Law covered in these questions
- Civil Procedure Rules r 36.17(4)
- CPR rr 36.2, 36.5 and 44.2(4)(c)
- Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] Fam 93
- CPR r 36.13(1) and (3)
- CPR r 36.13(4)-(5)
- CPR r 36.17(1), (3) and (5)
- CPR r 36.17(4)
- CPR r 36.17(2)
- CPR rr 36.9 and 36.11
- CPR r 36.14(6)-(7)
- CPR r 36.16
- CPR r 36.14(1)-(2) and (5)
- CPR rr 36.7, 36.11 and 36.13(4)(a)
- CPR rr 27.2(1)(g) and 27.14
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
A claimant makes a Part 36 offer to accept £80,000 to settle her claim. The defendant does not accept it. At trial the claimant is awarded £92,000. Which statement best describes the court's powers?
- Unless it would be unjust, the court can order enhanced interest, indemnity costs from the end of the relevant period, and an additional amount.Correct answer
- The court must automatically award every consequence, even if it would be unjust.
- The court must order standard basis costs only, because Part 36 does not change the costs basis.
- The court can do nothing, because only a defendant's Part 36 offer has costs consequences.
- The court can order the extra consequences only if the defendant had accepted the offer.
Where a claimant beats her own Part 36 offer at trial, the court must make the enhanced consequences unless it considers them unjust. They are enhanced interest, indemnity costs from expiry of the relevant period, interest on costs and an additional amount.
Law basis: Civil Procedure Rules r 36.17(4)Question 2 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
The defendant's solicitors write: 'Without prejudice save as to costs: our client offers £30,000 in full settlement of your client's claim. This offer is open for 14 days.' The letter does not mention Part 36. The claimant rejects it and later recovers £25,000 at trial. Which of the following best describes the status of the offer?
- It is a valid Part 36 offer, with the automatic costs consequences of Part 36.
- It has no effect on costs at all, because it is not a Part 36 offer.
- It is not a Part 36 offer, but the court may consider it when deciding costs.Correct answer
- It becomes a Part 36 offer once the 14 days expire without acceptance.
- It is inadmissible at all stages, as it is marked without prejudice.
Under CPR r 36.5, a Part 36 offer must be in writing, make clear that it is made pursuant to Part 36, specify a period of not less than 21 days within which the defendant will be liable for the claimant's costs if accepted, state whether it relates to the whole claim or part, and whether it takes account of any counterclaim. This letter fails several requirements, so the automatic Part 36 consequences do not apply. However, as a 'without prejudice save as to costs' Calderbank offer, the court may take it into account when exercising its costs discretion under r 44.2(4)(c).
Law basis: CPR rr 36.2, 36.5 and 44.2(4)(c); Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] Fam 93Question 3 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant makes a valid Part 36 offer of £45,000 to settle the whole of Jude's claim, with a relevant period of 21 days. Jude accepts it in writing on day 15. Which of the following best describes the costs position?
- Each party bears its own costs, as the claim settled.
- Jude pays the defendant's costs from the date of the offer.
- Jude recovers his costs up to acceptance, on the standard basis.Correct answer
- Jude recovers his costs on the indemnity basis, as the offer was accepted.
- The court decides costs at a hearing, with no presumption either way.
Under CPR r 36.13(1), where a Part 36 offer is accepted within the relevant period, the claimant is entitled to the costs of the proceedings, including recoverable pre-action costs, up to the date on which notice of acceptance was served on the offeror. Under r 36.13(3), those costs are assessed on the standard basis if not agreed. Jude accepted within 21 days, so he recovers his costs to day 15. The indemnity basis is associated with a claimant beating its own offer at trial, not with ordinary acceptance.
Law basis: CPR r 36.13(1) and (3)Question 4 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant made a valid Part 36 offer of £60,000 with a 21-day relevant period, which expired on 1 March. The claimant, Rosa, did not accept until 1 June, after reviewing expert evidence. The parties cannot agree costs. Which of the following best describes the order the court will normally make?
- Costs to 1 March for Rosa; she pays the defendant's costs after that.Correct answer
- Rosa recovers all of her costs up to 1 June, because the offer was accepted.
- Rosa pays all the defendant's costs from the date the offer was made.
- Each party pays its own costs from the date the offer was made.
- Rosa recovers all her costs on the indemnity basis up to 1 June.
