Law covered in these questions
- Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27
- Murphy v Brentwood DC [1991] 1 AC 398
- Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 ss 2(2), 11
- Caparo Industries plc v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605
- Smith v Eric S Bush [1990] 1 AC 831
- Chaudhry v Prabhakar [1989] 1 WLR 29
- White v Jones [1995] 2 AC 207
- Spring v Guardian Assurance plc [1995] 2 AC 296
- Customs and Excise Commissioners v Barclays Bank plc [2006] UKHL 28
- Williams v Natural Life Health Foods Ltd [1998] 1 WLR 830
- NRAM Ltd v Steel [2018] UKSC 13
- Henderson v Merrett Syndicates Ltd [1995] 2 AC 145
- Limitation Act 1980 s 14A
All 14 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Contractors digging a road negligently cut a power cable supplying Steelco's factory. The power is off for 14 hours. A melt in progress is damaged, losing Steelco the profit on it, and Steelco also loses profit on four further melts it could have processed during the shutdown. Which of the following best describes what Steelco can recover?
- All the losses, as they were all foreseeable consequences of cutting the power cable.
- Only the physical damage to the melt, as any loss of profit is pure economic loss.
- Nothing, as the cable belonged to the electricity board and not to Steelco.
- The damage to the melt and its lost profit, but not profit on later melts.Correct answer
- The lost profit on all five melts, but not the cost of the physical damage to the first.
In Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co the Court of Appeal held that the claimant could recover for physical damage to the melt in progress and the profit lost on that melt, as consequential economic loss flowing from physical damage to its property. However, the profit that would have been made on further melts during the power cut was pure economic loss, not consequent on any damage to the claimant's property, and was irrecoverable. Foreseeability is not enough for pure economic loss. Steelco's lack of ownership of the cable explains why the further losses were pure economic loss.
Law basis: Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27Question 2 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Grace buys a house built ten years earlier. Serious cracks appear because the foundations were negligently designed. Nobody has been injured and no other property has been damaged, but Grace has to spend £60,000 on repairs. She sues the original builder, with whom she has no contract, in negligence. Which of the following best describes her claim?
- It succeeds, as the cracks are physical damage to her property caused by the builder's negligence.
- It succeeds, as a builder owes every later owner a duty to build with reasonable care.
- It fails, as a later owner can never sue a builder for any loss arising from the building.
- It succeeds, but only for the part of the repair cost needed to prevent personal injury.
- It fails, as the cost of repairing a defective building is pure economic loss.Correct answer
In Murphy v Brentwood DC the House of Lords held that where a defect in a building is discovered before it causes injury or damage to other property, the cost of repair is pure economic loss and is not recoverable in negligence. The building is regarded as a defective product, and damage to the thing itself is not damage to other property. The builder would be liable in negligence if the defect caused personal injury or damage to other property. Grace may have a claim under the Defective Premises Act 1972, but there is no apportionment by reference to preventing injury.
Law basis: Murphy v Brentwood DC [1991] 1 AC 398Question 3 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Fiona, a director of a trading company, asks Kestrel Accounts Ltd for advice on a supplier's creditworthiness. Kestrel's letter states that it accepts no liability for the advice. The advice is careless, and Fiona's company loses £80,000 relying on it. Which of the following best describes the effect of the disclaimer?
- It is automatically effective, as a disclaimer prevents any assumption of responsibility arising.
- It is automatically void, as a business cannot exclude liability for negligent advice in any case.
- It is effective only if Fiona's company signed a copy of it before the advice was given.
- It is void under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, as the advice concerned a commercial matter.
- It is effective only if it is reasonable under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.Correct answer
In Hedley Byrne v Heller the House of Lords recognised a duty for negligent misstatements causing pure economic loss where there is an assumption of responsibility and reasonable reliance, but the bank's disclaimer prevented liability. Today, under section 2(2) of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, a business notice excluding liability for negligence causing loss other than death or personal injury is effective only so far as it satisfies the reasonableness requirement in section 11. A signature is not required. The Consumer Rights Act 2015 applies only to consumer contracts and notices, not to dealings with a trading company.
Law basis: Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465; Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 ss 2(2), 11 ↗Question 4 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Auditors carelessly certify a company's accounts as showing a healthy profit. Relying on the accounts, Ingrid, an existing shareholder, buys a large block of further shares and then mounts a successful takeover. The accounts were wrong and she loses heavily. She sues the auditors. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It succeeds, as it was foreseeable that shareholders would rely on audited accounts.
