Law covered in these questions
- Civil Procedure Rules r 15.4
- CPR rr 10.3 and 15.4
- CPR r 15.5
- CPR r 14.5
- CPR rr 14.9-14.12
- CPR Part 14 and PD 14 para 7.2
- CPR r 16.5(3)-(5)
- CPR rr 20.4 and 20.5
- PD 15
- CPR r 16.6 and Part 20
- Hanak v Green [1958] 2 QB 9
- CPR r 15.11
- CPR Part 37 (defence of tender before claim)
- CPR rr 9.1(2), 10.3 and 15.4
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Particulars of claim are served with the claim form. The defendant files an acknowledgement of service in time. Which statement best describes the time for filing a defence?
- 14 days after the acknowledgement of service is filed.
- 28 days after service of the particulars of claim.Correct answer
- 14 days after service of the particulars of claim.
- 21 days after service of the claim form.
- 56 days after service of the particulars of claim.
A defendant must file a defence within 14 days of service of the particulars of claim, or within 28 days if an acknowledgement of service has been filed. Failure allows the claimant to seek default judgment.
Law basis: Civil Procedure Rules r 15.4Question 2 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
A claim form and particulars of claim are deemed served on Global Freight Ltd on Tuesday 3 November 2026. Global Freight files an acknowledgment of service stating that it intends to defend the whole claim. It wants to know the latest date for filing its defence. Which of the following best describes that date?
- 17 November 2026, which is 14 days after service of the particulars.
- 15 December 2026, which is 28 days after the deadline for acknowledging.
- 24 November 2026, which is 21 days after service of the particulars.
- 3 December 2026, which is one month after service of the particulars.
- 1 December 2026, which is 28 days after service of the particulars.Correct answer
Under CPR r 15.4, the period for filing a defence is 14 days after service of the particulars of claim or, if the defendant files an acknowledgment of service, 28 days after service of the particulars of claim. Because Global Freight acknowledged service, it has 28 days from 3 November, which is 1 December 2026. The period runs from service of the particulars, not from the date of the acknowledgment or the deadline for filing it, so the 15 December option adds the two periods together in error.
Law basis: CPR rr 10.3 and 15.4Question 3 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Ruth is defending a contract claim and her defence is due on 1 December. Her solicitor needs more time to obtain documents from her accountant and asks the claimant's solicitor for an extension. The claimant's solicitor agrees in writing. Which of the following best describes the extension that can be agreed without the court?
- Any length of extension, provided both parties agree it in writing.
- An extension of up to 14 days, with no need to inform the court.
- No extension at all, because only the court can extend time for a defence.
- An extension of up to 56 days, provided the claimant agrees in writing.
- Up to 28 more days, and the defendant must notify the court in writing.Correct answer
Under CPR r 15.5, the defendant and claimant may agree that the period for filing a defence be extended by up to 28 days. Where they do so, the defendant must notify the court in writing of the agreed extension. Any further extension beyond that requires an application to the court. The parties cannot agree an unlimited extension, so the first option is wrong, and the rule expressly contemplates agreed extensions without a court order, so the third option is also wrong.
Law basis: CPR r 15.5Question 4 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Cleo claims £10,000 from a former client for unpaid consultancy fees. The client files an admission that £6,000 is owed and a defence to the remaining £4,000, saying that work was never done. Which of the following best describes Cleo's options?
- She must accept the £6,000, because a part admission ends the whole claim.
- She may enter default judgment for £10,000, as the defence is only partial.
- She may accept the £6,000 in settlement or go on with the whole claim.Correct answer
- She must apply for summary judgment on the £4,000 that remains in dispute.
- She may accept the £6,000 only if the court first approves the admission.
Under CPR r 14.5, where a defendant admits part of a specified claim, the court serves a notice requiring the claimant to state whether she accepts the amount admitted in satisfaction of the claim, does not accept it and wishes to proceed, or accepts it and asks the court to decide time and rate of payment. If Cleo accepts it, judgment is entered for £6,000. If she does not, the claim continues as a defended claim. Default judgment is not available because a defence has been filed, and the court does not need to approve the admission.
Law basis: CPR r 14.5Question 5 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Tariq, an individual, admits the whole of a specified claim for £4,800 brought by a car dealer, and on his admission form asks to pay £150 a month because of his limited income. The dealer refuses the offer and wants immediate payment. Which of the following best describes what happens next?
- The dealer may enter judgment for immediate payment, as it rejected the offer.
- The court will decide the rate of payment, as the parties cannot agree it.Correct answer
- The claim proceeds to a full trial, because the instalment offer was refused.
