Law covered in these questions
- Balfour v Balfour [1919] 2 KB 571
- Merritt v Merritt [1970] 1 WLR 1211
- Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Lincoln City Council [1999] 2 AC 349
- National Westminster Bank plc v Spectrum Plus Ltd [2005] UKHL 41
- Doctrine of precedent: reversing and overruling
- Doctrine of precedent: overruling
- res judicata
- Doctrine of precedent: distinguishing
- Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718
- Doctrine of precedent: distinguishing on material facts
- doctrine of implied overruling
- R v Wilson [1997] QB 47
- R v Brown [1994] 1 AC 212
- Burmah Oil Co Ltd v Lord Advocate [1965] AC 75
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
Fatima sues her husband for breach of a written agreement, made after they separated, that he would transfer the matrimonial home to her if she paid off the mortgage. He relies on an earlier Court of Appeal decision that domestic arrangements between spouses are presumed not to be intended to create legal relations. Which of the following best describes how a court could avoid applying the earlier decision?
- By overruling it, because a later Court of Appeal may always overrule an earlier Court of Appeal decision.
- By distinguishing it on the material fact that the spouses had separated when they made the agreement.Correct answer
- By reversing it, because Fatima's case raises the same legal issue as the earlier appeal did.
- By treating it as obiter, because presumptions about intention are never part of a ratio decidendi.
- By declaring it per incuriam, because it did not anticipate agreements between separated spouses.
A court distinguishes an earlier decision when it finds a material difference in the facts so that the earlier ratio does not apply. In Merritt v Merritt the Court of Appeal distinguished Balfour v Balfour because the spouses had separated when they made their agreement, so the presumption against intention to create legal relations was rebutted. The same route is open here. Overruling is done by a higher court, or the Court of Appeal only within the Young exceptions. Reversing happens when an appeal court changes the decision in the same case. Per incuriam concerns ignorance of binding authority or statute, not facts the earlier court did not foresee.
Law basis: Balfour v Balfour [1919] 2 KB 571; Merritt v Merritt [1970] 1 WLR 1211Question 2 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
A bank paid money to Laszlo's council under contracts later held void. For decades the law had been that money paid under a mistake of law was irrecoverable. In the bank's claim, the House of Lords abolishes that rule. The council argues that the change should apply only to payments made after the date of the decision. Which of the following best describes the effect of the decision?
- It applies to the bank's claim, because overruling normally operates retrospectively.Correct answer
- It applies only to future payments, because courts always overrule prospectively to protect reliance.
- It applies only once Parliament has passed legislation confirming that the old rule has been abolished.
- It applies only to payments made after the date on which the bank first issued its claim form.
- It cannot apply to the bank's claim, because a court cannot overrule a rule in the case before it.
When a court overrules an earlier rule, the change operates retrospectively under the declaratory theory: the court is treated as declaring what the law always was. In Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Lincoln City Council the House of Lords abolished the mistake of law bar and allowed the bank to recover payments already made. In National Westminster Bank plc v Spectrum Plus Ltd the House of Lords accepted that prospective overruling might be possible in wholly exceptional cases, but it is not the normal approach. No legislation is needed for a common law change to take effect, and a court can change the law in the very case before it.
Law basis: Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Lincoln City Council [1999] 2 AC 349; National Westminster Bank plc v Spectrum Plus Ltd [2005] UKHL 41Question 3 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
Anna wins her negligence claim against a hospital trust in the High Court. The trust appeals to the Court of Appeal, which allows the appeal and holds that the trust is not liable. Anna asks her solicitor to explain what the Court of Appeal has done to the High Court decision. Which term best describes it?
- Overruling, because a higher court has held that the lower court's legal reasoning was wrong.
- Distinguishing, because the Court of Appeal found the facts to be materially different.
- Reversing, because a higher court has changed the decision in the same case on appeal.Correct answer
- Disapproving, because the Court of Appeal expressed doubt about the decision without changing it.
