Law covered in these questions
- Miller v Minister of Pensions [1947] 2 All ER 372
- Criminal Justice Act 2003 Sch 3
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 ss 18-24A
- Juries Act 1974, s.17
- Crime and Disorder Act 1998, s.51
- Juries Act 1974, s.1
- Juries Act 1974, s.20A
- Juries Act 1974, ss.20D-20E
- R v Mirza [2004] UKHL 2
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, s.44
- R v Twomey [2009] EWCA Crim 1035
- Courts Act 2003, s.28
- Criminal Procedure Rules
- Children and Young Persons Act 1933, ss.45-46, 50
All 17 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
In a civil claim in negligence, which statement best describes the burden and standard of proof?
- The claimant must prove the case on the balance of probabilities.Correct answer
- The claimant must prove the case on a standard that is higher than the balance of probabilities but lower than beyond reasonable doubt.
- The defendant must disprove the claim beyond reasonable doubt.
- The defendant must prove the case on the balance of probabilities.
- The claimant must prove the case beyond reasonable doubt.
In civil cases the party who asserts must prove it, to the civil standard of more likely than not. The criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt applies to the prosecution in criminal cases.
Law basis: Miller v Minister of Pensions [1947] 2 All ER 372Question 2 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant is charged with theft, an offence triable either way. At the plea before venue hearing the defendant pleads not guilty. Which statement best describes what happens next?
- The magistrates decide whether the case is suitable for summary trial, and if so the defendant may elect trial in the Crown Court.Correct answer
- The case must go to the Crown Court, because it is not an indictable-only offence.
- The defendant must be tried by a jury of twelve in the magistrates' court.
- The magistrates must try the case, and the defendant has no right to elect Crown Court trial.
- The prosecution decides which court will try the case, with no input from the defendant.
Question 3 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
A jury of 12 in the Crown Court has been deliberating on Dominic's trial for 3 hours. The judge has given a majority direction. The jury returns and the foreman announces a guilty verdict, stating that 9 jurors agreed and 3 did not. Which of the following best describes whether the verdict can be accepted?
- It can be accepted, because a simple majority suffices once the jury has deliberated for 2 hours.
- It can be accepted, because a 9-3 majority is valid if the judge has given a majority direction.
- It cannot be accepted, because with 12 jurors a majority verdict requires at least 10 to agree.Correct answer
- It cannot be accepted, because majority verdicts are available only where a juror has been discharged.
- It cannot be accepted, because a guilty verdict in the Crown Court must always be unanimous.
Section 17 of the Juries Act 1974 permits majority verdicts. Where there are not less than 11 jurors, at least 10 must agree; where there are 10 jurors, 9 must agree. The jury must have deliberated for at least two hours (in practice the judge allows a little longer before giving a majority direction), and on a guilty majority verdict the foreman must state the numbers agreeing and dissenting (section 17(3)). A 9-3 split with 12 jurors falls below the required majority, so the verdict cannot be accepted. A majority verdict does not require a juror to have been discharged, and verdicts need not always be unanimous.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, s.17 ↗Question 4 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Hugo, aged 34, is charged with murder and makes his first appearance before a magistrates' court the next morning. His solicitor asks the magistrates to hear representations about where the case should be tried. Which of the following best describes what the magistrates must do?
- Hold an allocation hearing to decide whether to accept jurisdiction for summary trial.
- Ask Hugo to indicate a plea before deciding whether to commit him for sentence.
- Adjourn the case to the youth court, which deals with all serious offences at first.
- Try the case themselves if Hugo consents to summary trial in writing.
- Send the case forthwith to the Crown Court for trial.Correct answer
Murder is triable only on indictment. Under section 51(1) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, where an adult appears or is brought before a magistrates' court charged with an offence triable only on indictment, the court must send them forthwith to the Crown Court for trial. There is no allocation hearing or plea before venue, which apply only to offences triable either way. Magistrates have no jurisdiction to try an indictable-only offence, even with consent. The youth court deals with defendants under 18, not with adults according to the seriousness of the charge. Hugo's representations about venue are therefore irrelevant.
Law basis: Crime and Disorder Act 1998, s.51 ↗Question 5 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Margaret, aged 74, is registered on the electoral roll and has lived in England all her life. She has no criminal record and no mental disorder. She receives a summons for jury service and believes she is too old to be eligible. Which of the following best describes her eligibility?
- She is not qualified, because the upper age limit for jurors is 70.
- She is not qualified, because anyone over 65 is automatically excused.
- She is qualified only if she has served on a jury within the last five years.
