HomeTort LawPsychiatric harm

Tort Law · FLK1

Psychiatric harm: SQE1 notes and practice questions

Key rules, exam traps and 14 single best answer questions on psychiatric harm, with the answer explained and the law behind each one.

  • 3,641 SQE1 questions across all 14 subjects, in the exam's single best answer format
  • Reviewed by a team of qualified solicitors, with the case or statute behind every answer
  • Full 85-question FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks, built for the January 2027 format
  • Progress tracked topic by topic, so you revise what you actually get wrong
  • Start free: all notes and guides plus a sample question in every topic, no card needed
  • Solicitor-reviewed questions
  • Law cited on every answer
  • One-off payment, no auto-renewal
  • Secure Stripe checkout
Full SQE1 question bank
from£35£35 £24.50one-off
Black Friday: 30% off, up to 80% on bigger basketsUnlock all 3,641 questions

No auto-renewal · instant access · or try free sample questions

Revision notes

At a glanceCan the claimant recover for psychiatric injury?
  1. 1Is there a recognised psychiatric illness, not just grief or distress?
    YesGo on.NoNo claim.
  2. 2Was the claimant in the zone of physical danger or reasonably believed so?
    YesPrimary victim: recovers if physical injury foreseeable (Page v Smith).NoSecondary victim: apply Alcock.
  3. 3Close tie of love and affection with the primary victim?
    YesPresumed for spouses, parents and children.NoBystanders fail (McFarlane v EE Caledonia).
  4. 4Present at an external accident or its immediate aftermath, perceived with own senses?
    YesProximity satisfied (McLoughlin v O'Brian).NoFails, e.g. via TV or a medical crisis from earlier negligence (Paul).
  5. Rescuers have no special status; they recover only as primary victims (White v CC South Yorkshire).

Alcock [1992]; Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1

Key rules

  • Recognised psychiatric illness is required (eg PTSD, clinical depression, pathological grief). Ordinary grief, distress or fear is not enough (Hinz v Berry [1970] distinguishes grief from nervous shock).
  • Primary victims: those within the range of foreseeable physical injury, or who reasonably believe they are in danger. If physical injury was foreseeable, the defendant is liable for psychiatric injury even if no physical injury occurs and even if psychiatric harm was not itself foreseeable for a person of normal fortitude (Page v Smith [1996]).
  • Secondary victims: those who witness danger or injury to another. They must satisfy the Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] control mechanisms:
Requirement Detail
Close tie of love and affection Presumed for spouses, parents and children; others must prove it (Alcock)
Proximity in time and space Present at the event or its immediate aftermath (McLoughlin v O'Brian [1983]: hospital within about two hours)
Perception by own unaided senses Not via television or being told (Alcock)
Psychiatric harm foreseeable in a person of reasonable fortitude Unless the defendant knew of a particular susceptibility
  • Shock and events: the illness must result from a sudden, shocking event, though this can be a series of events over a short period (North Glamorgan NHS Trust v Walters [2002]: 36 hours). Identifying a body nine hours later fell outside the immediate aftermath in Alcock; Galli-Atkinson v Seghal [2003] allowed a mother who saw the scene and the mortuary shortly after.
  • The accident requirement: Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1 held that a secondary victim must witness an "accident", meaning an external, unexpected event causing injury or risk of injury to a primary victim. Witnessing a death or medical crisis caused by earlier negligent failure to diagnose or treat is not enough. Secondary victim claims arising from medical negligence will therefore rarely succeed.
  • Rescuers: no special status. A rescuer recovers only as a primary victim, ie if exposed to physical danger or reasonably believing so (White v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1999]; contrast Chadwick v BRB [1967], explained on the basis of danger).
  • Bystanders with no close tie cannot recover (McFarlane v EE Caledonia [1994]).
  • Self-harming primary victim: no duty owed to a relative traumatised by seeing a person injure themselves through their own negligence (Greatorex v Greatorex [2000]).
  • Occupational stress: ordinary principles apply; the key is foreseeability of psychiatric injury to this employee, with no occupation intrinsically dangerous to mental health (Hatton v Sutherland [2002]; Barber v Somerset CC [2004]; Walker v Northumberland CC [1995], liability after a first breakdown).

How it is tested

  • Near miss: a driver narrowly avoids a collision and develops PTSD without physical injury. Primary victim; recover under Page v Smith.
  • Mother hears of crash and goes to hospital: within two hours, sees injured family before treatment. Possible immediate aftermath (McLoughlin); days later would fail.
  • Relative at a hospital bedside watches a patient collapse from a previously undiagnosed condition. No claim after Paul.
  • Off-duty police officers helping at a disaster but not in danger. Not primary victims, so fail (White).

