Law covered in these questions
- Civil Procedure Rules r 44.2(2), (4), (5)
- CPR r 44.3
- CPR r 44.2(2), (4), (6) and (7)
- CPR rr 47.6-47.8
- CPR rr 47.9 and 47.11-47.12
- CPR r 44.2(8)
- CPR rr 44.13-44.16
- CPR r 44.16
- Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 s 57
- Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 ss 58 and 58A(6)
- Senior Courts Act 1981 s 51(6)-(7)
- Ridehalgh v Horsefield [1994] Ch 205
- CPR r 46.8
- Senior Courts Act 1981 s 51
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
A claimant claims £100,000 and wins, but recovers only £30,000. The defendant argues that no costs should be awarded. Which statement best describes the court's approach?
- The court must award the claimant all of its costs, because the claimant won.
- The court must award the defendant its costs, because the claimant lost most of the claim.
- The court must award no costs, because the claimant did not recover the sum claimed.
- The general rule is that the successful party recovers costs, but the court has a discretion and can reduce them to reflect partial success and conduct.Correct answer
- The court must order each party to pay its own costs when a claim succeeds only in part.
The general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party's costs, but the court may make a different order, taking account of conduct and whether a party succeeded in part.
Law basis: Civil Procedure Rules r 44.2(2), (4), (5)Question 2 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
At the end of a trial, the judge orders the defendant to pay the claimant's costs on the indemnity basis because of the defendant's unreasonable conduct during the proceedings. The defendant asks how this differs from the standard basis. Which of the following best describes the main difference?
- Indemnity costs cover every penny the claimant spent, whether reasonable or not.
- Indemnity costs are limited to the claimant's approved costs budget.
- Indemnity costs require proportionality, and doubts favour the paying party.
- Indemnity costs need not be proportionate, and doubts favour the receiver.Correct answer
- Indemnity costs are fixed by the court at a percentage of the damages.
Under CPR r 44.3, on either basis the court will not allow costs that have been unreasonably incurred or are unreasonable in amount. On the standard basis, the court allows only costs that are proportionate to the matters in issue and resolves any doubt about whether costs were reasonably incurred or reasonable in amount in favour of the paying party. On the indemnity basis, proportionality is not a requirement and any doubt is resolved in favour of the receiving party. Indemnity costs therefore do not cover unreasonable costs, which makes the first option a common misconception.
Law basis: CPR r 44.3Question 3 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Selby Ltd sued a contractor on three separate issues: delay, defective cladding and an unpaid variation. It won on delay and the variation but lost on the cladding issue, which took up about a third of the trial. The judge considers that Selby should not recover its costs of the cladding issue. Which of the following best describes the order the judge should normally make?
- An order that Selby recovers all its costs, as the overall winner.
- A percentage order cutting Selby's costs for the issue it lost.Correct answer
- An order that each party pays its own costs, as success was mixed.
- An issues-based order requiring separate assessment of each issue.
- An order that the contractor pays costs only of the delay issue.
The general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party's costs, but under CPR r 44.2(4) the court considers whether a party has succeeded on part of its case, even if not wholly successful. Under r 44.2(6) the court may order a party to pay a proportion of the other's costs or costs relating to distinct issues. Rule 44.2(7) provides that before considering an issues-based order, the court will consider whether it is practicable to make a percentage or date-based order instead. A percentage order is therefore usually preferred, as it avoids complex assessment.
Law basis: CPR r 44.2(2), (4), (6) and (7)Question 4 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
On 4 June, at the end of a five-day multi-track trial, Grove Homes Ltd was awarded its costs, to be subject to detailed assessment if not agreed. The parties cannot agree the amount. Which of the following best describes when Grove Homes must start detailed assessment proceedings?
- Within 21 days of the judgment, by filing a request for a hearing.
- Within 6 months of the judgment, by issuing a fresh Part 8 claim.
- Within 14 days of the judgment, by filing a statement of costs.
- At any time within six years, as a claim to enforce the costs order.
- Within 3 months of the judgment, by serving a notice and the bill.Correct answer
Under CPR r 47.7, the receiving party must commence detailed assessment proceedings within 3 months of the date of the judgment or order giving the right to costs. It does so by serving on the paying party a notice of commencement in the relevant form and a copy or copies of the bill of costs. Delay can be sanctioned under r 47.8 by disallowing all or part of the costs or interest. A statement of costs is used for summary assessment at shorter hearings, and no separate claim needs to be issued.
