A court finds that a provision in primary legislation cannot be read compatibly with a Convention right, even applying s 3 of the Human Rights Act 1998. Which statement best describes what the court can do?
- Make a declaration of incompatibility under s 4, which does not affect the validity of the provision.Correct answer
- Disapply the provision in the case before it only.
- Refer the matter to the European Court of Human Rights for a binding decision.
- Strike down the provision, because it is incompatible with the Convention.
- Amend the provision itself so that it complies with the Convention.
Courts must read legislation compatibly with Convention rights where possible. If that is not possible, a higher court may declare it incompatible, but the provision stays valid and Parliament decides whether to change it.
Law basis: Human Rights Act 1998 ss 3, 4 ↗