Law covered in these questions
- CPR r 32.5
- CPR rr 3.9 and 32.10
- Civil Evidence Act 1995 ss 1-2 and 4
- CPR r 33.2
- Civil Evidence Act 1995 s 4
- CPR r 33.4
- Civil Evidence Act 1995 s 3
- CPR r 32.18
- CPR r 32.19
- CPR rr 34.5 and 34.7
- CPR r 35.3 and PD 35 para 2
- CPR r 35.6
- CPR rr 35.4 and 35.7
- Daniels v Walker [2000] 1 WLR 1382
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Rhiannon's witness statement in her claim against a landlord was served months ago. At trial, after confirming it, she wants to tell the judge about a conversation with the landlord's agent that is not mentioned anywhere in her statement. Which of the following best describes the position?
- She may do so only with the court's permission, given for good reason.Correct answer
- She may do so freely, because oral evidence always overrides the statement.
- She may do so only if the landlord's counsel consents during the trial.
- She may not do so in any circumstances once her statement is served.
- She may do so only in re-examination, after she has been cross-examined.
Where a witness is called to give oral evidence at trial, the witness statement stands as the witness's evidence in chief unless the court orders otherwise, under CPR r 32.5(2). A witness may amplify the statement and give evidence about new matters which have arisen since it was served only if the court considers there is good reason not to confine the evidence to the statement, under r 32.5(3)-(4). Rhiannon therefore needs the court's permission. Re-examination is limited to matters raised in cross-examination, so it is not a route to introduce new evidence.
Law basis: CPR r 32.5Question 2 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Directions required witness statements to be exchanged by 1 May. The defendant served statements from two witnesses but not from its warehouse supervisor, whose evidence it now wishes to call at the trial in July. No extension was agreed or ordered. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The supervisor may give evidence, as the statement is merely late.
- The supervisor may give evidence if he attends in person to be cross-examined.
- The supervisor may give evidence only by written answers to questions.
- The supervisor may not be called without the court's permission.Correct answer
- The supervisor may give evidence only as a hostile witness.
Under CPR r 32.10, if a witness statement for use at trial is not served within the time specified by the court, the witness may not be called to give oral evidence unless the court gives permission. The defendant must therefore apply for permission, which in substance is an application for relief from sanctions assessed under the Denton principles. Attendance at trial does not cure the failure. The sanction exists to prevent ambush and ensure each side knows the evidence it must meet before trial.
Law basis: CPR rr 3.9 and 32.10Question 3 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
A key witness for the claimant gave a signed witness statement but has since emigrated to Australia and refuses to attend the trial or give evidence by video. The claimant still wants to rely on the statement. Which of the following best describes what the claimant must do?
- Nothing, because served witness statements are always admissible.
- Serve a hearsay notice saying the witness will not be called and why.Correct answer
- Apply for a witness summons to compel the witness to attend.
- Obtain an affidavit from the witness, since a statement is insufficient.
- Withdraw the statement, as evidence of an absent witness is inadmissible.
Under section 1 of the Civil Evidence Act 1995, hearsay evidence is admissible in civil proceedings. Under CPR r 33.2, where a party intends to rely on a witness statement as hearsay evidence without calling the witness, it must serve a notice which identifies the evidence, informs the other parties that the witness is not being called and gives the reason. A witness summons would be ineffective against someone outside the jurisdiction. The evidence is admissible, but its weight will be assessed under section 4, taking into account that the witness was not cross-examined.
Law basis: Civil Evidence Act 1995 ss 1-2 and 4; CPR r 33.2 ↗Question 4 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
In a contract dispute, the claimant relies on a hearsay statement from a former employee describing a meeting that took place three years before the statement was made. The employee is alive and living in Leeds, but the claimant has chosen not to call him. Which of the following best describes how the court will treat the hearsay evidence?
- It must exclude it, as the maker could have been called to give evidence.
- It must give it the same weight as oral evidence tested in cross-examination.
