Harun, managing director of a travel agency, dishonestly causes the agency to use money it holds on trust for an airline to pay its own expenses. The agency itself, which is the trustee, is not shown to have been dishonest apart from Harun's conduct. The agency is insolvent. The airline sues Harun personally. Which of the following best describes his liability?
- He is not liable, because he did not personally receive any trust money.
- He is not liable, because only the trustee can be liable for a breach of trust.
- He is liable only if the trustee company also acted dishonestly.
- He is liable only in knowing receipt, because the company received the money.
- He is liable for dishonest assistance.Correct answer
In Royal Brunei Airlines Sdn Bhd v Tan the Privy Council held that a third party who dishonestly assists in a breach of trust is personally liable to the beneficiaries, and that it is the accessory's dishonesty, not the trustee's, that matters. On similar facts the managing director of an insolvent travel company was liable for misusing ticket money held on trust for an airline. Liability does not depend on receiving trust property, which distinguishes dishonest assistance from knowing receipt. Harun did not receive the money beneficially, so knowing receipt is not the right claim against him.
Law basis: Royal Brunei Airlines Sdn Bhd v Tan [1995] 2 AC 378