lucian's position?
- He may keep his profit, because the trust also benefited from his actions.
- He may keep his profit, because he acted honestly and the trust could not have bought the shares.
- He must account only for the profit made with trust money, which was none.
- He must account for his profit and is also liable to pay exemplary damages.
- He must account for his profit, though he may receive an allowance for his work and skill.Correct answer
In Boardman v Phipps the House of Lords held that a solicitor and a beneficiary who used information obtained while acting for a trust to make a profit for themselves had to account to the trust, even though they acted honestly, the trust also made a profit, and the trust could not itself have bought the shares. They were fiduciaries who had made a profit from their position, and there was a real possibility of conflict. However, because of their honesty and the benefit to the trust, they were awarded a generous allowance for their work and skill. Exemplary damages are not available for this kind of breach.
Law basis: Boardman v Phipps [1967] 2 AC 46Question 3 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Myrtle, sole trustee of a will trust, sells a house belonging to the trust to herself at a price set by an independent valuer, which is its full market value. A year later house prices fall. A beneficiary seeks to have the sale set aside. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The sale is valid, because Myrtle paid the full market value.
- The sale is voidable at the beneficiary's instance, however fair the price.Correct answer
- The sale is valid, because an independent valuer fixed the price.
- The sale can be set aside only if the beneficiary proves that Myrtle made a profit.
- The sale can be set aside only if the court finds Myrtle acted dishonestly.
Under the self-dealing rule, a sale of trust property by a trustee to herself is voidable at the instance of any beneficiary, however fair the transaction, as explained in Tito v Waddell (No 2) and applied in Kane v Radley-Kane. The rule exists because the trustee is on both sides of the transaction, and it is not enough to show an independent valuation or full price. The sale will stand only if authorised by the trust instrument, the court, or the fully informed consent of all the beneficiaries. The beneficiary may not, however, wish to set aside the sale now that prices have fallen, and the choice is the beneficiary's.
Law basis: Tito v Waddell (No 2) [1977] Ch 106; Kane v Radley-Kane [1999] Ch 274Question 4 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Nils was named as an executor of his father's will but renounced probate before doing anything except a few minor acts. The estate's farm is later sold at a public auction, conducted by the acting executors, and Nils buys it at a good price. All the beneficiaries knew the facts. One of them later seeks to set the sale aside. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The sale must be set aside, because an executor can never buy property of the estate.
- The sale must be set aside, because Nils's minor acts made him an executor de son tort.
- The sale is unlikely to be set aside on these exceptional facts.Correct answer
- The sale will stand only if Nils pays the difference between price and current value.
- The sale must be set aside, because the self-dealing rule admits no exceptions.
In Holder v Holder the Court of Appeal refused to set aside the purchase of a farm at auction by a son who had been appointed executor but had renounced after doing only minor acts. He had not taken part in arranging the sale, had acquired no special knowledge as executor, and the beneficiaries had full knowledge and had acquiesced. The self-dealing rule was applied flexibly because its rationale, preventing a trustee from being on both sides of the transaction, did not apply. The case is regarded as exceptional, so the answer that the rule admits no exceptions overstates it, though the rule is normally strict.
Law basis: Holder v Holder [1968] Ch 353Question 5 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ophira is trustee of a family trust. She buys her adult nephew's equitable interest under the trust for a fair price after explaining to him everything she knows about the trust's value and prospects. He later regrets the sale and seeks to set it aside. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The purchase is voidable however fair, because the self-dealing rule applies.
- The purchase is void, because a trustee may never deal with a beneficiary.
- The purchase is voidable, because the nephew did not take independent legal advice.
- The purchase is valid only if the court approved it before completion.
- The purchase is likely to stand under the fair-dealing rule.Correct answer
A trustee who buys a beneficiary's interest is subject to the fair-dealing rule, not the self-dealing rule, as Megarry V-C explained in Tito v Waddell (No 2). The transaction is not voidable as of right; it can be set aside only if the trustee took advantage of her position. If she shows that she made full disclosure, paid a fair price and took no advantage, the purchase will stand. Independent advice is helpful evidence of fairness but is not an absolute requirement. The self-dealing answer is the tempting error, because that rule applies where a trustee buys the trust property itself from the trust.
Law basis: Tito v Waddell (No 2) [1977] Ch 106Question 6 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Pascal and Quinn are trustees of a trust holding a majority shareholding in a company. They use the trust's votes to appoint Pascal as a director, and he receives £40,000 a year in director's fees. The trust instrument does not authorise trustees to keep such fees. Which of the following best describes Pascal's position?
- He may keep the fees, because they are payment for his work as a director.
- He may keep the fees, because the company, not the trust, pays them.
- He must account for the fees, as he used the trust's votes.Correct answer
- He must account only for fees above a reasonable rate for the work done.
- He may keep the fees, provided he declared the appointment to the beneficiaries.