Where a Part 36 offer is accepted after the relevant period has expired, CPR r 36.13(4)(b) and (5) provide that, unless the court considers it unjust, the claimant is entitled to her costs up to the date on which the relevant period expired, and the claimant is liable for the defendant's costs from that date to the date of acceptance. Rosa therefore receives her costs to 1 March but must pay the defendant's costs from 1 March to 1 June. This encourages prompt acceptance and reflects the costs incurred by the delay.
Law basis: CPR r 36.13(4)-(5)Question 5 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant made a valid Part 36 offer of £80,000, which the claimant, Kwame, rejected. At trial Kwame is awarded £72,000. There are no special circumstances making the usual consequences unjust. Which of the following best describes the costs order the court will normally make?
- Kwame recovers all his costs, as he won at trial.
- Kwame pays all the defendant's costs from the start of the claim.
- Each party pays its own costs from the date of the offer.
- Kwame recovers his costs on the indemnity basis from the offer date.
- Kwame pays the defendant's costs from expiry, with interest.Correct answer
Where a claimant fails to obtain a judgment more advantageous than a defendant's Part 36 offer, CPR r 36.17(3) provides that, unless it would be unjust, the court will order that the defendant is entitled to its costs from the date on which the relevant period expired, and interest on those costs. Kwame recovers his own costs up to the expiry of the relevant period, but bears the defendant's costs after that. He is not ordered to pay costs from the start of the claim, because he was right to bring it and won some damages.
Law basis: CPR r 36.17(1), (3) and (5)Question 6 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
Claire made a valid claimant's Part 36 offer to accept £50,000. The defendant ignored it. At trial, Claire is awarded £60,000. There are no circumstances making the usual consequences unjust. Which of the following best describes one consequence the court will normally order?
- Claire's damages are increased to the full amount originally claimed.
- The defendant pays Claire's costs on the standard basis only.
- The defendant pays a penalty to the court of 10% of the damages.
- An additional amount of £6,000, which is 10% of the sum awarded.Correct answer
- Claire's damages are doubled because the offer was not accepted.
Where judgment against the defendant is at least as advantageous to the claimant as the claimant's own Part 36 offer, CPR r 36.17(4) provides that, unless unjust, the court will order enhanced interest on the sum awarded at up to 10% above base rate, costs on the indemnity basis from expiry of the relevant period, interest on those costs at up to 10% above base rate, and an additional amount. For awards up to £500,000, the additional amount is 10% of the sum awarded, so here £6,000. The additional amount is paid to the claimant, not the court.
Law basis: CPR r 36.17(4)Question 7 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant made a valid Part 36 offer of £40,000, inclusive of interest, which the claimant, Lorna, rejected. At trial, she is awarded £40,050 including interest. The defendant argues that she should be treated as having failed to beat the offer, because £50 is trivial. Which of the following best describes the position?
- She has not beaten the offer, as the difference is not significant.
- She has beaten the offer, as she did better by any amount in money terms.Correct answer
- She has not beaten it, as costs must also be considered in the comparison.
- She has beaten the offer only if she obtained over 10% more.
- She has matched the offer, so each party bears its own costs.
Under CPR r 36.17(2), in relation to any money claim or money element of a claim, 'more advantageous' means better in money terms by any amount, however small, and 'at least as advantageous' should be construed accordingly. Lorna's judgment of £40,050 is better than the £40,000 offer, so she has beaten it, and the defendant cannot rely on r 36.17(3). The comparison is between the judgment sum and the offer, and there is no requirement for a significant margin. This rule was introduced to avoid uncertain arguments about near misses.
Law basis: CPR r 36.17(2)Question 8 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
On 1 March, Tavistock Ltd made a valid defendant's Part 36 offer with a 21-day relevant period. On 10 March, it served written notice withdrawing the offer. On 15 March, the claimant served notice accepting it. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The acceptance is valid, as the withdrawal took effect only at expiry.Correct answer
- The offer was withdrawn on 10 March, so the acceptance has no effect.
- The acceptance is valid only if the court gives permission to accept late.
- The offer lapsed on 10 March, and the claimant must make a new offer.
- The acceptance is valid only if Tavistock agrees to it in writing.
Under CPR r 36.9, a Part 36 offer can be withdrawn or its terms changed only by written notice. Where the offeror serves notice of withdrawal before expiry of the relevant period, that notice has effect only on expiry of the relevant period, and if the offeree serves notice of acceptance before then, the acceptance takes effect and the withdrawal has no effect. The relevant period ran until 22 March, and the claimant accepted on 15 March, so the acceptance is valid. No permission or consent from Tavistock is needed.
