Leon is suing a builder for delay. While preparing standard disclosure, he finds an email he sent to the builder admitting that he changed the design three times, which helps explain the delay. Leon asks whether he can leave it out because it harms his case and the builder may have deleted its copy. Which of the following best describes his obligation?
- He may omit it, as he need only disclose documents he relies on.
- He may omit it, because the builder was the original recipient of it.
- He must disclose it, because it adversely affects his own case.Correct answer
- He must disclose it only if the builder specifically asks for it.
- He may omit it, provided he does not mention it in his evidence.
Standard disclosure under CPR r 31.6 requires a party to disclose the documents on which it relies, the documents which adversely affect its own case or another party's case or support another party's case, and documents required by a relevant practice direction. Leon's email adversely affects his own case and must be disclosed, regardless of whether the builder still has a copy. Deliberately withholding it would breach his duty and could be contempt, as the disclosure statement is signed with a statement of truth. There is no requirement for a specific request.
Law basis: CPR rr 31.6 and 31.10