The Supreme Court is asked by Hannah's counsel to depart from a House of Lords decision from 1985 on a point of tort law, arguing that it has caused unfairness and is out of step with modern conditions. The respondent argues that the Supreme Court is bound by decisions of the House of Lords. Which of the following best describes the Supreme Court's position?
- It is bound by the earlier decision, because the Practice Statement lapsed when the House of Lords was abolished.
- It may depart only if the earlier decision was given per incuriam, applying the Young v Bristol Aeroplane exceptions.
- It is bound unless Parliament has passed a resolution approving departure from the House of Lords decision.
- It may depart freely, because decisions of the House of Lords are merely persuasive for the Supreme Court.
- It may depart from the earlier decision when it appears right to do so, though it will do so sparingly.Correct answer
The Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent) [1966] allowed the House of Lords to depart from its previous decisions 'when it appears right to do so'. In Austin v Southwark LBC the Supreme Court confirmed that the Practice Statement continues to apply to it, and that House of Lords decisions are treated as its own. The power is used sparingly, mindful of certainty, especially where contracts, property or criminal law are concerned. House of Lords decisions are binding on the Supreme Court subject to this power, not merely persuasive. The Young exceptions govern the Court of Appeal, not the Supreme Court.
Law basis: Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent) [1966] 1 WLR 1234; Austin v Southwark LBC [2010] UKSC 28