Law covered in these questions
- Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718
- Davis v Johnson [1979] AC 264
- Doctrine of binding precedent (stare decisis)
- Broome v Cassell & Co Ltd [1972] AC 1027
- Attorney General for Jersey v Holley [2005] UKPC 23
- R v James [2006] EWCA Crim 14
- Willers v Joyce [2016] UKSC 44
- Doctrine of binding precedent: court hierarchy
- Police Authority for Huddersfield v Watson [1947] KB 842
- Colchester Estates (Cardiff) v Carlton Industries plc [1986] Ch 80
- Employment Tribunals Act 1996, s.21
- doctrine of binding precedent
- Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v Morts Dock & Engineering Co Ltd (The Wagon Mound (No 1)) [1961] AC 388
- Practice Direction (Citation of Authorities) [2001] 1 WLR 1001
All 19 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In a civil case, the Court of Appeal is asked to follow its own earlier decision, which the party says was wrongly decided. Which statement best describes the Court's approach?
- It is bound only if the earlier decision was made by the same three judges.
- It is free to depart from its earlier decisions whenever it thinks they were wrong.
- It is bound by its earlier decision only if the Supreme Court has endorsed it.
- It is never bound by its own earlier decisions in any circumstances.
- It is normally bound by its earlier decision, subject to exceptions such as a conflict between two earlier decisions or a decision made per incuriam.Correct answer
The Court of Appeal is generally bound by its own previous decisions, subject to the Young v Bristol Aeroplane exceptions: two conflicting earlier decisions, a decision inconsistent with a higher court, and a decision made per incuriam.
Law basis: Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718Question 2 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) is hearing an appeal by Bilal. Counsel shows that the court's own previous decision, which would defeat Bilal's claim, cannot stand with a later decision of the Supreme Court, although the Supreme Court did not expressly overrule it. Which of the following best describes the Court of Appeal's position?
- It must follow its earlier decision, because only an express overruling releases it from that decision.
- It may depart from its earlier decision whenever it appears right to do so under the 1966 Practice Statement.
- It must refer the conflict to the Supreme Court before deciding Bilal's appeal on its merits.
- It may decline to follow its earlier decision as inconsistent with the later Supreme Court ruling.Correct answer
- It may decline to follow its earlier decision only if that decision was given by a two-judge court.
The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) is generally bound by its own previous decisions, but Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd recognises three exceptions: where its own decisions conflict, it may choose which to follow; it must refuse to follow its own decision which, though not expressly overruled, cannot stand with a later House of Lords (now Supreme Court) decision; and it need not follow a decision given per incuriam. The second exception applies to Bilal's appeal. The Practice Statement of 1966 applies only to the House of Lords and Supreme Court, not the Court of Appeal, as confirmed in Davis v Johnson.
Law basis: Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718; Davis v Johnson [1979] AC 264Question 3 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
A High Court judge hearing Rosa's negligence claim considers that a relevant Court of Appeal decision is plainly wrong and out of line with modern authority from other common law jurisdictions. The decision has not been overruled. Which of the following best describes the High Court judge's position?
- The judge may depart from it, because High Court judges are not bound by decisions they consider wrong.
- The judge may depart from it, because more recent Commonwealth authority overrides older English cases.
- The judge must follow it only if it was decided by a five-judge Court of Appeal rather than three.
- The judge must refer the question directly to the Supreme Court using the leapfrog procedure.
- The judge must follow the Court of Appeal decision, but may say why it is thought to be wrong.Correct answer
Under the doctrine of stare decisis, decisions of the Court of Appeal bind the High Court. A High Court judge must follow them even if considered wrong, although the judge can explain their reservations and the matter can be taken on appeal. Decisions from other common law jurisdictions are persuasive only and cannot override binding English authority. The number of judges in the Court of Appeal does not affect its binding force on lower courts. Leapfrog appeals to the Supreme Court are possible in limited circumstances under the Administration of Justice Act 1969, but they require a certificate and permission and are not a mandatory referral mechanism.
Law basis: Doctrine of binding precedent (stare decisis); Broome v Cassell & Co Ltd [1972] AC 1027Question 4 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In an appeal from Jersey, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, sitting as a board of nine judges, decides a point on the defence of provocation differently from an earlier House of Lords decision, and states that its decision represents English law. Later, the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) must decide the same point in Ashok's case. Which of the following best describes the Court of Appeal's position?
- It must follow the House of Lords decision, because Privy Council decisions can never be followed over it.
- It must follow the Privy Council decision in every case, because it binds all English courts.
- It may follow the Privy Council decision, because the Board expressly stated it represents English law.Correct answer
- It may choose either decision, because conflicting authorities always leave a lower court free to choose.
