Law covered in these questions
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 53(1)(b), (2)
- Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(c)
- Grey v IRC [1960] AC 1
- Vandervell v IRC [1967] 2 AC 291
- Neville v Wilson [1997] Ch 144
- Law of Property Act 1925, s53(2)
- Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(b)
- Bannister v Bannister [1948] 2 All ER 133
- Rochefoucauld v Boustead [1897] 1 Ch 196
- Wills Act 1837, s9
- Law of Property Act 1925, s52(1)
- Land Registration Act 2002, s27
- Re Paradise Motor Co Ltd [1968] 1 WLR 1125
- Paul v Constance [1977] 1 WLR 527
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Tara orally declares that she holds her house on trust for her friend Uma. Nothing is written down. Which statement best describes the effect?
- The trust is valid for personal property only.
- The trust is valid, because oral declarations are always effective.
- The trust is valid, because Uma knows about it.
- The trust is unenforceable, because a declaration of trust of land must be evidenced in writing and signed by the settlor.Correct answer
- The trust is void and Tara holds the house for herself outright, even though the law of resulting trusts could apply.
Question 2 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Farid is the sole beneficiary of shares held on a bare trust by his nominee, Gail. Farid orally instructs Gail to hold the shares from now on for his grandchildren. Gail agrees, and some weeks later signs a written declaration that she holds them for the grandchildren. Which of the following best describes the effect of Farid's oral instruction?
- The oral instruction was effective, because a beneficiary under a bare trust may direct his trustee orally.
- The oral instruction was effective, because Gail's later written declaration validated it retrospectively.
- The oral instruction was effective, because shares are personalty and need no formality to be transferred.
- It did not dispose of Farid's equitable interest, because he signed no writing.Correct answer
- The oral instruction was void, but Farid's equitable interest passed when Gail signed the declaration.
Section 53(1)(c) of the Law of Property Act 1925 requires a disposition of a subsisting equitable interest to be in writing signed by the person disposing of it or by his agent authorised in writing. In Grey v IRC the House of Lords held that an oral direction by a beneficiary to his trustee to hold for others was a disposition and was ineffective without writing. Gail's later written declaration was not signed by Farid as disposer; in Grey the later document was itself treated as the disposition for stamp duty purposes. The tempting answer that shares are personalty confuses the legal title, which can move without writing, with dispositions of an equitable interest.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(c); Grey v IRC [1960] AC 1 ↗Question 3 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Harriet is absolutely entitled in equity to shares held by her bank as bare trustee. She orally instructs the bank to transfer the shares to the Royal College of Surgeons by way of gift, and the bank executes a share transfer which is registered. Harriet's executors later argue that the gift failed for lack of writing under s53(1)(c) LPA 1925. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The gift is effective, because the equitable interest passed with the legal title.Correct answer
- The gift fails, because every disposition of an equitable interest requires writing signed by the disposer.
- The gift fails, because Harriet's instruction to the bank was not authorised in writing.
- The gift is effective only if the College signs a written acceptance of the shares.
- The gift is effective only as to the legal title, so the College holds on trust for Harriet's estate.
In Vandervell v IRC the House of Lords held that where a beneficiary under a bare trust directs the trustee to transfer the legal estate to a third party, intending the third party to take beneficially, the equitable interest passes with the legal title and no separate writing is needed under s53(1)(c). The mischief of the section, preventing hidden oral transactions in equitable interests, does not arise, because the legal transfer is itself recorded. The tempting answer applies Grey v IRC, but in Grey the trustee kept the legal title and was simply told to hold for different beneficiaries, which is different from a transfer of the whole interest.
Law basis: Vandervell v IRC [1967] 2 AC 291; Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(c) ↗Question 4 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ian and Jo are the equitable owners of shares held by a nominee company. At a meeting the two orally agree, for consideration, to divide the shares between themselves, each giving up their interest in the other's portion. Nothing is put in writing. Jo now denies the agreement. Which of the following best describes the effect of the oral agreement?
- It is void, because each party was disposing of a subsisting equitable interest without signed writing.
- It is likely to be effective, because it creates a constructive trust exempt from writing.Correct answer
- It is unenforceable but not void, because s53(1)(b) requires written evidence of the agreement.
- It is effective only if the nominee company was informed of the agreement at the time.
- It is effective only if Ian and Jo had paid stamp duty on the agreement.
Section 53(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925 provides that s53 does not affect the creation or operation of resulting, implied or constructive trusts. Where there is a specifically enforceable contract to dispose of an equitable interest, for example in shares in a private company, the vendor holds on constructive trust for the purchaser from the time of the contract. In Neville v Wilson the Court of Appeal held that an oral agreement between shareholders to divide equitable interests in shares was effective on this basis. The tempting answer applying s53(1)(c) ignores the exemption in s53(2). Section 53(1)(b) concerns declarations of trusts of land, not shares.