- She is qualified to serve, because the upper age limit is 75.Correct answer
- She is qualified, because there is no upper age limit for jury service.
Section 1 of the Juries Act 1974 provides that a person is qualified to serve as a juror if they are registered as a parliamentary or local government elector, aged between 18 and 75, have been ordinarily resident in the United Kingdom, the Channel Islands or the Isle of Man for at least five years since the age of 13, and are not disqualified or a mentally disordered person. The upper limit was raised from 70 to 75 by the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015. Margaret, at 74, is therefore qualified. She may still apply for deferral or excusal for good reason, but age alone does not excuse her.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, s.1 ↗Question 6 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
During a Crown Court trial for assault, a juror, Paul, searches online at home for the defendant's name and discovers that the defendant has previous convictions. He does not tell the other jurors. Which of the following best describes Paul's legal position?
- He commits no offence unless he shares the information with other jurors.
- He commits no offence, because jurors may research defendants who are named in public.
- He commits an offence only if the judge expressly ordered the jury not to use the internet.
- He commits an offence of intentionally researching the case during the trial.Correct answer
- He commits contempt only if the defendant is later acquitted as a result of his research.
Section 20A of the Juries Act 1974, inserted by the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, makes it an offence for a juror intentionally to research the case during the trial period. Research includes seeking information about a person involved in the case, including by internet search. The offence is committed by the research itself, whether or not the juror passes the information on, and it does not depend on the outcome. Section 20B also makes it an offence to share such information with other jurors. Judges direct juries about this, but the offence does not depend on a specific direction, and the publicity of a name is irrelevant.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, s.20A ↗Question 7 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
During deliberations in a Crown Court trial, a juror, Ruth, becomes concerned that another juror has made remarks suggesting racial bias against the defendant. Before a verdict is reached, she wants to raise this but fears it is an offence to reveal what is said in the jury room. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She commits an offence if she discloses anything said during deliberations to anyone.
- She may disclose the concern only after the verdict, by writing to the defendant's solicitor.
- She may disclose the concern to the press, because it relates to a matter of public interest.
- She commits an offence unless all the other jurors agree that she may raise the concern.
- She may disclose the concern to the trial judge without committing an offence.Correct answer
Section 20D of the Juries Act 1974 makes it an offence intentionally to disclose information about statements made, opinions expressed, arguments advanced or votes cast by jurors in the course of their deliberations. However, section 20E provides exceptions, including disclosure to the judge during the trial where a juror reasonably believes an offence or contempt has been committed, or other conduct that may give grounds for appeal. Ruth can therefore tell the trial judge, who can then take appropriate steps. Disclosure to the press or the defendant's lawyers is not within the exceptions, and the other jurors' agreement is irrelevant.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, ss.20D-20E; R v Mirza [2004] UKHL 2 ↗Question 8 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Before the trial of several defendants for a large-scale robbery, the prosecution produces evidence that associates of the defendants have tried to bribe jurors in a previous linked trial. The police say that even full-time protection for jurors would probably not prevent further attempts. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- The judge may transfer the case to the magistrates' court, where no jury is needed.
- The judge must stay the proceedings as an abuse of process because a fair trial is impossible.
- The judge may order a trial without a jury only if every defendant consents in writing.
- The judge must order a jury to be drawn from a different region, which is the only remedy.
- The judge may order a trial without a jury if the statutory conditions are met.Correct answer
Section 44 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 allows the prosecution to apply for a trial on indictment to be conducted without a jury where there is evidence of a real and present danger that jury tampering would take place, and, despite any steps (including police protection) that might reasonably be taken, the likelihood is so substantial as to make trial without a jury necessary in the interests of justice. In R v Twomey the Court of Appeal ordered the first such trial. The defendants' consent is not required. Magistrates have no jurisdiction over indictable-only offences such as robbery, and a stay is not the appropriate response.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s.44; R v Twomey [2009] EWCA Crim 1035 ↗Question 9 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Three lay magistrates are trying Gemma on a charge of careless driving. During the trial, a dispute arises about whether a piece of evidence is admissible. The bench retires and asks the legal adviser to join them. Which of the following best describes the legal adviser's role?
- To decide the admissibility question, because lay magistrates may not rule on law.
- To advise the magistrates on the law, leaving the decision itself to them.Correct answer
- To decide the case alongside the magistrates, with an equal vote on the verdict.
- To remain in court, because any private contact with the bench is unlawful.
- To refer the admissibility question to a district judge for a binding ruling.