- Tariq must make a Part 36 offer if he wants to pay by instalments.
- The admission is withdrawn automatically, because the offer was refused.
Where a defendant who is an individual admits a specified sum and asks for time to pay, the claimant may accept or reject the proposed rate. If the claimant rejects the proposal, the court will determine the time and rate of payment, taking into account the defendant's statement of means and the claimant's objections, and enter judgment accordingly. The claimant cannot override the request simply by refusing it. The admission stands and liability is not in issue, so there is no trial, and Part 36 has no role in setting instalments.
Law basis: CPR rr 14.9-14.12Question 6 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
In its defence to a claim arising from a warehouse fire, Grantham Storage Ltd admitted that it breached its duty of care. Two months later, its new expert concludes that the fire started in the claimant's own equipment. Grantham wants to withdraw the admission, but the claimant will not agree. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Grantham may withdraw the admission freely at any time before trial.
- Grantham can never withdraw an admission once made in a statement of case.
- Grantham may withdraw it only if the claimant has not yet relied on it at all.
- Grantham needs the court's permission, weighing the evidence and prejudice.Correct answer
- Grantham may withdraw it by amending its defence without permission.
An admission made in a statement of case after proceedings have started may be withdrawn only with the consent of all parties or the court's permission. In deciding whether to give permission, the court considers all the circumstances, including the grounds for withdrawal, whether new evidence has come to light that was not available when the admission was made, the prejudice to each party, the stage of the proceedings and the interests of the administration of justice. New expert evidence is relevant but not decisive. Amendment without permission is not a route around this rule.
Law basis: CPR Part 14 and PD 14 para 7.2Question 7 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Jasmine sues a builder for £35,000 for defective roofing work. The builder's defence denies that the work was defective and gives reasons, but does not mention the paragraph of the particulars stating that the cost of repairs is £35,000. Which of the following best describes the effect of the defence on the amount claimed?
- The builder is taken to require Jasmine to prove the amount claimed.Correct answer
- The builder is taken to admit the £35,000, as that paragraph was not denied.
- The defence will be struck out, because every paragraph must be answered.
- Jasmine may enter default judgment for the £35,000 not dealt with.
- The builder must serve a Part 18 response before the amount is in issue.
Generally, a defendant who fails to deal with an allegation is taken to admit it, unless the defence sets out the nature of the defendant's case on that issue. However, CPR r 16.5(4) provides that where the claim includes a money claim, a defendant shall be taken to require that any allegation relating to the amount of money claimed be proved unless he expressly admits it. The builder has not admitted the amount, so Jasmine must prove it. The general rule about deemed admissions is the tempting but wrong answer.
Law basis: CPR r 16.5(3)-(5)Question 8 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Delta Kitchens Ltd is sued by a customer for the unpaid balance of a contract price. Delta's director says the customer also owes it money for extra work under a separate order and wants to claim that sum in the same proceedings. Delta's defence is due next week. Which of the following best describes how Delta should bring its own claim?
- Counterclaim when it files its defence, which needs no court permission.Correct answer
- Issue a separate claim, as a counterclaim must concern the same contract.
- Apply first for the court's permission to make any counterclaim at all.
- Raise the extra work only at trial, as part of its oral evidence.
- Ask the claimant to amend its particulars to include the extra work.
A defendant may make a counterclaim against the claimant by filing particulars of the counterclaim. Under CPR r 20.4(2)(a), a counterclaim filed with the defence does not require the court's permission; permission is needed only if it is made at any other time. Defence and counterclaim normally form one document. A counterclaim need not arise out of the same contract, although the court may order it to be dealt with separately. Raising a new claim for the first time at trial is not permitted, as it must be pleaded.
Law basis: CPR rr 20.4 and 20.5; PD 15Question 9 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Hartley Ltd sues Lark Ltd for £20,000 for goods delivered. Lark says the goods were faulty under the same contract and caused it losses of £28,000. Lark wants both to reduce what it owes and to recover the excess. Which of the following best describes how Lark should plead its case?
- Rely on the losses only as a counterclaim, as set-off is no defence to a price claim.
- Plead the losses as a set-off defence and counterclaim for the excess.Correct answer
- Plead the losses only in a set-off defence, which allows any excess to be recovered.
- Pay the £20,000 first, then bring a separate claim for its full losses.
- Admit the claim and rely on the losses at the hearing on quantum.
