Law covered in these questions
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(2), (3)(b)
- Roles v Nathan [1963] 1 WLR 1117
- Wheat v E Lacon & Co Ltd [1966] AC 552
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 1(2)
- Harris v Birkenhead Corp [1976] 1 WLR 279
- Phipps v Rochester Corp [1955] 1 QB 450
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(3)(a)
- Glasgow Corp v Taylor [1922] 1 AC 44
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(3)(b)
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(4)(a)
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(4)(b)
- Haseldine v CA Daw & Son Ltd [1941] 2 KB 343
- Woodward v Mayor of Hastings [1945] KB 174
- Ferguson v Welsh [1987] 1 WLR 1553
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A hotel hires an electrician, Eli, to repair a fault in its wiring. While working, he is shocked by a live wire in the ceiling, a risk ordinarily associated with his work. He sues the hotel under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957. Which statement best describes the position?
- The hotel is not liable, because occupiers owe no duty to visitors who are contractors.
- The hotel is liable, because it has no defence to a claim by a lawful visitor.
- The hotel is unlikely to be liable, because an occupier may expect a person in the exercise of his calling to guard against the special risks ordinarily incident to it.Correct answer
- The hotel is liable, because it owes every visitor the same duty whatever their trade.
- The hotel is not liable, because an electrician is a trespasser when working on site.
Question 2 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A brewery owns a pub. Its manager lives with his wife in the private part of the building under a licence, and they are allowed to take paying guests there. A guest falls down an unlit back staircase in the private part and dies. The brewery argues that only the manager was the occupier of the private part. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Only the manager is the occupier, as he lived in and controlled the private part.
- Only the brewery is the occupier, as it is the legal owner of the whole building.
- Neither is an occupier, as the guest was in the private part of the premises.
- Both may be occupiers, as the brewery retained a sufficient degree of control.Correct answer
- Only the manager's wife is the occupier, as she took in the paying guests.
In Wheat v E Lacon & Co Ltd the House of Lords held that there may be more than one occupier of premises. An occupier is anyone with a sufficient degree of control over premises to put them under a duty of care to visitors. The brewery had retained sufficient control over the private part, as well as the manager having control, so both owed the common duty of care under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957. Legal ownership is neither necessary nor sufficient; the test is control. On the facts, neither was in breach. The private part was still premises.
Law basis: Wheat v E Lacon & Co Ltd [1966] AC 552; Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 1(2)Question 3 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A council compulsorily acquires a house and gives the tenant notice to leave. The tenant moves out, but the council does not take physical possession or board the house up. Children enter, and a four-year-old falls from an upstairs window. The council argues that it was not the occupier because it had never entered the house. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The council was not the occupier, as it had not taken physical possession.
- The former tenant remained the occupier until the council moved in.
- The council was the occupier, as it had the right to control it.Correct answer
- Nobody was the occupier, as the house was empty when the child fell.
- The council was the occupier only if it had changed the locks to the house.
In Harris v Birkenhead Corp the Court of Appeal held that a council which had compulsorily acquired a house, and served notice on the tenant who then left, was the occupier, although it had not taken physical possession. Occupation depends on control, and the council had the immediate legal right to control the premises, so it owed a duty to visitors and, on the law then applicable, to the child who entered. Physical possession or changing locks is not required. Premises are not left without an occupier merely because they are empty.
Law basis: Harris v Birkenhead Corp [1976] 1 WLR 279Question 4 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A council is developing open land on which children regularly play with its permission. A five-year-old boy, accompanied only by his seven-year-old sister, falls into a deep trench dug for a sewer and breaks his leg. The trench would have been obvious to an adult. Which of the following best describes the council's liability?
- It is liable, as an occupier must protect young children from all dangers on its land.
- It is probably not liable, as it may rely on parents' supervision.Correct answer
- It is liable, as the trench was an allurement that attracted children to the land.
- It is not liable, as the boy was a trespasser to whom no duty was owed.
- It is liable, as a seven-year-old sister is not a responsible person in law.
In Phipps v Rochester Corp the court held that an occupier was entitled to assume that prudent parents would not allow very young children to go to such places unaccompanied by a responsible person. Responsibility for the safety of small children rests primarily with their parents, and the occupier is not liable if it has done what a reasonable occupier would do on that assumption. Section 2(3)(a) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 requires an occupier to be prepared for children to be less careful than adults, but that does not make it liable for all risks. The boy was a licensee, not a trespasser.
