A trustee wrongfully takes £10,000 of trust money, pays it into his own bank account that already contains £2,000 of his own funds, and spends £9,000 on a holiday. He leaves £3,000 in the account. Which statement best describes the beneficiaries' claim to the money in the account?
- They can claim nothing, because the bank is the owner of the account.
- They can claim the £3,000 by tracing, because the trustee is presumed to spend his own money first, so the balance is treated as trust money.Correct answer
- They can claim £3,000 only if the trustee agrees.
- They cannot claim any of it, because the money has been mixed.
- They can claim only £1,000, because the trustee's own funds are first used up.
When trust money is mixed with the trustee's own, the trustee is presumed to spend his own money first. Beneficiaries can trace into the lowest intermediate balance, so £3,000 is traceable here.
Law basis: Re Hallett's Estate (1880) 13 Ch D 696; Re Oatway [1903] 2 Ch 356