Law covered in these questions
- Rylands v Fletcher (1868) LR 3 HL 330
- Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 61
- Cambridge Water Co v Eastern Counties Leather plc [1994] 2 AC 264
- Read v J Lyons & Co Ltd [1947] AC 156
- Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd [1997] AC 655
- Stannard (t/a Wyvern Tyres) v Gore [2012] EWCA Civ 1248
- Rickards v Lothian [1913] AC 263
- Perry v Kendricks Transport Ltd [1956] 1 WLR 85
- Nichols v Marsland (1876) 2 Ex D 1
- Greenock Corp v Caledonian Railway Co [1917] AC 556
All 9 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
A householder's ordinary domestic water pipe bursts and floods a neighbour's flat. The neighbour sues under the rule in Rylands v Fletcher. Which statement best describes the position?
- The claim succeeds only if the householder knew the pipe was defective.
- The claim fails only because the householder was not negligent.
- The claim fails, because ordinary domestic water supply is not a non-natural or extraordinary and unusual use of land.Correct answer
- The claim succeeds, because the householder is strictly liable for water on his land.
- The claim succeeds, because anything that escapes from land is covered by the rule.
The rule needs a non-natural use of land, in the sense of an extraordinary and unusual use, and a foreseeable escape causing damage. Ordinary domestic uses do not qualify.
Law basis: Rylands v Fletcher (1868) LR 3 HL 330; Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 61Question 2 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
A leather tannery stores large quantities of an industrial solvent on its premises. Small spills over many years seep into the ground and, after the claimant's borehole is contaminated, the claimant sues in Rylands v Fletcher. Leaving aside foreseeability, which of the following best describes the storage of the solvent?
- It is a natural use, as the solvent is used in an ordinary local industry.
- It is a classic example of a non-natural use of land.Correct answer
- It is a natural use, as the tannery provides employment in the area.
- It is a non-natural use only if the solvent was stored in breach of regulations.
- It is a natural use, as storage on industrial premises is always ordinary.
In Cambridge Water Co v Eastern Counties Leather plc Lord Goff described the storage of substantial quantities of chemicals on industrial premises as almost a classic case of non-natural use, and said that the creation of employment did not make it a natural use. In Transco v Stockport MBC the House of Lords explained the requirement as an extraordinary and unusual use of land, judged by contemporary standards of time and place, where the thing accumulated is exceptionally dangerous or mischievous if it escapes. Compliance with regulations is not the test. The claim in Cambridge Water ultimately failed on foreseeability.
Law basis: Cambridge Water Co v Eastern Counties Leather plc [1994] 2 AC 264; Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 61Question 3 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
A government safety inspector, Hilda, is inspecting a munitions factory when a shell explodes inside the building, injuring her. Nothing escapes beyond the factory premises. She sues the operator under the rule in Rylands v Fletcher. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It succeeds, as manufacturing explosives is a non-natural use of land.
- It succeeds, as the operator is strictly liable for dangerous things.
- It fails, as there was no escape from the defendant's land.Correct answer
- It fails only because Hilda was a visitor protected by the 1957 Act.
- It succeeds, as she was lawfully on the premises when injured.
In Read v J Lyons & Co Ltd the House of Lords held that an inspector injured by an explosion inside a munitions factory could not recover under Rylands v Fletcher, because there had been no escape of a dangerous thing from a place where the defendant had occupation or control to a place outside its occupation or control. Escape is an essential element. A non-natural use alone is not enough, and there is no general principle of strict liability for ultra-hazardous activities in English law. Hilda's remedy, if any, lies in negligence or occupiers' liability.
Law basis: Read v J Lyons & Co Ltd [1947] AC 156Question 4 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
Chemicals stored on an industrial site escape in a sudden release onto the neighbouring land, owned by Petra. She suffers burns to her skin while gardening and her greenhouse is damaged. She sues the site operator under Rylands v Fletcher. Which of the following best describes what she can recover under that rule?
- The damage to her greenhouse, but not damages for her burns.Correct answer
- Damages for both her burns and her greenhouse, as both were caused by the escape.
- Damages for her burns only, as personal injury is the most serious harm.
- Nothing, as Rylands v Fletcher has been absorbed into the tort of negligence.
- Damages for both, but only if she proves the operator was negligent.
In Transco plc v Stockport MBC the House of Lords confirmed that Rylands v Fletcher is a sub-species of private nuisance, protecting interests in land, and that damages for personal injury are not recoverable under it. Petra can recover for damage to her property, her greenhouse, but must pursue her burns in negligence. The rule was not absorbed into negligence, as the High Court of Australia did in Burnie Port Authority; it survives in England as a form of strict liability for escapes, so proof of negligence is not required, though foreseeability of the type of damage is.
Law basis: Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 61; Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd [1997] AC 655Question 5 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
Over many years before 1980, small spills of a chemical solvent at a tannery seep into the ground. Nobody at the time could have foreseen that the solvent would travel to an aquifer and contaminate a water company's borehole a mile away. The water company sues the tannery under Rylands v Fletcher. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It fails, as damage of that type was not reasonably foreseeable.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as liability under Rylands is strict and needs no foreseeability.
- It succeeds, as storage of the solvent was a non-natural use of land.
- It fails, as there was no escape from the tannery's premises.
- It succeeds, as contamination of water is always within the rule.
