Law covered in these questions
- Civil Procedure Rules r 24.3
- CPR Part 24
- Swain v Hillman [2001] 1 All ER 91
- Easyair Ltd v Opal Telecom Ltd [2009] EWHC 339 (Ch)
- CPR Part 24 (timing of a claimant's summary judgment application)
- Doncaster Pharmaceuticals Group Ltd v Bolton Pharmaceutical Co 100 Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 661
- CPR Part 24 (procedure and evidence for summary judgment hearings)
- Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2
- CPR r 3.4(2)(a) and PD 3A
- Johnson v Gore Wood & Co [2002] 2 AC 1
- CPR r 3.4(2)(b)
- CPR Part 24 and PD 24 (conditional orders)
- CPR rr 1.1 and 3.4(2)(c)
- CPR Part 24 (summary judgment on the whole of a claim or on an issue)
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
The defendant applies for summary judgment on the whole of the claimant's claim. Which statement best describes the test the court applies?
- Whether the claimant has no real prospect of succeeding and there is no other compelling reason why the claim should be tried.Correct answer
- Whether the defendant has paid the application fee and given notice.
- Whether the claimant is more likely than not to lose at trial.
- Whether the claimant's case is merely arguable.
- Whether the claimant can prove every element of the claim on the papers.
The court gives summary judgment if the claimant has no real prospect of succeeding on the claim and there is no other compelling reason for a trial. A merely arguable claim has a real prospect, so it goes to trial.
Law basis: Civil Procedure Rules r 24.3Question 2 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Westfield Ltd applies for summary judgment on a claim for unpaid invoices. The defendant's evidence explains, with supporting emails, that the work was never completed, although Westfield's evidence strongly suggests otherwise. Westfield asks the judge to weigh the evidence and decide who is more likely to be telling the truth. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It will decide on the documents which party's account is more probable.
- It will ask if the defence has a real, rather than fanciful, prospect.Correct answer
- It will give judgment unless the defendant proves the work was incomplete.
- It will hear oral evidence from the witnesses to resolve the conflict.
- It will refuse judgment only if the defence is certain to succeed.
On a summary judgment application, the question is whether the respondent has a real prospect of successfully defending the claim. In Swain v Hillman, 'real' was contrasted with 'fanciful'. The court must not conduct a mini-trial, and where there is a genuine conflict of evidence supported by documents, it will usually be for the trial judge to resolve. The defendant does not have to prove its defence at this stage or show that it will certainly succeed. Weighing which version is more probable is the task of the trial, not of a summary judgment hearing.
Law basis: CPR Part 24; Swain v Hillman [2001] 1 All ER 91; Easyair Ltd v Opal Telecom Ltd [2009] EWHC 339 (Ch)Question 3 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Mira served her claim form and particulars on a defendant yesterday. She is confident there is no defence and wants to apply for summary judgment immediately, before the defendant has done anything. Which of the following best describes when she may apply?
- Immediately, as summary judgment can be sought at any time after issue.
- Only after the claim has been allocated to a track at the first CMC.
- Once the defendant files an acknowledgment of service or a defence.Correct answer
- Only after disclosure has taken place, so the court has all documents.
- Only after the defendant has filed a defence that the court can assess.
A claimant may not apply for summary judgment until the defendant has filed an acknowledgment of service or a defence, unless the court gives permission or a practice direction provides otherwise. Mira must therefore wait until the defendant takes one of those steps; if it does neither, default judgment will usually be the appropriate route. There is no requirement to wait for allocation or disclosure, and an application may be made after acknowledgment of service even before a defence is filed, which makes the final option too narrow.
Law basis: CPR Part 24 (timing of a claimant's summary judgment application)Question 4 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
A bank applies for summary judgment against Sean on a personal guarantee. Sean's defence is thin on the present evidence, but he says the bank's own internal files will show that its manager told him the guarantee would never be enforced, and those files have not yet been disclosed. Which of the following best describes the court's power to refuse summary judgment?
- It must give judgment, as a thin defence has no real prospect at all.
- It must refuse judgment, as summary judgment is never given before disclosure.
- It may refuse judgment only if Sean pays the full sum into court first.
- It must order the bank to give disclosure, then give judgment if nothing is found.
- It may refuse if there is another compelling reason for a trial.Correct answer
Summary judgment may be given only if the respondent has no real prospect of success and there is no other compelling reason why the case or issue should be disposed of at trial. A compelling reason may exist where the respondent shows reasonable grounds for believing that further evidence, such as documents held by the applicant, is likely to emerge on disclosure and could affect the outcome. The court may also make a conditional order. Summary judgment can be granted before disclosure, so the second option is too absolute.
