Law covered in these questions
- Saunders v Vautier (1841) Cr & Ph 240
- Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115
- Stephenson v Barclays Bank Trust Co Ltd [1975] 1 WLR 882
- Re Brockbank [1948] Ch 206
- Re Smith [1928] Ch 915
- Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(c)
- Re Weston's Settlements [1969] 1 Ch 223
- Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1
- Re Remnant's Settlement Trusts [1970] Ch 560
- Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(b)
- Re Suffert's Settlement [1961] Ch 1
- Goulding v James [1997] 2 All ER 239
- Re T's Settlement Trusts [1964] Ch 158
- Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(a)
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
A trust fund is held for Aled, aged 25, absolutely, with the trustees holding it until he is 30. No other person has any interest in the fund. Aled wants the money now. Which statement best describes his position?
- He can only after the Charity Commission approves.
- He can only if the court approves, as for a minor.
- He can only if the trustees agree to it unanimously.
- He can call for the trust property under the rule in Saunders v Vautier, because he is adult, of full capacity and the only beneficiary.Correct answer
- He cannot, because the trust deed fixes the age of 30.
If all beneficiaries are sui juris and together absolutely entitled, they may end the trust and call for the property, even against the settlor's wishes.
Law basis: Saunders v Vautier (1841) Cr & Ph 240Question 2 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Trustees hold a fund for Una for life, remainder to her son Vic absolutely. Both are adults of full capacity, and no one else has any possible interest. They agree that they want the trust brought to an end and the fund divided between them in agreed shares. The trustees prefer to keep the trust running. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Una and Vic together can end the trust and call for the fund on their agreed terms.Correct answer
- They cannot end the trust, because the settlor intended it to last for Una's life.
- They can end the trust only with the court's approval under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958.
- They can end the trust only if the trustees agree that it would be in their interests.
- Only Vic can end the trust, because he has the absolute interest in capital.
Under the rule in Saunders v Vautier, beneficiaries who are all of full age and capacity and who between them are absolutely entitled to the whole beneficial interest can together direct the trustees to transfer the trust property to them, or as they direct, and so bring the trust to an end, whatever the settlor intended. Una and Vic between them hold the whole beneficial interest, so they can end the trust and divide the fund as they agree. Court approval under the 1958 Act is needed only where some beneficiaries cannot consent, such as minors or unborn persons. Vic alone cannot end the trust because Una's life interest is prior to his.
Law basis: Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115Question 3 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Wendy and Xian, adult and together absolutely entitled under a trust, want the trust to continue, but they instruct the trustees to sell the trust's shares and invest only in a particular property fund that they choose. The trustees disagree. Which of the following best describes the beneficiaries' rights?
- They can direct the investment, because together they are absolutely entitled.
- They cannot direct how the trustees exercise their powers while the trust continues.Correct answer
- They can direct the investment, but only with the court's approval.
- They can direct the investment, provided the trustees are indemnified against loss.
- They can direct the investment, because the beneficiaries own the trust fund in equity.
In Re Brockbank and Stephenson v Barclays Bank Trust Co Ltd the courts held that beneficiaries who are together absolutely entitled may end the trust under Saunders v Vautier, but they cannot keep the trust alive and at the same time control the trustees in the exercise of their powers and discretions. If Wendy and Xian want control of the investments, they must call for the property and end the trust, and may then resettle it if they wish. Their equitable ownership does not give them a right to give binding instructions on investment while the trust continues.
Law basis: Stephenson v Barclays Bank Trust Co Ltd [1975] 1 WLR 882; Re Brockbank [1948] Ch 206Question 4 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Trustees hold a fund on discretionary trust for the income of Yasmin, Zara and Aled during Yasmin's life, with capital to the survivors. All three are adults of full capacity. No one else can benefit. They ask the trustees to pay the fund to them in equal shares. Which of the following best describes the position?
- They cannot end the trust, because objects of a discretionary trust have no interests.
- They can end the trust only if the trustees agree to exercise their discretion in this way.
- Each can demand one third of the fund immediately, without the others' agreement.
- They can together end the trust, because between them they are absolutely entitled.Correct answer
- They can end the trust only with the court's approval under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958.
An individual object of a discretionary trust has no entitlement to the fund. But where all the objects are adults of full capacity and together they comprise everyone who could possibly benefit, they are collectively entitled to the whole fund and can, by acting together, call for it under Saunders v Vautier. Re Smith applied the rule to the objects of a discretionary trust in this way. The trustees' discretion does not prevent this. Individually, an object cannot demand a share, because his entitlement depends on the trustees' discretion or on all the objects acting together. No court approval is needed.
Law basis: Re Smith [1928] Ch 915; Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115Question 5 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Trustees hold a fund for Bea for life, then for her children equally. Bea, aged 40, has two adult children and could have more. Everyone currently alive is adult and of full capacity, and all agree to end the trust and divide the fund. Which of the following best describes the position?
- They can end the trust under Saunders v Vautier, because all living beneficiaries consent.
- They can end the trust, provided they hold back a reserve for any future children.
- They cannot end the trust under Saunders v Vautier, because unborn children could take.Correct answer
- They can end the trust, because Bea is presumed past the age of having children.