- Overruling, because Court of Appeal decisions always override High Court decisions.
Reversing occurs when a higher court, on appeal in the same case, changes the decision of the lower court. Here the Court of Appeal reversed the High Court in Anna's own case. Overruling, by contrast, is where a higher court in a later, different case holds that the legal rule in an earlier case was wrong, so that the earlier decision ceases to be authoritative. A decision can be reversed and overruled at the same time if the appeal court also declares an earlier precedent wrong. Distinguishing involves finding material differences in facts between cases, and disapproval means doubting a decision without overruling it.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: reversing and overrulingQuestion 4 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
In 2018 the Court of Appeal decided a case between Patel and Jones, and Jones lost. In 2026 the Supreme Court, in an unrelated case, overrules the Court of Appeal's decision in Patel v Jones. Jones asks whether he can now recover the money he was ordered to pay Patel. Which of the following best describes the position?
- He can, because overruling operates retrospectively and so reverses his case.
- He can, but only if he applies to reopen his case within 21 days of the overruling.
- He cannot, because only decisions of the High Court can ever be overruled.
- He can, because the Supreme Court's decision automatically sets aside the 2018 order.
- He cannot, because the overruling does not reopen the final judgment in his case.Correct answer
Overruling occurs when a higher court in a later, different case decides that the legal rule in an earlier case was wrong. The earlier decision ceases to be good law for the future, and the change is generally treated as declaring what the law always was. However, overruling does not affect the actual outcome between the parties in the earlier case, which remains res judicata. Jones cannot recover the money simply because Patel v Jones has been overruled. Reversing, by contrast, happens on appeal in the same case. Decisions of the Court of Appeal can certainly be overruled by the Supreme Court, and there is no automatic setting aside of earlier orders.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: overruling; res judicataQuestion 5 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
A Court of Appeal decision holds that a worker engaged by an agency was not an employee of the end user. In a later County Court case, Grace, also engaged through an agency, shows that the end user controlled her hours, supplied all equipment and integrated her fully into its workforce, factors that were absent in the Court of Appeal case. Which of the following best describes what the County Court judge may do?
- Distinguish the earlier decision on the basis of the material differences in the facts.Correct answer
- Overrule the earlier decision, because it was decided on less complete evidence.
- Disregard the earlier decision, because County Court judges are not bound by appellate decisions.
- Follow the earlier decision, because a lower court may never distinguish a higher court's ruling.
- Refer the case directly to the Court of Appeal, which must decide whether to distinguish it.
A court bound by an earlier decision may distinguish it where there is a material difference between the facts of the two cases, so that the ratio of the earlier case does not govern the later one. Any court may distinguish a decision, including a decision of a higher court, provided the distinction is genuine and not merely a device to avoid authority. Here, the degree of control, provision of equipment and integration are material facts absent in the Court of Appeal case, so the judge may distinguish it. A lower court cannot overrule a higher court's decision, and the County Court is bound by Court of Appeal ratios that apply.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: distinguishingQuestion 6 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
A High Court judge decides in Kerry's favour on the basis of a 2015 Court of Appeal authority. On appeal in the same case, the Court of Appeal holds that the 2015 decision was wrongly decided under one of the recognised exceptions to its own precedent and finds against Kerry. Which of the following best describes what the Court of Appeal has done?
- It has distinguished the High Court decision and overruled the Supreme Court.
- It has disapproved the High Court decision without changing the outcome for Kerry.
- It has reversed the High Court decision and declined to follow its earlier decision.Correct answer
- It has overruled the High Court decision but left the result in Kerry's favour intact.
- It has reversed the 2015 decision, which now produces a different result for those parties.
