Kirsty's car broke down on the motorway on the morning of her trial and she arrived three hours late, by which time the judge had heard the defendant's evidence and given judgment against her. She applies the next day to set the judgment aside, and her claim appears to have a reasonable prospect of success. Which of the following best describes the test the court will apply?
- Whether there is some other good reason why the judgment should be set aside in all the circumstances.
- Whether she acted promptly, had good reason for not attending, and has a reasonable prospect.Correct answer
- Whether she has a real prospect of success, which alone is sufficient.
- Whether the defendant would suffer any prejudice from a fresh trial.
- Whether she can show the judge made an error of law in her absence.
Under CPR r 39.3(5), where a party did not attend the trial and judgment was given in their absence, the court may grant an application to set it aside only if the applicant acted promptly when she found out that the court had exercised its power, had a good reason for not attending the trial, and has a reasonable prospect of success at trial. All three conditions must be satisfied. Kirsty applied the next day, had a genuine breakdown and has a reasonable prospect, so she should succeed. The 'some other good reason' test belongs to default judgments.
Law basis: CPR r 39.3(3)-(5)