A testator leaves his house to Xavier in his will and tells Xavier before signing the will that Xavier is to hold it for the testator's partner. Xavier agrees. After the testator dies, Xavier refuses to hold the house for the partner. Which statement best describes the position?
- A fully secret trust arises, and Xavier holds the house on trust for the partner, because of the communication, the acceptance and the reliance, and it operates outside the Wills Act.Correct answer
- A trust arises only if Xavier signs a document after the death.
- A trust arises only if the partner knew about the arrangement.
- No trust arises, because the Wills Act requires all trusts to appear in the will.
- A half-secret trust arises, because the will does not mention the partner.
A fully secret trust needs the testator's intention, communication to the legatee, and acceptance by the legatee, and the legatee then holds on trust outside the will to prevent fraud.
Law basis: Ottaway v Norman [1972] Ch 698; McCormick v Grogan (1869) LR 4 HL 82