Law covered in these questions
- American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396
- Senior Courts Act 1981 s 37
- CPR PD 25A
- Ninemia Maritime Corp v Trave Schiffahrtsgesellschaft mbH [1983] 1 WLR 1412
- CPR Part 25 and its practice direction (example freezing injunction)
- Anton Piller KG v Manufacturing Processes Ltd [1976] Ch 55
- Civil Procedure Act 1997 s 7
- Brink's-MAT Ltd v Elcombe [1988] 1 WLR 1350
- NWL Ltd v Woods [1979] 1 WLR 1294
- Human Rights Act 1998 s 12(3)
- Cream Holdings Ltd v Banerjee [2004] UKHL 44
- Zockoll Group Ltd v Mercury Communications Ltd [1998] FSR 354
- National Commercial Bank Jamaica Ltd v Olint Corp Ltd [2009] UKPC 16
- CPR rr 38.2 and 38.6
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A company applies for an interim injunction to stop a former employee using its customer list pending trial. Which test does the court apply?
- Whether the claimant has paid the defendant's costs of the application in advance.
- Whether the claimant will probably win at trial on the balance of probabilities.
- Whether there is a serious question to be tried, whether damages would be an adequate remedy, and where the balance of convenience lies, usually with a cross-undertaking in damages.Correct answer
- Whether the defendant consents to the order being made.
- Whether the claimant has a strong prima facie case that is certain to succeed.
The court asks whether there is a serious question to be tried, whether damages would be adequate for either side, and where the balance of convenience lies. The applicant normally gives a cross-undertaking in damages.
Law basis: American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396Question 2 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Willow Software Ltd applies for an interim injunction to stop a competitor using a product name that Willow says infringes its rights. The competitor argues that Willow must first prove that it is more likely than not to win at trial. Which of the following best describes the first question the court will ask?
- Whether Willow is more likely than not to succeed at trial.
- Whether Willow has a strong prima facie case of infringement.
- Whether there is a serious question to be tried.Correct answer
- Whether the competitor acted dishonestly in choosing the name.
- Whether Willow has already suffered quantifiable financial loss.
Under the guidelines in American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd, the court first asks whether there is a serious question to be tried, meaning the claim is not frivolous or vexatious. The applicant does not need to show that it is more likely than not to succeed at trial. If there is a serious question, the court goes on to consider whether damages would be an adequate remedy for either party and then where the balance of convenience lies. A strong prima facie case is the higher threshold used for exceptional orders such as search orders.
Law basis: American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396; Senior Courts Act 1981 s 37Question 3 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A distributor seeks an interim injunction to stop a supplier selling to a rival in its territory, in breach of an exclusivity clause. The distributor's only loss would be lost sales, which its accounts make easy to calculate, and the supplier is a large, solvent company. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The injunction will be granted, as a breach of contract is always restrained.
- The injunction will be granted, as there is a serious question to be tried.
- The injunction will be granted if the distributor gives a cross-undertaking.
- The injunction will be refused, as damages would be an adequate remedy.Correct answer
- The injunction will be refused, because exclusivity clauses are unenforceable.
Under American Cyanamid, once a serious question to be tried is established, the court considers whether damages would be an adequate remedy for the applicant if it succeeded at trial and whether the respondent could pay them. If damages would be adequate and the respondent could pay, no interim injunction should normally be granted, however strong the claim appears. The distributor's loss is easily quantified and the supplier can pay, so damages are adequate. A serious question to be tried is necessary but not sufficient for an injunction.
Law basis: American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396Question 4 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Juno Ltd obtains an interim injunction stopping a former director from running a competing business until trial. At trial, the court finds that Juno had no valid claim, and the former director shows that the injunction caused him substantial lost profits. Which of the following best describes how the director can recover those losses?
- By enforcing the cross-undertaking in damages given by Juno.Correct answer
- By suing Juno for malicious prosecution of a civil claim.
- Through the costs order, which includes compensation for lost profits.
- By applying for an interim payment against Juno before the trial ends.
- He cannot recover them, because the injunction was lawfully granted.
An applicant for an interim injunction is normally required to give the court a cross-undertaking in damages, promising to pay any damages the court considers the respondent should be compensated for if it later turns out that the injunction should not have been granted. When Juno's claim fails, the director may apply for an inquiry as to damages under the undertaking to recover the losses the injunction caused him. Costs orders cover legal costs, not lost profits, and the fact that the order was properly made at the time does not prevent enforcement.
Law basis: American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396; CPR PD 25AQuestion 5 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Coral Ltd is suing a former finance manager for £300,000 she allegedly diverted to her own accounts. Coral has learned she has listed her house for sale and has opened accounts abroad. Coral wants an order preventing her disposing of her assets before trial. Which of the following best describes what Coral must show?
