Law covered in these questions
- CPR rr 2.8 and 23.7(1)(b)
- CPR rr 23.9 and 23.10
- CPR r 32.6
- CPR r 44.6 and PD 44 para 9
- CPR PD 44 para 4.2
- CPR rr 3.9 and 32.10
- Denton v TH White Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 906
- CPR r 3.8(4)
- CPR rr 3.5 and 3.9
All 9 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
The court has listed Nina's application for specific disclosure for a hearing on Thursday 19 November 2026. There are no bank holidays that month. Her solicitor wants to know the latest date on which the application notice must be served on the other side, assuming the rules on notice apply. Which of the following best describes that date?
- Monday 16 November.
- Sunday 15 November.
- Friday 13 November.Correct answer
- Tuesday 17 November.
- Wednesday 11 November.
Under CPR r 23.7(1)(b), an application notice must be served at least three clear days before the court is to deal with the application. Under r 2.8, 'clear days' excludes the day on which the period begins and the day of the hearing, and where the period is five days or less, Saturdays, Sundays and bank holidays are excluded. The three clear days must therefore be Monday 16, Tuesday 17 and Wednesday 18 November, so the notice must be served by Friday 13 November. Counting the weekend gives the tempting but wrong Sunday answer.
Law basis: CPR rr 2.8 and 23.7(1)(b)Question 2 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
On an urgent without notice application, the court ordered Harper Ltd to preserve certain electronic records. The order, application notice and evidence were served on Harper three days later. Harper believes the order should never have been made. Which of the following best describes how Harper can challenge it?
- Appeal to the Court of Appeal within 21 days of the order.
- Wait for the trial, at which the judge will review the order.
- Apply within 14 days for relief from sanctions under r 3.9.
- Request a reconsideration by letter to the judge's clerk.
- Apply to set aside or vary it within 7 days of service.Correct answer
Under CPR r 23.9, where the court deals with an application without notice, the applicant must serve the order, the application notice and the evidence in support on the respondent. Under r 23.10, a person who was not served with the application notice before the order was made may apply to have the order set aside or varied within 7 days after the date on which the order was served. This is the appropriate first route, rather than an appeal, because Harper has not yet been heard. Relief from sanctions concerns failures to comply with rules or orders.
Law basis: CPR rr 23.9 and 23.10Question 3 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Kasim's solicitor is applying for an order that the defendant provide further information. Box 10 of the application notice sets out in detail the facts relied on, and the notice is verified by a statement of truth. The solicitor asks whether a separate witness statement is also required. Which of the following best describes the position?
- A separate witness statement is always required for any interim application.
- An affidavit is required, because the application seeks a court order.
- Only oral evidence at the hearing can be used for interim applications.
- The facts in the application notice may be relied on as evidence.Correct answer
- No evidence at all is needed, because the request speaks for itself.
Under CPR r 32.6(2), at hearings other than the trial a party may rely on the matters set out in its statement of case or its application notice, if verified by a statement of truth, as well as on witness statements. The general rule under r 32.6(1) is that evidence at such hearings is given by witness statement unless the court, a practice direction or another enactment requires otherwise. Affidavits are needed only in specific cases, such as some applications relating to search orders or contempt, and oral evidence is unusual at interim hearings.
Law basis: CPR r 32.6Question 4 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Orla's application to set aside a default judgment is listed for a one-hour hearing. Her solicitor wants the court to summarily assess her costs of the application if she succeeds. Which of the following best describes what the solicitor should do?
- Nothing, because costs of interim hearings are assessed only after trial.
- File and serve a statement of costs at least 24 hours beforehand.Correct answer
- Prepare a bill for detailed assessment and serve it within three months.
- Serve a costs budget in Precedent H with the application notice.
- Hand a statement of costs to the judge at the end of the hearing.
The general rule is that the court will make a summary assessment of costs at the end of any hearing which lasts no more than one day, unless there is good reason not to. To enable this, each party intending to claim costs must file and serve a statement of costs, in substantially the form of Form N260, as soon as possible and in any event not less than 24 hours before the hearing. Failing to do so is taken into account in deciding costs. Handing it up only at the end of the hearing is too late.
Law basis: CPR r 44.6 and PD 44 para 9Question 5 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
At an interim hearing about specific disclosure, the district judge orders that the costs of the application be 'costs in the case'. At trial, the claimant loses and is ordered to pay the defendant's costs of the claim. Which of the following best describes who pays the costs of the disclosure application?
- The defendant pays them, because the defendant resisted the application.
- The claimant pays them, as the order follows the result at trial.Correct answer
- Each party bears its own costs of that application.
- The party who made the application pays them, whatever the outcome.