- It fails, as the audit was not done to help investors decide whether to buy shares.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as auditors owe a duty to all existing shareholders for any use of the accounts.
- It fails, as auditors owe no duty to anyone other than the company's directors.
- It succeeds, but only for the value of the shares she held before the takeover.
In Caparo Industries plc v Dickman the House of Lords held that auditors owed no duty to an existing shareholder or to potential investors who relied on the audited accounts in buying shares. The purpose of the statutory audit is to enable shareholders as a body to exercise their governance rights, not to guide individual investment decisions. Foreseeability of reliance is not enough; there must be proximity, which requires knowledge that the statement will be communicated to the claimant for a particular purpose and relied on for that purpose. The auditors' duty is owed to the company itself.
Law basis: Caparo Industries plc v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605Question 5 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Ruth applies for a mortgage on a modest terraced house. The lender instructs a valuer, whose report Ruth pays for and receives, and which contains a disclaimer. The valuer carelessly misses serious structural defects. Ruth buys without her own survey. Which of the following best describes her claim against the valuer?
- No duty is owed, as the valuer was instructed by and contracted with the lender only.
- A duty is owed, but the disclaimer is effective because she could have had her own survey.
- A duty is owed to her, and the disclaimer is likely to fail the reasonableness test.Correct answer
- No duty is owed, as a valuation report is an opinion rather than a statement of fact.
- A duty is owed only if she told the valuer directly that she would rely on his report.
In Smith v Eric S Bush the House of Lords held that a mortgage valuer owed a duty to the purchaser of a modest house, because he knew that the purchaser would very probably rely on the valuation without an independent survey. The disclaimer was a notice subject to the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 and failed the reasonableness test, given the modest value of the property, the parties' unequal bargaining power and the ease of the valuer insuring. The absence of a contract with Ruth does not prevent a duty. She did not need to speak to the valuer directly.
Law basis: Smith v Eric S Bush [1990] 1 AC 831; Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 ss 2(2), 11 ↗Question 6 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Asif, who is not a professional mechanic but tells his friend Leila he knows a lot about cars, offers to find her a used car. He recommends one, assuring her it has never been in an accident. It has been badly damaged and repaired, and is worth far less than she paid. He received no payment. Which of the following best describes Asif's liability?
- He owes no duty, as advice given between friends without payment cannot create liability.
- He may owe a duty, having held himself out as having skill which she relied on.Correct answer
- He owes no duty, as only a professional acting in the course of business can be liable.
- He is strictly liable, as he gave a statement of fact rather than an opinion.
- He owes a duty only if he and Leila signed an agreement about the search for a car.
In Chaudhry v Prabhakar the Court of Appeal held that a friend who acted as an unpaid agent in finding a car, holding himself out as having relevant knowledge, owed a duty of care when he assured the claimant that it had not been in an accident. The key questions under Hedley Byrne are whether the defendant assumed responsibility and whether reliance was reasonable, not whether he was paid. Social or informal contexts will often negate a duty, but not where the defendant undertakes a task and knows the claimant will rely on his skill. Liability is in negligence, not strict.
Law basis: Chaudhry v Prabhakar [1989] 1 WLR 29; Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465Question 7 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Arthur instructs his solicitor to prepare a new will leaving his estate to his two nieces. The solicitor carelessly delays for several weeks, and Arthur dies before the will is signed. Under his earlier will the nieces receive nothing. They sue the solicitor in negligence. Which of the following best describes their claim?
- It succeeds, as a solicitor can owe a duty to intended beneficiaries of a will.Correct answer
- It fails, as the solicitor's duty was owed only to Arthur, his client.
- It fails, as the nieces' loss of an expected inheritance is too speculative to be recovered.
- It succeeds, but only if Arthur's estate also brings a claim against the solicitor.
- It fails, as the nieces did not rely on anything the solicitor said or did.
In White v Jones the House of Lords held that a solicitor who negligently failed to prepare a will before the testator died owed a duty to the intended beneficiaries. Otherwise there would be a gap in the law: the estate suffered no loss, and those who did suffer loss would have no remedy. Lord Goff extended the Hedley Byrne assumption of responsibility to the beneficiaries even though they had not relied on the solicitor. The loss is measured by what they would have received. The estate does not need to sue, and the absence of reliance is not fatal.
