Law covered in these questions
- Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17
- [2007] 2 AC 432
- Jones v Kernott [2011] UKSC 53
- [2012] 1 AC 776
- Lloyds Bank plc v Rosset [1991] 1 AC 107
- Eves v Eves [1975] 1 WLR 1338
- Grant v Edwards [1986] Ch 638
- Abbott v Abbott [2007] UKPC 53
- Oxley v Hiscock [2004] EWCA Civ 546
- Burns v Burns [1984] Ch 317
- Goodman v Gallant [1986] Fam 106
- Pankhania v Chandegra [2012] EWCA Civ 1438
- Geary v Rankine [2012] EWCA Civ 555
- Marr v Collie [2017] UKPC 17
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Esra and Fynn, an unmarried couple, buy a house in their joint names with no declaration of beneficial interests. Esra paid 60% of the deposit and they shared mortgage payments and other bills from a joint account throughout their ten-year relationship. They separate. Esra claims 60% of the equity. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- Esra is entitled to 60%, because shares follow contributions to the purchase price.
- They are likely to be equal owners.Correct answer
- Esra is entitled to 60%, because a resulting trust arises from her larger deposit payment.
- Fynn is entitled to more than half, because he contributed to bills as well as the mortgage.
- The court will divide the equity according to what it considers fair in all the circumstances.
In Stack v Dowden the House of Lords held that, where a family home is bought in joint names with no express declaration, the starting point is that equity follows the law and the parties are joint beneficial owners in equal shares. The burden is on the party seeking to show different shares, and that will be unusual. The court looks at the whole course of dealing to find the parties' shared intention, not simply at contributions. Pooling of finances and sharing of outgoings over ten years supports equality. The court does not impose its own view of fairness where the parties' intention can be found, which is why the final answer is wrong.
Law basis: Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17; [2007] 2 AC 432Question 2 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Gaia and Hugo bought a house in joint names in 1990 with no declaration of trust. They separated in 1998, after which Gaia paid the mortgage and all outgoings alone for 14 years while Hugo bought a home of his own. Hugo now claims half the equity. The court finds that their intention changed after separation but cannot find what shares they intended. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- The court may decide the shares on the whole course of dealing.Correct answer
- Hugo takes half, because the starting point for joint names can never be displaced.
- Hugo takes half, because an intention cannot be imputed to joint legal owners.
- The shares are fixed by their contributions at the date of purchase in 1990.
- The court must order sale and divide the proceeds by the mortgage payments each made.
In Jones v Kernott the Supreme Court held that the starting point of equal shares for joint names can be displaced by showing that the parties had a different common intention, either at acquisition or later. Their common intention must be inferred from conduct, not imputed. But where it is clear that the parties intended their shares to change and the court cannot infer the actual shares, each is entitled to the share the court considers fair having regard to the whole course of dealing in relation to the property. On similar facts the court awarded the woman 90%. The answer that the starting point can never be displaced overlooks this.
Law basis: Jones v Kernott [2011] UKSC 53; [2012] 1 AC 776Question 3 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Imelda's husband buys a farmhouse in his sole name with money from a family trust. Imelda never discussed ownership with him. She spends months supervising builders, decorating, and arranging finance for renovations, but contributes nothing to the price or the mortgage. The bank seeks possession. Imelda claims a beneficial interest. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She has an interest, because her work increased the value of the farmhouse.
- She has an interest, because a spouse has a beneficial share in the matrimonial home.
- She has an interest under a resulting trust in proportion to the value of her work.
- She is unlikely to have an interest in the farmhouse.Correct answer
- She has an interest only if her work was carried out before completion of the purchase.
Where the home is in one person's sole name, the claimant must first show a common intention that she was to have a beneficial interest, and then detrimental reliance. In Lloyds Bank plc v Rosset the House of Lords held that, without any express agreement, conduct such as supervising renovation work, which a wife might do anyway, was insufficient to infer such an intention; Lord Bridge said direct contributions to the purchase price would readily justify an inference, but little else would. Stack v Dowden doubted that this is the only route, yet Imelda's conduct remains weak evidence. Marriage alone confers no beneficial interest; divorce courts have separate statutory powers.