Lay magistrates are not legally qualified, so they are assisted by a legal adviser (justices' clerk or assistant), whose functions derive from the Courts Act 2003, section 28, and the Criminal Procedure Rules. The adviser advises the bench on law, practice and procedure, including admissibility, but takes no part in deciding the facts or the verdict; the decision belongs to the magistrates. Any advice given in private should be repeated in open court so that the parties can comment. The adviser has no vote and cannot make the ruling. There is no procedure for referring a point of law to a district judge for a binding ruling.
Law basis: Courts Act 2003, s.28; Criminal Procedure Rules ↗Question 10 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ellis, aged 15, is charged with theft from a shop, an offence triable either way. It is his first offence and the value of the goods is small. His mother asks where his case will be dealt with. Which of the following best describes the normal position?
- In the youth court, which deals with defendants aged 10 to 17.Correct answer
- In the adult magistrates' court, because theft is triable either way.
- In the Crown Court, because all charges against children go to a judge.
- In the Family Court, because Ellis is still a child under 18.
- In the youth court only if his mother consents to it on his behalf.
Youth courts, established under the Children and Young Persons Act 1933, are specialist magistrates' courts that deal with most criminal cases involving children and young people aged 10 to 17. The age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales is 10 (section 50 of the 1933 Act). A young defendant charged with an either-way offence such as theft will normally be tried summarily in the youth court; only grave crimes, homicide and certain other cases are sent to the Crown Court. Ellis would appear in an adult court only in limited circumstances, such as a joint charge with an adult. Parental consent does not determine venue.
Law basis: Children and Young Persons Act 1933, ss.45-46, 50Question 11 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Imogen's trial for a summary motoring offence is listed before a magistrates' court. On the day, only one lay magistrate is available, and no district judge is sitting. The magistrate suggests trying the case alone to avoid delay. Which of the following best describes the position?
- A single lay magistrate may try the case if Imogen consents to it in writing.
- A single lay magistrate may try any summary offence where the fine is limited.
- A single lay magistrate may try the case if the legal adviser sits as a second justice.
- A single lay magistrate may try the case because district judges always sit alone.
- A single lay magistrate cannot try the case; at least two lay justices are required.Correct answer
Section 121(1) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 provides that a magistrates' court shall not try a case summarily unless it is composed of at least two justices, or a District Judge (Magistrates' Courts) sitting alone. Lay benches normally sit as two or three justices. A single lay justice can deal with some preliminary or administrative matters, and certain low-level cases may be dealt with under the single justice procedure on the papers, but that procedure does not apply to a contested trial in court. The legal adviser is not a justice and cannot make up the bench. A district judge's power to sit alone does not extend to lay magistrates.
Law basis: Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s.121(1) ↗Question 12 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
During a long Crown Court trial, two jurors fall seriously ill and the judge discharges them. A third juror is later discharged for a family emergency, leaving nine jurors. Defence counsel for Bashir argues that the trial must now be abandoned. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The trial must be abandoned, because a jury of fewer than twelve cannot return a verdict.
- The trial may continue only if Bashir consents to being tried by fewer than twelve jurors.
- The trial may continue, but only a unanimous verdict of not guilty could then be accepted.
- The trial may continue, because a jury of nine is still properly constituted.Correct answer
- The trial must be abandoned, because no more than two jurors may ever be discharged.
Section 16(1) of the Juries Act 1974 provides that where, in the course of a criminal trial, a juror dies or is discharged, the jury is still treated as properly constituted for all purposes so long as the number of jurors is not reduced below nine. The trial may therefore continue with nine jurors without the defendant's consent. With nine jurors, a majority verdict is not available, because section 17 permits majority verdicts only where there are at least ten jurors, so any verdict would have to be unanimous. That applies to guilty and not guilty verdicts alike.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, ss.16-17 ↗Question 13 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Clive receives a jury summons. He is currently on bail awaiting trial for an unrelated assault charge. He has no previous convictions and meets the age and residence requirements. He wants to serve. Which of the following best describes his position?
- He is disqualified from serving while on bail in criminal proceedings.Correct answer
- He is qualified, because he has not been convicted of any offence.
- He is qualified, but must tell the court about the pending charge.
- He is disqualified for life, because he has been charged with violence.
- He is qualified, unless the assault charge is triable only on indictment.
Schedule 1, Part 2 of the Juries Act 1974 sets out the categories of persons disqualified from jury service. They include persons who have been sentenced to certain terms of imprisonment or custody, and persons who are on bail in criminal proceedings. Clive is therefore disqualified while he is on bail, regardless of the presumption of innocence and regardless of the classification of the offence. It is an offence for a disqualified person to serve knowingly. Being charged does not disqualify him for life; once the proceedings end without a disqualifying sentence, he may again be qualified.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, s.1 and Sch 1, Part 2 ↗Question 14 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
At the start of a Crown Court trial, counsel for the defendant, Ayo, wishes to remove two jurors from the panel because he has a feeling they would be unsympathetic, although he cannot give any specific reason. Which of the following best describes his ability to do so?
