Key rules
- Structure: the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 (TCEA) created a unified two-tier system: the First-tier Tribunal (FtT) and the Upper Tribunal (UT), each divided into chambers, led by the Senior President of Tribunals.
| First-tier Tribunal chambers |
Upper Tribunal chambers |
| General Regulatory |
Administrative Appeals |
| Health, Education and Social Care |
Immigration and Asylum |
| Immigration and Asylum |
Lands |
| Property |
Tax and Chancery |
| Social Entitlement |
|
| Tax |
|
| War Pensions and Armed Forces Compensation |
|
- Status: the UT is a superior court of record (TCEA s 3(5)). Its decisions bind the FtT; the UT is itself bound by the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court.
- Review: the FtT may review its own decision and set it aside for error (s 9).
- Appeal from FtT to UT: on a point of law, with permission from the FtT or UT (s 11).
- Appeal from UT to Court of Appeal: on a point of law with permission (s 13). The second-appeals test applies: an important point of principle or practice, or another compelling reason (s 13(6); Appeals from the Upper Tribunal to the Court of Appeal Order 2008).
- Judicial review of UT permission refusals ("Cart" JRs): R (Cart) v Upper Tribunal (2011) allowed it on the second-appeals criteria, but the Judicial Review and Courts Act 2022 s 2 inserted TCEA s 11A, making a UT refusal of permission to appeal final and not open to judicial review, save in limited cases (for example bad faith or a fundamental breach of natural justice).
- UT judicial review jurisdiction: the UT may hear certain classes of judicial review, including many immigration cases (TCEA ss 15, 18; Senior Courts Act 1981 s 31A).
- Judicial independence: the guarantee of continued judicial independence extends to the tribunal judiciary (TCEA s 1; Constitutional Reform Act 2005 s 3).
Employment tribunals sit outside the two-tier structure.
- Governed by the Employment Tribunals Act 1996. A prospective claimant must usually contact Acas for early conciliation before presenting a claim (s 18A).
- Appeal lies to the Employment Appeal Tribunal on a point of law (s 21), then to the Court of Appeal with permission. EAT decisions bind employment tribunals; one employment tribunal does not bind another.
Advantages of tribunals: specialist panels (often a judge plus expert lay members), speed, lower cost, informality, and in most jurisdictions no general costs-shifting. Disadvantages: imbalance where one side is represented, limited legal aid, delays in some chambers, and limited onward appeal (points of law only).
How it is tested
- Which tribunal. An HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) tax dispute goes to the FtT (Tax Chamber); a social security decision to the FtT (Social Entitlement Chamber).
- Next step after FtT loss. Appeal to the UT on a point of law with permission, or ask the FtT to review.
- Unfair dismissal claim. Early conciliation first; appeal from the ET to the EAT on law only.
- Precedent. A UT decision binds the FtT; an ET decision binds no one.
- UT refuses permission. Under s 11A the refusal is final; no judicial review on ordinary grounds.
Exam traps
- Saying appeals from the FtT lie on fact. They lie on points of law only.
- Treating employment tribunals as a chamber of the FtT.
- Relying on Cart judicial review as still generally available. It was largely abolished in 2022.
- Saying tribunal judges lack the protection of judicial independence.
- Going straight to the Court of Appeal from the FtT. The route is through the UT.
Quick check
Remember: FtT to UT to Court of Appeal, each step on a point of law with permission; the UT is a superior court of record whose decisions bind the FtT.