Ben watches live from the stand as a crowd crush develops in the section where his two brothers are standing. Both are killed. Ben develops post-traumatic stress disorder. At trial he produces no evidence of his relationship with his brothers beyond the fact that they were siblings. Which of the following best describes his claim?
- It is likely to succeed, as he was present at the scene and saw the event with his own senses.
- It is likely to fail, as a close tie is not presumed between brothers and must be proved.Correct answer
- It is likely to succeed, as a close tie of love and affection is presumed between all siblings.
- It is likely to fail, as only spouses and parents can ever claim as secondary victims.
- It is likely to succeed, as anyone who witnesses a death at close quarters is a primary victim.
A secondary victim must satisfy the Alcock control mechanisms, including a close tie of love and affection with the primary victim. That tie is presumed between parents and children and between spouses or engaged couples, but for other relationships, including siblings, it must be proved by evidence. In Alcock a claimant who was at the ground and lost two brothers failed because he did not prove such a tie. Siblings are not excluded as a class, so it is wrong to say only spouses and parents can claim. Ben was not in danger, so he is not a primary victim.
Law basis: Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] 1 AC 310