Law basis: White v Jones [1995] 2 AC 207Question 8 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Zara applies for a job with an insurance firm. Her former employer writes a reference carelessly stating, without checking, that she has a history of dishonesty. The allegation is untrue. The new firm rejects her, and she loses the job. A defamation claim would fail because of qualified privilege. Which of the following best describes any claim in negligence?
- No negligence claim lies, as defamation is the only tort that protects against untrue statements.
- No duty is owed, as the reference was addressed to the new firm and not to Zara herself.
- A duty is owed only if the reference was written with malice, as in defamation.
- Her former employer owed her a duty to take reasonable care in preparing the reference.Correct answer
- A duty is owed only to the new firm, which relied on the reference in making its decision.
In Spring v Guardian Assurance plc the House of Lords held that an employer who provides a reference about a former employee owes that employee a duty to take reasonable care in its preparation. The employer assumes responsibility to the employee, who relies on it to exercise care. The existence of a defence of qualified privilege in defamation, which requires malice to defeat it, does not prevent a claim in negligence. The duty is owed to the subject of the reference, not merely to the recipient, and the claimant need not prove malice, only carelessness.
Law basis: Spring v Guardian Assurance plc [1995] 2 AC 296Question 9 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
HMRC obtains a freezing order against two companies and serves notice of it on their bank. Through carelessness, the bank allows the companies to transfer large sums out of their accounts within hours. HMRC cannot recover the money owed to it and sues the bank in negligence. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- A duty is owed, as the bank had actual notice of the order and the loss was foreseeable.
- A duty is owed, as a court order creates a relationship of proximity with the applicant.
- No duty is owed, as banks are immune from claims arising from their customers' transactions.
- No duty is owed, as the bank did not voluntarily assume responsibility to HMRC.Correct answer
- A duty is owed, but HMRC's remedy is limited to contempt of court proceedings only.
In Customs and Excise Commissioners v Barclays Bank plc the House of Lords held that a bank notified of a freezing order owed no duty of care to the party that had obtained it. The bank's obligations arose by operation of law from the order, not from any voluntary assumption of responsibility, and the remedy for breach of the order is contempt of court. Foreseeability of loss and actual notice were not enough. The case confirms that assumption of responsibility, incremental reasoning and the Caparo factors are all relevant tools for pure economic loss.
Law basis: Customs and Excise Commissioners v Barclays Bank plc [2006] UKHL 28Question 10 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Hale Health Foods Ltd sells franchises. Its managing director, Ian, provides financial projections for prospective franchisees, based on his own experience, in the company's brochure. The projections are careless, and Kim's franchise fails. The company is insolvent, so Kim sues Ian personally. Ian never dealt with Kim directly. Which of the following best describes Ian's personal liability?
- He is liable, as the projections were based on his personal expertise and experience.
- He is not liable unless he personally assumed responsibility to Kim.Correct answer
- He is liable, as a director is jointly liable with the company for all its torts.
- He is not liable, as directors can never be liable in tort for acts done for their company.
- He is liable, as Kim relied on the projections and the company is unable to pay.
In Williams v Natural Life Health Foods Ltd the House of Lords held that a director was not personally liable for negligent projections given by his company. A director is liable only if he personally assumed responsibility to the claimant, and the claimant reasonably relied on that personal assumption rather than on the company's. Merely relying on the director's expertise as reflected in the company's materials is not enough. Directors are not automatically jointly liable for their company's torts, though they can be liable if the requirements are met, and the company's insolvency does not change the test.
Law basis: Williams v Natural Life Health Foods Ltd [1998] 1 WLR 830Question 11 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Steve, a solicitor acting for a borrower, emails the lender, which is not separately represented, wrongly stating that the lender has agreed to release its charge over part of the land on sale. The lender's employee reads the email and releases the whole charge without checking her own file. The lender sues Steve. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It succeeds, as Steve made a careless statement that he knew would be acted upon.
- It fails, as it was not reasonable for the lender to rely on its opponent's solicitor.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as a solicitor owes a duty to every party to a transaction he is involved in.
- It fails, as a solicitor can never owe a duty of care to anyone other than his own client.
- It succeeds, but the lender's damages will be reduced for its employee's carelessness.
