Hugo, walking his dog in a park, sees a toddler fall into a shallow pond. He could easily wade in and pull her out but does nothing, and she suffers brain injury before others arrive. Hugo has no connection with the child or the park. Which of the following best describes Hugo's liability in negligence?
- Hugo is not liable, because the law imposes no general duty to rescue a stranger from danger.Correct answer
- Hugo is liable, because the risk to the toddler was obvious and he could easily have prevented it.
- Hugo is liable, because anyone present at the scene of an emergency assumes responsibility for victims.
- Hugo is not liable, because a toddler's injury in water is caused by the parents' failure of supervision.
- Hugo is liable, but his damages will be reduced to reflect the fact that he did not create the danger.
English law draws a firm distinction between acts and omissions. There is no general duty to prevent harm to others or to rescue a stranger, however easy the rescue and however obvious the danger. A duty to act arises only in recognised exceptions, such as an assumption of responsibility, control over the third party or the claimant, creation of the danger, or occupation of land where the hazard arises. Mere presence at the scene does not amount to an assumption of responsibility. Hugo's failure to act may be morally wrong, but it is not actionable.
Law basis: Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd [1987] AC 241; Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police [2018] UKSC 4