Law covered in these questions
- Doctrine of binding precedent (court hierarchy)
- R v Howe [1987] AC 417
- R v Gotts [1992] 2 AC 412
- Candler v Crane, Christmas & Co [1951] 2 KB 164
- Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465
- Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562
- Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130
- Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd [2017] UKSC 67
- R v Barton and Booth [2020] EWCA Crim 575
- Doctrine of precedent: ratio decidendi and obiter dicta
- Doctrine of precedent: persuasive authority
- R (Kadhim) v Brent LBC Housing Benefit Review Board [2001] QB 955
- Jacobs v London County Council [1950] AC 361
- Qualcast (Wolverhampton) Ltd v Haynes [1959] AC 743
All 17 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
A judge in the High Court is considering a decision from a lower court on identical facts. The earlier decision reasoned from a different principle. Which statement best describes the status of the earlier judgment?
- It is binding, because the ratio decidendi of any English court binds all later courts.
- It has no weight at all, because only Supreme Court decisions can be cited.
- It is binding only if the lower court was a Crown Court.
- It is not binding on the High Court, because decisions of a lower court do not bind a higher court, although the judge may treat it as persuasive.Correct answer
- It is binding, because it was decided on identical facts.
A court is bound only by decisions of courts above it in the hierarchy, and sometimes its own. A decision of a lower court may persuade but does not bind.
Law basis: Doctrine of binding precedent (court hierarchy)Question 2 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In a House of Lords decision on duress, the judges held that duress is no defence to murder. In the course of their speeches, several Law Lords added that duress should also be unavailable on a charge of attempted murder. Later, Kieran is charged with attempted murder and seeks to rely on duress. Which of the following best describes the status of the remark about attempted murder in the earlier case?
- It was part of the ratio, because it was stated by a majority of the judges.
- It was binding on lower courts, because it came from the House of Lords.
- It was obiter dictum, so it was persuasive but not binding on later courts.Correct answer
- It had no legal effect at all, because statements outside the ratio are ignored.
- It was part of the ratio, because the later court agreed with it and followed it.
The ratio decidendi is the legal principle necessary for the decision on the material facts. Statements on matters that did not arise for decision are obiter dicta: they may be highly persuasive but do not bind. In R v Howe the issue was murder, so the comments about attempted murder were obiter. In R v Gotts the House of Lords later adopted that view, but the remark did not become ratio of Howe simply because a later court followed it. Obiter remarks are not ignored; dicta of senior judges can carry great persuasive weight, as they did in Gotts.
Law basis: R v Howe [1987] AC 417; R v Gotts [1992] 2 AC 412Question 3 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In a Court of Appeal case on liability for negligent statements, the majority held that an accountant owed no duty of care to an investor. One judge dissented, giving a detailed judgment explaining why a duty should exist. Years later, in Callum's case, the House of Lords is asked to consider the same issue. Which of the following best describes the status of the dissenting judgment?
- It is binding, because it was given by a judge of the Court of Appeal in a reported case.
- It has no legal status, because only the majority judgments in a case may ever be cited.
- It becomes binding once more than ten years have passed since the original decision.
- It is persuasive authority which the House of Lords may adopt, though it is not binding.Correct answer
- It is binding on lower courts, but not on the House of Lords, which may ignore it.
A dissenting judgment is not part of the ratio decidendi and so does not bind any court. It may, however, be persuasive and can be adopted by a higher court in a later case. In Candler v Crane Christmas & Co the majority of the Court of Appeal held there was no duty of care for negligent misstatement, but Denning LJ dissented. The House of Lords later approved his reasoning in Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd. Dissents may be cited and can be influential. Lower courts are bound by the majority ratio, not by a dissent, and the passage of time does not change its status.
Law basis: Candler v Crane, Christmas & Co [1951] 2 KB 164; Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465Question 4 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In a House of Lords case, a consumer became ill after drinking ginger beer from an opaque bottle containing a decomposed snail. The majority held the manufacturer owed her a duty of care. Lord Atkin also stated a general 'neighbour' principle. Lucy, a student, asks which part of the decision is generally treated as its narrow ratio. Which of the following best describes it?