Exam traps

  • Treating rescuers or employees as automatically primary victims (White).
  • Allowing recovery for grief or distress without a recognised illness.
  • Accepting perception through live broadcast or a phone call.
  • Ignoring Paul and relying on Walters to found a secondary victim claim in a medical negligence case. After Paul, the question is whether the claimant witnessed an external accident, not whether the events were sufficiently sudden or shocking.
  • Requiring foreseeability of psychiatric harm for primary victims where physical injury was foreseeable.

Quick check

Remember: Classify first: a primary victim in the zone of physical danger recovers under Page v Smith; a secondary victim must satisfy every Alcock control and, after Paul [2024], witness an external accident.

Law covered in these questions

  • Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] 1 AC 310
  • McLoughlin v O'Brian [1983] 1 AC 410
  • Page v Smith [1996] AC 155
  • White v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1999] 2 AC 455
  • Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1
  • Hinz v Berry [1970] 2 QB 40
  • McFarlane v EE Caledonia Ltd [1994] 2 All ER 1
  • Greatorex v Greatorex [2000] 1 WLR 1970
  • North Glamorgan NHS Trust v Walters [2002] EWCA Civ 1792
  • Galli-Atkinson v Seghal [2003] EWCA Civ 697
  • Hatton v Sutherland [2002] EWCA Civ 76
  • Barber v Somerset CC [2004] UKHL 13
  • Walker v Northumberland CC [1995] 1 All ER 737
  • Chadwick v British Railways Board [1967] 1 WLR 912

Worked answer: 1 free sample question

Try it above first, then read the worked answer below. Members get every psychiatric harm question.

Question 1 · Psychiatric harm✓ Solicitor reviewed

Ben watches live from the stand as a crowd crush develops in the section where his two brothers are standing. Both are killed. Ben develops post-traumatic stress disorder. At trial he produces no evidence of his relationship with his brothers beyond the fact that they were siblings. Which of the following best describes his claim?

  1. It is likely to succeed, as he was present at the scene and saw the event with his own senses.
  2. It is likely to fail, as a close tie is not presumed between brothers and must be proved.Correct answer
  3. It is likely to succeed, as a close tie of love and affection is presumed between all siblings.
  4. It is likely to fail, as only spouses and parents can ever claim as secondary victims.
  5. It is likely to succeed, as anyone who witnesses a death at close quarters is a primary victim.

Members

13 more psychiatric harm questions with full answers

Unlock all 3,641 solicitor-reviewed questions, full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks and the practice builder. From £35, one-off, no auto-renewal.

More Tort Law topics

Back to all Tort Law questions, or sit a timed mock.

What you get

Everything you need to practise for SQE1, from £35

One-off payment, no subscription. Every question, every mock and every member tool unlocks the moment you pay.

Every subject covered

3,641 questions across all 14 SQE1 subjects and every topic in the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) specification.

Built like the real exam

Five options, one single best answer, client-based scenarios: the format SQE1 uses.

The law behind every answer

Each answer cites the case or statute that decides it. Statute questions link to legislation.gov.uk.

Timed FLK1 and FLK2 mocks

Full 85-question sessions at exam pace (2 hours 33 minutes), matching the January 2027 format.

See your weak topics

Your score is tracked by topic, so your next study session goes where the marks are.

Checked by solicitors

Every question is reviewed by a team of qualified solicitors in England and Wales.

Why it matters: SQE1 costs £2,006 per attempt, and only 53% of candidates passed both papers in January 2026. A few weeks of exam-format practice costs a fraction of one resit. See pass rates.

1 month

Black Friday −30%
£35£35 £24.50one-off

£35 a month · A focused final push before your sitting.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 30 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 1 month for £35
Most popular

3 months

Black Friday −30%
£79£79 £55.30one-off

About £26 a month · The most popular length for one SQE1 sitting.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 90 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 3 months for £79

6 months

Black Friday −30%
£129£129 £90.30one-off

About £21.50 a month · Time to study steadily, sit, and resit if needed.

  • All 3,641 questions with explained answers
  • Full FLK1 and FLK2 timed mocks
  • Practice builder and progress tracking
  • 180 days of access, no auto-renewal
Get 6 months for £129
  • Solicitor-reviewed questions
  • Law cited on every answer
  • One-off payment, no auto-renewal
  • Secure Stripe checkout