- They can end the trust only if Bea's existing children agree to share with any later ones.
The rule in Saunders v Vautier applies only where all the beneficiaries who could possibly benefit are ascertained, adult and of full capacity, and together absolutely entitled. Because Bea could have more children, who would be within the class, the existing beneficiaries are not together absolutely entitled. They therefore cannot end the trust on their own. They could apply to the court under s1 of the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 for approval of an arrangement on behalf of any unborn persons, which the court will give only if it is for their benefit. There is no presumption that a woman of 40 cannot have children.
Law basis: Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115; Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(c) ↗Question 6 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Trustees hold a large fund for the minor children of Clive. Clive proposes that the family move to Jersey and that the trust be exported there, saving significant tax. The children have lived all their lives in England and have no connection with Jersey. An application is made under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 for approval on the children's behalf. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- The court may refuse despite the tax saving.Correct answer
- The court must approve, because the arrangement saves tax for the children.
- The court must approve, because the parents' wishes are decisive for minors.
- The court cannot consider non-financial matters under the 1958 Act.
- The court must refuse, because exporting a trust is never a benefit.
Under s1 of the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 the court may approve an arrangement on behalf of minors only if it is for their benefit. Benefit is not purely financial. In Re Weston's Settlements Lord Denning MR refused to approve a scheme to move a trust and the family to Jersey to save tax, because the children's upbringing in England and their social and educational benefits outweighed the tax advantage, and the move appeared to be motivated by tax avoidance alone. Exporting a trust can be a benefit in appropriate cases, such as where the beneficiaries genuinely live abroad, so the final answer is too absolute.
Law basis: Re Weston's Settlements [1969] 1 Ch 223; Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1 ↗Question 7 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
A will trust contains a forfeiture clause under which any of the testator's daughters' children who becomes a Roman Catholic loses their interest. The adult beneficiaries apply under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 to delete the clause, which would reduce the financial expectations of some minor beneficiaries, arguing that it causes family discord. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- The court cannot approve, because any variation reducing a minor's financial prospects is not a benefit.
- The court may approve if it is for the minors' benefit overall.Correct answer
- The court cannot approve, because the testator's wishes must be respected.
- The court must approve, because religious forfeiture clauses are void as against public policy.
- The court may approve only if the minors themselves consent to the deletion.
In Re Remnant's Settlement Trusts the court approved the deletion of a forfeiture clause against beneficiaries who practised Roman Catholicism, under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958, even though some minors would lose a financial advantage. Pennycuick J held that removing a source of family discord and freedom of choice in religion and marriage were benefits, which outweighed the financial loss. The court considers the settlor's wishes but is not bound by them. Such clauses are not automatically void. Minors cannot consent for themselves, which is precisely why the court's approval is needed.
Law basis: Re Remnant's Settlement Trusts [1970] Ch 560; Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1 ↗Question 8 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
An application is made under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 to vary a trust for Diane for life, then for her issue, and in default for her next of kin. Diane's adult brother, Eli, would be her next of kin if she died today. Eli is of full capacity but refuses to agree to the variation. The applicants ask the court to approve on Eli's behalf. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- The court can approve on Eli's behalf, because his interest is contingent.
- The court can approve on Eli's behalf if the variation is for his benefit.
- The court can approve on Eli's behalf, because next of kin cannot be ascertained until death.
- The court can approve on Eli's behalf, because he has only a mere expectancy.
- The court cannot approve on Eli's behalf, because he must give his own consent.Correct answer
Section 1(1)(b) of the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 allows the court to approve on behalf of any person who may become entitled at a future date or on a future event as a member of a specified class, such as next of kin. But the proviso excludes any person who would be of that description, or a member of that class, if the said date had fallen or the said event had happened at the date of the application. Eli would be next of kin if Diane died today, so the court cannot consent for him; he must consent himself, as in Re Suffert's Settlement. His refusal therefore blocks the arrangement as regards his interest.
Law basis: Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(b); Re Suffert's Settlement [1961] Ch 1 ↗Question 9 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
A family wants to vary a trust that would currently pass to the settlor's grandchildren, including any born in future. The variation would give a modest capital sum to each grandchild now and save inheritance tax. The court is asked to approve on behalf of unborn grandchildren, who might do better if the trust continued and certain events occurred. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- The court must refuse unless it is certain that every unborn grandchild will benefit.
- The court cannot approve on behalf of persons who are not yet born.
- The court may approve if a prudent adult would take the risk.Correct answer
- The court must approve, because a tax saving is always a benefit to unborn beneficiaries.
- The court may approve only if the unborn grandchildren's parents consent on their behalf.
Section 1(1)(c) of the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 allows the court to approve an arrangement on behalf of any person unborn, but only if it would be for that person's benefit. The court does not require certainty of benefit: it is enough that the arrangement involves a risk that a prudent adult, looking after his own interests, would be prepared to accept, taking a broad view of the possibilities. A tax saving that increases the overall fund for beneficiaries is often a benefit, but it is not automatically so. Parents cannot consent for unborn persons; that is the court's function.