Law basis: Phipps v Rochester Corp [1955] 1 QB 450; Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(3)(a)Question 5 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A council's public park contains a shrub bearing attractive, poisonous berries that look like cherries or grapes. The council knows the berries are poisonous but puts up no fence or warning. A seven-year-old boy visiting the park eats some and dies. Which of the following best describes the council's liability?
- It is not liable, as a seven-year-old should know not to eat unknown berries.
- It is not liable, as the shrub was a natural feature rather than a man-made danger.
- It is liable only if the boy's parents had first complained about the shrub.
- It is not liable, as eating the berries made the boy a trespasser at that time.
- It is liable, as the berries were an allurement to children.Correct answer
In Glasgow Corp v Taylor the House of Lords held that the occupier of a public park was liable for the death of a child who ate poisonous berries from a shrub that looked tempting to children. The berries were an allurement, and an occupier must take account of the fact that children are attracted to things adults would ignore. This principle is reflected in section 2(3)(a) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957: an occupier must be prepared for children to be less careful than adults. Natural features can found liability, and no prior complaint is required.
Law basis: Glasgow Corp v Taylor [1922] 1 AC 44; Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(3)(a)Question 6 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
Megan engages Rhys, a qualified plumber, to replace a radiator. While walking across the landing to reach it, Rhys falls through a rotten floorboard that Megan knew was weak, and is injured. Megan argues that a skilled tradesman is expected to guard against risks on site. Which of the following best describes her liability?
- She is not liable, as a specialist can be expected to guard against all site risks.
- She is liable, as the risk was not one incident to the work of a plumber.Correct answer
- She is not liable, as Rhys was a contractor rather than a visitor to her house.
- She is liable only if Rhys had asked her in advance about the state of the floor.
- She is not liable, as she was entitled to rely on Rhys's skill and experience.
Under section 2(3)(b) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, an occupier may expect that a person in the exercise of his calling will appreciate and guard against any special risks ordinarily incident to it, so far as the occupier leaves him free to do so. A rotten floorboard on a landing is not a risk ordinarily incident to plumbing; it is a general risk of the premises. Megan therefore owes Rhys the ordinary common duty of care and is liable for failing to warn of a danger she knew about. Contractors are visitors, and Rhys did not need to ask.
Law basis: Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(3)(b); Roles v Nathan [1963] 1 WLR 1117Question 7 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
The only path from a riverside café to its toilets crosses a narrow footbridge which is dangerously slippery. The café puts up a sign at the bridge saying 'Warning: bridge slippery'. Hassan, a customer, crosses carefully but slips and is injured. Which of the following best describes the effect of the warning?
- It discharges the duty, as Hassan was warned of the danger before he crossed.
- It excludes all liability, as the sign was clearly displayed at the bridge.
- It is not enough unless it enabled Hassan to be reasonably safe.Correct answer
- It discharges the duty, as the café is not responsible for natural hazards.
- It is irrelevant, as warnings have no effect on the common duty of care.
Under section 2(4)(a) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, a warning of danger does not absolve the occupier unless in all the circumstances it was enough to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe. Where there is no alternative route, as Lord Denning illustrated in Roles v Nathan, a warning that a bridge is dangerous may not be enough; the occupier may need to make the bridge safe or provide another route. A warning is relevant, but it is not automatically sufficient, and it is distinct from a notice excluding liability. The danger here arises from the premises, not a natural hazard.
Law basis: Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(4)(a); Roles v Nathan [1963] 1 WLR 1117Question 8 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A block of flats' managing agent engages a reputable, competent firm of lift engineers to service the lift. The engineers negligently fail to replace a worn part, and the lift falls, injuring Gita, a visitor. The agent had no means of discovering the fault. Which of the following best describes the agent's liability as occupier?
- It is liable, as an occupier is responsible for all contractors' work on its premises.
- It is liable, as it should have personally checked every part of the lift's mechanism.
- It is not liable, as it reasonably used competent contractors.Correct answer
- It is not liable, as lifts are excluded from the scope of the 1957 Act.
- It is liable, but it can recover a contribution from the lift engineers.
