Law covered in these questions
- Poole BC v GN [2019] UKSC 25
- Gorringe v Calderdale MBC [2004] UKHL 15
- Capital & Counties plc v Hampshire CC [1997] QB 1004
- Kent v Griffiths [2001] QB 36
- Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire [1989] AC 53
- Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police [2018] UKSC 4
- Smith v Ministry of Defence [2013] UKSC 41
- HXA v Surrey CC
- YXA v Wolverhampton City Council [2023] UKSC 52
- Rigby v Chief Constable of Northamptonshire [1985] 1 WLR 1242
All 8 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
A council housing department places a mother and her two sons next to a family who subject them to years of antisocial behaviour. The sons claim that the council's social services department negligently failed to use its statutory powers to protect them by taking them into care. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- A duty is owed, because a council's statutory child protection powers give rise to private law duties.
- A duty is owed, because the council's housing decision created the danger that harmed the children.
- No duty is owed, because local authorities are immune from negligence claims when acting under statute.
- A duty is owed, because the harm to the children was clearly foreseeable once the council investigated.
- No duty is owed, as statutory powers alone do not create a private law duty.Correct answer
In Poole BC v GN the Supreme Court held that public authorities are subject to the same principles of negligence as private individuals. The existence of statutory powers does not, in itself, give rise to a common law duty to exercise them. A council may be liable if it causes harm or has assumed responsibility for the claimant, but investigating and monitoring a situation is not an assumption of responsibility. Housing the family next to the neighbours did not itself create the danger. There is no general immunity; the claim failed on ordinary omissions principles.
Law basis: Poole BC v GN [2019] UKSC 25Question 2 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
Carmen drives too fast over the crest of a hill and collides with a bus. She argues that the highway authority was negligent in failing to repaint a 'SLOW' marking that would have warned her of the hidden danger. The authority has a general statutory duty to promote road safety. Which of the following best describes her claim in negligence?
- It succeeds, because a highway authority's statutory duty is automatically actionable by road users.
- It succeeds, because the authority had previously painted the marking and so assumed responsibility.
- It fails, because a general statutory duty does not create a common law duty to give warnings.Correct answer
- It fails, because highway authorities are immune from liability in respect of road markings.
- It succeeds, because the hidden danger made it foreseeable that a driver would be injured there.
In Gorringe v Calderdale MBC the House of Lords held that a highway authority owed no common law duty to paint warning signs on the road. A broad statutory duty to promote road safety could not be used to generate a common law duty to act, and drivers are responsible for their own safe driving. Previously painting a marking did not amount to an assumption of responsibility to individual drivers. Foreseeability of harm is not enough where the complaint is a failure to confer a benefit. There is no immunity, but there is no duty on these facts.
Law basis: Gorringe v Calderdale MBC [2004] UKHL 15Question 3 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
A fire breaks out in a warehouse. When the fire brigade arrives, the officer in charge orders the building's sprinkler system to be switched off, mistakenly believing this will help. The fire spreads and destroys the warehouse, which the sprinklers would probably have saved. Which of the following best describes the brigade's liability?
- It is not liable, because a fire brigade owes no duty to the owner of a burning building.
- It is not liable, because firefighting decisions are policy matters immune from review.
- It is liable, because its positive act made the claimant's position worse.Correct answer
- It is liable, because a fire brigade owes a duty to answer every call and fight fires with care.
- It is not liable, because the fire, not the brigade, was the true cause of the destruction.
In Capital & Counties plc v Hampshire CC the Court of Appeal held that a fire brigade owes no duty simply to answer a call or to fight a fire competently. However, where the brigade by a positive act creates a new danger or makes the situation worse, it is liable. Ordering the sprinklers to be turned off was such an act, and it caused damage that would otherwise have been avoided. The brigade therefore is not under a general duty to every caller, but nor does it enjoy immunity for operational decisions that worsen the position.
Law basis: Capital & Counties plc v Hampshire CC [1997] QB 1004Question 4 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
Dr Shah calls an ambulance for Lola, who is suffering a severe asthma attack, and the call is accepted. The ambulance takes 40 minutes to arrive for no good reason, when it should have taken 15, and Lola suffers a respiratory arrest. The ambulance service argues it owes no duty to members of the public. Which of the following best describes the position?
- No duty was owed, because an emergency service is under no obligation to respond to calls.
- No duty was owed, because ambulance services are treated in the same way as the fire brigade.
- A duty was owed only if Lola had previously been a patient of the ambulance service.
- No duty was owed, because the delay was caused by the allocation of scarce resources.
- A duty was owed once the service accepted the call for a named patient.Correct answer
In Kent v Griffiths the Court of Appeal held that once an ambulance service accepted a call relating to a named individual, it owed that person a duty to arrive within a reasonable time, absent good reason for delay. The ambulance service is part of the health service, providing care to identified patients, and so is distinguishable from the fire brigade and police, whose duties are owed to the public at large. If the delay had been caused by a genuine choice about allocating limited resources, the result might differ, but here there was no explanation for the delay.