- A manufacturer owes a duty of care to the ultimate consumer where no intermediate examination is reasonably possible.Correct answer
- Every person owes a duty of care to anyone whom they can reasonably foresee might be harmed by any act or omission of theirs.
- A retailer who sells contaminated food or drink is strictly liable to the consumer, whether or not it was negligent.
- A duty of care arises in every case where it is fair, just and reasonable to impose one, considering all the circumstances.
- A manufacturer owes a duty of care only under a contract made with the consumer or with the retailer who sold the product.
In Donoghue v Stevenson the material facts concerned a manufacturer, a product in a form intended to reach the consumer without intermediate examination, and injury to the consumer. The narrow ratio is that a manufacturer owes a duty of care to the ultimate consumer in those circumstances. Lord Atkin's broader neighbour principle was wider than necessary for the decision and is often described as obiter, although it has been enormously influential. The 'fair, just and reasonable' formulation comes from later cases such as Caparo Industries plc v Dickman. The case established liability in tort without a contract, and it concerned the manufacturer, not strict liability of a retailer.
Law basis: Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562Question 5 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In a House of Lords case, the judges said that a bank giving a reference could owe a duty of care for negligent misstatement. However, because the bank had expressly disclaimed responsibility, the claim failed. Later, Ngozi sues her financial adviser for a negligent statement. Which of the following best describes the status of the statements about the duty of care in the earlier case?
- They were the ratio, because they were the main reason the claim failed.
- They were the ratio, because a duty of care is always the ratio of a negligence case.
- They were strictly obiter, but have since been accepted as stating the law.Correct answer
- They were obiter and are of no weight, because the claim ultimately failed.
- They were the ratio only for banks, not for other professional advisers.
The ratio decidendi is the principle necessary to the decision on the material facts. In Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd, the claim failed because of the disclaimer, so the Law Lords' statements that a duty of care could arise for negligent misstatement were, strictly, not necessary to the result and are often described as obiter. Their authority and later acceptance have, however, made them the foundation of the law on negligent misstatement. The obiter status of a statement does not mean it has no weight; dicta of the House of Lords are highly persuasive. The principle has been applied to professional advisers generally.
Law basis: Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465Question 6 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
A landlord agreed to halve the rent of a block of flats during wartime because tenants could not be found. After the war he sued for the full rent for the post-war period, and won. Denning J also said that he could not have recovered the full rent for the war years because of his promise. Later, Abena relies on that statement in a dispute about a promise to accept reduced payments. Which of the following best describes its status?
- It was the ratio, because it explained why the landlord's claim succeeded.
- It was the ratio, because it was the most important legal point in the judgment.
- It was obiter, and so it may not be cited in any later court proceedings.
- It was obiter, but it has become an influential basis for promissory estoppel.Correct answer
- It was binding on all courts, because it was a decision of the High Court.
In Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd the landlord claimed rent only for the post-war period, and succeeded because the promise was intended to last only while the war conditions continued. Denning J's statement that the landlord would have been unable to recover the full rent for the war years was not necessary for the decision and was therefore obiter. It nevertheless became the foundation of the modern doctrine of promissory estoppel. Obiter dicta can be cited and may be very persuasive. High Court decisions bind lower courts, but only as to their ratio, and they do not bind all courts.
Law basis: Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130Question 7 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In a civil case about a gambling dispute, the Supreme Court stated that the long-standing criminal test for dishonesty should no longer be applied and set out a new test. The statement was not necessary to decide the case. Later, the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) must decide which test to apply to Lorna's theft charge, given its own earlier decision setting out the old test. Which of the following best describes what the Court of Appeal did in this situation?
- It followed its own earlier decision, because obiter statements can never displace precedent.
- It followed the Supreme Court's statement, even though it was strictly obiter.Correct answer
- It applied both tests and allowed the jury to choose between them in each case.
- It referred the question to the Supreme Court before deciding the case before it.
- It held that only Parliament could change the test, so the old test still applied.
In Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd, a civil case, the Supreme Court said that the second limb of the test in R v Ghosh should no longer be applied and that dishonesty should be judged objectively by the standards of ordinary decent people, once the defendant's actual state of knowledge or belief is established. Those remarks were obiter. In R v Barton and Booth the Court of Appeal held that, applying Willers v Joyce, where the Supreme Court has clearly directed that an earlier decision should no longer be followed, the Court of Appeal may follow that direction. It therefore applied the Ivey test rather than its own earlier decision in Ghosh.
Law basis: Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd [2017] UKSC 67; R v Barton and Booth [2020] EWCA Crim 575Question 8 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
A Court of Appeal judgment holds that a landlord was liable to a tenant for damage caused by water leaking from a pipe the landlord had agreed to maintain. In explaining the decision, the judge also comments on what the position would have been had there been no agreement to maintain. Kemi, a tenant whose landlord made no such agreement, wants to rely on that comment. Which of the following best describes its status?
- It is the ratio, because the judge stated it as a general principle of law.
- It is binding on lower courts, because it was expressed in clear terms.
- It is the ratio, because it was given by the Court of Appeal and not a lower court.
- It has no value at all, because hypothetical comments cannot be cited.
- It is obiter, because it concerns facts that were not before the court.Correct answer
The ratio decidendi is the legal principle on which the decision is based, applied to the material facts actually before the court. A statement about what the law would be on different, hypothetical facts is obiter dictum. Here, the agreement to maintain was a material fact in the case, so the comment about the position without an agreement is obiter and not binding on later courts, however clearly it was expressed. Obiter remarks of the Court of Appeal may still be persuasive, so Kemi may cite the comment, but the court in her case is not bound to follow it. Seniority of the court does not convert obiter into ratio.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: ratio decidendi and obiter dictaQuestion 9 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In a High Court claim, counsel for Dmitri relies on a recent decision of the High Court of Australia on the duty of care owed by auditors. No English appellate authority covers the point. The other side says that the Australian decision is irrelevant. Which of the following best describes the status of the Australian decision?
- It is binding, because Australia is a common law jurisdiction within the Commonwealth.
- It is persuasive authority, which the judge may follow if convinced by it.Correct answer
- It is irrelevant, because English courts may cite only decisions of English courts.
- It is binding, but only if the Privy Council has previously approved its reasoning.
- It is persuasive only if the Australian court cited English authority in reaching it.
Decisions of courts in other jurisdictions, particularly common law jurisdictions such as Australia, Canada and New Zealand, are not binding on English courts but may be cited as persuasive authority. Where there is no binding domestic authority on a point, an English judge may find a well-reasoned foreign decision helpful and choose to follow it. Membership of the Commonwealth does not make foreign decisions binding, and Privy Council approval does not give them binding force in England. Whether the foreign court cited English cases may affect the weight given, but not whether the decision can be considered at all.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: persuasive authorityQuestion 10 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In an earlier Court of Appeal case about housing benefit, both parties assumed without argument that a particular regulation applied, and the court decided the case on that basis. In Kadir's appeal, the Court of Appeal is asked whether the regulation applies at all. Which of the following best describes whether the earlier case binds the court on that point?
- It does not, because a point assumed without argument is not part of the ratio.Correct answer
- It does, because everything necessary to the earlier outcome forms part of the ratio.
- It does, because the Court of Appeal is bound by all its decisions without exception.
- It does not, because housing benefit decisions are made by tribunals, not courts.
- It does, unless the Supreme Court has expressly disapproved the earlier assumption.
A proposition of law that was assumed by the court, without argument or consideration, is not part of the ratio decidendi and does not bind later courts. In R (Kadhim) v Brent LBC Housing Benefit Review Board the Court of Appeal held that it was not bound by an earlier decision on a point that had been assumed rather than argued and decided. This is consistent with the idea that precedent binds because the court has considered and decided the issue. The Court of Appeal is otherwise generally bound by its own decisions, subject to the Young exceptions, and the fact that housing benefit cases may start in tribunals is irrelevant.