Section 2(4)(b) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 provides that an occupier is not liable for damage caused by the faulty work of an independent contractor if it acted reasonably in entrusting the work to the contractor, took reasonable steps to satisfy itself that the contractor was competent, and, where appropriate, that the work had been properly done. In Haseldine v Daw the occupier was not liable for a lift accident caused by competent engineers' negligence, as it could not be expected to check technical work. Gita should sue the engineers. Lifts are within the Act.
Law basis: Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(4)(b); Haseldine v CA Daw & Son Ltd [1941] 2 KB 343Question 9 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A school engages a cleaning contractor. One winter morning the cleaner sweeps snow from the school steps but leaves them covered in a thin film of ice. Tobias, a visiting parent, slips and is injured. The school argues it is protected because it engaged a contractor. Which of the following best describes the school's liability?
- It is not liable, as it acted reasonably in engaging a contractor to clean.
- It is not liable, as an occupier cannot be liable for snow and ice on its premises.
- It is liable only if the cleaning contractor proves to be insolvent.
- It is not liable, as Tobias should have noticed the ice and walked carefully.
- It is liable, as checking this simple work required no technical knowledge.Correct answer
Under section 2(4)(b) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 an occupier is protected from liability for a contractor's faulty work only if it took reasonable steps to check that the work was properly done, where appropriate. In Woodward v Mayor of Hastings the occupier was liable where a cleaner left a step icy, because the danger of an icy step was obvious and checking the work called for no technical knowledge. This contrasts with technical work, such as lift maintenance in Haseldine v Daw. Tobias's own care may be relevant to contributory negligence, not to whether the school is liable.
Law basis: Woodward v Mayor of Hastings [1945] KB 174; Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(4)(b)Question 10 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
A council engages a contractor to demolish a building. Without the council's permission, the contractor subcontracts the work to a firm that uses an unsafe method. Tom, an employee of the subcontractor, is injured when a wall collapses on him. Tom sues the council as occupier. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It is not liable, as it need not police a contractor's methods.Correct answer
- It is liable, as an occupier owes all contractors' workers a duty to supervise them.
- It is liable, as the subcontracting was in breach of its contract with the main contractor.
- It is not liable, as the subcontractor's workers were trespassers on its land.
- It is liable, as demolition is an ultra-hazardous activity carrying strict liability.
In Ferguson v Welsh the House of Lords held that an occupier who engages an independent contractor is not ordinarily liable under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 for injuries to the contractor's employees caused by the contractor's unsafe system of work. The common duty of care relates to the safety of the premises, and the occupier is not generally required to supervise the contractor's working methods, though it may be liable if it knows or has reason to suspect an unsafe system is being used. Unauthorised subcontracting did not make the worker a trespasser on the facts. There is no strict liability for demolition.
Law basis: Ferguson v Welsh [1987] 1 WLR 1553Question 11 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
The National Trust owns a country estate with an ornamental pond. Visitors sometimes swim in it, though staff discourage this. Kamal, a visitor and a competent swimmer, goes swimming in the middle of the pond and drowns. His widow argues that the Trust should have put up signs warning of the danger of drowning. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It succeeds, as the Trust knew that visitors sometimes swam in the pond.
- It succeeds, as an occupier must warn of every danger on its premises.
- It fails, as Kamal was a trespasser once he entered the water to swim.
- It succeeds, as the pond's depth was a hidden danger to any swimmer.
- It fails, as there is no duty to warn of an obvious risk.Correct answer
In Darby v National Trust the Court of Appeal held that the occupier was not liable for the drowning of a visitor swimming in a pond. The risk of drowning in open water is obvious to any adult, and there is no duty to warn of obvious risks. A warning sign would have told Kamal nothing he did not already know. The case is consistent with Tomlinson v Congleton BC. Whether he became a trespasser by swimming was not the basis of the decision, and there was nothing hidden about the danger. Knowledge that visitors swam did not create a duty to warn.
Law basis: Darby v National Trust [2001] EWCA Civ 189Question 12 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
Carlos, a self-employed courier, enters a distribution warehouse to deliver a parcel. A sign at the entrance says: 'The company accepts no liability for any injury howsoever caused, including by negligence.' He is injured when a stack of pallets, negligently left unsecured, falls on him. Which of the following best describes the effect of the sign?