- It must follow the House of Lords decision unless the Supreme Court has since approved the Privy Council.
Privy Council decisions are not formally binding on English courts and are normally only persuasive. However, in R v James the Court of Appeal followed Attorney General for Jersey v Holley rather than the House of Lords decision in R v Smith (Morgan) because the Board, sitting with nine judges, had made clear that it was stating English law. In Willers v Joyce the Supreme Court confirmed that, where the Board expressly directs that its decision states English law, domestic courts should treat it as binding. This is an exception, not a general rule, so Privy Council decisions do not bind all English courts in every case.
Law basis: Attorney General for Jersey v Holley [2005] UKPC 23; R v James [2006] EWCA Crim 14; Willers v Joyce [2016] UKSC 44Question 5 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
During a trial in the Crown Court, a circuit judge makes a ruling on the admissibility of evidence. In a later, unrelated trial in the Crown Court, counsel for Megan argues that the second judge is bound by the earlier ruling on an identical point. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The earlier ruling is binding, because judges of the same court must follow one another's decisions.
- The earlier ruling is binding, unless it has been reported in an official series of law reports.
- The earlier ruling is not binding, because Crown Court decisions do not create binding precedent.Correct answer
- The earlier ruling is binding only if it was made by a High Court judge sitting in the Crown Court.
- The earlier ruling is binding on later Crown Court judges, but not on magistrates' courts.
Only certain courts create binding precedent: the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal, the Divisional Courts and, for lower courts, the High Court. Decisions of first-instance courts such as the Crown Court, county court and magistrates' courts do not bind other courts, although they may be of persuasive value. The second Crown Court judge is bound by decisions of the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court on the point, but not by the earlier Crown Court ruling. Reporting a decision does not make it binding, and whether a High Court judge sits in the Crown Court does not turn a Crown Court ruling into binding precedent.
Law basis: Doctrine of binding precedent: court hierarchyQuestion 6 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
A Divisional Court of the King's Bench Division is hearing an appeal by way of case stated from magistrates in Fiona's case. Counsel cites a previous decision of the Divisional Court directly in point. Which of the following best describes whether the Divisional Court is bound by its own earlier decision?
- It is generally bound, subject to the same exceptions that apply to the Court of Appeal.Correct answer
- It is never bound, because High Court judges are free to depart from each other's decisions.
- It is bound absolutely, with no exceptions, because it is an appellate court.
- It is bound only if the earlier decision was later approved by the Supreme Court.
- It is not bound, because only the Court of Appeal's decisions bind the Divisional Court.
A Divisional Court exercising appellate jurisdiction is generally bound by its own previous decisions, subject to the same exceptions as apply to the Court of Appeal under Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd (Police Authority for Huddersfield v Watson). In criminal matters, as with the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), it may have a little more flexibility where liberty is at stake. It is also bound by the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. The rule that High Court judges at first instance are not strictly bound by each other relates to single judges, not Divisional Courts acting on appeal. Supreme Court approval is not needed for its decisions to bind.
Law basis: Police Authority for Huddersfield v Watson [1947] KB 842; Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718Question 7 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
A High Court judge is hearing Marta's claim. Two earlier first-instance decisions of the High Court on the same point conflict. The second judge considered the first decision fully, with full argument, but declined to follow it. No appellate court has ruled on the point. Which of the following best describes the approach the current judge should normally take?
- Follow the first decision, because the earliest High Court decision always prevails.
- Disregard both decisions, because High Court decisions do not bind other High Court judges.
- Follow whichever decision was given by the more senior High Court judge.
- Follow the second decision, unless satisfied that it was plainly wrong.Correct answer
- Refer the conflict to a Divisional Court, which must resolve it before trial.
High Court judges sitting at first instance are not strictly bound by each other's decisions, but for the sake of certainty they normally follow them unless convinced they are wrong. In Colchester Estates (Cardiff) v Carlton Industries plc it was held that where there are conflicting first-instance decisions and the later one was reached after full consideration of the earlier one, the later decision should normally be followed, unless the third judge is convinced that the second judge was wrong in not following the first. Seniority of the judge is not the test, and there is no procedure for referring such a conflict to a Divisional Court.
Law basis: Colchester Estates (Cardiff) v Carlton Industries plc [1986] Ch 80Question 8 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
A district judge in the County Court is hearing Zoe's claim. A Court of Appeal decision from 2019 supports Zoe. A High Court judge in 2024, sitting at first instance, refused to follow that Court of Appeal decision on the basis that it was unworkable. Which of the following best describes what the district judge should do?