- He can, because each defendant has three peremptory challenges without reasons.
- He can, but only with the consent of the prosecution and the trial judge.
- He can, because a defendant may challenge any juror at any time before verdict.
- He cannot, because peremptory challenges without reasons have been abolished.Correct answer
- He cannot, because only the prosecution may challenge jurors in a criminal trial.
Section 118 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 abolished the defendant's right of peremptory challenge, which had allowed jurors to be removed without giving reasons. The defence may still challenge a juror for cause, for example where there is a real basis for believing the juror is biased or disqualified, and the judge decides the challenge. The prosecution retains a limited power to ask jurors to 'stand by', which is used rarely and subject to guidelines. A vague feeling that jurors might be unsympathetic is not a ground for challenge for cause, so Ayo's counsel cannot remove the jurors on that basis.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 1988, s.118; Juries Act 1974, s.12 ↗Question 15 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
Patience receives a summons for jury service starting in three weeks. She has a non-refundable family holiday booked for the same period, and she is willing to serve at a later date. Which of the following best describes the most appropriate course?
- She is automatically excused, because she has a holiday booked.
- She may apply for her jury service to be deferred to a later date.Correct answer
- She must attend, because there is no power to excuse or defer service.
- She may refuse to attend, provided she gives notice in writing.
- She is disqualified from service for as long as her holiday lasts.
Under section 9A of the Juries Act 1974, a person summoned for jury service may apply to have their attendance deferred, and the summoning officer must defer it if satisfied there is a good reason. A pre-booked holiday is a typical reason for deferral to a later date within a set period. Section 9 allows excusal for good reason, but excusal is not automatic, and where deferral is possible it is generally preferred. Failing to attend without reasonable cause is an offence, so Patience cannot simply refuse. Disqualification relates to matters such as certain convictions or being on bail, not personal commitments.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, ss.9-9A ↗Question 16 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
During a multi-defendant drugs trial, a juror, Joanne, contacts one of the defendants, who had already been acquitted on some counts, through a social networking site and discusses the case while the jury is still deliberating on other counts. The trial collapses. Which of the following best describes Joanne's likely liability?
- She has no liability, because the defendant contacted had been acquitted.
- She is liable only to pay the wasted costs of the trial, not to punishment.
- She has no liability, because jurors may discuss cases with defendants.
- She is liable only if she voted to convict the remaining defendants.
- She is likely to be found in contempt of court and may be imprisoned.Correct answer
In Attorney General v Fraill a juror who contacted an acquitted defendant via Facebook and discussed the case while the jury was still deliberating on other defendants was found guilty of contempt of court and sentenced to eight months' imprisonment. Her conduct breached the judge's directions and undermined the integrity of the trial, which had to be abandoned. Since 2015 such conduct may also amount to statutory offences under the Juries Act 1974, such as researching the case or sharing information. The acquittal of the person she contacted did not protect her, and liability does not depend on how she voted.
Law basis: Attorney General v Fraill [2011] EWHC 1629 (Admin); Juries Act 1974, ss.20A-20BQuestion 17 · Criminal courts and juriesDraft, pending solicitor review
A jury of 12 has been deliberating for one hour and twenty minutes in Stefan's straightforward trial for assault. The jury sends a note saying it is split 10-2. The judge proposes to give a majority direction immediately to save time. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The judge may give a majority direction at once, because the jury is already split 10-2.
- The judge cannot accept a majority verdict before two hours' deliberation.Correct answer
- The judge may give a majority direction at once, because the case is straightforward.
- The judge must discharge the jury, because it cannot reach a unanimous verdict.
- The judge may give a majority direction only if Stefan consents to it.
Section 17(4) of the Juries Act 1974 provides that a court shall not accept a majority verdict unless it appears that the jury has had such period of time for deliberation as the court thinks reasonable, having regard to the nature and complexity of the case, and in any event not less than two hours. In practice, judges allow a little longer before giving a majority direction. One hour and twenty minutes is too short, however simple the case. The judge should ask the jury to continue trying to reach a unanimous verdict. Discharge is premature, and the defendant's consent is not relevant to a majority direction.
Law basis: Juries Act 1974, s.17(4) ↗More Legal System of England and Wales topics
Back to all Legal System of England and Wales questions, or sit a timed mock.