Joseph wants to issue a claim for £60,000 for breach of contract. He has no personal injury element and no specialist list applies. His solicitor is considering whether to issue in the High Court or the County Court. Which of the following best describes where the claim may be started?
- It must be started in the County Court, because the claim does not exceed £100,000.Correct answer
- It may be started in either court, because there is no financial threshold for High Court claims.
- It must be started in the High Court, because it exceeds the £25,000 fast track limit.
- It may be started in the High Court only, because contract claims are reserved to the King's Bench Division.
- It must be started in the County Court, because claims under £150,000 cannot be heard in the High Court.
Practice Direction 7A, paragraph 2.1, provides that proceedings for damages or a specified sum may not be started in the High Court unless the value of the claim is more than £100,000 (with a separate £50,000 threshold for personal injury claims). Joseph's £60,000 claim does not exceed that, so it must be issued in the County Court. The fast track limit is relevant to track allocation, not to the choice of court. Claims below the threshold can still be transferred to the High Court in appropriate cases, so it is wrong to say they can never be heard there.
Law basis: CPR PD 7A, para 2.1; High Court and County Courts Jurisdiction Order 1991