Law basis: CPR Part 24; Doncaster Pharmaceuticals Group Ltd v Bolton Pharmaceutical Co 100 Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 661Question 5 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Hamilton Ltd has been served with the claimant's application for summary judgment, which is listed for hearing in five weeks. Hamilton's solicitor wants to file a witness statement from its operations director setting out its defence. Which of the following best describes when that evidence must be filed and served?
- At the hearing itself, when the judge invites evidence in reply.
- Within 14 days of service of the application notice.
- At least 14 days before the hearing date that has been fixed.
- At least 7 days before the summary judgment hearing.Correct answer
- At least 3 clear days before the hearing, as for other applications.
On a summary judgment application, the respondent must be given at least 14 days' notice of the hearing date and the issues the court is to decide. If the respondent wishes to rely on written evidence, it must file and serve it at least 7 days before the hearing, and the applicant may then file evidence in reply at least 3 days before the hearing. The general three clear day notice rule for interim applications is displaced by these specific timetables. Waiting until the hearing itself risks the evidence being excluded.
Law basis: CPR Part 24 (procedure and evidence for summary judgment hearings)Question 6 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Callum sues his neighbour, alleging that she orally agreed to sell him a strip of her garden for £15,000 and then backed out. Nothing was ever put in writing. The neighbour's solicitor considers the claim hopeless as a matter of law. Which of the following best describes the neighbour's options?
- She must wait for trial, as summary judgment is available only to claimants.
- She may apply for summary judgment on the claim as having no real prospect.Correct answer
- She may apply for default judgment, as an oral contract for land is void.
- She may apply only for security for costs, as the claim is weak.
- She must serve a Part 18 request before taking any other step.
Summary judgment may be sought by a claimant or a defendant, and the court may give judgment against a claimant on the whole claim or an issue if the claimant has no real prospect of succeeding and there is no other compelling reason for a trial. Under section 2 of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989, a contract for the sale of land must be made in writing, so an oral agreement is not a valid contract. The neighbour can therefore apply for summary judgment. Default judgment is a claimant's remedy for a defendant's failure to respond.
Law basis: CPR Part 24; Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2 ↗Question 7 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
A claimant's particulars of claim allege that the defendant, a stranger, caused him distress by refusing to sell him concert tickets at face value. No contract, statutory duty or recognised tort is identified, and even if every fact alleged is true, there is no legal basis for liability. Which of the following best describes the defendant's most appropriate response?
- File a defence and wait for trial, as the facts are disputed.
- Apply for security for costs, as the claim is plainly weak.
- Request further information under Part 18 about the facts alleged.
- Apply for a declaration that the claimant is a vexatious litigant.
- Apply to strike out, as no reasonable grounds are disclosed.Correct answer
Under CPR r 3.4(2)(a), the court may strike out a statement of case if it appears that it discloses no reasonable grounds for bringing or defending the claim. On such an application the court generally assumes the facts pleaded are true and asks whether they disclose a legally recognisable claim. Here no cause of action is identified even on the claimant's own facts, so strike-out is appropriate and does not require evidence. The facts being disputed is irrelevant where the claim fails as a matter of law, and Part 18 would not cure the absence of a cause of action.
Law basis: CPR r 3.4(2)(a) and PD 3AQuestion 8 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Two years ago, Elise sued her former business partner for unpaid profit share and the claim was decided at trial. She now brings a fresh claim against him for misuse of the same partnership funds, based on facts she knew about and could easily have raised in the first claim. Which of the following best describes the likely response of the court?
- It may strike out the claim as an abuse, if she should have raised it before.Correct answer
- It must hear the claim, because the cause of action is different.
- It may strike out the claim only if it is outside the limitation period.
- It must hear the claim, as abuse of process applies only to identical claims.
- It may hear the claim, but only on condition that she pays security for costs.
Under the rule in Henderson v Henderson, as explained in Johnson v Gore Wood & Co, it may be an abuse of process to raise in later proceedings a matter which could and should have been raised in earlier proceedings. The court takes a broad, merits-based approach, asking whether in all the circumstances the party is misusing or abusing the process of the court. The bar is not limited to identical claims, and a different cause of action does not automatically avoid it. Abusive claims may be struck out under CPR r 3.4(2)(b).
Law basis: Johnson v Gore Wood & Co [2002] 2 AC 1; CPR r 3.4(2)(b)Question 9 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
On a claimant's summary judgment application, the judge considers that the defence of set-off is possible but improbable. There is no compelling reason to send the whole case to trial, but the judge is not prepared to say the defence is fanciful. Which order is the judge most likely to make?
- Summary judgment for the claimant on the whole claim.
- Dismissal of the application with costs against the claimant.