- It will assess its weight, considering why the maker was not called.Correct answer
- It may admit it only if the defendant does not object at trial.
- It must treat it as conclusive unless the defendant calls the employee.
Hearsay evidence is admissible in civil proceedings, but under section 4 of the Civil Evidence Act 1995 the court must have regard to any circumstances from which inferences can reasonably be drawn about its reliability. These include whether it would have been reasonable and practicable to produce the maker as a witness, whether the statement was made contemporaneously, whether it involves multiple hearsay and whether there is any motive to conceal or misrepresent. The employee's availability and the three-year gap will reduce its weight. It is not excluded merely because the maker could have attended.
Law basis: Civil Evidence Act 1995 s 4 ↗Question 5 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
The defendant has served a hearsay notice saying it will rely on a written statement by a former site manager without calling him. The claimant wants to test his account by cross-examining him. Which of the following best describes what the claimant should do?
- Wait until trial and ask the judge to adjourn so that he can attend.
- Serve its own hearsay notice in reply within 7 days of the notice.
- Object at trial, which makes the statement automatically inadmissible.
- Ask the defendant to withdraw the notice, as it has no other remedy.
- Apply within 14 days for permission to cross-examine him.Correct answer
Under CPR r 33.4, where a party proposes to rely on hearsay evidence and does not propose to call the person who made the original statement, the court may, on the application of any other party, permit that party to call the maker of the statement to be cross-examined on its contents. The application must be made not more than 14 days after the day on which the hearsay notice was served. Objecting at trial does not render the statement inadmissible, because hearsay is admissible under the Civil Evidence Act 1995.
Law basis: CPR r 33.4; Civil Evidence Act 1995 s 3Question 6 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
In a road traffic claim, the claimant expects the defendant to dispute that it was raining at the time of the accident, although weather records clearly show heavy rain. The claimant wants to avoid the cost of calling a meteorologist to prove it. The trial is in three months. Which of the following best describes a suitable step?
- Serve a notice to prove documents on the defendant.
- Serve a Part 18 request asking the defendant to agree the weather.
- Serve a notice to admit the fact at least 21 days before trial.Correct answer
- Ask the court to take judicial notice of the weather records.
- Apply for summary judgment on the issue of the weather alone.
Under CPR r 32.18, a party may serve notice on another party requiring it to admit the facts, or the part of the case, specified in the notice. The notice must be served no later than 21 days before the trial. If the other party unreasonably refuses to admit a fact that is later proved, the court may reflect this in its costs orders. A notice to prove documents concerns the authenticity of disclosed documents, not facts. Judicial notice covers matters of common knowledge, not local weather on a particular day.
Law basis: CPR r 32.18Question 7 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
The claimant disclosed a letter which it says the defendant signed agreeing to a price increase. The defendant believes the signature on the letter is forged. Witness statements have now been exchanged, and the defendant has done nothing about the letter. Which of the following best describes the defendant's position?
- It may challenge the signature at trial at any time, since forgery is always open to it.
- It is deemed to admit the letter is authentic, having served no notice to prove.Correct answer
- It must apply to strike out the claim as being based on a forged document.
- It may challenge authenticity only if it obtains a handwriting expert's report.
- It must serve a notice to admit facts asking the claimant to admit the forgery.
Under CPR r 32.19, a party is deemed to admit the authenticity of a document disclosed to it under Part 31 unless it serves notice that it wishes the document to be proved at trial. The notice must be served by the latest date for serving witness statements or within 7 days of disclosure of the document, whichever is later. The defendant has missed that deadline, so it is deemed to admit authenticity and would need the court's permission to challenge it. A notice to admit facts is a different tool and would not help the defendant here.
Law basis: CPR r 32.19Question 8 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Olu needs evidence at trial from a former colleague who saw the incident but is reluctant to get involved and has refused to attend voluntarily. The trial starts on 20 January. Olu's solicitor obtains a witness summons. Which of the following best describes when it must be served to bind the witness to attend?
- At least 28 days before 20 January.