- Follow the High Court decision, because it is more recent than the Court of Appeal decision.
- Choose between the two decisions, because the County Court is not bound by either court.
- Follow the High Court decision, because the High Court is the court immediately above the County Court.
- Adjourn the claim and refer the conflict to the Court of Appeal before giving judgment.
- Follow the Court of Appeal decision, which binds both the County Court and the High Court.Correct answer
Under the doctrine of binding precedent, decisions of the Court of Appeal bind all lower courts, including the High Court and the County Court. The High Court judge was therefore wrong not to follow the 2019 Court of Appeal decision, and the later High Court decision does not displace it. The district judge must follow the Court of Appeal decision. Although High Court decisions generally bind the County Court, a High Court decision cannot override a binding Court of Appeal authority, and recency does not matter. There is no procedure for a district judge to refer a conflict of authority to the Court of Appeal before deciding the case.
Law basis: Doctrine of binding precedent: court hierarchyQuestion 9 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
Magistrates are trying Imran for a summary offence. The prosecution cites a recent decision of the Divisional Court of the King's Bench Division, given on an appeal by way of case stated, on the meaning of the offence. The defence says the magistrates may reach their own view. Which of the following best describes the magistrates' position?
- They may decline to follow it, because only the Supreme Court binds magistrates.
- They may decline to follow it, because case stated decisions bind only the parties.
- They are bound only if the Crown Court has also applied the same interpretation.
- They are bound to follow the Divisional Court decision on the point of law.Correct answer
- They may decline to follow it if their legal adviser considers it wrongly decided.
Magistrates' courts are at the bottom of the court hierarchy and are bound by decisions of the higher courts, including the High Court, the Divisional Court, the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. A decision of the Divisional Court on appeal by way of case stated establishes a precedent on the point of law decided, not merely a ruling between the parties. The magistrates must therefore follow it. Crown Court decisions do not create binding precedent, so what the Crown Court has done is irrelevant. The legal adviser advises on the law, including binding precedent, but cannot authorise the bench to disregard a binding decision.
Law basis: Doctrine of binding precedent: court hierarchyQuestion 10 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
An employment tribunal is deciding Gloria's discrimination claim. A decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal on the precise point supports her, but the employer relies on an earlier first-instance decision of another employment tribunal that reached the opposite view. Which of the following best describes the tribunal's position?
- It may choose between the two, because tribunal decisions are never binding.
- It must follow the employment tribunal decision, because it was decided first.
- It is bound by the EAT decision only if the Court of Appeal has approved it.
- It is bound by the EAT decision, and the other tribunal's decision is not binding.Correct answer
- It must stay the claim until the EAT reconsiders its decision in light of the other.
The Employment Appeal Tribunal hears appeals on points of law from employment tribunals, and its decisions bind employment tribunals. Decisions of employment tribunals, which are first-instance bodies, do not bind other tribunals. The employment tribunal must therefore follow the EAT decision. In turn, the EAT is bound by decisions of the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court, but approval by a higher court is not required for an EAT decision to bind employment tribunals. The order in which decisions were made does not matter where one is binding and the other is not.
Law basis: Employment Tribunals Act 1996, s.21; doctrine of binding precedentQuestion 11 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) is hearing Ben's appeal. Counsel shows that two of the court's previous decisions on the same point directly conflict with each other, and neither has been considered by the Supreme Court. Which of the following best describes the Court of Appeal's position?
- It may choose which of its two conflicting decisions to follow.Correct answer
- It must follow the earlier decision, because the first decision always prevails.
- It must follow the later decision, because it impliedly overruled the earlier one.
- It must refer the conflict to the Supreme Court before deciding the appeal.
- It must disregard both decisions and decide the point afresh as if new.
In Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd the Court of Appeal held that it is bound by its own previous decisions, subject to three exceptions. The first is that where there are two conflicting decisions of its own, it is entitled and bound to decide which to follow; the decision not followed is then effectively overruled. There is no rule that the earlier or later decision automatically prevails. The Court of Appeal cannot refer a question to the Supreme Court in the abstract; the matter can reach the Supreme Court only on appeal. Disregarding both decisions would be inconsistent with the doctrine of precedent.
Law basis: Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718Question 12 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In a negligence claim in the High Court, counsel for Adele relies on a decision of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, given on appeal from Australia, on remoteness of damage. There is an older Court of Appeal decision taking a different view. The Board did not state that its decision represents English law. Which of the following best describes the status of the Privy Council decision?
- It binds the High Court, because the Privy Council is made up of Supreme Court justices.
- It binds the High Court, because it is more recent than the Court of Appeal decision.
