After a trial in the County Court, a circuit judge dismissed Lydia's claim for breach of contract. Lydia believes the judge misinterpreted a key clause and wants to appeal. Her solicitor considers whether permission is needed and, if so, what must be shown. Which of the following best describes the position?
- No permission is needed for an appeal against a final decision after trial.
- Permission is needed and is given if there is a real prospect of success.Correct answer
- Permission is needed and is given only if the judge's error was obvious.
- No permission is needed if the appeal raises a point of law.
- Permission is needed and is given only if the point is of general importance.
Under CPR r 52.3(1), an appellant needs permission to appeal from a decision of a judge in the County Court or High Court, except in a few specified cases such as committal orders. Under r 52.6(1), permission to appeal may be given only where the court considers that the appeal would have a real prospect of success or there is some other compelling reason for the appeal to be heard. A point of law does not remove the need for permission, and general importance is the higher test reserved for second appeals.
Law basis: CPR rr 52.3 and 52.6