Pennine Textiles Ltd, based in Manchester, wants to sue Clyde Mills Ltd, a company domiciled in Glasgow, in the High Court in England for the price of goods delivered to Manchester. There are no proceedings about the dispute in Scotland. Which of the following best describes whether Pennine needs the court's permission to serve the claim form in Scotland?
- Permission is needed, because Scotland is outside England and Wales.
- Permission is needed unless the contract has an English jurisdiction clause.
- Permission is not needed, because service is always permitted anywhere in the world at all.
- Permission is not needed if the court has power under the 1982 Act to decide the claim.Correct answer
- Service in Scotland is impossible, and the claim must be issued in Scotland.
Under CPR r 6.32 a claim form may be served in Scotland or Northern Ireland without permission where each claim is one the court has power to determine under the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982, no proceedings concerning the same claim are pending in the other part of the UK, and the claim form contains a statement of the grounds. The intra-UK rules in Schedule 4 to the 1982 Act give the English court jurisdiction where the goods were to be delivered in England. Permission is not required merely because Scotland is a separate jurisdiction.
Law basis: CPR r 6.32; Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 Sch 4