- Only that it has a serious question to be tried against the manager.
- That the manager has already transferred assets out of England and Wales.
- That Coral is certain to obtain judgment for at least £300,000 at trial.
- That damages would be an inadequate remedy if the order were refused.
- A good arguable case, assets, and a real risk of dissipation.Correct answer
A freezing injunction, granted under section 37 of the Senior Courts Act 1981, requires the applicant to show a good arguable case on the merits, that the respondent has assets within or outside the jurisdiction, and a real risk that, unless restrained, the respondent will dissipate or dispose of the assets so that a judgment would go unsatisfied. It must also be just and convenient to grant the order. The American Cyanamid serious question test is not enough. Coral need not prove that assets have already been moved, but must provide solid evidence of the risk.
Law basis: Senior Courts Act 1981 s 37; Ninemia Maritime Corp v Trave Schiffahrtsgesellschaft mbH [1983] 1 WLR 1412 ↗Question 6 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Dylan has been served with a freezing injunction covering all his assets up to £500,000. He runs a small catering business and needs to pay his staff, his rent and his solicitors to defend the claim. Which of the following best describes his position under a standard freezing order?
- He may make no payments at all until the order is discharged.
- He may spend a set weekly sum, plus legal fees and normal trading.Correct answer
- He may make any payment, provided he tells the claimant beforehand.
- He may pay his solicitors only after obtaining a separate court order each time.
- He may pay living costs, but legal fees must come from public funding.
A freezing injunction is not intended to punish the respondent or bring his business to a halt. The standard form of order permits the respondent to spend a specified sum each week on ordinary living expenses and a reasonable sum on legal advice and representation, and to deal with or dispose of assets in the ordinary and proper course of business. The respondent may agree further exceptions with the applicant or apply to vary the order. A blanket ban on all payments is not the standard position, nor is advance notice of any payment sufficient.
Law basis: CPR Part 25 and its practice direction (example freezing injunction)Question 7 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Aldgate Designs Ltd believes a former employee has copied its confidential product drawings onto a laptop at his home and is about to give them to a rival. It fears that if he learns of the claim he will wipe the files. It wants an order allowing its representatives to enter his home and remove the laptop. Which of the following best describes what Aldgate must show?
- A serious question to be tried and that the balance of convenience favours it.
- A good arguable case and a risk the employee will move his assets abroad.
- That the police have declined to investigate the employee's conduct.
- That the employee has refused a written request to return the drawings.
- A very strong prima facie case, serious harm and a real risk of destruction.Correct answer
A search order is an exceptional remedy. The applicant must show an extremely strong prima facie case, that the actual or potential damage is very serious, clear evidence that the respondent has incriminating documents or things in his possession, and a real possibility that he may destroy them before an application with notice can be made. The order is executed under the supervision of an independent supervising solicitor. The American Cyanamid test is too low, and a good arguable case with risk of dissipation is the test for freezing injunctions.
Law basis: Anton Piller KG v Manufacturing Processes Ltd [1976] Ch 55; Civil Procedure Act 1997 s 7 ↗Question 8 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Rafael obtained a without notice freezing injunction against a business partner. At the return date, it emerges that he did not tell the judge that the partner had offered to provide security for the claim, a fact Rafael knew. Which of the following best describes the likely consequence?
- None, because the partner can raise the offer at the return date anyway.
- The injunction may be discharged for lack of full and frank disclosure.Correct answer
- Rafael must pay a fine, but the injunction will continue until trial.
- The injunction stays in place, as the omission was not deliberate fraud.
- Rafael's whole claim will be struck out as an abuse of process.
An applicant for a without notice order owes a duty of full and frank disclosure of all material facts, including those adverse to its own case. In Brink's-MAT Ltd v Elcombe the Court of Appeal held that if material non-disclosure is established, the court will be astute to ensure the applicant does not obtain an advantage, and the order may be discharged even if a fresh order might otherwise be justified. The court retains a discretion to continue or re-grant the order. The duty is not limited to deliberate concealment, and the underlying claim is not struck out.
Law basis: Brink's-MAT Ltd v Elcombe [1988] 1 WLR 1350Question 9 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A hair salon seeks an interim injunction to enforce a six-month non-compete covenant against a former stylist. The covenant will have expired long before any trial could take place, so the interim decision will effectively decide the dispute. Which of the following best describes how this affects the court's approach?
- It makes no difference, as the court never considers the merits at the interim stage.
- The court will refuse any injunction, since the covenant will soon expire.
- The court will give weight to the likely outcome at trial when deciding.Correct answer
- The court will grant the injunction automatically to preserve the covenant.
- The court must order a speedy trial instead of considering an injunction.