Law basis: Neville v Wilson [1997] Ch 144; Law of Property Act 1925, s53(2) ↗Question 5 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
In January, Kamal orally declares that he holds his flat on trust for his sister Lina. In March he signs a letter to his solicitor confirming 'the flat I declared in January that I hold on trust for Lina'. Kamal dies in June, and his executor claims the flat for the estate. Which of the following best describes Lina's position?
- Lina cannot enforce the trust, because the writing must be made at the same time as the declaration.
- Lina cannot enforce the trust, because a declaration of trust of land must be made by deed.
- Lina cannot enforce the trust, because the letter was addressed to Kamal's solicitor and not to her.
- Lina can enforce the trust, because Kamal's later signed letter is sufficient evidence.Correct answer
- Lina can enforce the trust only from March, when the written evidence came into existence.
Section 53(1)(b) of the Law of Property Act 1925 requires a declaration of trust of land to be 'manifested and proved by some writing signed by some person who is able to declare such trust'. It is an evidential requirement: the trust need not be declared in writing, and the writing may come into existence after the declaration, as long as it is available when the trust is to be enforced. The letter identifies the property, the beneficiary and the trust and is signed by Kamal, who was able to declare it. The trust takes effect from the January declaration. The letter need not be addressed to the beneficiary, and no deed is needed.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(b) ↗Question 6 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Megan owns a cottage. She tells her nephew Neil orally that she now holds it on trust for him. Neil writes and signs a note recording what Megan said, and Megan reads the note but does not sign it. After Megan's death, her executors refuse to recognise the trust. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The trust is enforceable, because the writing was signed by the beneficiary who has an interest in proving it.
- The trust is enforceable, because Megan approved the note, which counts as her signature.
- The trust is unenforceable, because Megan did not sign any writing.Correct answer
- The trust is void, because a declaration of trust of land must be made in writing at the time.
- The trust is enforceable, because s53(1)(b) applies only to transfers of land and not to declarations.
Under s53(1)(b) of the Law of Property Act 1925, the writing must be signed by 'some person who is able to declare such trust', which means the owner of the land, here Megan. A note signed only by the intended beneficiary does not satisfy the section, and reading a note is not signing it. The declaration is not void, but without compliant written evidence it cannot be enforced, and Neil would need to rely on another doctrine such as a constructive trust or proprietary estoppel if he has acted to his detriment. The answer treating Megan's approval as a signature is tempting but unsupported: there must be an actual signature by the declarant or a person authorised to declare.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(b) ↗Question 7 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Olga transfers her cottage to her friend Pavel for a nominal sum, on Pavel's oral promise that she may live there rent-free for the rest of her life. The transfer contains no reference to the promise. Two years later Pavel seeks possession, relying on the absence of writing. Which of the following best describes Olga's position?
- Olga is likely to be protected by a constructive trust giving effect to the promise.Correct answer
- Olga has no protection, because her right to occupy land was not evidenced by signed writing.
- Olga has no protection, because the transfer was for value and was registered without qualification.
- Olga is protected only by a contractual licence, which Pavel may end on reasonable notice.
- Olga is protected only if she can show she paid Pavel the full market value of her occupation.
Equity will not allow a statute requiring formalities to be used as an instrument of fraud. Where land is transferred on an oral undertaking that the transferor may stay in occupation, and the transferee then denies the undertaking to keep the land free of it, the court will impose a constructive trust giving effect to the undertaking. In Bannister v Bannister the Court of Appeal applied this to give a transferor a life interest, following Rochefoucauld v Boustead. Section 53(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925 exempts constructive trusts from s53(1). Relying on lack of writing is exactly what equity prevents here, so the licence answer understates Olga's protection.
Law basis: Bannister v Bannister [1948] 2 All ER 133; Rochefoucauld v Boustead [1897] 1 Ch 196; Law of Property Act 1925, s53(2) ↗Question 8 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Quilla is a beneficiary entitled to a quarter of a trust fund of shares. She tells her friend Rafe orally that he may sign documents on her behalf, and Rafe signs a written assignment of her equitable interest to her daughter. Quilla later changes her mind. Which of the following best describes the effect of the assignment?
- It is effective, because the assignment was in writing and signed by Quilla's agent.
- It is ineffective, because an agent disposing of an equitable interest must be authorised in writing.Correct answer
- It is effective, because an agent may be authorised orally for any transaction concerning personalty.
- It is effective, because s53(1)(c) applies only to equitable interests in land and not in shares.
- It is ineffective, because an equitable interest may only be assigned by deed executed by the beneficiary.