A trustee must account for profits obtained by using his position or trust property. In Re Macadam trustees who used their power under the articles, attached to their trusteeship, to appoint themselves directors had to account for their fees. By contrast, in Re Gee a trustee who would have been appointed director independently of the trust's votes was allowed to keep his fees. Pascal was appointed by using the trust's votes, so he must account for the full fees, though the court may allow remuneration for work done in exceptional cases. Declaration to beneficiaries without their fully informed consent is not enough.
Law basis: Re Macadam [1946] Ch 73; Re Gee [1948] Ch 284Question 7 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Rufus, an agent acting for a company in buying a hotel, secretly receives a £1 million commission from the seller. He invests it in property that rises in value to £1.5 million. The company seeks the property itself. Which of the following best describes the company's claim?
- The company has only a personal claim for £1 million, because a bribe is not trust property.
- The company has a personal claim for £1 million plus interest, but no proprietary claim.
- The company can claim the property only if Rufus is insolvent and unable to pay.
- The company can claim the property under a constructive trust.Correct answer
- The company can claim the property only if the bribe was paid with the company's own money.
In FHR European Ventures LLP v Cedar Capital Partners LLC the Supreme Court held that a bribe or secret commission received by an agent in breach of fiduciary duty is held on constructive trust for the principal. The principal therefore has a proprietary claim and may trace into assets acquired with the bribe and take any increase in value. The court approved Attorney General for Hong Kong v Reid and overruled Sinclair Investments v Versailles Trade Finance on this point. It does not matter that the bribe was paid by a third party rather than out of the principal's money, which is why the final answer is wrong.
Law basis: FHR European Ventures LLP v Cedar Capital Partners LLC [2014] UKSC 45Question 8 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Sanjay, a solicitor, and his friend Tess, a lay person, are the trustees of a family trust that has no charging clause. Sanjay carries out legal work for the trust. Tess agrees in writing that he may be paid reasonable remuneration for his work. Which of the following best describes Sanjay's entitlement?
- He is entitled to reasonable remuneration under s29 of the Trustee Act 2000.Correct answer
- He is entitled to nothing, because trustees may only be paid under an express charging clause.
- He is entitled to remuneration only if all the beneficiaries agree in writing.
- He is entitled to remuneration only with the court's approval under its inherent jurisdiction.
- He is entitled to his normal hourly rate, whether or not it is reasonable.
Section 29(2) of the Trustee Act 2000 provides that a trustee who acts in a professional capacity, but is not a trust corporation or a sole trustee, is entitled to receive reasonable remuneration out of the trust funds for services provided to the trust if each other trustee has agreed in writing that he may be remunerated. The section applies only where the trust instrument does not make provision for remuneration. Sanjay is a professional, not a sole trustee, and Tess has agreed in writing, so he can be paid reasonable remuneration. Beneficiary consent and a court order are not required.
Law basis: Trustee Act 2000, s29 ↗Question 9 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
A trust deed contains a clause allowing any professional trustee to charge for services. Una, an accountant trustee, charges the trust for time spent signing routine cheques and attending to tasks that a lay trustee could perform. A beneficiary argues that she may charge only for professional accountancy work. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Una may charge only for services requiring professional accountancy skills.
- Una may charge for all services, including those a lay trustee could provide.Correct answer
- Una may charge nothing, because charging clauses are construed strictly against trustees.
- Una may charge only if the beneficiaries approve each invoice in advance.
- Una may charge only for services provided before the trust deed was signed.
Section 28(2) of the Trustee Act 2000 provides that where a trust instrument entitles a trustee acting in a professional capacity to receive payment for services, he is to be treated as entitled to payment even if the services are capable of being provided by a lay trustee. This reversed the old approach, under which charging clauses were construed strictly, so that a professional trustee could charge only for professional work. Una acts in a professional capacity and the trust contains a charging clause, so she may charge for routine work too, subject to the usual duty to act in the beneficiaries' interests and keep charges reasonable.
Law basis: Trustee Act 2000, s28 ↗Question 10 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
A trust corporation agreed to act as trustee of a large family trust on fixed fee terms set out in the trust instrument decades ago. The trust's work has grown greatly in complexity and the fees are now wholly inadequate. The trustee asks whether it can increase its charges. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The trustee may simply increase its fees, because the work has become more complex.
- The trustee is bound by the fixed fees and can do nothing except retire.
- The trustee may increase its fees only with the written consent of every beneficiary.
- The court may authorise increased remuneration under its inherent jurisdiction.Correct answer
- The trustee may claim reasonable remuneration under s29, overriding the trust instrument.
The court has an inherent jurisdiction to authorise payment of remuneration to a trustee, or to increase remuneration authorised by the trust instrument. In Re Duke of Norfolk's Settlement Trusts the Court of Appeal held that the jurisdiction extends to increasing remuneration where this would be beneficial to the administration of the trust, for example because the work has become more onerous than anticipated. The court balances the importance of trustees not being under-rewarded against the protection of beneficiaries. A trustee cannot increase its fees unilaterally. Section 29 of the Trustee Act 2000 applies only where the trust instrument makes no provision for remuneration.
