Key rules
Forms: statutory instruments (regulations, orders, rules), Orders in Council (made by the King on the advice of the Privy Council) and byelaws (made by local authorities and other bodies). Where a parent Act says a power is exercisable by statutory instrument, the Statutory Instruments Act 1946 applies (s 1).
Parliamentary control
| Procedure |
How it works |
| Negative |
Instrument is laid; either House may annul it by resolution within 40 days (Statutory Instruments Act 1946 ss 5, 7). Periods when Parliament is dissolved or prorogued, or both Houses are adjourned for more than four days, are excluded. |
| Affirmative |
Draft (or made instrument) must be approved by resolution of each House (or the Commons alone for financial matters). |
| Made affirmative (urgent) |
Takes effect at once but lapses unless approved within a set period, e.g. 28 days (Public Health (Control of Disease) Act 1984 s 45R). |
- Scrutiny committees: the Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments examines technical and legal defects (vires, drafting); the Lords Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee considers policy merits.
- Publication defence: it is a defence to a charge under a statutory instrument to prove it had not been issued at the date of the contravention, unless reasonable steps had been taken to bring it to notice (SIA 1946 s 3(2)).
- Henry VIII clauses permit secondary legislation to amend or repeal primary legislation. They are construed narrowly (R (Public Law Project) v Lord Chancellor (2016)).
Judicial control (ultra vires)
- Substantive ultra vires: outside the scope of the parent Act. In R (Public Law Project) v Lord Chancellor (2016) a power to "vary or omit" legal aid services did not extend to a residence test. A fees order that effectively prevented access to justice was unlawful (R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor (2017)).
- Procedural ultra vires: failure to follow a mandatory procedure, such as consultation (Agricultural, Horticultural and Forestry Industry Training Board v Aylesbury Mushrooms Ltd (1972): order did not bind an association not consulted) or affirmative approval.
- Unreasonableness: byelaws can be invalid if unreasonable or too wide (Kruse v Johnson (1898); Strickland v Hayes Borough Council (1896)).
- Parliamentary approval does not exclude judicial review (R (Javed) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (2001)).
- Delegation: officials may exercise a minister's powers as the minister's alter ego (Carltona Ltd v Commissioners of Works (1943)), but other bodies generally cannot sub-delegate a judicial or disciplinary power (Barnard v National Dock Labour Board (1953)).
- Human rights: a court may disapply incompatible secondary legislation if the parent Act does not prevent removal of the incompatibility (HRA 1998 s 3(2)(c); RR v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (2019)).
Advantages: speed, technical detail, flexibility, expertise, saves parliamentary time. Disadvantages: limited scrutiny, volume, and the democratic concerns raised by broad and Henry VIII powers.
How it is tested
- Negative procedure. Either House may annul within 40 days; it cannot amend.
- Consultation not carried out. Procedurally ultra vires and not binding on those who should have been consulted.
- Power used beyond its words. Substantively ultra vires (PLP, UNISON).
- Official decides instead of minister. Valid under Carltona.
Exam traps
- Saying Parliament can amend a statutory instrument. It can only approve or annul.
- Assuming approval by both Houses makes an SI immune from challenge (Javed).
- Treating ignorance of an unpublished SI as no defence: s 3(2) provides one.
- Treating every procedural slip as fatal; the requirement must be mandatory.
- Applying Carltona to bodies other than government departments.
Quick check
Remember: Secondary legislation is valid only within the parent Act's powers and procedures; Parliament controls it by negative or affirmative resolution, and courts by ultra vires review.