Law covered in these questions
- CPR rr 12.4 and 12.5
- CPR r 12.3(3)
- CPR rr 13.2 and 15.4
- CPR rr 13.2 and 13.3
- CPR r 13.3(2)
- FXF v English Karate Federation Ltd [2023] EWCA Civ 891
- Denton v TH White Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 906
- CPR r 12.8
- CPR rr 12.4 and 12.12
- CPR r 12.3(2)
- CPR r 13.2(c)
- CPR rr 12.6 and 16.4(2)
- County Courts Act 1984 s 69
- CPR rr 3.1(3) and 13.3
All 11 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Isaac sues a neighbour in negligence for unspecified damages after water from the neighbour's flat ruined his ceiling. The neighbour fails to file an acknowledgment of service within the time allowed. Isaac files a request for default judgment. Which of the following best describes the judgment he will obtain?
- Judgment for the full sum Isaac has estimated in his statement of value.
- No judgment, because default judgment is unavailable for unspecified claims.
- Judgment only after a trial at which Isaac proves both liability and loss.
- Judgment for a sum fixed by a court officer from Isaac's invoices.
- Judgment for an amount to be decided by the court at a later hearing.Correct answer
Default judgment is available for both specified and unspecified money claims. Where the claim is for an amount of money to be decided by the court, CPR r 12.5 provides that judgment will be for an amount to be decided by the court, together with costs. Liability is established by the judgment, and the court then gives directions for a disposal hearing to assess damages. The claimant cannot obtain judgment for the figure estimated in the statement of value, because that is only an estimate, and no trial on liability is required.
Law basis: CPR rr 12.4 and 12.5Question 2 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Sterling Ltd was served with a claim but, instead of filing a defence, it issued an application to strike out the particulars of claim as disclosing no reasonable grounds. The application has not yet been heard. The time for filing a defence has now passed and the claimant requests default judgment. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Default judgment cannot be entered while the strike-out application is live.Correct answer
- Default judgment must be entered, because no defence was filed in time.
- Default judgment can be entered, but Sterling may apply to set it aside.
- Default judgment can be entered for any part of the claim not challenged.
- Default judgment can be entered unless the court has already fixed a hearing date.
Under CPR r 12.3(3)(a), the claimant may not obtain default judgment if the defendant has applied to have the claimant's statement of case struck out under r 3.4, or for summary judgment under Part 24, and that application has not been disposed of. Sterling's pending strike-out application therefore protects it from default judgment, even though it has not filed a defence. If the application fails, the court will usually set a timetable for the defence. The rule applies whether or not a hearing date has been fixed.
Law basis: CPR r 12.3(3)Question 3 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Particulars of claim were served on Wren Ltd on 2 March and it filed an acknowledgment of service on 10 March. On 20 March, believing that the defence was 14 days late, the claimant obtained default judgment. Wren applies to set the judgment aside. Which of the following best describes the court's position?
- It may set aside the judgment if Wren shows a real prospect of defending.
- It must set aside the judgment, as it was entered before time expired.Correct answer
- It may refuse to set aside the judgment if Wren was slow in applying.
- It must set aside the judgment only if Wren pays the claimant's costs.
- It must leave the judgment in place, as Wren had not yet filed a defence.
Because Wren filed an acknowledgment of service, it had 28 days from service of the particulars, until 30 March, to file a defence. The default judgment was entered on 20 March, before that time had expired, so the conditions in r 12.3 were not satisfied. Under CPR r 13.2, the court must set aside a judgment wrongly entered in these circumstances. No real prospect of success needs to be shown, because the mandatory ground applies; the tempting first option describes the discretionary ground under r 13.3, which is not needed here.
Law basis: CPR rr 13.2 and 15.4Question 4 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Valid service of a claim was effected at Simone's home while she was working abroad for three months. Default judgment was entered against her. On returning, she applies within a week to set it aside, with a draft defence and documents showing she had already paid the sum claimed by bank transfer, which the claimant disputes. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It must set aside the judgment, because Simone did not know about the claim.
- It cannot set aside the judgment, because service at her home was valid.
