HomeLegal System of England and WalesDeparting from precedent

Legal System of England and Wales · FLK1

Departing from precedent: SQE1 notes and practice questions

Key rules, exam traps and 18 single best answer questions on departing from precedent, with the answer explained and the law behind each one.

  • 3,641 SQE1 questions across all 14 subjects, in the exam's single best answer format
  • Reviewed by a team of qualified solicitors, with the case or statute behind every answer
  • Full 85-question FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks, built for the January 2027 format
  • Progress tracked topic by topic, so you revise what you actually get wrong
  • Start free: all notes and guides plus a sample question in every topic, no card needed
  • Solicitor-reviewed questions
  • Law cited on every answer
  • One-off payment, no auto-renewal
  • Secure Stripe checkout
Full SQE1 question bank
from£35£35 £24.50one-off
Black Friday: 30% off, up to 80% on bigger basketsUnlock all 3,641 questions

No auto-renewal · instant access · or try free sample questions

Revision notes

At a glanceHow the highest court came to depart from its own decisions
  1. 1898London Tramways: House of Lords holds itself absolutely bound by its own decisions.
  2. 1966Practice Statement: former decisions normally binding, but may depart when it appears right to do so.
  3. 1972Herrington departs from Addie v Dumbreck: limited duty owed to child trespassers.
  4. 1987R v Shivpuri overrules Anderton v Ryan within a year: first criminal use, on impossible attempts.
  5. 2003R v G departs from Caldwell: recklessness is subjective.
  6. 2010Austin v Southwark confirms the Supreme Court inherits the Practice Statement.
  7. 2016R v Jogee corrects joint enterprise; old convictions need exceptional leave and substantial injustice.

Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent) [1966] 1 WLR 1234

Key rules

  • Before 1966 the House of Lords considered itself absolutely bound by its own decisions (London Tramways Co Ltd v London County Council (1898)).
  • Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent) [1966] 1 WLR 1234: the House would treat former decisions as normally binding but depart "when it appears right to do so". It flagged the danger of retrospectively disturbing contracts, property and fiscal arrangements, and the special need for certainty in criminal law. The Supreme Court has adopted the same approach (Austin v Southwark LBC (2010)).
  • Use is sparing. The court will not depart merely because it thinks the earlier decision wrong; something more is needed, such as changed social conditions or a decision causing injustice or uncertainty. In R v Kansal (No 2) (2001) the House declined to depart from R v Lambert (2001), though it thought it probably wrong, in the interests of certainty.
  • Court of Appeal cannot use the Practice Statement (Davis v Johnson (1979)); when the Court of Appeal declined to follow House of Lords authority (Re United Railways of Havana (1961), sterling-only judgments), the House in Miliangos v George Frank (Textiles) Ltd (1976) said it was wrong to do so, although the House itself then departed from Havana under the Practice Statement.
  • Court of Appeal and its own decisions: see Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd (1944). Per incuriam covers decisions made in ignorance of a binding statute or authority, not simply poorly argued cases (Morelle Ltd v Wakeling (1955)). The Criminal Division may depart where the law was misapplied and liberty is at stake (R v Taylor (1950); R v Simpson (2003)).
Case Earlier decision departed from Point
Conway v Rimmer (1968) Duncan v Cammell Laird (1942) Courts may inspect documents for public interest immunity
British Railways Board v Herrington (1972) Addie v Dumbreck (1929) Limited duty to child trespassers
R v Shivpuri (1987) Anderton v Ryan (1985) Impossible attempts; first criminal use, within a year
R v Howe (1987) DPP for NI v Lynch (1975) Duress no defence to murder for any party
Murphy v Brentwood DC (1991) Anns v Merton LBC (1978) Pure economic loss irrecoverable
Pepper v Hart (1993) Davis v Johnson (1979) on Hansard Hansard may be used in limited cases
Arthur JS Hall v Simons (2002) Rondel v Worsley (1969) Advocates' immunity removed
R v G (2003) MPC v Caldwell (1982) Recklessness is subjective
Knauer v MoJ (2016) Cookson v Knowles (1979); Graham v Dodds (1983) Multiplier runs from trial date
Patel v Mirza (2016) Tinsley v Milligan (1994) Illegality: policy-based approach
R v Jogee (2016) The Chan Wing-Siu (1985) line of authority Joint enterprise had taken a "wrong turn"; foresight is evidence of intent, not a substitute
  • Effect on past cases: after Jogee, a person convicted under the old law needs exceptional leave to appeal out of time and must show substantial injustice (R v Johnson (2016)).