- At least 3 clear days before 20 January.
- At any time before the witness is called.
- At least 21 days before 20 January.
- At least 7 days before 20 January.Correct answer
A witness summons requires a witness to attend court to give evidence or produce documents. Under CPR r 34.5, a witness summons is binding if it is served at least 7 days before the date on which the witness is required to attend, unless the court directs that a summons served less than 7 days before is binding. The witness must also be offered or paid a sum reasonably sufficient to cover travel expenses and compensation for loss of time. A summons served later than 7 days before may not bind the witness without such a direction.
Law basis: CPR rr 34.5 and 34.7Question 9 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Nicola's building consultant expert tells her that, while most of the defects she complains of were caused by the builder, one significant crack was probably caused by her own alterations. Nicola asks the expert to leave that finding out of the report for court, since she is paying the fee. Which of the following best describes the expert's position?
- The expert must include it, as the duty to the court overrides duties to Nicola.Correct answer
- The expert may omit it, because an expert acts on the instructions of the client.
- The expert may omit it if Nicola confirms the instruction in writing.
- The expert must include it only if the builder's expert has found the same thing.
- The expert may omit it, but must tell the court that a finding was left out.
Under CPR r 35.3, it is the duty of experts to help the court on matters within their expertise, and this duty overrides any obligation to the person from whom they have received instructions or by whom they are paid. PD 35 requires expert evidence to be the independent product of the expert, uninfluenced by the pressures of litigation, and to address matters that detract from the expert's opinion. The expert must therefore include the finding about the crack. Payment of the fee and written instructions from Nicola do not change the expert's overriding duty.
Law basis: CPR r 35.3 and PD 35 para 2Question 10 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
The claimant served its engineering expert's report on 2 March. The defendant finds parts of the methodology unclear and wants to ask the expert about them. On 20 March the defendant's solicitor drafts some written questions to send. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Questions may be asked only with the court's permission at a hearing.
- Questions may be asked at any time before trial about any matter.
- Questions must be sent to the court, which passes them to the expert.
- Questions may be put within 28 days of service, for clarification only.Correct answer
- Questions may be put only to a single joint expert, not a party's expert.
Under CPR r 35.6, a party may put written questions about an expert's report to an expert instructed by another party or to a single joint expert. Unless the court permits or the other party agrees, the questions may be put once only, must be put within 28 days of service of the report and must be for the purpose of only clarifying the report. The answers are treated as part of the report. The defendant's questions on 20 March are within 28 days. If the expert does not answer, the court may order that the party may not rely on that evidence.
Law basis: CPR r 35.6Question 11 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
The court directed a single joint expert to value a business in a partnership dispute. The expert's valuation is far lower than the claimant expected, and the claimant has reasonable grounds for thinking the expert used an inappropriate method. The claimant wants to obtain a report from its own expert. Which of the following best describes the position?
- It may instruct its own expert and rely on the report without permission.
- It must accept the single joint expert's report, as the court ordered it.
- It may cross-examine the joint expert at trial, but not obtain other evidence.
- It may seek permission to rely on its own expert if it has good reason.Correct answer
- It may ask the court to discharge the joint expert and appoint another.
No party may call an expert or put in evidence an expert's report without the court's permission. Where a single joint expert has reported and a party has reasons, which are not fanciful, for wanting to obtain further expert evidence, the court may permit it to do so, as explained in Daniels v Walker. The court considers proportionality and the overriding objective. The claimant may first put written questions to the joint expert. A single joint expert's report is not automatically conclusive, but a party cannot simply rely on its own expert without permission.
Law basis: CPR rr 35.4 and 35.7; Daniels v Walker [2000] 1 WLR 1382Question 12 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
The court ordered the parties' surveying experts to meet and produce a joint statement. At the meeting, the claimant's expert agreed that some of the damp was caused by a leaking gutter not covered by the claim. The claimant's solicitor is concerned that this binds the claimant. Which of the following best describes the effect of the experts' agreement?