Section 53(1)(c) of the Law of Property Act 1925 requires a disposition of an equitable interest to be in writing signed by the person disposing of it 'or by his agent thereunto lawfully authorised in writing or by will'. Rafe was authorised only orally, so his signature does not satisfy the section and the assignment is ineffective; Quilla still owns her equitable interest. Section 53(1)(c) applies to equitable interests in any property, including shares, as Grey v IRC shows. No deed is required, only signed writing, which is why the deed answer is wrong.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(c) ↗Question 9 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Selwyn signs, but does not have witnessed, a document stating: 'On my death my house is to be held by my brother Tom on trust for my daughter Una.' He gives it to Tom, who agrees. Selwyn's valid earlier will leaves everything to his wife. Which of the following best describes the effect of the document?
- It creates a valid trust, because it is in writing and signed as s53(1)(b) LPA 1925 requires.
- It creates a valid trust, because Tom accepted the trusteeship during Selwyn's lifetime.
- It creates a valid fully secret trust, because Tom agreed before Selwyn's death.
- It creates a valid trust of a half share, because the house is shared with Selwyn's wife.
- It has no effect, because it is an invalid testamentary disposition.Correct answer
A document that is intended to take effect only on death is testamentary and must comply with s9 of the Wills Act 1837: in writing, signed by the testator, and signed or acknowledged in the presence of two witnesses. Selwyn's document was not witnessed, so it is not a valid will or codicil, and s53(1)(b) cannot save it because it did not create a present trust during his life. A secret trust is not available because a secret trust attaches to property that passes to the secret trustee under a will or intestacy, and here the house passes to Selwyn's wife, not to Tom.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837, s9Question 10 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Vanessa wants to create a trust of her registered freehold land, appointing Will and Xan as trustees. She signs a letter to them saying 'I transfer my land to you to hold on trust for my son'. No deed or registered disposition is made. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Legal title has passed, because the letter is a signed writing as required by s53(1)(b) LPA 1925.
- Legal title has passed, because a transfer to trustees needs less formality than an outright gift.
- Legal title has not passed, because a deed and registration are required.Correct answer
- Legal title has passed, but only once the trustees signed a written acceptance of the trust.
- Legal title has not passed, because a trust of land can only be created by a will.
A conveyance of a legal estate in land must be made by deed under s52(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925, and a transfer of registered land does not operate at law until it is completed by registration under s27 of the Land Registration Act 2002. Vanessa's signed letter is neither, so the trust is not constituted by transfer and legal title remains with her. Section 53(1)(b) concerns written evidence of a declaration of trust, which is a different requirement from transferring legal title. Whether equity can assist the son, for example under Re Rose, depends on whether Vanessa had done everything in her power, which she plainly had not.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, s52(1); Land Registration Act 2002, s27 ↗Question 11 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Yara is entitled to a share of a fund held on trust. She does not want her share and, without anything in writing, tells the trustees that she disclaims it before she has accepted any benefit. The other beneficiaries argue that her disclaimer was ineffective because it was not in writing. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The disclaimer is ineffective, because it disposes of a subsisting equitable interest without signed writing.
- The disclaimer is likely to be effective, because a disclaimer is not a disposition within s53(1)(c).Correct answer
- The disclaimer is ineffective, because a beneficiary can only give up an interest by deed.
- The disclaimer is effective only if the trustees confirm it in writing within a reasonable time.
- The disclaimer is ineffective, because a beneficiary cannot refuse an interest once a trust is constituted.
Nobody can be forced to accept a gift, and a beneficiary may disclaim an interest under a trust before accepting it. In Re Paradise Motor Co Ltd the Court of Appeal held that a disclaimer operates by way of avoidance and not by way of disposition, so it falls outside s53(1)(c) of the Law of Property Act 1925 and need not be in writing. Yara has not accepted any benefit, so her oral disclaimer is effective. The tempting answer treats the disclaimer like an assignment; but an assignment transfers an interest to someone else, whereas a disclaimer refuses it altogether.
Law basis: Re Paradise Motor Co Ltd [1968] 1 WLR 1125; Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(c)Question 12 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Zoltan is entitled under a family trust to a one-third share of a fund of listed shares. At a party he tells his friend Ade, 'I give you my interest in the family trust', and Ade thanks him. Nothing is put in writing. Zoltan dies a month later and Ade claims the share from the trustees. Which of the following best describes Ade's position?
- Ade has no claim, because the oral assignment is void for want of signed writing.Correct answer
- Ade has a claim, because the gift of an equitable interest in shares needs no formality.
- Ade has a claim, because the oral assignment is valid but merely unenforceable until written evidence exists.