Reversing occurs where an appeal court changes the decision of the lower court in the same case, so the Court of Appeal has reversed the High Court's decision in Kerry's case. At the same time, by declining to follow its 2015 decision under a Young v Bristol Aeroplane exception, it has effectively departed from that earlier precedent for the future. That does not change the result between the parties to the 2015 case, which remains binding on them. Disapproval means expressing doubt without overruling and leaves the outcome unchanged, which is not the case here. The Supreme Court is not involved.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: reversing and overruling; Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718Question 7 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
A Court of Appeal decision holds that a driver was not liable for injuring a pedestrian who suddenly ran into the road from behind a parked lorry. In a later County Court case, counsel for the driver, Beatrice, tries to distinguish it on the ground that her car was red rather than blue, and that the pedestrian was wearing a coat. Which of the following best describes whether the judge may distinguish the earlier case?
- Yes, because any difference in the facts allows a lower court to distinguish.
- No, because a case can be distinguished only on material differences in fact.Correct answer
- Yes, because County Court judges may always depart from appellate decisions.
- No, because a lower court may never distinguish a decision of the Court of Appeal.
- Yes, provided the judge gives written reasons for treating the facts as different.
A court may distinguish an earlier binding decision only where there is a material difference in the facts, meaning a difference that affects the application of the legal principle. Differences that are legally irrelevant, such as the colour of a car or a pedestrian's clothing, do not justify distinguishing. If they did, the doctrine of precedent would be undermined, because almost every case differs in some trivial respect. Lower courts can distinguish decisions of higher courts where there is a genuine material difference, so it is wrong to say they can never do so. Giving reasons does not turn an immaterial difference into a material one.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: distinguishing on material factsQuestion 8 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
The Court of Appeal is hearing Yannis's appeal. A Supreme Court decision held that a hospital owed no duty of care to a patient in specified circumstances. Yannis's case concerns a private clinic in circumstances that differ in a way the Supreme Court said was central to its reasoning. Which of the following best describes the Court of Appeal's options?
- It must apply the Supreme Court decision, because only the Supreme Court can distinguish it.
- It may overrule the Supreme Court decision, because the facts in Yannis's case are different.
- It must stay the appeal until the Supreme Court decides whether its decision applies.
- It may distinguish the Supreme Court decision because of the material difference in facts.Correct answer
- It may disregard the Supreme Court decision, because it concerned a public hospital.
Any court, including a lower court, may distinguish a decision of a higher court if there is a genuine material difference in the facts, so that the ratio of the earlier decision does not apply. Since the Supreme Court regarded the relevant feature as central to its reasoning, and that feature differs in Yannis's case, the Court of Appeal may distinguish it. The Court of Appeal cannot overrule the Supreme Court, and it cannot simply disregard a binding decision because it concerned a different kind of defendant unless that difference is material. There is no procedure for staying an appeal for the Supreme Court to rule on the scope of its own decision.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: distinguishingQuestion 9 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
A 2018 Court of Appeal decision supports Nadia's claim. In 2024, the Supreme Court decided another case on the same principle in a way that cannot be reconciled with the 2018 decision, although the Supreme Court did not mention it. A High Court judge now hears Nadia's claim. Which of the following best describes how the judge should treat the 2018 decision?
- As still binding, because only express overruling has any effect.
- As binding, because the Supreme Court did not cite it in 2024.
- As impliedly overruled, and follow the Supreme Court decision.Correct answer
- As per incuriam, but still binding on the High Court until reversed.
- As a matter of choice, because the two authorities conflict.
Where a later decision of a higher court is inconsistent with an earlier decision of a lower appellate court, the earlier decision is treated as impliedly overruled to the extent of the inconsistency, even if it was not mentioned. The High Court must follow the Supreme Court, which sits at the top of the hierarchy. Under Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd, even the Court of Appeal itself must refuse to follow its own decision that cannot stand with a later decision of the House of Lords or Supreme Court. Failure to cite the earlier decision does not preserve it, and the judge has no free choice between the authorities.