Law basis: Lloyds Bank plc v Rosset [1991] 1 AC 107Question 4 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Jacqui moves in with Kurt, who buys a house in his sole name. He tells her that her name cannot go on the title because she is under 21, which is untrue. Relying on her expectation of a share, she does heavy work on the house, including demolishing a shed with a sledgehammer and breaking up concrete. They split up. Which of the following best describes Jacqui's position?
- She has no interest, because Kurt's excuse shows that he never intended her to share.
- She has no interest, because she made no financial contribution to the purchase.
- She has an interest only under proprietary estoppel, limited to the cost of her work.
- She has no interest, because a promise of land must be in writing under s53(1)(b) LPA 1925.
- She is likely to have a share under a constructive trust.Correct answer
An express common intention may be shown by an excuse for not putting the claimant on the title, because the excuse implies that she would otherwise have been a joint owner. In Eves v Eves the man told his partner she was too young to be on the title; she then did heavy work on the house. The Court of Appeal held that she had a beneficial interest under a constructive trust, assessing it at a quarter. Her heavy work was detrimental reliance. The answer that the excuse shows no intention to share reflects later doubts, but Eves remains authority. Section 53(2) LPA 1925 exempts constructive trusts from the writing requirement.
Law basis: Eves v Eves [1975] 1 WLR 1338Question 5 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Lidia lives with Marek in a house bought in Marek's sole name. He told her that her name was left off the title because it might prejudice her pending divorce from her husband. Lidia pays most of the household bills from her wages so that Marek can afford the mortgage instalments. They separate. Which of the following best describes Lidia's position?
- She has no interest, because she made no direct contribution to the purchase price or mortgage.
- She has an interest under a resulting trust equal to the total household bills she paid.
- She has no interest, because Marek's statement was an excuse rather than an agreement to share.
- She has an interest only if she can show that Marek intended to deceive her about the title.
- She is likely to have a share under a common intention constructive trust.Correct answer
In Grant v Edwards a man told his partner that her name was not on the title because it might prejudice her divorce. The Court of Appeal held that this excuse showed a common intention that she was to have an interest, and her substantial contributions to household expenses, which enabled him to pay the mortgage, were conduct on which she could not reasonably have been expected to embark unless she was to have a share. She was awarded half. Lidia's position is materially the same. Her indirect contributions are not relevant to a resulting trust, which depends on direct contributions to the price, so that answer applies the wrong framework.
Law basis: Grant v Edwards [1986] Ch 638Question 6 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Nell's mother-in-law gives her son and Nell £50,000 towards buying a home. The house is registered in the son's sole name, but Nell and her husband are jointly liable on the mortgage, pool their earnings in a joint account and share all outgoings. They separate. There was never any express discussion about ownership. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- Nell has no interest, because there was no express agreement that she would share the home.
- Nell has no interest, because the gift from her mother-in-law was made to her husband alone.
- Nell's share is limited to the proportion of the mortgage she can prove she paid personally.
- Nell is likely to have a beneficial share inferred from the whole course of dealing.Correct answer
- Nell is entitled to half automatically, because she was married to the legal owner.
In Abbott v Abbott the Privy Council, applying Stack v Dowden, held that where the home is in one partner's sole name, the court may infer a common intention to share from the whole course of dealing between the parties in relation to the property, not just from direct contributions to the purchase price. A gift from the husband's mother intended for both of them, joint liability on the mortgage and pooled finances justified an inference that the wife was to have an equal share. The answer requiring an express agreement reflects the narrow reading of Lloyds Bank v Rosset, which the Privy Council regarded as having been overtaken.
Law basis: Abbott v Abbott [2007] UKPC 53; Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17Question 7 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Orla and Piotr's home is in Piotr's sole name. The court finds that they had a common intention that Orla should have a beneficial interest and that she relied on it to her detriment, but there was never any discussion of how large her share should be. Which of the following best describes how the court will quantify her share?