- A conditional order, such as a payment into court.Correct answer
- A stay of proceedings while the parties try mediation.
- An order striking out the set-off as an abuse of process.
Where it appears to the court possible that a claim or defence may succeed but improbable that it will do so, the court may make a conditional order. This typically requires a party to pay a sum of money into court or to take a specified step, failing which its statement of case will be struck out. A conditional order reflects that the defence is not fanciful enough for summary judgment but is weak enough to justify protecting the other party. Outright summary judgment would be wrong because there is some real prospect, however slim.
Law basis: CPR Part 24 and PD 24 (conditional orders)Question 10 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Ingram Ltd failed to comply with an order to file a pre-trial checklist on time and was three weeks late. The trial date is still achievable. The other side applies to strike out Ingram's claim for failure to comply with a court order. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It may strike out, but will consider if a lesser sanction is enough.Correct answer
- It must strike out, because any breach of a court order justifies it.
- It cannot strike out, because only unless orders lead to striking out.
- It must strike out unless Ingram has paid the other side's costs.
- It cannot strike out a claim for a procedural failure of this type.
Under CPR r 3.4(2)(c), the court may strike out a statement of case where there has been a failure to comply with a rule, practice direction or court order. However, striking out is a draconian sanction and the court must act proportionately, in line with the overriding objective. It will consider whether a lesser sanction, such as a costs order or an unless order, would be more appropriate, particularly where the trial date is not threatened. The power is discretionary, so strike-out is neither automatic nor confined to breaches of unless orders.
Law basis: CPR rr 1.1 and 3.4(2)(c)Question 11 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Petra sues a haulier for goods destroyed in transit. The haulier's defence admits the goods were destroyed in its care but disputes the value of the goods and raises no real answer on liability. Petra wants to avoid a full trial on liability. Which of the following best describes what she can seek?
- Default judgment on liability, as the defence admits the loss occurred.
- Nothing, because summary judgment must cover the whole of a claim.
- An interim injunction requiring the haulier to pay for the goods.
- A split trial in which liability is tried first at a full hearing.
- Summary judgment on liability, with the value assessed later.Correct answer
The court may give summary judgment on the whole of a claim or on a particular issue. Where the respondent has no real prospect of defending an issue such as liability, and there is no other compelling reason for a trial of it, judgment can be entered on that issue alone, with directions for the remaining issues such as quantum to be decided later. Default judgment is not available because a defence has been filed. A split trial would still require a full liability hearing, which Petra wants to avoid.
Law basis: CPR Part 24 (summary judgment on the whole of a claim or on an issue)Question 12 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
Dominic, a litigant in person, has issued his fourth claim in two years against his former employer about the same dismissal. The judge strikes out the latest claim and considers that it was bound to fail and had no rational basis. Which of the following best describes what the judge must do?
- Nothing further, because striking out is the only sanction available.
- Refer Dominic to the Attorney General to be declared vexatious.
- Record that the claim was totally without merit and consider restraint.Correct answer
- Order Dominic to pay security for costs before issuing any further claim.
- Transfer any future claims by Dominic to the Court of Appeal.
Under CPR r 3.4(6), where the court strikes out a claimant's statement of case and considers that the claim is totally without merit, the court order must record that fact and the court must at the same time consider whether it is appropriate to make a civil restraint order. A civil restraint order can restrict a litigant from issuing further claims or applications without permission. Proceedings by the Attorney General for a civil proceedings order under the Senior Courts Act 1981 are a separate and rarer remedy, not the court's immediate duty.
Law basis: CPR rr 3.3(7), 3.4(6) and 3.11Question 13 · Summary judgment and strike outDraft, pending solicitor review
A dispute about whether a commercial lease contains a valid break clause turns entirely on the construction of the written lease. All relevant documents are before the court on the landlord's summary judgment application, and no further evidence could affect the meaning of the clause. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It must send the matter to trial, as construction issues are always complex.
- It may decide the point only if both parties consent to summary disposal.
- It must refuse summary judgment if the tenant's argument is not fanciful.
- It should decide the point of construction now if it has all the evidence.Correct answer
- It may decide the point only after the parties have exchanged expert evidence.
Where an application for summary judgment gives rise to a short point of law or construction, and the court is satisfied that it has before it all the evidence necessary for its proper determination, it should grasp the nettle and decide it. If the respondent's case is bad in law, it has no real prospect of success, and it is in no one's interest to delay the decision. This principle was summarised in Easyair Ltd v Opal Telecom Ltd. The respondent's consent is not needed, and construction of a written lease does not call for expert evidence.
Law basis: CPR Part 24; Easyair Ltd v Opal Telecom Ltd [2009] EWHC 339 (Ch)More Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.