Law basis: CPR rr 36.9 and 36.11Question 9 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
Ewan accepted a defendant's Part 36 offer of £28,000 for the whole of his money claim. Three weeks after acceptance, the defendant has paid nothing, and no different payment date was agreed. Which of the following best describes Ewan's position?
- He must issue a new claim for breach of the settlement agreement.
- He may enter judgment, as payment was due within 14 days.Correct answer
- He may restore the original claim and seek the full sum at trial.
- He must wait 28 days from acceptance before taking any step.
- He may apply for summary judgment on the original claim.
Under CPR r 36.14(6), unless the parties agree otherwise, a single sum of money offered in a defendant's Part 36 offer must be paid to the claimant within 14 days of acceptance. If it is not paid within that time, r 36.14(7) allows the claimant to enter judgment for the unpaid sum. The claim was stayed on acceptance, but the claimant may enforce the terms within those proceedings. There is no need to issue a new claim, and the stay prevents the claimant simply restoring the original claim and pursuing it to trial.
Law basis: CPR r 36.14(6)-(7)Question 10 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
The defendant made a Part 36 offer of £75,000 that the claimant rejected. At the start of the trial, the defendant's counsel wants to tell the judge about the offer to show the defendant has been reasonable throughout. The claimant does not agree. Which of the following best describes whether the offer may be mentioned?
- It may be mentioned in opening, to show the defendant's reasonable conduct.
- It may be mentioned once the claimant has finished giving evidence.
- It may be mentioned if counsel shows it is relevant to liability.
- It may not be mentioned until liability and quantum are decided.Correct answer
- It may be mentioned only if the claimant has made an offer as well.
Under CPR r 36.16, a Part 36 offer is treated as without prejudice except as to costs, and the fact that it has been made must not be communicated to the trial judge until the case has been decided, meaning all questions of liability and the amount of money to be awarded. There are limited exceptions, such as where the defence of tender before claim has been raised or the parties agree in writing. Once the case is decided, the offer can be revealed to deal with costs. Counsel cannot raise it simply to show reasonable conduct.
Law basis: CPR r 36.16Question 11 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
Within the relevant period, a claimant validly accepted the defendant's Part 36 offer to settle the whole claim for £52,000. The next day, the defendant's insurer tells its solicitors it has changed its mind and wants to defend the claim after all. Which of the following best describes the effect of the acceptance?
- Nothing, because acceptance needs a sealed consent order to bind.
- The defendant may withdraw, as long as it pays the claimant's costs to date.
- The claim is stayed on the terms of the offer, which bind the defendant.Correct answer
- The claim continues unless the court approves the settlement.
- The defendant may withdraw within 7 days of the claimant's acceptance.
Under CPR r 36.14(1), if a Part 36 offer is accepted, the claim is stayed upon the terms of the offer. Where the offer relates to the whole claim, the stay is of the whole claim, and the stay does not affect the court's power to enforce the terms of the offer. A valid acceptance creates a binding settlement, and the offeror cannot then withdraw. No consent order or court approval is required, except in special cases such as a claim by a child or protected party, where court approval is needed under Part 21.
Law basis: CPR r 36.14(1)-(2) and (5)Question 12 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
Ten days before trial, a defendant makes a valid Part 36 offer of £90,000. Five days before trial, the claimant, Anouk, wants to accept it. The parties cannot agree costs. Which of the following best describes Anouk's position?
- She cannot accept, as offers made within 21 days of trial are invalid.
- She needs the court's permission to accept, because trial is so close.
- She can accept, and she recovers all her costs on the indemnity basis.
- She can accept only if the defendant renews the offer in writing.
- She can accept, but the court decides costs if not agreed.Correct answer
A Part 36 offer may be made at any time, including less than 21 days before trial. Permission to accept is required only in specified cases, such as after the trial has started. Under CPR r 36.13(4)(a), where a Part 36 offer is made less than 21 days before the start of the trial and accepted, the liability for costs must be determined by the court unless the parties agree. Anouk can therefore accept before the trial begins, but costs will be decided by the court in the absence of agreement, rather than by the usual automatic rule.
