Gemma is preparing particulars of claim for loss of profits caused by a supplier's late delivery. She tells her solicitor she wants to claim £50,000 although she knows her real loss was about £20,000, because 'the other side will negotiate down anyway'. She is about to sign the statement of truth. Which of the following best describes the risk she faces?
- None, because only witness statements carry a statement of truth.
- A costs penalty, but only if she loses the claim at trial.
- Her claim will automatically be reduced to £20,000 by the court.
- Contempt proceedings for a false statement made without honest belief.Correct answer
- Only a professional conduct risk for her solicitor, and none for Gemma herself.
Statements of case must be verified by a statement of truth under CPR Part 22. Under CPR r 32.14, proceedings for contempt of court may be brought against a person who makes, or causes to be made, a false statement in a document verified by a statement of truth without an honest belief in its truth. Gemma knows the figure is inflated, so signing would expose her to contempt proceedings. Her solicitor must also not mislead the court, but the personal risk to Gemma remains. Particulars of claim, not only witness statements, are verified by a statement of truth.
Law basis: CPR Part 22; CPR r 32.14