- Ade has a claim, because Zoltan's death completed the gift under the rule in Strong v Bird.
- Ade has a claim, because the trustees are bound by any assignment of which they later receive notice.
A disposition of a subsisting equitable interest must be in writing signed by the disposer or his agent authorised in writing: s53(1)(c) of the Law of Property Act 1925. Unlike s53(1)(b), which is evidential and makes an oral declaration of a trust of land unenforceable, s53(1)(c) requires the disposition itself to be in writing, so an oral disposition is void. Zoltan's equitable interest therefore remained his and passes under his will or intestacy. Strong v Bird applies only where the donee becomes the donor's executor or administrator, which Ade has not. Notice to the trustees cannot cure the absence of writing.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(c); Grey v IRC [1960] AC 1 ↗Question 13 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Bodil orally declares, in front of witnesses, that she now holds her freehold house and all the antique furniture in it on trust for her grandson Carl. Nothing is written or signed. Bodil later changes her mind and refuses to recognise any trust. Which of the following best describes Carl's position?
- Carl can enforce the trust of both the house and the furniture, because the declaration was witnessed.
- Carl cannot enforce the trust of either, because a single declaration covering land must be wholly in writing.
- Carl can enforce the trust of the house, but not the furniture, because chattels must be delivered.
- Carl can enforce the trust of the furniture but not of the house.Correct answer
- Carl cannot enforce either trust, because Bodil remained in possession of the house and furniture.
Section 53(1)(b) of the Law of Property Act 1925 requires written evidence, signed by the settlor, of a declaration of trust of land. There is no equivalent requirement for personalty, so a trust of chattels can be declared orally, as Paul v Constance illustrates for money. Bodil's declaration is therefore enforceable as to the furniture, which she holds as trustee for Carl, but unenforceable as to the house. Witnesses do not satisfy s53(1)(b), which needs signed writing. Delivery is not required where the settlor declares herself trustee, because she already holds legal title and need transfer nothing.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(b); Paul v Constance [1977] 1 WLR 527 ↗Question 14 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Dorota has a life interest under her late father's settlement. She signs and sends a letter to the trustees saying: 'I hereby assign my life interest to my brother Emil as a gift.' Emil gave no consideration, and the trustees have not yet acknowledged the letter. Dorota now wishes to revoke the gift. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The assignment is revocable, because Emil is a volunteer and equity will not assist a volunteer.
- The assignment is revocable, because a gift of an equitable interest requires a deed.
- The assignment is incomplete until the trustees acknowledge it in writing.
- The assignment is incomplete, because a life interest cannot be assigned during the settlor's lifetime.
- The assignment is complete and irrevocable, because it was in signed writing.Correct answer
An equitable interest can be given away by a voluntary assignment that complies with s53(1)(c) of the Law of Property Act 1925, that is, writing signed by the assignor. Once that is done, the assignor has done everything required, the gift is complete and the volunteer can enforce it, as Kekewich v Manning shows. Dorota's signed letter satisfies s53(1)(c), so Emil now owns the life interest and Dorota cannot revoke. The maxim that equity will not assist a volunteer applies to incomplete gifts, not completed ones. Notice to trustees matters for priority between competing assignees, not for validity between assignor and assignee.
Law basis: Kekewich v Manning (1851) 1 De GM & G 176; Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(c) ↗Question 15 · FormalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Fenella, aged 80, transfers her registered house to her lodger Gus after he orally agrees that he will hold it for her and that she will remain in charge of it. Nothing about the arrangement is written down. Gus later claims that he owns the house beneficially, relying on s53(1)(b) LPA 1925. Which of the following best describes Fenella's position?
- Fenella has no interest, because the express trust was not evidenced by writing signed by her.
- Fenella has no interest, because a voluntary registered transfer is conclusive of beneficial title.
- Fenella has a personal claim against Gus for damages, but no interest in the house itself.
- Fenella has an interest only if she can show that she relied on Gus's promise to her detriment.
- Fenella keeps the beneficial interest under a resulting trust, which needs no writing.Correct answer
Section 53(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925 provides that s53(1) does not affect the creation or operation of resulting, implied or constructive trusts. In Hodgson v Marks an elderly woman transferred her house to her lodger on an oral understanding that it remained hers. The express trust was unenforceable for want of writing, but the Court of Appeal held that the lodger held on resulting trust for her because she never intended him to take beneficially. The same applies to Fenella. Detrimental reliance is relevant to common intention constructive trusts and estoppel, not to a resulting trust of this kind, so that answer applies the wrong test.
Law basis: Hodgson v Marks [1971] Ch 892; Law of Property Act 1925, s53(2) ↗More Trusts Law topics
Back to all Trusts Law questions, or sit a timed mock.