Law basis: CPR rr 47.6-47.8Question 5 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
A claimant served a notice of commencement of detailed assessment and its bill of costs for £85,000 on the defendant. Thirty days later the defendant has served nothing in response, and no extension has been agreed. Which of the following best describes the claimant's position?
- It must apply for a detailed assessment hearing before taking any other step.
- It must give the defendant a further 14 days before taking any step.
- It may request a default costs certificate, as no points were served.Correct answer
- It may enforce the bill at once without any certificate or order.
- It must accept a provisional assessment of the bill on paper.
Under CPR r 47.9, the paying party may dispute any item in the bill by serving points of dispute within 21 days after the date of service of the notice of commencement. If the paying party fails to do so within the period, the receiving party may, under r 47.11, file a request for a default costs certificate. The certificate entitles the receiving party to the costs claimed in the bill. The paying party may apply to set aside the certificate, showing good reason, but the claimant need not wait or apply for a hearing.
Law basis: CPR rr 47.9 and 47.11-47.12Question 6 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
After winning a long trial, Hollins Ltd is awarded its costs, which it estimates at £400,000, to be assessed by detailed assessment if not agreed. Detailed assessment is likely to take over a year. Hollins wants some money now. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It cannot order any payment until the detailed assessment is complete.
- It may order an interim payment only if the defendant agrees.
- It must order payment of the full £400,000 on account at once.
- It will order a reasonable sum on account unless good reason.Correct answer
- It will order 25% of the estimate, which is fixed by the CPR.
Under CPR r 44.2(8), where the court orders a party to pay costs subject to detailed assessment, it will order that party to pay a reasonable sum on account of costs, unless there is good reason not to do so. The amount is usually an estimate of the likely level of recovery on assessment, with an appropriate margin for error, rather than the full amount claimed. There is no fixed percentage under the rules. The paying party's consent is not required, and the court does not have to wait for the assessment.
Law basis: CPR r 44.2(8)Question 7 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ali's honest personal injury claim against his employer was dismissed at trial because the judge preferred the employer's evidence. No damages or costs orders were made in Ali's favour at any stage. The judge ordered Ali to pay the employer's costs of £35,000. Which of the following best describes whether the employer can enforce the order?
- It cannot enforce it, as Ali recovered nothing to set it against.Correct answer
- It can enforce the order in full, because costs follow the event.
- It can enforce the order up to 25% of the costs incurred.
- It can enforce the order only against Ali's home through a charging order.
- It can enforce the order only if Ali's claim was struck out as an abuse.
Qualified one-way costs shifting applies to claims for damages for personal injury. Under CPR r 44.14, orders for costs made against the claimant may be enforced without permission only to the extent that the aggregate amount does not exceed the aggregate amount of damages, interest and costs orders made in the claimant's favour. Ali recovered nothing, so the employer's costs order cannot be enforced. The protection is lost in certain cases, such as fundamental dishonesty or strike-out for no reasonable grounds or abuse, but Ali's claim was simply lost on the evidence.
Law basis: CPR rr 44.13-44.16Question 8 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Leanne claimed £120,000 for a back injury suffered in a minor road accident. Surveillance footage showed her carrying heavy furniture and playing sport, and the judge found that she had grossly exaggerated her symptoms and dismissed the claim as fundamentally dishonest. Which of the following best describes the defendant's position on costs?
- It can enforce costs only up to the damages Leanne was awarded.
- It cannot recover costs, because QOCS protects every injury claimant.
- It can recover costs only by suing Leanne for deceit in new proceedings.
- It may enforce its costs order in full, with the court's permission.Correct answer
- It can enforce costs only if Leanne is also convicted of fraud.
Under CPR r 44.16, orders for costs made against a personal injury claimant may be enforced to their full extent, with the permission of the court, where the claim is found on the balance of probabilities to be fundamentally dishonest. Leanne's gross exaggeration was found to go to the root of her claim, so the qualified one-way costs shifting protection is lost. The defendant does not need a criminal conviction or separate proceedings, and the cap linked to damages awarded no longer applies. QOCS does not protect dishonest claimants.