- It must set aside the judgment, because the claim had been fully paid.
- It may set aside the judgment if she shows a real prospect of defending.Correct answer
- It may set aside only if the claimant agrees, as service was valid.
The judgment was regularly entered because service was valid, so the mandatory ground in r 13.2 does not apply. Under CPR r 13.3 the court may set aside or vary the judgment if the defendant has a real prospect of successfully defending the claim or there is some other good reason, and it must consider whether the application was made promptly. Simone's evidence of payment and her prompt application support setting aside. The court has not found that the claim was satisfied, as payment is disputed, so the mandatory option for a paid claim is not made out.
Law basis: CPR rr 13.2 and 13.3Question 5 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Default judgment was regularly entered against Barrow Ltd in January. Barrow's finance director learned of it in early February but did not instruct solicitors until July, when bailiffs arrived. Barrow then applied to set aside, with a defence that has a real prospect of success. Which of the following best describes how the court will approach the delay?
- Delay is irrelevant if the defence has a real prospect of success.
- Promptness matters, and the court applies the relief from sanctions approach.Correct answer
- The court must refuse the application, as it was made over three months later.
- The court must set aside, but may order Barrow to pay indemnity costs.
- Delay is relevant only if the claimant has already started enforcement.
Under CPR r 13.3(2), in considering whether to set aside a default judgment the court must have regard to whether the application was made promptly. The Court of Appeal in FXF v English Karate Federation Ltd held that the Denton approach to relief from sanctions applies to such applications, so the court considers the seriousness of the default, the reasons for it and all the circumstances. A defence with a real prospect of success does not make the delay irrelevant. There is no fixed three-month cut-off, but unexplained delay of five months weighs heavily against Barrow.
Law basis: CPR r 13.3(2); FXF v English Karate Federation Ltd [2023] EWCA Civ 891; Denton v TH White Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 906Question 6 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivy sues two brothers, Ken and Les, for £12,000 owed under a loan they took jointly. Ken files a defence denying liability. Les does nothing and the time for him to respond has expired. Which of the following best describes whether Ivy can obtain default judgment?
- She cannot obtain default judgment against Les while Ken defends the claim.
- She may obtain default judgment against both brothers, as Les failed to respond.
- She must wait until trial and obtain one judgment against both brothers.
- She may obtain default judgment against Les and continue against Ken.Correct answer
- She may obtain default judgment against Les only if Ken consents to it.
Where a claimant claims a money remedy against more than one defendant, CPR r 12.8 allows the claimant to obtain default judgment against a defendant who has failed to respond and to continue the proceedings against the other defendants. Ivy can therefore enter default judgment against Les while the claim proceeds against Ken, who has filed a defence. The rule differs for claims for other remedies, where the court may need to deal with the application at the same time as disposing of the claim against the others. Ken's consent is not required.
Law basis: CPR r 12.8Question 7 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Clarke Ltd sues a former employee, seeking both damages and an injunction restraining him from using its confidential client list. The employee fails to file an acknowledgment of service in time. Clarke Ltd's solicitor wants to obtain default judgment. Which of the following best describes the procedure?
- File a request for judgment, which a court officer will process on paper.
- Apply for summary judgment, as default judgment never covers injunctions.
- File a request for judgment on damages, and issue a new claim for the injunction.
- Wait for the employee to file a defence out of time and then seek a trial.
- Make an application under Part 23, because the claim includes another remedy.Correct answer
Default judgment is obtained by filing a request where the claim is only for money or for delivery of goods with an option to pay their value. Under CPR r 12.4(2), where the claim includes some other remedy, such as an injunction, the claimant must make an application under Part 23, and the court will decide what judgment the claimant is entitled to on the statement of case. Default judgment is therefore available for the injunction, but only by application, so the option suggesting that injunctions can never be granted in default is wrong.
Law basis: CPR rr 12.4 and 12.12Question 8 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant's deadline for filing a defence expired on 5 May. The defendant filed a defence on 9 May, without any agreed or court-ordered extension. On 11 May, the claimant files a request for default judgment, arguing that the defence was late. Which of the following best describes whether default judgment may be entered?