How it is tested

  • Supreme Court asked to depart. Correct answer: it may, when it appears right to do so, but will be cautious, particularly where property or contracts relied on the old rule or in criminal law.
  • Court of Appeal asked to ignore a Supreme Court decision. It must follow it.
  • Retrospective consequences. A convicted defendant relies on a later change in the law.

Exam traps

  • Saying the Supreme Court is bound by House of Lords decisions. It is not; it inherited the Practice Statement.
  • Saying per incuriam applies whenever the earlier court had poor argument. It requires ignorance of a binding authority or statute.
  • Allowing the Court of Appeal to use the Practice Statement.

Quick check

Remember: Only the Supreme Court may depart from its own previous decisions, under the 1966 Practice Statement, and it does so sparingly, especially where certainty or reliance matters.

Law covered in these questions

  • Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent) [1966] 1 WLR 1234
  • Austin v Southwark LBC [2010] UKSC 28
  • R v Taylor [1950] 2 KB 368
  • R v Gould [1968] 2 QB 65
  • R v Simpson [2003] EWCA Crim 1499
  • Morelle Ltd v Wakeling [1955] 2 QB 379
  • Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718
  • R v Shivpuri [1987] AC 1
  • Anderton v Ryan [1985] AC 560
  • R v G [2003] UKHL 50
  • Metropolitan Police Commissioner v Caldwell [1982] AC 341
  • Miliangos v George Frank (Textiles) Ltd [1976] AC 443
  • Re United Railways of Havana and Regla Warehouses Ltd [1961] AC 1007
  • British Railways Board v Herrington [1972] AC 877

Worked answer: 1 free sample question

Try it above first, then read the worked answer below. Members get every departing from precedent question.

Question 1 · Departing from precedent✓ Solicitor reviewed

The Supreme Court is asked by Hannah's counsel to depart from a House of Lords decision from 1985 on a point of tort law, arguing that it has caused unfairness and is out of step with modern conditions. The respondent argues that the Supreme Court is bound by decisions of the House of Lords. Which of the following best describes the Supreme Court's position?

  1. It is bound by the earlier decision, because the Practice Statement lapsed when the House of Lords was abolished.
  2. It may depart only if the earlier decision was given per incuriam, applying the Young v Bristol Aeroplane exceptions.
  3. It is bound unless Parliament has passed a resolution approving departure from the House of Lords decision.
  4. It may depart freely, because decisions of the House of Lords are merely persuasive for the Supreme Court.
  5. It may depart from the earlier decision when it appears right to do so, though it will do so sparingly.Correct answer

Members

17 more departing from precedent questions with full answers

Unlock all 3,641 solicitor-reviewed questions, full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks and the practice builder. From £35, one-off, no auto-renewal.

More Legal System of England and Wales topics

Back to all Legal System of England and Wales questions, or sit a timed mock.

What you get

Everything you need to practise for SQE1, from £35

One-off payment, no subscription. Every question, every mock and every member tool unlocks the moment you pay.

Every subject covered

3,641 questions across all 14 SQE1 subjects and every topic in the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) specification.

Built like the real exam

Five options, one single best answer, client-based scenarios: the format SQE1 uses.

The law behind every answer

Each answer cites the case or statute that decides it. Statute questions link to legislation.gov.uk.

Timed FLK1 and FLK2 mocks

Full 85-question sessions at exam pace (2 hours 33 minutes), matching the January 2027 format.

See your weak topics

Your score is tracked by topic, so your next study session goes where the marks are.

Checked by solicitors

Every question is reviewed by a team of qualified solicitors in England and Wales.

Why it matters: SQE1 costs £2,006 per attempt, and only 53% of candidates passed both papers in January 2026. A few weeks of exam-format practice costs a fraction of one resit. See pass rates.

1 month

Black Friday −30%
£35£35 £24.50one-off

£35 a month · A focused final push before your sitting.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 30 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 1 month for £35
Most popular

3 months

Black Friday −30%
£79£79 £55.30one-off

About £26 a month · The most popular length for one SQE1 sitting.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 90 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 3 months for £79

6 months

Black Friday −30%
£129£129 £90.30one-off

About £21.50 a month · Time to study steadily, sit, and resit if needed.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 180 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 6 months for £129
  • Solicitor-reviewed questions
  • Law cited on every answer
  • One-off payment, no auto-renewal
  • Secure Stripe checkout