Law basis: CPR r 44.16; Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 s 57Question 9 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Bethan instructed solicitors under a conditional fee agreement with a 50% success fee for her commercial claim. She wins and is awarded her costs. Her solicitor's base costs are £60,000 and the success fee is £30,000. Which of the following best describes who pays the success fee?
- The defendant pays it, as part of Bethan's recoverable costs.
- It is shared equally between Bethan and the defendant.
- Bethan pays it, as success fees are not recoverable from opponents.Correct answer
- Nobody pays it, as success fees are unlawful in all commercial claims.
- The defendant pays it, but only on the indemnity basis.
Since the reforms introduced by the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012, section 58A(6) of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 provides that a costs order made in proceedings may not include provision requiring the payment by one party of all or part of a success fee payable by another party under a conditional fee agreement. Bethan can recover her base costs from the defendant, subject to assessment, but must pay the success fee herself, usually from her damages. Success fees remain lawful in commercial claims, subject to the statutory maximum.
Law basis: Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 ss 58 and 58A(6) ↗Question 10 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
The claimant's solicitors repeatedly failed to check the court list and, as a result, missed two hearings, which had to be adjourned at the defendant's expense. The defendant wants the solicitors themselves, rather than the claimant, to pay those wasted costs. Which of the following best describes the test the court will apply?
- Whether they acted improperly, unreasonably or negligently, causing waste.Correct answer
- Whether the solicitors acted dishonestly in failing to attend both hearings.
- Whether the claimant would be unable to pay a costs order personally.
- Whether the solicitors breached the SRA Code, as found by the regulator.
- Whether the defendant would have won the hearings had they gone ahead.
Under section 51(6) and (7) of the Senior Courts Act 1981, the court may order a legal representative to meet wasted costs incurred as a result of any improper, unreasonable or negligent act or omission on the representative's part. Ridehalgh v Horsefield sets out the approach: whether the representative acted improperly, unreasonably or negligently, whether that conduct caused the applicant to incur unnecessary costs, and whether it is just in all the circumstances to order compensation. Dishonesty and a prior regulatory finding are not required, and the client's means are irrelevant.
Law basis: Senior Courts Act 1981 s 51(6)-(7); Ridehalgh v Horsefield [1994] Ch 205; CPR r 46.8 ↗Question 11 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
A claimant company with no assets loses its claim and cannot pay the defendant's costs. Throughout the litigation, the company's sole director funded the claim personally, gave all instructions and stood to receive any damages. The defendant wants the director to pay its costs. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- None, because costs orders can be made only against parties.
- It may order the director to pay as a non-party if it is just to do so.Correct answer
- It may order the director to pay only if he acted dishonestly.
- None, because a director is protected by the company's separate identity.
- It may order the director to pay only if he gave a personal guarantee.
Section 51 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 gives the court a discretion to make costs orders against non-parties, and CPR r 46.2 sets out the procedure. In Dymocks Franchise Systems (NSW) Pty Ltd v Todd the Privy Council held that where a non-party not merely funds the proceedings but substantially controls them or is to benefit from them, justice will ordinarily require that, if the proceedings fail, the non-party pays the successful party's costs. The director funded, controlled and stood to benefit from the claim, so an order is likely to be just. Impropriety is not required.
Law basis: Senior Courts Act 1981 s 51; CPR r 46.2; Dymocks Franchise Systems (NSW) Pty Ltd v Todd [2004] UKPC 39Question 12 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Freddie, a retired engineer, represented himself and won his claim against a builder. He spent about 80 hours preparing the case, but suffered no loss of earnings as he is retired. He is awarded his costs. Which of the following best describes what he can recover for his time?
- Nothing, because litigants in person cannot recover costs for their time.
- His time at the hourly rate that a solicitor would have charged for the work.
- His time at a rate fixed by the judge as reasonable for an engineer.
- His time, but only if he provides an hourly-rate costs budget.
- His time at the fixed hourly rate, as he can prove no lost earnings.Correct answer
Under CPR r 46.5, a litigant in person may recover costs for time reasonably spent on doing the work. Where the litigant can prove financial loss, the amount allowed is the amount the litigant can prove to have been lost for time reasonably spent. Where the litigant cannot prove financial loss, the time is allowed at the fixed hourly rate set out in the practice direction. Freddie is retired and lost no earnings, so he recovers at the fixed rate. The costs allowed cannot exceed two-thirds of what a legal representative would have been allowed.