Law basis: R (Kadhim) v Brent LBC Housing Benefit Review Board [2001] QB 955Question 11 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In an earlier House of Lords case, the claim failed for two independent reasons, each of which was fully argued and decided. In a later case, counsel for Gwen argues that only the first reason given by the House is binding, as the second was unnecessary once the first was decided. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Only the first reason is binding, as the second was not necessary to the decision.
- Only the second reason is binding, as it was the final reason given.
- Neither reason is binding, because the case has no single clear ratio.
- Both reasons form part of the ratio and are binding on lower courts.Correct answer
- The later court may choose which reason to treat as the ratio.
Where a court bases its decision on two or more independent grounds, each of which is sufficient to dispose of the case and each of which has been fully considered, all of them form part of the ratio decidendi. In Jacobs v London County Council the House of Lords held that a decision resting on two grounds is binding as to both, and neither can be dismissed as obiter merely because the other would have been enough. Gwen's argument therefore fails. The order in which the reasons are given is irrelevant, and the later court cannot pick whichever ground it prefers.
Law basis: Jacobs v London County Council [1950] AC 361Question 12 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In an earlier negligence case, the House of Lords upheld a trial judge's finding that an employer was negligent in not making a worker wear protective goggles. In Hamid's case, his employer did not insist that he wear goggles, and Hamid argues that the earlier case established a rule of law that this is always negligent. Which of the following best describes the status of the earlier finding?
- It established a rule of law that employers must always insist on protective equipment.
- It was a finding of fact on those circumstances, not a binding rule of law.Correct answer
- It is binding as part of the ratio because it was upheld by the House of Lords.
- It is binding only on cases involving the same type of goggles and machinery.
- It is binding on the County Court but not on the High Court in later cases.
Precedent applies to principles of law, not findings of fact. In Qualcast (Wolverhampton) Ltd v Haynes the House of Lords warned against treating a judge's reasoning on what was reasonable in particular circumstances as creating rules of law binding in later cases. Whether an employer was negligent depends on the facts of each case, applying the general standard of reasonable care. Hamid cannot therefore rely on the earlier case as establishing that failing to insist on goggles is always negligent, though it may be relevant evidence of what is reasonable. The status of the decision does not depend on whether it was upheld at a higher level.
Law basis: Qualcast (Wolverhampton) Ltd v Haynes [1959] AC 743Question 13 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
A Court of Appeal judge, in a contract case, sets out a detailed view of how a different type of clause, not in issue, should be interpreted. Two years later, a High Court judge must interpret that type of clause in Orla's case. No other authority exists. Which of the following best describes the effect of the Court of Appeal's view?
- It binds the High Court, because it was a considered statement of the Court of Appeal.
- It binds the High Court only if the other two judges expressly agreed with it.
- It has no weight at all, because it concerned a clause not before the court.
- It binds the High Court, unless it was expressed to be provisional.
- It is persuasive and may well be followed, but it does not bind the High Court.Correct answer
Statements of law that are not necessary to the decision on the material facts are obiter dicta. The judge's view on a type of clause not in issue is obiter, so it does not bind the High Court, even though it is a carefully considered statement by a senior court and even if the other judges agreed. However, considered dicta of the Court of Appeal carry substantial persuasive weight, particularly where there is no other authority, so the High Court judge may well follow it. Obiter statements are not without weight, and whether a statement was provisional affects only its persuasiveness, not its binding force.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: ratio decidendi and obiter dictaQuestion 14 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In a High Court case, the judge held that Simon's claim was statute-barred. She then said: 'It is unnecessary for me to decide liability, but had I needed to, I would have found the defendant negligent.' In a later case on similar facts, the claimant relies on the statement about negligence as binding. Which of the following best describes its status?
- It is obiter, because the judge said it was unnecessary to the decision.Correct answer
- It is part of the ratio, because it was a considered finding by the trial judge.
- It is part of the ratio, because both grounds formed part of the reasoning.
- It is binding, but only on the parties to the original claim, not on others.
- It is binding on later High Court judges, but not on the County Court.