The American Cyanamid approach normally avoids assessing the relative merits at the interim stage. However, in NWL Ltd v Woods the House of Lords recognised that where the grant or refusal of an interim injunction will in effect dispose of the action finally, because the matter will not go to trial or will be academic by then, the likelihood of the applicant succeeding at trial is a factor to be weighed in the balance of convenience. A short restrictive covenant is a classic example. The court may order an expedited trial, but it is not obliged to do so instead.
Law basis: NWL Ltd v Woods [1979] 1 WLR 1294; American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396Question 10 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A newspaper plans to publish a story based on documents leaked from inside a property company. The company applies for an interim injunction to restrain publication until trial, relying on breach of confidence. Which of the following best describes the threshold the company must satisfy?
- That there is a serious question to be tried on breach of confidence.
- That the newspaper has no public interest defence that could possibly succeed.
- That damages would be an inadequate remedy for the company.
- That it is likely to establish at trial that publication is not allowed.Correct answer
- That the leaked documents are marked as confidential on their face.
Section 12(3) of the Human Rights Act 1998 provides that no relief affecting the exercise of the right to freedom of expression is to be granted to restrain publication before trial unless the court is satisfied that the applicant is likely to establish that publication should not be allowed. In Cream Holdings Ltd v Banerjee the House of Lords held that 'likely' generally means more likely than not, although a lower threshold may be appropriate in some cases. This displaces the ordinary American Cyanamid serious question test, which is the tempting but insufficient answer.
Law basis: Human Rights Act 1998 s 12(3); Cream Holdings Ltd v Banerjee [2004] UKHL 44 ↗Question 11 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A telecoms company has re-routed a taxi firm's well-known telephone number to a competitor, claiming a contractual right to do so. The taxi firm seeks an interim order compelling the company to restore the number to it before trial. Which of the following best describes the court's approach to this application?
- It will consider which course risks less injustice, needing high assurance.Correct answer
- It applies exactly the same test as for an order restraining the defendant.
- It will refuse the order, as positive acts are only ordered after trial.
- It will grant the order if the claim is not frivolous or vexatious.
- It will make the order only if the taxi firm pays the number's value into court.
The order sought is a mandatory interim injunction, requiring the defendant to take positive action. Such orders are granted more sparingly than prohibitory injunctions. The overriding approach is to take whichever course appears to carry the lower risk of injustice if it turns out to have been wrong, but the court will usually need a high degree of assurance that the applicant will succeed at trial before granting a mandatory order. They can be granted before trial, so a blanket refusal is wrong, and the low serious question threshold is not enough on its own.
Law basis: Zockoll Group Ltd v Mercury Communications Ltd [1998] FSR 354; National Commercial Bank Jamaica Ltd v Olint Corp Ltd [2009] UKPC 16Question 12 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Elgin Ltd obtained an interim injunction preventing a former partner from contacting its clients. Three months later, Elgin decides it no longer wishes to pursue the claim and its solicitor proposes simply to file and serve a notice of discontinuance. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Elgin may discontinue at any time by filing and serving a notice.
- Elgin must obtain the defendant's written consent but not the court's.
- Elgin may discontinue only by agreeing a Tomlin order with the defendant.
- Elgin needs the court's permission, as an interim injunction was made.Correct answer
- Elgin cannot discontinue once an interim injunction has been granted.
A claimant may generally discontinue all or part of a claim at any time by filing and serving a notice of discontinuance. However, under CPR r 38.2(2)(a), the claimant must obtain the court's permission to discontinue where the court has granted an interim injunction. This allows the court to consider matters such as enforcing the cross-undertaking in damages for the defendant's benefit. Elgin is therefore not barred from discontinuing, but must apply for permission. The defendant's consent is relevant in other situations, such as where an interim payment has been made.
Law basis: CPR rr 38.2 and 38.6Question 13 · Interim injunctionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Paolo was personally served with an injunction, bearing a penal notice, forbidding him from approaching his former business premises. A week later CCTV shows him entering the premises and removing stock. The claimant wants the court to punish the breach. Which of the following best describes the appropriate course?
- Apply for committal for contempt, which must be proved to the criminal standard.Correct answer
- Report Paolo to the police, as only a criminal court can deal with the breach.
- Apply for summary judgment on the whole claim, which is the only sanction.
- Ask the court for indemnity costs, as contempt has no other consequence.
- Apply to strike out Paolo's defence, which must be proved on the balance of probabilities.
Breach of an injunction is a contempt of court. Where the order bore a penal notice and was personally served, the claimant may make a contempt application under CPR Part 81. The breach must be proved to the criminal standard, so the court must be sure, and the respondent has rights including the privilege against self-incrimination. The court may impose imprisonment of up to two years, a fine or seizure of assets. The civil court deals with the contempt itself, and contempt sanctions are not limited to costs or striking out.
Law basis: CPR Part 81; Contempt of Court Act 1981 s 14 ↗More Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.