- No, because a defence has now been filed, even though it was filed late.Correct answer
- Yes, because the defence was filed after the time for doing so had expired.
- Yes, unless the defendant applies for relief from sanctions within 7 days.
- No, unless the claimant first applies to strike out the late defence.
- Yes, because a late defence is treated as if it had never been filed.
Under CPR r 12.3(2), the claimant may obtain default judgment for failure to defend only if the defendant has filed an acknowledgment of service but has not filed a defence and the relevant time has expired. The question is whether a defence has been filed at the time judgment is sought, not whether it was filed in time. Once a defence is on the court file, default judgment cannot be entered, although the claimant may raise the lateness in costs or case management. The late defence is not treated as a nullity.
Law basis: CPR r 12.3(2)Question 9 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Ahmed was sued for £3,100 for unpaid rent. Shortly after being served, he paid the full £3,100 and the claimant's statutory interest and fixed costs, but did not file anything with the court. A week later the claimant, by oversight, obtained default judgment. Which of the following best describes Ahmed's position on applying to set aside?
- The court may set aside only if Ahmed shows a real prospect of defending.
- The court will refuse to set aside, as Ahmed should have filed a defence.
- The court must set aside the judgment, as the claim was paid beforehand.Correct answer
- The court will vary the judgment to nil but leave it on the register.
- The court must set aside only if the claimant agrees that it was paid.
Under CPR r 13.2, the court must set aside a default judgment if it was wrongly entered because one of the conditions for default judgment was not satisfied, or because the whole of the claim was satisfied before judgment was entered. Ahmed paid the full claim, including interest and costs, before judgment, so the court must set it aside. He does not need to show a real prospect of defending, which is the test for the discretionary ground in r 13.3, and the claimant's agreement is not required once payment is proved.
Law basis: CPR r 13.2(c)Question 10 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Ellis Supplies Ltd claims £14,000 for goods sold. Its particulars of claim state that it claims statutory interest under section 69 of the County Courts Act 1984 at 8% a year, giving the amount to the date of issue and the daily rate thereafter. The defendant fails to respond and Ellis requests default judgment. Which of the following best describes the interest Ellis can include?
- No interest, because interest is only awarded after a contested hearing.
- Interest only up to the date of issue, as stated in the particulars.
- Interest at whatever rate the court officer considers reasonable.
- Interest at the Judgments Act rate from the date the debt fell due.
- Interest at the claimed rate up to the date of the default judgment.Correct answer
Under CPR r 12.6, where the claim includes a claim for interest and the particulars of claim include the details required by r 16.4, including the basis, rate and daily rate, default judgment for a specified sum may include interest calculated up to the date of judgment at the rate claimed, provided that the statutory rate is not exceeded where interest is claimed under statute. Ellis properly pleaded its interest claim, so it can include interest to the date of judgment. Judgment debt interest after judgment is a separate matter.
Law basis: CPR rr 12.6 and 16.4(2); County Courts Act 1984 s 69Question 11 · Default judgmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Harlow Ltd applies promptly to set aside a regularly entered default judgment for £60,000. Its draft defence raises an argument about defective goods that the judge regards as thin, although not fanciful, and the evidence about Harlow's finances suggests it may be moving assets. Which of the following best describes the order the court may make?
- It must refuse to set aside, because the defence is thin.
- It may set aside on conditions, such as paying money into court.Correct answer
- It must set aside unconditionally, as the defence is not fanciful.
- It may set aside only if Harlow offers security for costs.
- It may vary the judgment to a smaller sum instead of setting it aside.
Under CPR r 13.3 the court may set aside a regular default judgment if the defendant shows a real prospect of successfully defending. The court has a general power under r 3.1(3) to make an order subject to conditions, including a condition to pay a sum of money into court. Where a defence has some prospect but is shadowy, or there is concern about the defendant's conduct, setting aside on condition of a payment into court is a common outcome. The court is not obliged to set aside unconditionally simply because the defence is not fanciful.
Law basis: CPR rr 3.1(3) and 13.3More Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.