Law basis: Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(c) ↗Question 10 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
A testatrix's will gave her sons' interests absolutely at 30, and her letter of wishes stressed that she did not want them to receive capital before then. The sons and their mother apply under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 to bring forward their entitlement, with the variation conferring large financial benefits on minor and unborn beneficiaries. The trustees oppose it as contrary to the testatrix's wishes. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- The court must refuse, because a variation cannot defeat the settlor's clear intentions.
- The court may approve, because the testatrix's intentions are relevant but not decisive.Correct answer
- The court must refuse, because adult beneficiaries cannot vary a trust in their own favour.
- The court must refuse unless the trustees consent to the variation.
- The court must approve, because benefit to the beneficiaries is the only consideration.
In Goulding v James the Court of Appeal approved a variation of a will trust although it was contrary to the testatrix's expressed wishes. The court held that the settlor's intentions and wishes are relevant, but that the focus under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 is on whether the arrangement is for the benefit of the persons on whose behalf the court is asked to approve. Here the variation clearly benefited them financially. The court approves on behalf of those who cannot consent; the adults consent for themselves. The trustees' opposition is not a veto. Benefit is the key, but the court retains a discretion, so the final answer overstates it.
Law basis: Goulding v James [1997] 2 All ER 239; Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1 ↗Question 11 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
A trust provides that Faye, a minor, will become absolutely entitled to a large fund at 18. Evidence shows that she is immature and irresponsible with money. Her mother applies under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 to postpone Faye's entitlement to capital until she is 25, with the income meanwhile applied for her benefit. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- The court may approve the postponement as a benefit, in view of Faye's immaturity.Correct answer
- The court cannot approve, because a variation must increase a minor's financial interests.
- The court cannot approve, because postponing entitlement can never benefit a beneficiary.
- The court may approve only if Faye consents when she reaches 18.
- The court may approve only if the postponement also saves tax.
Benefit under s1 of the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 is not limited to financial advantage. In Re T's Settlement Trusts Wilberforce J approved an arrangement postponing a minor's entitlement to capital, because her immaturity and irresponsibility meant that it would be for her benefit to be protected from receiving the capital outright at 18. The court may approve on behalf of a minor beneficiary where the arrangement is for her benefit overall, even if it delays or limits her financial rights. A tax saving is not required. Faye cannot consent while a minor, which is why the court's approval is needed now.
Law basis: Re T's Settlement Trusts [1964] Ch 158; Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(a) ↗Question 12 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Trustees of a will trust hold a country house under an instrument that forbids sale. The house is falling into disrepair and costs more to maintain than the trust can afford. The trustees want to sell it and invest the proceeds, without changing any beneficiary's interest. Some beneficiaries are minors. Which of the following best describes the trustees' best course?
- They may sell without the court, because a sale is in the beneficiaries' interests.
- They may sell only if all beneficiaries, including minors, consent.
- They cannot sell, because the court has no power to override a prohibition in a will.
- They may apply to the court under s57 of the Trustee Act 1925 to authorise the sale.Correct answer
- They may sell only after applying for a variation of beneficial interests under the 1958 Act.
Section 57 of the Trustee Act 1925 allows the court, where it is expedient for a sale, lease, mortgage, investment or other transaction in the management or administration of trust property but the trustees lack the power, to confer the necessary power. It is a jurisdiction over administrative matters and does not allow the court to alter beneficial interests. A sale of a house the trust cannot afford to maintain, with proceeds invested for the same beneficiaries, is a classic case. The Variation of Trusts Act 1958 can also confer administrative powers, but where no beneficial interest is altered s57 is the more direct route. Minors cannot consent, so the beneficiaries cannot authorise the sale themselves.
Law basis: Trustee Act 1925, s57 ↗Question 13 · Termination and variation of trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
Gil is entitled to income under a protective trust for life, under s33 of the Trustee Act 1925. An application is made to vary the trust under the Variation of Trusts Act 1958, and the court is asked to approve on behalf of the persons who would become entitled under the discretionary trust if Gil's life interest were forfeited. The arrangement is not shown to benefit those persons. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- The court cannot approve, because benefit to each person is always required.
- The court cannot approve on behalf of discretionary beneficiaries under a protective trust.
- The court may approve only if Gil's life interest has already been forfeited.
- The court may approve only if the persons concerned are minors or unborn.
- The court may approve on their behalf without needing to find that it benefits them.Correct answer
Section 1(1)(d) of the Variation of Trusts Act 1958 allows the court to approve an arrangement on behalf of any person in respect of any discretionary interest of his under protective trusts where the interest of the principal beneficiary has not failed or determined. The proviso to s1(1), which requires the arrangement to be for the benefit of the person on whose behalf approval is given, applies except by virtue of paragraph (d). The court therefore need not find benefit for these persons, although it will still exercise its discretion properly. The persons concerned need not be minors or unborn; they may be adults whose interests are contingent on a forfeiture that has not occurred.
Law basis: Variation of Trusts Act 1958, s1(1)(d); Trustee Act 1925, s33 ↗More Trusts Law topics
Back to all Trusts Law questions, or sit a timed mock.