A defendant with a cross-claim closely connected to the claim can rely on it as an equitable set-off, which is a defence that reduces or extinguishes the claimant's claim. A set-off on its own cannot produce a positive judgment for the excess, so Lark should also counterclaim for the balance of £8,000. CPR r 16.6 confirms that a defendant may include a set-off in its defence whether or not it is also a counterclaim. Paying first and suing separately is unnecessary, and set-off is available against a claim for the price where the cross-claim is closely connected.
Law basis: CPR r 16.6 and Part 20; Hanak v Green [1958] 2 QB 9Question 10 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Liam served a claim on a tenant who neither acknowledged service nor filed a defence. Liam was distracted by other matters and did nothing further. Seven months after the time for filing a defence expired, he asks for default judgment. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Liam may still request default judgment, as there is no time limit for doing so.
- The claim has been struck out automatically and must be issued again.
- The claim is deemed abandoned and Liam must pay the tenant's costs.
- The claim is stayed, and Liam must apply to lift the stay before going on.Correct answer
- The claim may proceed only if the tenant now consents to default judgment.
Under CPR r 15.11, where at least six months have expired since the end of the period for filing a defence, no defendant has served or filed an admission or a defence or counterclaim, and the claimant has not entered or applied for judgment, the claim is stayed. Any party may apply for the stay to be lifted, giving reasons for the delay. The claim is not struck out or treated as abandoned, so Liam can continue after the stay is lifted. Until then he cannot simply request default judgment.
Law basis: CPR r 15.11Question 11 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Before proceedings were issued, Felicity offered her landlord the full £2,400 he claimed as a service charge, but he refused it and demanded £3,500. He then sued for £3,500. Felicity wants to plead in her defence that she tendered the sum actually due before the claim was brought. Which of the following best describes what she must do?
- Plead the tender in her defence, with no further step required.
- Make a Part 36 offer for £2,400 within 21 days of filing her defence.
- Pay the £2,400 into court in order to rely on the defence of tender.Correct answer
- Pay the £2,400 directly to the landlord before filing her defence.
- Apply for summary judgment on the basis of the earlier tender.
A defendant who wishes to rely on a defence of tender before claim must make a payment into court of the amount she says was tendered. If she does not, the defence of tender will not be available until the payment is made. The defence acts as a complete answer to the claim for that sum and can protect her on costs and interest if the court finds the tendered amount was all that was due. A Part 36 offer is a separate settlement mechanism, and paying the landlord directly is not the procedure the rule requires.
Law basis: CPR Part 37 (defence of tender before claim)Question 12 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Amir was served with a claim form stating that particulars of claim will follow. Ten days later he still has not received the particulars, and he asks his solicitor whether he must file an acknowledgment of service now to avoid default judgment. Which of the following best describes the position?
- He must acknowledge within 14 days of service of the claim form.
- He must file a full defence within 14 days of service of the claim form.
- He must apply to strike out the claim, as particulars were not served with it.
- He must acknowledge within 28 days of the date the claim was issued.
- He need not respond until the particulars of claim have been served.Correct answer
Under CPR r 9.1(2), where the claim form states that particulars of claim are to follow, the defendant need not respond to the claim until the particulars of claim have been served. The time for acknowledging service, 14 days, and for filing a defence then runs from service of the particulars under rr 10.3 and 15.4. Amir is therefore not at risk of default judgment yet. The claimant must serve the particulars within 14 days of serving the claim form, but failure to do so does not automatically justify strike-out.
Law basis: CPR rr 9.1(2), 10.3 and 15.4Question 13 · Responding to a claimDraft, pending solicitor review
Bella sues a hairdresser for damages for a scalp burn, without stating a specified sum. The hairdresser returns an admission accepting liability and offers £1,500 in satisfaction of the claim. Bella thinks her claim is worth considerably more. Which of the following best describes her options?
- She must accept the £1,500, because liability has been admitted in full.
- She may enter judgment for whatever sum she claims in her particulars.
- She may reject it and ask for judgment with damages decided by the court.Correct answer
- She must discontinue and issue a new claim stating a specified sum.
- She may reject the offer only if she makes a Part 36 counter-offer instead.
Where a defendant admits liability for an unspecified sum and offers an amount in satisfaction, the claimant may accept the offer, in which case judgment is entered for that sum, or reject it and request judgment for an amount to be decided by the court. The admission of liability stands, so only quantum remains in issue, and the court will give directions for deciding it. Bella is not bound to accept the offer, and she cannot enter judgment for whatever sum she chooses because her claim is unspecified.
Law basis: CPR Part 14 (admission of liability to pay an unspecified sum)More Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.