Law basis: CPR rr 36.7, 36.11 and 36.13(4)(a)Question 13 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
Jamal's £6,500 claim against a car repairer has been allocated to the small claims track. The repairer's solicitor writes making a formal 'Part 36 offer' of £4,000 and warns that Jamal will face Part 36 costs penalties if he does not beat it at the hearing. Which of the following best describes the effect of the offer?
- The full Part 36 consequences will apply if Jamal fails to beat the offer.
- Part 36 applies, but the additional amount is capped at £500 on this track.
- Part 36 does not apply on the small claims track, so no such penalties.Correct answer
- The offer is valid only if the repairer pays £4,000 into court with it.
- Jamal must accept within 21 days or the claim will be stayed.
Under CPR r 27.2(1)(g), Part 36 does not apply to claims allocated to the small claims track. The repairer's offer therefore cannot carry the automatic costs consequences of Part 36, and on the small claims track recoverable costs are in any event restricted by r 27.14. Jamal can still consider the offer on its merits as an ordinary settlement proposal. There is no requirement for payment into court with a Part 36 offer, and failure to accept a settlement offer does not stay a claim.
Law basis: CPR rr 27.2(1)(g) and 27.14Question 14 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
In a disputed claim for injuries from a fall in a warehouse, the claimant makes a valid Part 36 offer to accept 80% liability, leaving damages to be assessed. The defendant does not accept. After a split trial on liability, the court finds the defendant 100% liable. Which of the following best describes the effect of the offer?
- It is a valid offer on liability, so Part 36 benefits may follow.Correct answer
- It is invalid, because a Part 36 offer must specify a sum of money.
- It has no effect until damages are assessed and compared with a sum.
- It is valid, but only the defendant can benefit from issue-based offers.
- It operates only as a Calderbank offer, as it concerns liability alone.
Under CPR r 36.2(3), a Part 36 offer may be made in respect of the whole, or part of, or any issue that arises in, a claim, counterclaim or other additional claim. An offer to accept a percentage of liability is a valid Part 36 offer on the issue of liability. Because the claimant obtained a judgment on liability at least as advantageous as the offer, the court will consider the consequences in r 36.17(4) unless it would be unjust. Only a defendant's offer in a money claim must be a single sum of money, so the second option is wrong.
Law basis: CPR rr 36.2(3) and 36.17(4)Question 15 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
Early in a straightforward debt claim for £100,000, the claimant made a Part 36 offer to accept £99,500, with nothing else conceded. The defendant ignored it, and the claimant later obtained judgment for the full £100,000. The defendant argues that the enhanced Part 36 consequences should not apply. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It must apply the enhanced consequences, as the claimant beat the offer.
- It must refuse all costs to the claimant, as the offer was a tactical device.
- It may apply only the additional amount, but no enhanced interest.
- It may find them unjust if the offer was not a genuine attempt to settle.Correct answer
- It must treat the offer as invalid, because it was for nearly the full sum.
Where a claimant obtains a judgment at least as advantageous as its own Part 36 offer, the court will make the orders in CPR r 36.17(4) unless it considers it unjust to do so. In deciding whether it would be unjust, the court considers all the circumstances, including the terms of the offer, the stage at which it was made, the information available and whether the offer was a genuine attempt to settle the proceedings, under r 36.17(5)(e). An offer to accept 99.5% of a debt claim may be found not to be a genuine attempt to settle. The offer is still valid as a Part 36 offer.
Law basis: CPR r 36.17(4)-(5)Question 16 · Part 36 and settlementDraft, pending solicitor review
Three days ago, a defendant made a Part 36 offer of £55,000 'in full and final settlement'. The claimant, Imran, is unsure whether the offer takes account of the defendant's counterclaim for unpaid fees. Which of the following best describes what Imran's solicitor can do?
- Accept the offer and argue about the counterclaim afterwards.
- Treat the offer as invalid, because it is unclear on its face.
- Apply to the court at once for an order declaring the offer void.
- Make a counter-offer, which automatically clarifies the terms.
- Request clarification within 7 days of the offer being made.Correct answer
Under CPR r 36.8, the offeree may, within 7 days of a Part 36 offer being made, request the offeror to clarify the offer. If the offeror does not give the clarification within 7 days of receiving the request, the offeree may apply for an order that it does so, unless the trial has started. Imran's solicitor is within the 7-day period. A Part 36 offer must state whether it takes into account any counterclaim, so a lack of clarity may be resolved by clarification rather than treating the offer as void. Accepting first risks an unintended settlement.
Law basis: CPR rr 36.5(1)(e) and 36.8More Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.