- The court will give her a share equal to her financial contributions to the purchase price.
- The court will give her a fair share on the whole course of dealing.Correct answer
- The court will presume that she is entitled to half, because she has an established interest.
- The court cannot quantify her share without evidence of an agreement as to its size.
- The court will give her a share reflecting the value of her unpaid domestic work.
Once a common intention to share the beneficial interest in a sole-name property is established, the court must quantify the share. Where the parties' intention as to the size of the shares cannot be found from their words or conduct, the court may impute an intention, awarding the share that is fair having regard to the whole course of dealing between them in relation to the property, as in Oxley v Hiscock and confirmed in Jones v Kernott. The equal-shares starting point applies to joint-name cases, not sole-name ones, so the answer presuming half is wrong. Financial contributions are relevant but not the only factor.
Law basis: Jones v Kernott [2011] UKSC 53; Oxley v Hiscock [2004] EWCA Civ 546Question 8 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Rosa lived with Silas for 19 years in a house he bought in his sole name. She brought up their children, kept house, and paid for some furniture and decorations from her small earnings. She never contributed to the price or the mortgage, and nothing was said about ownership. They were never married. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She is unlikely to have any beneficial interest in the house.Correct answer
- She has an interest, because her domestic work over 19 years was a contribution in money's worth.
- She has an interest, because she has lived in the house as Silas's partner for over ten years.
- She has an interest equal to half the house, because she raised their children there.
- She has an interest under a resulting trust in proportion to her spending on furniture.
In Burns v Burns a woman who lived with her partner for 19 years, raising their children and running the home, was held to have no beneficial interest in the house he had bought in his sole name. Without a contribution to the acquisition or other conduct showing a common intention to share, domestic work alone did not justify the inference. The court noted that the remedy lay with Parliament. Cohabitants have no statutory property adjustment rights equivalent to those on divorce, so length of cohabitation does not of itself give an interest. Spending on furniture and decorations is not a contribution to the purchase price for resulting trust purposes.
Law basis: Burns v Burns [1984] Ch 317Question 9 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Tarik and Una buy a flat in joint names. The transfer form contains an express declaration that they hold as tenants in common in equal shares. Tarik paid 80% of the price. When they separate, Tarik argues that the flat should be divided according to contributions. There is no evidence of fraud or mistake. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Tarik owns 80%, because a resulting trust arises from his larger contribution.
- Tarik owns 80%, because the declaration is only a starting point that contributions can displace.
- The express declaration is conclusive, so they own the flat equally.Correct answer
- The court will impute an intention reflecting the whole course of dealing between them.
- They own the flat equally only if Una can show that Tarik intended to make her a gift.
Where the legal owners have expressly declared the beneficial interests in writing, that declaration is conclusive in the absence of fraud or mistake, or a later agreement varying it. In Goodman v Gallant the Court of Appeal held that an express declaration of beneficial joint tenancy was conclusive, and Pankhania v Chandegra confirmed that the Stack v Dowden approach to finding intention does not apply where there is an express declaration. Tarik's larger contribution is therefore irrelevant. The answers applying a resulting trust or a whole course of dealing analysis are correct only where there is no express declaration.
Law basis: Goodman v Gallant [1986] Fam 106; Pankhania v Chandegra [2012] EWCA Civ 1438Question 10 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Vita and Wes, a cohabiting couple, run a guest house bought in Wes's sole name with his money, as an investment. Vita works in the business unpaid for some years. There was never any discussion of her owning part of the guest house. She claims a beneficial interest in it. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She is unlikely to have an interest, because no common intention to share the property is shown.Correct answer
- She has an interest, because she worked in the business without pay for several years.
- She has an interest, because the Stack v Dowden presumption of joint ownership applies to cohabitants.
- She has an interest under a resulting trust valued by reference to her unpaid wages.
- She has an interest, because the court can impute an intention to share in a sole-name case.