- It binds the claimant, because the expert acts as the claimant's agent.
- It binds the claimant only if the judge approves the joint statement.
- It does not bind the parties unless they expressly agree to be bound.Correct answer
- It does not bind anyone, and the joint statement is inadmissible at trial.
- It binds both parties, because the meeting was ordered by the court.
Under CPR r 35.12, the court may direct a discussion between experts to identify and discuss the expert issues and, where possible, reach an agreed opinion. The experts must prepare a statement showing the issues on which they agree and disagree, with reasons. Under r 35.12(5), where experts reach agreement on an issue during their discussions, the agreement does not bind the parties unless they expressly agree to be bound by it. The joint statement is, however, usually admissible and highly influential, so the claimant should consider the expert's change of view carefully.
Law basis: CPR r 35.12Question 13 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
The defendant suspects that the claimant's medical expert was given incomplete information, because the report's summary of instructions omits any mention of the claimant's previous back injury. The defendant asks for disclosure of the claimant's letter of instruction to the expert. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It may order disclosure if there are reasonable grounds to doubt it.Correct answer
- It cannot order disclosure, because the instructions are privileged.
- It must order disclosure, because instructions are never privileged.
- It may order disclosure only if the expert agrees to the request.
- It may order disclosure only after the expert has given oral evidence.
An expert's report must state the substance of all material instructions on the basis of which it was written. Under CPR r 35.10(4), those instructions are not privileged against disclosure, but the court will not order disclosure of any specific document or permit questioning about the instructions unless it is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds to consider the statement of instructions to be inaccurate or incomplete. The omission of a known previous back injury may provide such grounds. The rule is therefore neither full privilege nor automatic disclosure.
Law basis: CPR r 35.10(3)-(4)Question 14 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Bruno lost his personal injury claim after his own expert, at the experts' meeting, negligently signed a joint statement accepting conclusions she did not actually hold, which undermined his case. Bruno wants to sue the expert for negligence. Which of the following best describes the position?
- He cannot sue, because experts have immunity for evidence given in court.
- He can sue only if the expert acted dishonestly, not merely negligently.
- He cannot sue, because the expert's duty is owed only to the court.
- He can sue only the solicitors who instructed the expert, not the expert.
- He can sue, as expert witnesses have lost that immunity.Correct answer
In Jones v Kaney the Supreme Court abolished the immunity from suit previously enjoyed by expert witnesses in respect of claims for breach of duty by their clients in relation to evidence given in, or for the purposes of, legal proceedings. The facts of that case were very similar, involving an expert who signed a joint statement that did not reflect her true views. An expert's overriding duty to the court does not prevent a duty of care also being owed to the client. Bruno need not prove dishonesty, and he can sue the expert directly.
Law basis: Jones v Kaney [2011] UKSC 13Question 15 · Witness and expert evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Arthur sues a van driver for injuries suffered when the van hit his car. The van driver was convicted in the magistrates' court of careless driving arising from the same incident and did not appeal. Which of the following best describes the effect of the conviction in Arthur's civil claim?
- It is inadmissible, because criminal and civil proceedings are separate.
- It is admissible, and the driver must prove he did not commit the offence.Correct answer
- It is conclusive proof of negligence, which the driver cannot dispute.
- It is admissible only if Arthur calls the police officer who gave evidence.
- It is admissible only as evidence of the driver's general bad character.
Under section 11 of the Civil Evidence Act 1968, a subsisting conviction for an offence by a UK court is admissible in civil proceedings to prove that the person committed that offence. Where the conviction is proved, the person convicted is taken to have committed the offence unless the contrary is proved, so the burden shifts to the driver to prove on the balance of probabilities that he did not. The conviction is therefore strong but not conclusive evidence. It should be pleaded in the particulars of claim under PD 16.
Law basis: Civil Evidence Act 1968 s 11; CPR PD 16 para 8.1 ↗More Dispute Resolution topics
Back to all Dispute Resolution questions, or sit a timed mock.