- It is irrelevant, because decisions on Australian law can never be cited in England.
- It binds the High Court, but not the Court of Appeal, which may choose between them.
- It is highly persuasive, but the Court of Appeal decision still binds the judge.Correct answer
The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council is the final court of appeal for certain Commonwealth countries and other territories. Its decisions are not binding on English courts, although they are highly persuasive, particularly as its members are usually justices of the Supreme Court. For example, The Wagon Mound (No 1) was decided by the Privy Council but became widely accepted in England. However, a lower court remains bound by a Court of Appeal decision. The exception in Willers v Joyce applies only where the Board expressly states that its decision represents English law, which did not happen here. Recency does not alter the hierarchy.
Law basis: Willers v Joyce [2016] UKSC 44; Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v Morts Dock & Engineering Co Ltd (The Wagon Mound (No 1)) [1961] AC 388Question 13 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
The Court of Appeal is hearing Laura's appeal. A Supreme Court decision from 2012 is directly against her. In a 2025 case on a different point, several Supreme Court justices remarked obiter that the 2012 decision may need to be revisited. Which of the following best describes the Court of Appeal's position?
- It may depart from the 2012 decision, because the Supreme Court has signalled doubt about it.
- It must follow the 2012 decision until the Supreme Court actually departs from it.Correct answer
- It may depart from the 2012 decision, because it is per incuriam after the 2025 remarks.
- It must follow the 2025 remarks, because they are the most recent Supreme Court statement.
- It may use the Practice Statement to depart from the 2012 decision in exceptional cases.
The Court of Appeal is bound by decisions of the Supreme Court. Obiter remarks in a later case doubting an earlier decision do not release lower courts from a binding ratio; only the Supreme Court can depart from its own decision, using the Practice Statement. The Court of Appeal should therefore follow the 2012 decision, although it may grant permission to appeal so that the Supreme Court can reconsider it. Doubts expressed later do not make a decision per incuriam, which concerns ignorance of binding statute or authority at the time. The Practice Statement is not available to the Court of Appeal (Davis v Johnson; Broome v Cassell & Co Ltd).
Law basis: Broome v Cassell & Co Ltd [1972] AC 1027; Davis v Johnson [1979] AC 264Question 14 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In the Court of Appeal, counsel for Freddie cites a short judgment given by a single Lord Justice refusing permission to appeal in an earlier case, which said the point was 'not arguable'. The judgment does not claim to establish any new principle. Which of the following best describes whether it may be cited and relied upon?
- It should not normally be cited, as permission decisions are not precedents.Correct answer
- It must be followed, because all Court of Appeal judgments bind the Court of Appeal.
- It may be cited and is binding, provided it has been reported in a recognised series.
- It is binding on lower courts, but not on the Court of Appeal itself in later appeals.
- It may be cited only if the Lord Justice who gave it is sitting on the present appeal.
The Practice Direction (Citation of Authorities) [2001] provides that judgments on applications for permission to appeal, and judgments deciding only that an application is arguable or not arguable, should not be cited as authority unless they clearly indicate that they purport to establish a new principle or extend the present law. Such decisions are not considered and argued determinations of law and do not form binding precedent in the ordinary way. Freddie's counsel should not rely on it. Reporting does not change this, and the identity of the judges hearing the present appeal is irrelevant.
Law basis: Practice Direction (Citation of Authorities) [2001] 1 WLR 1001Question 15 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In the County Court, counsel for Sophia relies on a Court of Appeal decision directly in point. It was transcribed but never published in any series of law reports. The other side says that an unreported case cannot bind the court. Which of the following best describes the position?
- It is not binding, because only decisions published in official law reports bind courts.
- It is persuasive only, because unreported decisions have not been checked by a judge.
- It is binding only if the Court of Appeal marked the transcript as suitable for citation.
- It is binding, because a decision's authority does not depend on its being reported.Correct answer
- It is not binding, because County Court judges must follow reported cases only.
The binding force of a decision comes from the status of the court that decided it and the principle decided, not from whether it appears in a law report. An unreported Court of Appeal decision is therefore as binding on the County Court as a reported one, provided a reliable transcript or record is available. There are practice restrictions on citing unreported cases in higher courts, for example the House of Lords in Roberts Petroleum Ltd v Bernard Kenny Ltd discouraged citing unreported Court of Appeal decisions without good reason, but those restrictions do not deprive a decision of authority. The other side's argument fails.
Law basis: Roberts Petroleum Ltd v Bernard Kenny Ltd [1983] 2 AC 192; doctrine of binding precedentQuestion 16 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
The Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) is deciding an appeal by Raymond. A Court of Appeal decision interpreting the relevant regulation goes against him, but several judges of the Upper Tribunal consider it wrong. Which of the following best describes the Upper Tribunal's position?
