Key rules
Intrinsic aids (within the Act): long and short title, preamble, headings, schedules, definition sections and punctuation may be considered as context. Headings and side notes carry less weight than the operative words but may be used (R v Montila (2004)).
Extrinsic aids (outside the Act):
- Interpretation Act 1978: words importing the masculine include the feminine and the singular includes the plural unless the contrary intention appears (s 6); repeal does not affect rights already accrued (s 16(1)); an Act without a commencement provision comes into force at the start of the day of royal assent (s 4).
- Explanatory Notes are admissible to understand the contextual scene and mischief (Westminster City Council v National Asylum Support Service (2002)).
- Hansard may be used where (1) the legislation is ambiguous, obscure or leads to absurdity, (2) the material is a statement by a minister or other promoter of the Bill, and (3) the statement is clear (Pepper v Hart (1993)). It cannot be used to find the meaning of clear words, and courts use it cautiously (Wilson v First County Trust Ltd (No 2) (2003)).
- Official reports (Law Commission, committee reports) may be used to identify the mischief, but not to find the meaning directly (Black-Clawson International Ltd v Papierwerke Waldhof-Aschaffenburg AG (1975)).
- Dictionaries may be consulted for ordinary meaning (Cheeseman v DPP (1992)).
- Treaties: where an Act gives effect to an international convention, the court may refer to it and presume Parliament intended to comply (Salomon v Commissioners of Customs and Excise (1967)).
- Earlier statutes behind a consolidation Act may be used only if the consolidation Act is ambiguous (Farrell v Alexander (1977)).
Linguistic rules
- Ejusdem generis: general words following specific words are limited to the same kind (Powell v Kempton Park Racecourse Co Ltd (1899): "house, office, room or other place" means indoor places).
- Noscitur a sociis: a word is known by its neighbours (IRC v Frere (1965)).
- Expressio unius est exclusio alterius: express mention of one thing excludes others (Tempest v Kilner (1846): "goods, wares and merchandise" did not include shares).
Presumptions (rebuttable by clear words)
| Presumption |
Authority |
| Mens rea required for criminal offences |
Sweet v Parsley (1970); B (A Minor) v DPP (2000) |
| No retrospective criminal liability |
Waddington v Miah (1974); ECHR Art 7 |
| Penal provisions construed strictly in favour of the defendant |
Tuck & Sons v Priester (1887) |
| Crown not bound unless expressly or by necessary implication |
Lord Advocate v Dumbarton DC (1990) |
| No ouster of the courts' jurisdiction without clear words |
Anisminic v Foreign Compensation Commission (1969); R (Privacy International) v IPT (2019) |
| No interference with fundamental rights without clear words (principle of legality) |
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Simms (2000) |
| No deprivation of property without compensation |
Central Control Board v Cannon Brewery (1919) |
| No change to the common law without clear words |
general principle |
| Compliance with international obligations |
Salomon (1967) |
How it is tested
- Hansard. Counsel wants to cite a minister's statement. Check all three Pepper v Hart conditions.
- List of words then general words. Apply ejusdem generis or expressio unius.
- Silent offence. A new offence says nothing about mental element; the presumption of mens rea applies.
- Ouster clause. "Shall not be called in question" is read narrowly and does not protect a decision that is a nullity.
Exam traps
- Using Hansard whenever helpful. It requires ambiguity or absurdity plus a clear ministerial statement.
- Using a committee report for the meaning of words rather than the mischief.
- Treating presumptions as absolute. Clear words or necessary implication rebut them.
- Saying an Act with no commencement provision starts at midnight after royal assent. It starts at the beginning of the day of royal assent.
Quick check
Remember: Pepper v Hart allows Hansard only for ambiguity, obscurity or absurdity, and only for clear statements by the promoter; presumptions guide meaning but yield to clear words.