Fenwick Retail Ltd is sued by a customer injured by a defective ladder it sold. Fenwick says the manufacturer, which is not a party, must indemnify it under their supply contract. Fenwick's defence is due in ten days. Which of the following best describes how Fenwick can bring the manufacturer into the proceedings?
- Issue an additional claim before or with its defence, without permission.Correct answer
- Apply for permission to issue an additional claim once its defence is filed.
- Ask the customer to add the manufacturer as a second defendant.
- Serve a contribution notice on the manufacturer with its defence.
- Bring separate proceedings against the manufacturer after the trial.
Under CPR r 20.7(3)(a), a defendant may make an additional claim against a person who is not already a party without the court's permission if the additional claim is issued before or at the same time as it files its defence. Otherwise permission is required. Fenwick can therefore issue a claim against the manufacturer now, so that all issues are decided in the same proceedings. A contribution notice under r 20.6 is used against an existing co-defendant, not a non-party, and asking the customer to sue the manufacturer is unnecessary.
Law basis: CPR rr 20.2 and 20.7