In NRAM Ltd v Steel the Supreme Court held that a solicitor acting for one party did not owe a duty to the other party, even though it was unrepresented. In an arm's-length transaction, a party is generally not entitled to rely on representations by the other side's solicitor about matters it could check itself, unless the solicitor has assumed responsibility to it. It was not reasonable for the lender to rely on the email without checking its own records. Solicitors can sometimes owe duties to non-clients, so the absolute statement is wrong.
Law basis: NRAM Ltd v Steel [2018] UKSC 13Question 12 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Lloyd's Names who invested through managing agents suffered losses because the agents carelessly underwrote risks. The Names' claims in contract are time-barred because the breaches occurred more than six years ago, but they discovered the loss only recently. They wish to sue the agents in tort. Which of the following best describes their position?
- They may sue in tort, as a duty in negligence can co-exist with a contract.Correct answer
- They cannot sue in tort, as a contractual relationship excludes any concurrent duty in tort.
- They can sue in tort only for physical damage, as pure economic loss is excluded in contract cases.
- They cannot sue in tort, as the contract limitation period applies equally to any claim in tort.
- They may sue in tort only if the contract expressly preserves the right to do so.
In Henderson v Merrett Syndicates Ltd the House of Lords held that a defendant who assumes responsibility to provide professional services may owe a duty in tort concurrently with a contractual duty, and the claimant may choose the more advantageous claim unless the contract excludes or limits the tortious duty. This matters for limitation: in negligence, the cause of action accrues when damage is suffered, and section 14A of the Limitation Act 1980 may give extra time from the date of knowledge for latent damage. Pure economic loss is recoverable within Hedley Byrne principles.
Law basis: Henderson v Merrett Syndicates Ltd [1995] 2 AC 145; Limitation Act 1980 s 14A ↗Question 13 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
A valuer carelessly values a commercial property at £5 million for a lender when its true value is £4 million. The lender advances £3.5 million. The borrower defaults and, after a fall in the property market, the lender recovers only £1.5 million on sale. It sues the valuer. Which of the following best describes the maximum it can recover?
- £2 million, being the whole of the shortfall on the loan after the sale.
- £3.5 million, being the whole of the sum advanced in reliance on the valuation.
- £1 million, being the amount by which the valuation was too high.Correct answer
- Nothing, as the loss was caused by the market fall rather than the valuation.
- £2 million, less a reduction for the lender's own decision to lend on that property.
In South Australia Asset Management Corp v York Montague Ltd (SAAMCO) the House of Lords held that a valuer who provides information to a lender is liable only for the consequences of the information being wrong, not for all the consequences of the lending decision. The recoverable loss is capped at the difference between the negligent valuation and the true value at the time, here £1 million, even though the market fall increased the actual shortfall to £2 million. The scope of duty principle was restated in Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton UK LLP. The loss is not wholly irrecoverable.
Law basis: South Australia Asset Management Corp v York Montague Ltd [1997] AC 191; Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton UK LLP [2021] UKSC 20Question 14 · Pure economic lossDraft, pending solicitor review
Nkem agrees to buy a cargo of steel which is being shipped to her. Under the contract, the risk passes to her on shipment but legal title will not pass until she pays on arrival. The cargo is damaged during the voyage by the shipowner's careless stowage. Nkem sues the shipowner in negligence. Which of the following best describes her claim?
- It fails, as she had neither ownership nor possession of the goods when damaged.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as the goods were at her risk when they were damaged at sea.
- It succeeds, as the damage was physical and was a foreseeable result of careless stowage.
- It fails, as a buyer of goods can only ever sue the seller under the contract of sale.
- It succeeds, but only for the reduction in resale value rather than repair costs.
In Leigh & Sillavan Ltd v Aliakmon Shipping Co Ltd the House of Lords held that a claimant cannot recover in negligence for loss caused by damage to property unless, at the time of the damage, it had legal ownership of or a possessory title to that property. A buyer who bears the risk but has neither ownership nor possession suffers only pure economic loss, which is not recoverable on these facts. Foreseeability of the loss does not overcome this rule. Nkem's remedies, if any, lie in contract or under carriage of goods legislation.
Law basis: Leigh & Sillavan Ltd v Aliakmon Shipping Co Ltd [1986] AC 785More Tort Law topics
Back to all Tort Law questions, or sit a timed mock.