- It may depart from it, because the Upper Tribunal is a superior court of record.
- It may depart from it, because tribunals apply their own specialist rules of precedent.
- It is bound only if the Court of Appeal decision was heard on appeal from the Upper Tribunal.
- It may depart from it if a three-judge panel of the Upper Tribunal is convened.
- It is bound by the Court of Appeal decision on the point of law.Correct answer
Although the Upper Tribunal is a superior court of record under section 3(5) of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007, and its decisions bind the First-tier Tribunal, it sits below the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court in the hierarchy. Appeals from the Upper Tribunal go to the Court of Appeal under section 13. The Upper Tribunal is therefore bound by decisions of the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court on points of law. Convening a larger panel does not give it power to depart from Court of Appeal authority, and it does not matter whether the Court of Appeal case started in a tribunal or a court.
Law basis: Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007, ss.3(5), 13; doctrine of binding precedent ↗Question 17 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In a High Court negligence claim brought by Hamish, counsel relies on a decision of the Inner House of the Court of Session in Scotland, which considered a similar issue under Scots law of delict. There is no English authority on the point. Which of the following best describes the status of the Scottish decision?
- It is binding, because the Court of Session is a UK appellate court.
- It is persuasive, but not binding on the English High Court.Correct answer
- It is binding, because Scots and English law are now identical in tort.
- It is irrelevant, because Scottish decisions can never be cited in England.
- It is binding only if the Supreme Court refused permission to appeal from it.
England and Wales and Scotland are separate legal jurisdictions with different court systems. Decisions of the Scottish courts, including the Court of Session, are not binding on English courts, but they may be cited as persuasive authority, particularly where the law in the two jurisdictions is similar, as it often is in negligence. The Supreme Court hears appeals from both jurisdictions, and its decisions on law common to both may be treated as authoritative in each, but a Court of Session decision itself does not bind an English court. A refusal of permission by the Supreme Court does not make the decision binding.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: persuasive authorityQuestion 18 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) convenes a special court of five judges, rather than the usual three, to hear Isla's appeal. The five judges are invited to depart from one of the court's previous three-judge decisions, which none of the Young v Bristol Aeroplane exceptions covers. Which of the following best describes the position?
- A five-judge court may depart from three-judge decisions as of right.
- A five-judge court may use the Practice Statement in civil cases.
- A five-judge court is bound in the same way as a three-judge court.Correct answer
- A five-judge court may depart if all five judges agree to do so.
- A five-judge court may depart if the Master of the Rolls presides.
In Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd a full court of the Court of Appeal held that the court is bound by its own previous decisions, subject only to the recognised exceptions. In Davis v Johnson a five-judge Court of Appeal declined to follow earlier decisions, but the House of Lords reaffirmed the rule in Young and made clear that the Court of Appeal (Civil Division) cannot extend the exceptions. A larger court does not have greater power to depart from the court's previous decisions than a court of three. The Practice Statement applies only to the House of Lords and now the Supreme Court.
Law basis: Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718; Davis v Johnson [1979] AC 264Question 19 · Court hierarchy and binding precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In a libel action, the Court of Appeal held that a House of Lords decision restricting exemplary damages was given per incuriam because it overlooked two earlier House of Lords cases, and declined to follow it. On further appeal by Captain Broome's publishers, which of the following best describes the House of Lords' response?
- The Court of Appeal was right, because per incuriam applies to all decisions.
- The Court of Appeal was right, because the House of Lords decision was unworkable.
- The Court of Appeal was wrong only because it gave no notice to the Attorney General.
- The Court of Appeal was right, but only because the case concerned civil damages.
- The Court of Appeal was wrong, because it must follow House of Lords decisions.Correct answer
In Cassell & Co Ltd v Broome the House of Lords strongly criticised the Court of Appeal for treating Rookes v Barnard as per incuriam and declining to follow it. The House held that, in the hierarchical system of courts, each lower tier, including the Court of Appeal, must accept loyally the decisions of the higher tiers. The per incuriam exception in Young v Bristol Aeroplane concerns the Court of Appeal's own decisions, not decisions of the House of Lords (now Supreme Court). Whether a decision is unworkable is for the higher court to decide, and the nature of the claim makes no difference.
Law basis: Cassell & Co Ltd v Broome [1972] AC 1027; Rookes v Barnard [1964] AC 1129More Legal System of England and Wales topics
Back to all Legal System of England and Wales questions, or sit a timed mock.