In a sole-name case the claimant must first establish that the parties had a common intention that she should have a beneficial interest; only then can the court consider imputing an intention as to the size of her share. In Geary v Rankine the Court of Appeal held that a woman who worked in a guest house bought by her partner as a business investment had no interest, because there was no evidence of a common intention that she should share ownership. The search is for the parties' actual shared intention, and in a commercial context it is not readily inferred. Imputation is permitted only at the quantification stage, which is why the final answer is wrong.
Law basis: Geary v Rankine [2012] EWCA Civ 555; Jones v Kernott [2011] UKSC 53Question 11 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Xander and Yves, a cohabiting couple, buy several rental properties as investments in their joint names. Xander provides most of the money. Their relationship was close and their finances were intertwined. When they separate, Xander argues that, because the properties were investments, resulting trust principles must apply. Which of the following best describes the likely approach?
- Resulting trust principles must apply, because the properties were bought as investments.
- The court must presume equal shares, because the presumption in Stack v Dowden is never rebutted.
- The shares must be decided by the date-of-purchase contributions, under Laskar v Laskar.
- The court will look for their actual common intention in all the circumstances.Correct answer
- The court must divide the properties according to the rental income each partner received.
In Marr v Collie the Privy Council held that there is no rule that resulting trust principles apply whenever property is bought as an investment. Where a couple in a personal relationship buy property in joint names, the court should consider whether they had a common intention that the beneficial interests should be shared in a particular way, taking all the circumstances into account, including the nature of their relationship. Laskar v Laskar did not lay down a rule for all investment purchases. The court must therefore look at the evidence of shared intention, which may support equal ownership notwithstanding unequal contributions.
Law basis: Marr v Collie [2017] UKPC 17; Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17Question 12 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Zelda owns her house outright. Her unmarried partner Arto lives there and, over several years, redecorates every room, builds fitted wardrobes and lays a patio, all at his own cost and with his own labour. There was never any discussion about ownership. They separate and Arto claims a share in the house. Which of the following best describes his position?
- He has an interest by statute, because he made a substantial contribution to improving the property.
- He has an interest under a resulting trust equal to the cost of the improvements.
- He has an interest, because the improvements increased the value of the house.
- He has an interest, because a cohabitant who improves property is treated in the same way as a spouse.
- He is unlikely to have any interest, because improvements alone do not show a common intention.Correct answer
In Pettitt v Pettitt the House of Lords held that a husband who carried out redecoration and improvements to his wife's house did not thereby acquire a beneficial interest; such work did not show a common intention that he should share ownership. Section 37 of the Matrimonial Proceedings and Property Act 1970 later provided that a spouse or civil partner who makes a substantial contribution to the improvement of property may acquire a share, but it does not apply to unmarried cohabitants. Arto must therefore show a common intention constructive trust or proprietary estoppel, and nothing suggests one. A resulting trust arises from contributions to acquisition, not later improvements.
Law basis: Pettitt v Pettitt [1970] AC 777; Matrimonial Proceedings and Property Act 1970, s37Question 13 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Bryn and Cai each want to buy a plot of land at auction. They agree orally that Cai will not bid, and that Bryn will buy it and then transfer half of it to Cai. Cai stays away from the auction and Bryn buys the plot cheaply, then refuses to transfer anything to Cai. Which of the following best describes Cai's position?
- Cai has no claim, because the arrangement was not in writing as s2 LP(MP)A 1989 requires.
- Bryn is likely to hold the plot on constructive trust for both.Correct answer
- Cai has no claim, because he paid nothing towards the price of the plot.
- Cai has a claim only in damages for breach of an oral contract for the sale of land.
- Cai has a claim only if the arrangement was recorded in a signed memorandum.
Under the Pallant v Morgan equity, where two parties agree that one will acquire property for the benefit of both, and the other refrains from competing in reliance on that arrangement, it is unconscionable for the acquirer to keep the property for himself. In Pallant v Morgan, and later Banner Homes Group plc v Luff Developments Ltd, the court imposed a constructive trust giving effect to the arrangement. Cai's staying away from the auction was the advantage to Bryn and detriment to Cai. Section 2(5) of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 preserves constructive trusts, so the absence of a written contract is not fatal.