Law basis: Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718; doctrine of implied overrulingQuestion 10 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
A House of Lords decision held that consent was no defence to actual bodily harm inflicted during sadomasochistic activity. Later, Mr Wilson branded his initials on his wife's buttocks with a hot knife at her request. He is charged with assault occasioning actual bodily harm. Which of the following best describes how the Court of Appeal treated the earlier decision?
- It applied the earlier decision, because consent is never a defence to actual bodily harm.
- It overruled the earlier decision, because it was out of step with modern attitudes.
- It held the earlier decision per incuriam, because it overlooked earlier authority.
- It distinguished the earlier decision, likening the conduct to tattooing.Correct answer
- It applied the earlier decision, but reduced Mr Wilson's sentence to a discharge.
In R v Wilson the Court of Appeal distinguished R v Brown, in which the House of Lords held that consent was no defence to actual bodily harm in sadomasochistic encounters. In Wilson there was no aggressive intent; the branding was done at the wife's request as a form of personal adornment, comparable to tattooing, and it was not in the public interest to criminalise consensual activity between husband and wife in the matrimonial home. The Court of Appeal could not overrule a House of Lords decision, and it did not treat Brown as per incuriam. Distinguishing on material facts was the legitimate route.
Law basis: R v Wilson [1997] QB 47; R v Brown [1994] 1 AC 212Question 11 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
The House of Lords held that an oil company was entitled to compensation from the Crown for property destroyed by British forces in wartime to prevent it falling into enemy hands. Parliament then passed an Act retrospectively removing any right to such compensation, including for the company. Which of the following best describes the effect of the Act?
- It had no effect on the company, because a statute cannot override a House of Lords ruling.
- It defeated the claim, because Parliament can change the law retrospectively.Correct answer
- It was invalid, because retrospective legislation is never permitted under English law.
- It applied only to future claims, because statutes are always presumed to be prospective.
- It required the approval of the Supreme Court before it could affect the company's claim.
Parliament is sovereign and may legislate to change the law laid down by the courts, including with retrospective effect if it uses clear words. In Burmah Oil Co Ltd v Lord Advocate the House of Lords held that compensation was payable for property destroyed under the prerogative in wartime. Parliament responded with the War Damage Act 1965, which retrospectively abolished the right to such compensation, defeating the company's claim. There is a presumption against retrospective legislation, but it is only a rule of interpretation and gives way to clear words. Courts have no power to approve or invalidate Acts of Parliament.
Law basis: Burmah Oil Co Ltd v Lord Advocate [1965] AC 75; War Damage Act 1965Question 12 · Distinguishing, overruling and reversingDraft, pending solicitor review
For over 20 years, banks relied on a High Court decision that a particular form of charge over book debts was a fixed charge. In a later case, the House of Lords decided that such charges are floating charges and overruled the earlier decision. The banks, including one represented by Mr Mason, asked the House to make its ruling apply only to future charges. Which of the following best describes the outcome?
- The House overruled the earlier decision for future charges only.
- The House declined to overrule the earlier decision because of reliance.
- The House referred the question of prospective effect to Parliament.
- The House overruled the earlier decision with retrospective effect.Correct answer
- The House held that High Court decisions cannot be overruled at all.
In National Westminster Bank plc v Spectrum Plus Ltd the House of Lords overruled Siebe Gorman & Co Ltd v Barclays Bank Ltd and held that the charge was a floating charge. The House accepted that, in wholly exceptional circumstances, it might have power to overrule prospectively, but it declined to do so in this case, so the decision operated retrospectively in the ordinary way despite the banks' reliance. Reliance was therefore not enough to justify prospective overruling or to prevent overruling altogether. Higher courts can overrule decisions of lower courts, and there was no reference to Parliament.
Law basis: National Westminster Bank plc v Spectrum Plus Ltd [2005] UKHL 41; Siebe Gorman & Co Ltd v Barclays Bank Ltd [1979] 2 Lloyd's Rep 142More Legal System of England and Wales topics
Back to all Legal System of England and Wales questions, or sit a timed mock.