Law basis: Re Duke of Norfolk's Settlement Trusts [1982] Ch 61Question 11 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Vera, a lay trustee of a family trust with no charging clause, spends many hours managing a rental property owned by the trust. She also pays £600 of her own money for urgent roof repairs. She asks to be paid for her time and reimbursed for the repairs. Which of the following best describes her entitlement?
- She may recover both the £600 and reasonable payment for her time under s29.
- She may recover nothing, because a lay trustee acts entirely gratuitously.
- She may recover the £600 she spent, but not payment for her time.Correct answer
- She may recover payment for her time, but not the cost of repairs.
- She may recover the £600 only with the court's approval.
Section 31(1) of the Trustee Act 2000 entitles a trustee to be reimbursed from the trust funds, or pay out of them, expenses properly incurred when acting on behalf of the trust. Vera can therefore recover the £600 for urgent repairs. But the statutory right to remuneration in s29 applies only to trust corporations and trustees acting in a professional capacity, and lay trustees are expected to act without payment unless the trust instrument, the beneficiaries or the court authorise remuneration. Her time is therefore unpaid. The answer denying all recovery confuses remuneration with reimbursement of expenses.
Law basis: Trustee Act 2000, ss29 and 31 ↗Question 12 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Wren, Xavi and Yoko are trustees of a private family trust. Wren and Xavi vote to sell a trust property; Yoko refuses to agree. The trust instrument says nothing about majority decisions. Wren and Xavi propose to sign a contract of sale without Yoko. Which of the following best describes the position?
- They cannot proceed, because trustees of a private trust must act unanimously.Correct answer
- They may proceed, because trustees act by majority unless the trust says otherwise.
- They may proceed, provided Yoko is given written notice of the sale.
- They may proceed, provided they obtain an independent valuation first.
- They may proceed, because a dissenting trustee must defer to the majority.
The general rule for private trusts is that trustees must act unanimously, unless the trust instrument permits majority decisions or the court directs otherwise. A decision by two of three trustees therefore does not bind the trust, and Wren and Xavi cannot validly sell without Yoko. Charitable trustees, by contrast, may act by majority. If the trustees are deadlocked, they may apply to the court for directions, or, in the case of land, any trustee or person interested may apply under s14 of the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996. Notice to Yoko or a valuation cannot replace her agreement.
Law basis: Luke v South Kensington Hotel Co (1879) 11 Ch D 121Question 13 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Zoe is a beneficiary of a discretionary trust. The trustees decided not to make any distribution to her this year. She demands copies of the trustees' minutes recording their reasons, and of the settlor's letter of wishes. Which of the following best describes the trustees' obligation?
- They must disclose all documents relating to the trust, including their reasons.
- They need not disclose their reasons for exercising their dispositive discretion.Correct answer
- They must disclose their reasons, because a beneficiary is entitled to see all trust documents.
- They must disclose the letter of wishes, but not the minutes, as the settlor intended her to see it.
- They need not disclose anything, because discretionary beneficiaries have no right to information.
In Re Londonderry's Settlement the Court of Appeal held that trustees exercising a dispositive discretion are not obliged to disclose their reasons, or documents revealing their deliberations, to beneficiaries; otherwise the trust could not be administered effectively. Schmidt v Rosewood Trust Ltd held that disclosure of trust documents is a matter for the court's supervisory discretion, not an absolute proprietary right. Letters of wishes are generally treated as confidential to the trustees, as in Breakspear v Ackland. Discretionary beneficiaries do have some rights to information, such as accounts, so the final answer goes too far.
Law basis: Re Londonderry's Settlement [1965] Ch 918; Schmidt v Rosewood Trust Ltd [2003] UKPC 26Question 14 · Fiduciary duties of trusteesDraft, pending solicitor review
Trustees of a family trust exercise a power to transfer funds to a new settlement, acting on advice from a solicitor. The solicitor fails to mention that the transfer triggers a large tax charge. The trustees did not themselves fail to take proper advice. A beneficiary seeks to set aside the transfer on the ground that the trustees did not consider the tax consequences. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The transfer is void, because the trustees failed to consider a relevant matter.
- The transfer is voidable, because any unforeseen adverse consequence vitiates a decision.
- The transfer is valid, but the trustees are personally liable for the tax charge.
- The transfer is voidable, because tax consequences are always a relevant consideration.
- It is not voidable, because the trustees committed no breach of duty.Correct answer
In Pitt v Holt the Supreme Court reformulated the so-called rule in Hastings-Bass. A trustee's exercise of a discretion is voidable, not void, for failure to take into account a relevant consideration only where the failure amounts to a breach of the trustee's fiduciary duty. Trustees who take and act on apparently competent professional advice do not usually breach that duty, even if the advice was wrong. The remedy for the beneficiaries lies, if anywhere, against the negligent adviser. The decision is therefore not voidable on this ground. Mistake can sometimes found rescission of a voluntary disposition, but that is a separate doctrine.
Law basis: Pitt v Holt [2013] UKSC 26More Trusts Law topics
Back to all Trusts Law questions, or sit a timed mock.