Law basis: CPR r 46.5 and PD 46 para 3.4Question 13 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Marcel claimed £200,000 for lost business following a supplier's breach and maintained that figure to trial, though it was based on wildly unrealistic projections. The judge awarded him £20,000, rejecting most of the claim as exaggerated. The supplier made no settlement offers. Which of the following best describes the court's approach to costs?
- Marcel recovers all his costs, as he won and no offers were made.
- Marcel's costs are automatically capped at 10% of his damages.
- The supplier recovers all its costs, as Marcel lost most of the claim.
- Marcel's costs are limited to the small claims track scale for £20,000.
- The court may reduce Marcel's costs, or more, for exaggeration.Correct answer
In deciding what costs order to make, the court must have regard to all the circumstances, including the conduct of the parties. Under CPR r 44.2(5)(d), conduct includes whether a claimant who has succeeded in the claim, in whole or in part, exaggerated the claim. The court may therefore reduce Marcel's costs, deprive him of them entirely or even order him to pay some of the supplier's costs. There is no automatic cap or track-based limit for multi-track claims, and the outcome is a matter of discretion rather than an automatic switch in the costs order.
Law basis: CPR r 44.2(4)-(5)Question 14 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ingrid received her solicitor's final bill of £18,000 for a boundary dispute two weeks ago. She thinks it is far too high but has not paid it. She asks whether she can have the bill checked independently by the court. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She can seek assessment only if her solicitor first sues her for the fees.
- She must complain to the SRA, which will decide the reasonableness of the fee.
- She may seek assessment only if she pays the bill in full first.
- She may apply for an assessment of the bill as of right.Correct answer
- She may seek assessment only with the court's permission, after showing special circumstances.
Under section 70 of the Solicitors Act 1974, a client may apply for an order for the assessment of a solicitor's bill. If the application is made within one month of delivery of the bill, the court will order assessment as of right, without requiring the client to pay the bill first. After one month, the court may order assessment on terms, and after twelve months or after payment, special circumstances must be shown. Ingrid received the bill two weeks ago, so she is within the one-month period. Complaints about fees can also go to the Legal Ombudsman, not the SRA.
Law basis: Solicitors Act 1974 s 70 ↗Question 15 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
At an interim hearing, the judge was unable to decide who should pay the costs and ordered that the costs be 'reserved'. The claim settled later without any further order dealing with those interim costs. Which of the following best describes the effect?
- Each party bears its own costs, as no further order was made.
- The costs become costs in the case, as no later order was made.Correct answer
- The claimant pays them, because it brought the claim originally.
- The costs fall away entirely and cannot be recovered by anyone.
- The court must hold a further hearing before anyone can recover them.
Under PD 44 para 4.2, an order that costs are 'reserved' means that the decision about costs is deferred to a later occasion. If no later order is made, the costs will be costs in the case, so that the party who obtains its costs of the proceedings at the end also obtains the reserved costs. In practice, the settlement agreement should deal expressly with all interim costs, but if it is silent and no later order is made, the default rule applies. The costs do not simply fall away or become 'no order as to costs'.
Law basis: CPR PD 44 para 4.2Question 16 · CostsDraft, pending solicitor review
Viktor wants to bring a commercial debt claim for £500,000 but cannot pay hourly rates. His solicitor offers a damages-based agreement under which the firm will take a percentage of whatever Viktor recovers. The claim is not a personal injury or employment matter. Which of the following best describes the maximum payment the firm can take?
- 50% of the sums ultimately recovered, including VAT.Correct answer
- 25% of past losses only, excluding VAT.
- 35% of the sums recovered, excluding VAT.
- No cap, provided Viktor agrees the figure in writing.
- 100% of the costs recovered from the defendant.
Damages-based agreements are regulated by section 58AA of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 and the Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013. In claims other than personal injury and employment matters, the payment to the representative, including VAT, must not exceed 50% of the sums ultimately recovered by the client. The cap is 25% of certain damages in personal injury claims and 35% in employment matters, which makes those the tempting wrong options. There is no freedom to agree an uncapped percentage.
Law basis: Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013 reg 4; Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 s 58AAMore Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.