Where a court decides a case on one ground and expressly states that it is unnecessary to decide another issue, comments on that other issue are obiter dicta. Here the claim failed because it was statute-barred, and the judge said the negligence point did not need to be decided, so her view on negligence is not part of the ratio. This differs from the situation in Jacobs v London County Council, where a court actually decides a case on two independent grounds, both of which are then binding. The statement may be persuasive, but it does not bind later courts, whatever their level.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: obiter dicta; Jacobs v London County Council [1950] AC 361Question 15 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
A claimant developed dermatitis from chemicals left in woollen underwear he bought from a shop. The manufacturer argued that the leading House of Lords case on manufacturers' duty of care concerned only food and drink in sealed bottles. Which of the following best describes how the Privy Council treated the earlier ratio?
- It applied the ratio to other products, as the drink itself was not a material fact.Correct answer
- It held the ratio was limited to drinks, so the manufacturer owed no duty in this case.
- It held the earlier case had no ratio, because the neighbour principle was obiter.
- It held that the earlier ratio applied only to Scottish cases and not to Australia.
- It overruled the earlier case and created a new rule for clothing manufacturers.
In Grant v Australian Knitting Mills Ltd the Privy Council applied the principle in Donoghue v Stevenson to underwear containing excess sulphites. The material facts of Donoghue were that a manufacturer put a product into circulation in a form intended to reach the consumer without reasonable possibility of intermediate examination, and harm resulted. The fact that the product was ginger beer in an opaque bottle was not material. This shows how later courts determine the level of generality at which a ratio is stated. The Privy Council did not overrule Donoghue, and it was not confined to Scotland.
Law basis: Grant v Australian Knitting Mills Ltd [1936] AC 85; Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562Question 16 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
In 2024 the Court of Appeal decided a boundary dispute between Rhodri and his neighbour, Sian, in Rhodri's favour, and laid down a principle about boundary agreements. In 2026, Sian's new neighbour, Tomos, has a similar dispute with her. Which of the following best describes how the 2024 decision affects each of them?
- Sian and Tomos are both bound by the 2024 order, because it concerned Sian's land.
- Sian is bound by the order against Rhodri; its ratio governs Tomos's case.Correct answer
- Neither is affected, because a decision binds only the court that made it.
- Only the obiter remarks in the 2024 decision can be relied on by Tomos.
- Tomos is bound by the 2024 order, but its ratio is only persuasive.
A judgment has two different binding effects. The order itself binds the parties to the case and those claiming through them: under the doctrine of res judicata, Sian cannot relitigate the same dispute with Rhodri. The ratio decidendi, by contrast, binds lower courts and, subject to the usual rules, the Court of Appeal itself in later cases involving different parties. Tomos was not a party, so he is not bound by the order, but the principle laid down will bind the court hearing his dispute with Sian if the material facts are the same. Obiter remarks are only persuasive.
Law basis: Doctrine of precedent: ratio decidendi; res judicataQuestion 17 · Ratio decidendi and obiter dictaDraft, pending solicitor review
A High Court judge is applying a Court of Appeal ratio in Adele's case. The judge considers that the Court of Appeal's reasoning contained a logical flaw and was based on a misreading of an older case, although no statute or binding authority was overlooked. Which of the following best describes what the judge must do?
- Refuse to apply it, because a ratio based on flawed reasoning is not binding.
- Refuse to apply it, because the decision was per incuriam on these facts.
- Apply the older case instead, because it was misread by the Court of Appeal.
- Ask the parties to agree whether the ratio should be applied in their case.
- Apply the ratio, because it binds even if the reasoning seems flawed.Correct answer
Under the doctrine of stare decisis, a lower court must apply the ratio of a decision of a higher court binding on it, even if it considers that decision wrong or poorly reasoned. The proper course is to apply the ratio and, if appropriate, explain the concerns and grant permission to appeal so that a higher court can reconsider the point. The per incuriam exception concerns decisions made in ignorance of binding statute or authority, which is not the case here, and in any event it is an exception for the Court of Appeal in relation to its own decisions. The parties cannot agree to disapply binding precedent.
Law basis: Doctrine of binding precedent; Cassell & Co Ltd v Broome [1972] AC 1027More Legal System of England and Wales topics
Back to all Legal System of England and Wales questions, or sit a timed mock.