In Cambridge Water Co v Eastern Counties Leather plc the House of Lords held that foreseeability of damage of the relevant type is a prerequisite of liability under Rylands v Fletcher, as in nuisance. Liability is strict in the sense that the defendant is liable even if it took all reasonable care to prevent the escape, but not for damage of an unforeseeable type. The storage was a non-natural use, and there was an escape, but the claim failed because contamination of the borehole could not have been foreseen at the time.
Law basis: Cambridge Water Co v Eastern Counties Leather plc [1994] 2 AC 264Question 6 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
Gore runs a tyre-fitting business and stores about 3,000 tyres in his premises. A fire, caused by faulty wiring and not by his negligence, spreads through the tyres and to his neighbour's property, destroying it. The neighbour sues under Rylands v Fletcher. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It fails, as tyres are not exceptionally dangerous and it was fire that escaped.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as the tyres made the fire spread faster to the neighbour's property.
- It succeeds, as storing large quantities of tyres is a non-natural use of land.
- It fails, as the neighbour must show that Gore was negligent in storing the tyres.
- It succeeds, as fire spreading from one property to another is always actionable.
In Stannard (t/a Wyvern Tyres) v Gore the Court of Appeal held that a tyre business was not liable under Rylands v Fletcher for a fire that spread to a neighbour's property. Tyres are not exceptionally dangerous or likely to cause mischief if they escape, and storing them at a tyre business was not an extraordinary or unusual use. What escaped was fire, not the tyres themselves, and fire was not the thing accumulated. The rule is not a general basis for liability for spreading fire. A negligence claim would require proof of fault, which was not established.
Law basis: Stannard (t/a Wyvern Tyres) v Gore [2012] EWCA Civ 1248Question 7 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
A chemicals company stores a hazardous liquid in a locked, fenced tank on its land. Without any warning signs that they might do so, intruders break in at night and deliberately open the tank's valve. The liquid escapes and damages the neighbouring farmer's crops. The farmer sues under Rylands v Fletcher. Which of the following best describes the company's best defence?
- The escape was caused by the act of a stranger.Correct answer
- The escape was caused by an act of God, as it happened at night.
- The farmer consented to the risk by farming next to a chemicals site.
- There was no non-natural use, as the tank was locked and fenced.
- Liability under Rylands requires proof that the company was negligent.
It is a defence to liability under Rylands v Fletcher that the escape was caused by the unforeseeable act of a stranger over whom the defendant had no control. In Rickards v Lothian the defendant was not liable when a third party maliciously blocked a washbasin and caused a flood, and in Perry v Kendricks Transport the defence applied where children dropped a lit match into a petrol tank. The defence may fail if the defendant should reasonably have foreseen and guarded against the stranger's act. Act of God concerns natural forces, and the storage remained a non-natural use.
Law basis: Rickards v Lothian [1913] AC 263; Perry v Kendricks Transport Ltd [1956] 1 WLR 85Question 8 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
A reservoir operator's dam bursts during a spell of very heavy rain, flooding Nadia's land. Rainfall of that intensity occurs in the area every few years and is recorded in local records, but this was the heaviest for some time. The operator pleads act of God as a defence to a Rylands v Fletcher claim. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The defence succeeds, as the flooding was caused by natural forces.
- The defence succeeds, as it was the heaviest rain for some time.
- The defence fails, as act of God is not a defence to Rylands v Fletcher.
- The defence succeeds, as the operator could not prevent the rain falling.
- The defence fails, as rainfall of that kind was reasonably foreseeable.Correct answer
Act of God is a defence to Rylands v Fletcher only where the escape is caused by natural forces so extraordinary that no human foresight could reasonably have anticipated or guarded against them. In Nichols v Marsland an exceptional rainfall was accepted as an act of God, but in Greenock Corp v Caledonian Railway Co the House of Lords rejected the defence for an extraordinary rainfall that could have been foreseen. Rain that occurs every few years and appears in local records is foreseeable. The fact that natural forces were involved, or that this was the heaviest for some time, is not enough.
Law basis: Nichols v Marsland (1876) 2 Ex D 1; Greenock Corp v Caledonian Railway Co [1917] AC 556Question 9 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review
Water stored in large quantities in a factory's tanks escapes onto the neighbouring house, owned by Hari. The water damages the house and also ruins valuable musical instruments belonging to Leo, a lodger who has a room there but no tenancy or other interest in the house. Both sue the factory under Rylands v Fletcher. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Both can sue, as both suffered property damage caused by the escape.
- Neither can sue, as water is not a thing likely to do mischief if it escapes.
- Hari can sue under Rylands, but Leo, lacking any interest, cannot.Correct answer
- Leo can sue, but Hari cannot, as only movable property is protected.
- Both can sue, but Leo only if he proves the factory was negligent.
In Transco plc v Stockport MBC the House of Lords confirmed that Rylands v Fletcher is a sub-species of private nuisance, and so, following Hunter v Canary Wharf, a claimant must have a right to or interest in the land affected. Hari, as owner, can sue for damage to his house, assuming the other elements are met. Leo, a lodger with no proprietary interest, cannot sue under the rule, though he may sue in negligence if he can prove fault. Water accumulated in large quantities can satisfy the requirements, as in Rylands itself.
Law basis: Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 61; Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd [1997] AC 655More Tort Law topics
Back to all Tort Law questions, or sit a timed mock.