Law basis: Pallant v Morgan [1953] Ch 43; Banner Homes Group plc v Luff Developments Ltd [2000] Ch 372Question 14 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Dara, a builder, orally agrees with the owner of a house that, if Dara does all the building work to convert it into flats, he will be given the ground-floor flat. Dara carries out the work. The owner then sells the building and refuses to honour the agreement, relying on s2 LP(MP)A 1989. Which of the following best describes Dara's position?
- He has no claim to the flat, because a contract for an interest in land must be in signed writing.
- He has a claim only for the reasonable value of his work as a quantum meruit.
- He may be able to claim the flat under a constructive trust or proprietary estoppel despite s2.Correct answer
- He has no claim, because proprietary estoppel cannot be used to enforce a void contract.
- He has a claim to the flat only if he can show the owner acted fraudulently.
Section 2 of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 makes a contract for the sale or other disposition of an interest in land void unless it is in writing signed by both parties and incorporating all the terms. However, s2(5) provides that nothing in the section affects the creation or operation of resulting, implied or constructive trusts. In Yaxley v Gotts the Court of Appeal held that a builder who did work in reliance on an oral promise of a flat was entitled to a long lease of it under a constructive trust, which overlapped with proprietary estoppel. A quantum meruit claim may be possible but understates his rights.
Law basis: Yaxley v Gotts [2000] Ch 162; Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989, s2(5) ↗Question 15 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
For nearly 30 years Elwyn worked unpaid on his elderly cousin's farm. The cousin never made an express promise, but made oblique remarks over the years, such as handing Elwyn a bonus notice for his life insurance and saying 'that's for my death duties', which Elwyn understood to mean that he would inherit the farm. The cousin died intestate. Which of the following best describes Elwyn's position?
- He has no claim, because an assurance must be express and unambiguous.
- He has no claim, because the cousin's promise concerned property not yet owned at his death.
- He has a claim only to the value of his unpaid labour, assessed at market rates.
- He has no claim, because a promise to leave land by will can always be revoked.
- He may establish proprietary estoppel based on an implied assurance.Correct answer
In Thorner v Major the House of Lords held that a farmer's oblique remarks and conduct over many years, including handing over a bonus notice and saying 'that's for my death duties', amounted to an assurance that the claimant would inherit the farm. An assurance need not be express; it is enough that it was clear enough in context and was reasonably understood as intended to be relied on. The claimant relied on it to his detriment by working unpaid for decades. Although a will can be revoked, an assurance relied on to the claimant's detriment can make it unconscionable to resile. The remedy in Thorner was the farm itself.
Law basis: Thorner v Major [2009] UKHL 18Question 16 · Constructive trusts and the family homeDraft, pending solicitor review
Fion lives with Gareth in a house in his sole name. Before he bought it, they had an express conversation in which Gareth agreed that the house would be 'half hers'. Fion has since contributed nothing, done nothing differently in reliance on the agreement, and continued living as before. They separate. Which of the following best describes Fion's position?
- She has a half share, because an express common intention is sufficient on its own.
- She has a half share, because Gareth's agreement amounted to a declaration of trust.
- She is unlikely to have an interest, because there was no detriment.Correct answer
- She has an interest only under a resulting trust, which requires no detriment.
- She has a half share, because a constructive trust arises whenever a promise is broken.
A common intention constructive trust requires both a common intention that the claimant should have a beneficial interest and detrimental reliance by the claimant on that intention. Lloyds Bank plc v Rosset confirmed that where an express agreement is shown, the claimant must still show that she acted to her detriment or significantly altered her position in reliance on it. Without detriment it is not unconscionable for the legal owner to rely on his title. Gareth's oral statement cannot operate as an express declaration of trust of land without signed writing under s53(1)(b) LPA 1925, so that route also fails.
Law basis: Lloyds Bank plc v Rosset [1991] 1 AC 107; Law of Property Act 1925, s53(1)(b)More Trusts Law topics
Back to all Trusts Law questions, or sit a timed mock.