Following a trial in the County Court before a district judge, Callum loses his claim. He wishes to appeal against the district judge's final order. The case is not a specialist or insolvency matter. Which of the following best describes the route and requirement for his appeal?
- Appeal lies directly to the Court of Appeal, and permission to appeal is required.
- Appeal lies to a circuit judge of the County Court, and no permission is needed for final orders.
- Appeal lies to a High Court judge, and permission is needed only if the claim was on the small claims track.
- Appeal lies to a circuit judge of the County Court, and permission to appeal is required.Correct answer
- Appeal lies to the Divisional Court, and permission is required from the district judge only.
Under the Access to Justice Act 1999 (Destination of Appeals) Order 2016 and PD 52A, an appeal from a district judge of the County Court lies to a circuit judge of the County Court. An appeal from a circuit judge goes to a High Court judge, and from a High Court judge to the Court of Appeal. Under CPR 52.3(1) permission is required for almost all appeals, whether against a final or interim decision; the narrow exceptions include committal orders and refusals of habeas corpus. Since 2016, final multi-track decisions of district judges no longer go directly to the Court of Appeal, so that route is outdated.
Law basis: CPR 52.3; Access to Justice Act 1999 (Destination of Appeals) Order 2016; PD 52A