- It is effective, as the 1957 Act allows an occupier to exclude its duty by notice.
- It is ineffective, as liability for negligent injury cannot be excluded.Correct answer
- It is effective only if it satisfies the reasonableness test under the 1977 Act.
- It is effective, as Carlos entered the warehouse after seeing the sign.
- It is ineffective only because Carlos was a consumer for the purposes of the 2015 Act.
Section 2(1) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 allows an occupier to restrict or exclude its duty by agreement or otherwise, so far as it is free to do so. However, section 2(1) of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 provides that a person cannot, by contract term or notice, exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence, where the liability is business liability. This is not subject to a reasonableness test. Carlos was acting in the course of his business, so UCTA, rather than the Consumer Rights Act 2015, applies. Entering after seeing the sign does not change this.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 ss 1(3), 2(1); Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 2(1) ↗Question 13 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
Freya invites Bryn to a party at her house and tells guests to stay downstairs. Bryn climbs a ladder into the loft, which has a sign on the hatch reading 'Private - keep out', to look for a quiet place to make a phone call. He falls through the unboarded loft floor and is injured. Which of the following best describes Bryn's status when injured?
- He was a visitor, as he had been lawfully invited into the house by Freya.
- He was a visitor, as a guest's licence extends to every part of the house.
- He was a visitor, as he entered the loft for an innocent purpose.
- He was a trespasser only if he had been told about the loft personally.
- He was a trespasser, as he went beyond the limits of his invitation.Correct answer
A visitor who goes to a part of the premises where he is not permitted, or uses the premises for a purpose beyond his permission, becomes a trespasser in relation to that part. As Scrutton LJ put it in The Calgarth, when you invite a person into your house to use the staircase, you do not invite him to slide down the banisters. Bryn had been told to stay downstairs and the hatch was marked private, so in the loft he was a non-visitor, and any duty would arise under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1984, not the 1957 Act. His innocent purpose does not change his status.
Law basis: The Calgarth [1927] P 93; Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 s 1(2)Question 14 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
For 35 years, local people have used a path across Owen's field as a short cut to the railway station. Owen has occasionally grumbled but has never put up signs, fenced the path or taken other steps to stop them. He then lets a dangerous horse loose in the field, and it attacks Leah as she crosses. Which of the following best describes Leah's status?
- She was a trespasser, as Owen never expressly permitted use of the path.
- She was a trespasser, as Owen had objected to the use on several occasions.
- She was a visitor only if the path had become a public right of way.
- She was a visitor, as Owen's tolerance gave rise to an implied licence.Correct answer
- She was a trespasser, as mere knowledge of trespassers is never permission.
In Lowery v Walker the House of Lords held that members of the public who had used a short cut across a field for many years, without any real attempt by the owner to stop them, had an implied licence and were lawful visitors. Mere knowledge that people are crossing is not always enough, but long-standing tolerance without effective steps to exclude them can amount to implied permission. Occasional grumbling did not withdraw it. Leah does not need to show that a public right of way had come into being; indeed, users of a public right of way are not visitors.
Law basis: Lowery v Walker [1911] AC 10Question 15 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ruby is walking along a public footpath which crosses a housing estate owned by a housing authority. The path has worn into a hole, and she trips and breaks her ankle. She sues the authority under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 as a visitor. Which of the following best describes her claim?
- It succeeds, as she was lawfully on the authority's land when injured.
- It succeeds, as the authority as landowner owes all lawful entrants the common duty of care.
- It fails, as a person using a public right of way is not a visitor.Correct answer
- It fails, as she was a trespasser because the path was not part of the estate.
- It succeeds, but only if the authority had been told about the hole beforehand.
In McGeown v Northern Ireland Housing Executive the House of Lords held that a person using a public right of way across land is not a visitor of the landowner and is not owed the common duty of care under the occupiers' liability legislation. Such a person uses the path as of right, not by the occupier's permission, and the owner cannot prevent use. Lawful presence is therefore not the same as visitor status. Ruby was not a trespasser either; she simply falls outside the 1957 Act. Prior notice of the defect is irrelevant to her status.
Law basis: McGeown v Northern Ireland Housing Executive [1995] 1 AC 233More Tort Law topics
Back to all Tort Law questions, or sit a timed mock.