Jodie, aged 20, suffers a severe brain injury in a road accident caused by Kev's negligence. Her mother gives up her job to care for Jodie full-time without payment. Jodie claims damages including the value of her mother's care. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Nothing can be recovered for care, as the mother provided it without charge.
- The mother must bring her own separate claim against Kev for her lost earnings.
- Jodie can recover the care costs only if she agrees in writing to pay her mother.
- Jodie can recover only what a professional carer would charge, paid to the state.
- Jodie can recover the value of the care, held on trust for her mother.Correct answer
A claimant may recover damages for the reasonable value of gratuitous care provided by a relative. In Hunt v Severs the House of Lords held that such damages are held by the claimant on trust for the carer, as their purpose is to compensate the carer. The value may be assessed by reference to the carer's lost earnings or the commercial cost of care, usually discounted. The carer does not have her own claim against the tortfeasor, and no contract between claimant and carer is needed. Where the tortfeasor is himself the carer, Hunt v Severs held that the claim fails.
Law basis: Hunt v Severs [1994] 2 AC 350; Donnelly v Joyce [1974] QB 454