- No one pays them, because interim costs are not recoverable.
An order for 'costs in the case' means that the party in whose favour the court makes an order for costs at the end of the proceedings is entitled to that party's costs of the part of the proceedings to which the order relates. Because the defendant obtained its costs at trial, the claimant must also pay the defendant's costs of the disclosure application. 'No order as to costs' would have meant each party bearing its own costs, and the identity of the applicant is irrelevant under a costs in the case order.
Law basis: CPR PD 44 para 4.2Question 6 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
The claimant succeeded on an application to amend its particulars, and the judge ordered 'claimant's costs in the case'. At trial, the claimant loses and is ordered to pay the defendant's costs. Which of the following best describes the effect of the interim order on the costs of the amendment application?
- The claimant recovers its application costs despite losing at trial.
- The claimant pays the defendant's costs of the application as well.
- The defendant pays the claimant's costs of the application, as ordered.
- Each party pays half of the total costs of the application.
- The claimant gets nothing but does not pay the defendant's costs.Correct answer
Under PD 44 para 4.2, an order for 'claimant's costs in the case' means that if the claimant is awarded costs at the end of the proceedings, it is entitled to its costs of the application; but if any other party is awarded costs at the end, the claimant is not liable to pay that party's costs of the application. The claimant lost at trial, so it recovers nothing for the application, but nor does it pay the defendant's costs of it. Under a plain 'costs in the case' order, the claimant would also have had to pay those costs.
Law basis: CPR PD 44 para 4.2Question 7 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Theo's solicitors served his witness statements nine days late because of a computer failure at the firm, which they reported at once. Under the rules, a party who fails to serve a witness statement in time may not call that witness without permission. The trial date is unaffected. Theo applies for relief. Which of the following best describes how the court will decide the application?
- It will refuse relief, because any breach of a court order is fatal.
- It will grant relief automatically, because the trial date is unaffected.
- It will grant relief only if the defendant consents to the late service.
- It will consider the seriousness, the reason, and all the circumstances.Correct answer
- It will decide only whether Theo personally was at fault.
Applications for relief from sanctions under CPR r 3.9 are decided using the three-stage approach in Denton v TH White Ltd. First, the court identifies and assesses the seriousness and significance of the breach. Second, it considers why the default occurred. Third, it evaluates all the circumstances of the case, including the need for litigation to be conducted efficiently and at proportionate cost and to enforce compliance with rules and orders. A short delay that does not imperil the trial date may well not be serious, but relief is never automatic.
Law basis: CPR rr 3.9 and 32.10; Denton v TH White Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 906Question 8 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Directions require the parties to give standard disclosure by 6 November. Both solicitors realise that more time is needed and agree in writing to extend the deadline to 27 November. The trial is fixed for next June and the extension will not affect it or any other hearing. Which of the following best describes whether the extension is effective?
- It is effective, as up to 28 days may be agreed if no hearing is at risk.Correct answer
- It is ineffective, because only the court can vary any date it has set.
- It is effective only once the court approves a consent order.
- It is ineffective, because agreed extensions are limited to 14 days.
- It is effective for any period at all, provided the trial date is not affected.
Under CPR r 3.8(4), where a rule, practice direction or court order requires a party to do something within a specified time and specifies the consequence of failure, the time may be extended by prior written agreement of the parties for up to 28 days, provided that any such extension does not put at risk any hearing date. The parties have agreed 21 days in writing and no hearing is affected, so the extension is effective without a court order. A longer extension, or one jeopardising a hearing date, would need the court's permission.
Law basis: CPR r 3.8(4)Question 9 · Interim applicationsDraft, pending solicitor review
The court ordered that unless Rowan Ltd served its list of documents by 4pm on 2 October, its defence would be struck out. Rowan served nothing and has not applied for anything. The claimant's claim is for a specified sum of £42,000. Which of the following best describes the claimant's position?
- It must apply at a hearing for an order that the defence now be struck out.
- It must wait for the trial, at which Rowan will be barred from giving evidence.
- It may request judgment, as the defence was struck out at the deadline.Correct answer
- It must serve a further notice giving Rowan 14 days to comply with the order.
- It may obtain judgment only after proving its claim at a disposal hearing.
An unless order takes effect automatically on non-compliance, without the need for a further order. Rowan's defence was therefore struck out at 4pm on 2 October. Under CPR r 3.5, where the defence has been struck out under an order and the claim is for a specified sum of money, the claimant may obtain judgment by filing a request. Rowan's only route back is to apply for relief from sanctions under r 3.9, which will be judged on the Denton principles. There is no requirement to serve a further warning notice.
Law basis: CPR rr 3.5 and 3.9More Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.