Law basis: Kent v Griffiths [2001] QB 36Question 5 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
Police investigating a series of murders fail, through careless analysis of evidence, to identify the killer, who goes on to murder Jacqui. Her mother sues the police, arguing that competent investigation would have led to the killer's arrest before Jacqui was attacked. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It fails, because the police owe no duty to protect the public from harm caused by a criminal.Correct answer
- It succeeds, because police carelessness in a murder investigation is a positive act causing harm.
- It succeeds, because Jacqui fell within an identifiable class of young women at risk from the killer.
- It fails, because the police enjoy a general immunity from all claims in the tort of negligence.
- It succeeds, because the police had assumed responsibility for her by investigating the earlier murders.
In Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire the House of Lords held that the police owed no duty to a victim of a murderer they had failed to catch. Since Robinson and Michael, this is explained not as a public policy immunity but as an application of the general rule that there is no duty to protect people from harm caused by third parties, absent an exception such as assumption of responsibility. The victim was simply a member of the public, so there was no special relationship. A careless investigation is an omission to protect, not a positive act causing injury.
Law basis: Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire [1989] AC 53; Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police [2018] UKSC 4Question 6 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
Soldiers are killed when their lightly armoured patrol vehicle is hit by a roadside bomb in an overseas conflict. Their families allege that the Ministry of Defence negligently failed, years earlier, to provide better-protected vehicles. The MoD argues that combat immunity bars the claim. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Combat immunity bars all claims by soldiers injured in the course of military operations abroad.
- Combat immunity applies because the deaths were caused by enemy action, not by the MoD.
- No duty is owed because the Crown cannot be sued in tort by members of the armed forces.
- Combat immunity is narrow and may not cover earlier equipment decisions.Correct answer
- Combat immunity applies to all decisions concerning equipment that is later used in combat.
In Smith v Ministry of Defence the Supreme Court held that combat immunity should be narrowly construed. It covers acts and omissions in the course of actual or imminent armed conflict, but not necessarily decisions about equipment and training taken well in advance, away from the battlefield. Whether a duty was owed in respect of such decisions depended on whether imposing one would be fair, just and reasonable, which required the facts to be found at trial, so the claims were not struck out. The Crown can be sued in tort by servicemen following the Crown Proceedings (Armed Forces) Act 1987.
Law basis: Smith v Ministry of Defence [2013] UKSC 41Question 7 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
A council's children's services department receives several reports that Mia, aged eight, is being neglected and abused by her mother's partner. It investigates and monitors the family but does not apply for a care order. Mia later sues the council for failing to protect her. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It is likely to fail, as investigating and monitoring is not an assumption of responsibility.Correct answer
- It is likely to succeed, as the reports gave the council actual knowledge of the abuse.
- It is likely to succeed, as the council's statutory child protection duties are actionable by children.
- It is likely to fail, as councils cannot be sued in negligence in respect of child protection.
- It is likely to succeed, as the council took control of Mia's welfare once it opened a file.
In HXA v Surrey CC the Supreme Court applied Poole BC v GN and held that councils which had investigated and monitored children at risk had not assumed responsibility to protect them from abuse by third parties. A duty would arise only if the council had, for example, taken the child into care or otherwise undertaken to protect her, so that she or others relied on it. Knowledge of risk and the existence of statutory duties do not of themselves create a common law duty. There is no blanket immunity; the claim fails under ordinary omissions principles.
Law basis: HXA v Surrey CC; YXA v Wolverhampton City Council [2023] UKSC 52Question 8 · Public authority liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review
An armed man barricades himself inside Rhys's gun shop. Police decide to fire a CS gas canister into the shop to drive him out, knowing that it carries a fire risk, but no firefighting equipment is on standby. The shop catches fire and is destroyed. Rhys sues the police. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The police are not liable, because the decision to use CS gas was a lawful operational choice.
- The police are not liable, because they owe no duty to protect property from a criminal's actions.
- The police are liable, but only if the decision to use that type of canister was irrational.
- The police are liable for failing to have firefighting equipment available.Correct answer
- The police are not liable, because a property owner must insure against risks from crime.
In Rigby v Chief Constable of Northamptonshire the police were not liable for the decision to use a particular canister, which was a justifiable choice. However, they were negligent in firing it when no firefighting equipment was available to deal with the known fire risk, and so were liable for the destruction of the shop. This was a positive act by the police which directly caused damage, not a mere failure to protect against a criminal. A public law irrationality standard is not the test for operational negligence, and the owner's insurance position is irrelevant.
Law basis: Rigby v Chief Constable of Northamptonshire [1985] 1 WLR 1242More Tort Law topics
Back to all Tort Law questions, or sit a timed mock.