A defendant proposes mediation, and the claimant refuses without giving reasons. Which statement best describes whether the court can encourage or order ADR?
- The court can never order ADR, because the parties have an absolute right to refuse mediation.
- The court can order the parties to engage in ADR, or stay the case for that purpose, because it is part of its case management powers, although it cannot force a settlement.Correct answer
- The court can order ADR only after judgment has been given.
- The court can order ADR only if both parties agree to it in writing.
- The court can order the parties to settle on terms it chooses.
The Court of Appeal held that courts can order parties to engage in non-court-based dispute resolution, and the Civil Procedure Rules now expressly list ADR among the court's case management powers. The parties are not compelled to settle.
Law basis: Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil CBC [2023] EWCA Civ 1416; Civil Procedure Rules r 3.1(2)(o)